Jump to content

Stick.

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3863

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Stick.

  1. Stick.
  2. Stick.
    @Ecthelion III Chinese Fire Drill XD The sudden change of the lynch target.
  3. Stick.
    Alright first, I totally expected someone to bring this up against me and was kinda wondering why anyone hasn't done that yet. All this(the quoted bit)happened in like 2 seconds. When there were like 3 minutes for the turn to end. Wasn't really up for lynching Straw, Rand or Yitzi, none of them had done things that seemed very suspicious to me. Okay, so I guess I'll try to explain why I voted Jond. A part of me was actually tempted to leave it to a tie. In the last minute, the lynch on Jond just...seemed better than the other three because I thought that lynches D1 rarely get elims, like they manage to get out if one way to the other (though I guess this theory's flop now since we almost got Yitzi D1), and if the lynch targets changes like that, especially when it's changed like that by a neutral, elim teammates cant do much to steer the lynch away can they? Besides, how can you not join a bandwagon like that? Not everyday that you wake up to a CFD (I'd just woken up). Also, if elim!stick wanted to save a teammate, she could've just voted along on any of the two village wagons. If I were an elim and had voted on Straw, I'm pretty sure I would've gotten away with it because no everyone had pretty much the same reasons for voting Straw. And I explained I said I'd vote on Rand out of the three here: And this: That's the thing. I wasn't really suspicious of anyone. The post I linked above explains that, iirc Why did you leave out Crimsn? Okay how am I supposed to defend my self against this, even. I'm sure I've talked about him, but didn't analyse his posts, yes. There's lots of payers whose posts I haven't analysed. I was going to change my vote to Aster because I thought I didn't have enough evidence against you, but I'm not so sure now. Though I'm still considering it. @asterion137 what are your thoughts on this? Edit: ninjad a lot @The Flash what are your reasons for voting Cloud? edit2: Vote tally: (1)STINK: Ecth (1)Ecth: Dalinar (3)Len: Araris, Stick, Wilson (1)Stick: Len (1)Cloud: Flash (1)Flash: Striker @Ecthelion III You didn't remove your vote from Stink, did you?
  4. Stick.
    Vote Tally by Stick because Aman is dead: (1)STINK: Ecth (1)Ecth: Dalinar (2)Len: Araris, Stick
  5. Stick.
    @Ecthelion III so you had no idea why so many others were voting on Stink? Len's posts: 1,2) Votes on Straw because he's not Joe. Reading village on stink 3) Keeping vote on Straw because he'd rather see him lynched than Rand. 4) Asks Aman why his vote's on Aster when he thinks we should lynch yitzi today. Votes Yitzi bc following village!aman's suspicions is good and he'd want his vote on yitzi anyway. 5,6) OOG 7) QF17 vibes 8) Votes Stink for uncool moves 9) Unvotes Stink in order to give an example of how using leverage isnt always bad. 10) Asks Aman why he'd get an elim read on len if straw flips town and then votes on straw bc it's better than a stink lynch 11) More PMs =/= more info 12, 13, 14, 15) RP 16) Asks Rae if she was in contact with Orlok. So his D1 vote on Straw reads elim, his vote on yitzi (post4) was the ninth vote on yitzi, so I wouldnt exactly give that a village read. I'd expect elims to join a wagon that lynches their teammate at that point -when the lynch was pretty much solid. But then again, it's Len. He joins bandwagons. [That's not alignment indicative, though]. Len. But I'm skeptical. Might remove the vote if I find a better lead. About 10 hours left till turn over, you guys want to...vote, maybe?
  6. Stick.
    @Ecthelion III you were part of the stink bandwagon the other day weren't you? Why did you vote on him?
  7. Stick.
    I can try to get @Daniyah to join if we still need more players later
  8. Stick.
    *her Rae is the Ringleader He stole from Rae, preventing the coinshot kill
  9. Stick.
    I think we probably shouldn't lynch neutrals....
  10. Stick.
    How about we make this thread not dead Went through Araris' posts 1) Votes on Straw because too many PMs 2) A player in a previous game started lots of PMs and turned out to be an elim 3) Often leaves the tab open, doesn't mean he's always there. Surprised by the Jondesu lynch. 4) Is sick and tells the coinshot to feel free to kill him if he doesn't post useful things soon 5) Shares a few reads. Village: Flash, Dalinar, Brightness, Seonid, Striker. Elim: Rae, Elenion, Stick (*grumble grumble), PK. Is not sure about Rand, though the reasons for the votes on him were poor. 6) Doesn't support the Stink lynch. Thinks Stink wouldn't have stolen the vial if he was aware Rae was targeting Straw. 7) Missed the part where Aman said they'd be killing Straw. 8,9) Says he had a better reason to vote on Straw D1 than Len. Says that he's suspicious of me and Flash because of our votes on Straw. I see why people are having trouble getting reads on him. So more than a few of these are NAI. Slight elim read for voting Straw. Post 4 makes me lean village, but that could easily be an elim as well, given how Cluny wanted to die in lg33 for a weird reason and that made me lean village but he turned out to be an elim. Overall read: Honestly, I think he could be one of the two unknown neutrals. Looking at len's posts next. I think Im going to vote on either him or Aster today.
  11. Stick.
    Great. >> I didn't Hael shortened the turns by 2.5 hours
  12. Stick.
    Did what? Well, your tone plays a huge part in why I said 'slight' elim read. Your posts mostly sound village. I think I'll do Araris' posts next
  13. Stick.
    Striker's posts: D1 1) Gives advice to neutrals: create PMs, avoid role-claiming in-thread. Gives advice to mistings: make PMs for strategizing, but PMs are dangerous, though we need them N1. Is suspicious of Jond but will wait to see what others' suspicions are. 2) Will analyse later, but Straw is suspicious. 3) Gives thoughts on first 5 pages of turn. Is suspicious of Rand and Straw. N1 4) Did not like Jond lynch. Forgot to vote last turn. Will post analysis later. D2 5) Answers Aman's question about thoughts on a few players: Neutral/Elim read on Straw bc PMs. Neutral/slight village read on Rand. Is not sure of Stick or Yitzi, will say more about them later. BR seems village, but she always seems village. 6) Clarifies why he was suspicious of Jond [because he was evil in lg34]. He had thought Stink was a bad lynch because he trusts him due to their PM. Thinks Straw's PM thing was NAI. Is leaning village on Rand because of the neutral bandwagon on him D1, which mightve been part of their deal wit the elims. Doesnt see why people want to lynch Aster. 7) Aman explained, and role claimed. Striker is now convinced and votes Aster. Will do analysis later. 8) Changed vote to Yitzi after Aman asked him and a few others if theyre willing to do so. 9) Analysis post. Elim reads: Flash, Straw. Neutral/no reads: Straw, Shqueeves, Len, Stink. Village reads: BR, Aman. N2 10) Tells Dalinar that he [Striker] voted on Aster after Aman explained the reasoning and then switched to yitzi after Aman gave better reasoning for that. D3 11) Votes on Stink. Claims tineye with two charges left [now one charge left]. 12) Switches vote to Straw. Might lynch Stink some other day. 13) Mayoring did come up in the QF. Stuff I'd like to point out: - Never did give his thought on me or Yitzi. Could be elim partners with him. - Some things in post6 contradict posts 3, 2. - Before post7, Aman gave a detailed explanation that also included that he's 90% sure that yitzi is evil. Yet Striker chose to vote Aster, until post8 where he switched it upon Aman's request. Overall: slight elim read. could be neutral.
  14. Stick.
    @randuir 48h
  15. Stick.
    Joining as Stick :-D And maybe this time I should actually read the rules before the game starts
  16. Stick.
    @Araris Valerian As Rand said, safer play for the elims would've been waiting for someone to vote on Straw first (I think a straw lynch was kinda inevitable) and then join the wagon if needed. Or just, yknow, let the village waste a day on lynching a neutral.
  17. Stick.
    sigh Stink's vote was rioted, it seems. I predicted this (:D) Though why would anyone waste their vial like that.
  18. Stick.
    Hopefully I'll be more useful tomorrow morning, after I've gotten some sleep Also, she* No, we don't know who the thief's child, or the convict's ward are, I think. also, she* edit: just wanted to point out that the lynch rn is v easy to be manipulated by a soother/rioter, if the elims have one. But I guess they won't gain anything by delaying straws lynch if he really is evil
  19. Stick.
    In other news, the votes are tied now. Which I don't know how to feel about.
  20. Stick.
    wow @little wilson Sorry but who is Eponine? I havent watched les mis
  21. Stick.
    Maybe it's this bit: Emphasis mine and all
  22. Stick.
    exactly
  23. Stick.
    Hm. It's something in or before that last sentence, I'm sure. I'm going to take a look at Striker's posts as soon as I stop being lazy
  24. Stick.
    No questions for Stick :[ It probably crossed other people's minds too, but is it possible that the CDF D1 was part of their deal? It could...
  25. Stick.
    @randuir didn't BR change her vote?
×
×
  • Create New...