Apologies for the double post, but I don't feel like editing all this in.
BR, I couldn't respond to this earlier as I was asleep, sorry. @BrightnessRadiant
Which sounds a little strange... @_Stick_ why did you say you thought he seemed suspicious if his behavior looked normal to you? (looks a little like an elim trying not to be too "sure" of a player's alignment) Maybe it was because how he wasn't posting more than usual, but the content wasn't much different from how he'd normally post. I'm pretty sure in one of my posts D1 I said that the 'lots of PMs' thing isn't really alignment indicative.
3. This was in response to Straw's revelation that he'd gotten a pm from Joe saying that he would help him if he was an elim:
I'm a little confused why you would say this about Joe not doing this were he an elim, when it was apparent from this that he was a neutral? What I'm trying to say I guess is: Were you suspicious of Joe being an elim before this?No, I meant that straw, as an elim -or anyone, really- wouldn't admit to being an elim just because joe asked him if he was in a PM. Sorry if it wasn't clear.
4. This was in response to Yitzi day one: (talking about always hitting a villager on day one)
This did kind of seem to have happened....actually you personally helped to save Yitzi by switching to Jon. (So did I, but there was a plan in the works to break the tie in favor of lynching Yitzi(in pms) until Joe suggested lynching Jon so I moved over there instead because I was more suspicious of Jon at that point.) Well, yeah, it did. But the way and time it happened it is possible that no elims were involved at all. Unless the reason why Joe suggested we lynch Jond in the first place was because it was part of a deal with the Elims.
5. When you found out that PK made the weird group pms instead of Straw(and that was your basis for being suspicious of Straw) then why weren't you suspicious of PK for the same reasons? (Was he an elim teammate? ) I actually did say that I was, can't bother to look for the post but I'm pretty sure I asked him why he made those PMs and never got a response. :/
6. You said you would probably break the tie in favor of Rand, but then voted Jon instead...why? (You probably could've still gotten Rand lynched Day 1 if you wanted because of how close the votes were. In fact it was your vote that put the Jon lynch over.) You said you'd just read Aman's post about Jon, but what post were you referring to exactly? I couldn't find any post Aman made about Jon exactly other than him saying that last minute reaction votes tend to be more pure. In my post responding to Len last turn, I've linked a post that explains why I said that (the one you quoted below is the same, actually). And this is Aman's post I was referring to:
"Jon: First few posts NAI. His tinfoil of Wilson feels like he knows Crimsn and Wilson are town (or, at least, not elims) and he's trying to discourage the former trusting the latter. He's got a bit of an authoritative tone going that I'm not sure is alignment indicative, but it's triggering me a little (for example, "Everyone else keep your roles to yourselves"). I would say him giving Joe time to respond is sensible, but that could just be hedging because he'd rather lynch a villager. The timing of his vote on Rand suggests he's town, even if I think it's a really bad vote. Him trying to get Flash to talk more about his reads is good, but it's probably NAI since an elim could say that just as easily. Conclusion: Leaning evil but would not lynch him today, as it's unfair to start a lynch on someone when they aren't around, and I'd like to do some real-time interaction with him later." This was a post he made earlier during the turn but quoted it at the end of the turn after joe suggested the lynch.
7. This post from Night one:
why would lynching Straw day 1 not have given us any info? You seemed a lot more interested in finding out Aman's alignment than Yitzi's. Is there a reason for this? Especially since you seemed to have voted on Jon on the previous cycle due to something Aman said which seems like you were already leaning village on him. And Jond flipped town. :-PSo, then why would you have been more interested in finding out Aman's alignment than Yitzi's? As you can probably tell, I wasn't so keen with lynching Rand anyway, but it seemed like the better option among the three at that moment. Ans yeah, I can't think of what info Straw's lynch at that point would've given us.
8. This post from Day 2? (I think lolz)
Since it's kinda obvious now I'd expect the elims to hop on the bandwagon too, so...yeah we shouldnt need my vote EoD, but we'll see.
Since I'm suspicious of Asterion, this makes me wonder if elim!Stick would possibly try and avoid adding to the lynch on elim!Aster? Can't think of anyway to defense myself against this. But yeah, I did suggest we may lynch him last turn, but enough votes were on Len so...
9. She later votes Yitzi and says she'd be fine with lynching either Yitzi or Aster, but Yitzi was leading the lynch. (not sure whether this was just distancing from possible elim!Aster or actual suspicion?) My vote on Aster would've done literally nothing. :-P
10. almost every other post she's made this game gives me a village vibe and I could see these as being things an actual villager would do for different reasons as well so I think all in all I'd say my read on Stick is village.
@_Stick_ I'd appreciate it if you could clarify some of the questions I asked if you don't mind? (but I'd say you're likely a villager so yeah lol)
Edit: If it comes down to the end of cycle and no one votes Aster then I'll probably switch to voting on Len because I'm suspicious of him too, and he voted on Stick (who I'm pretty sure is village at this point), and Stick and Rae(confirmed villager) have both voted for him.
Bolded text is mine.
edit: turns out it wasn't a double post huh
