Ecthelion III

Don't hit El with the scan, remember. 40% chance that it means nothing. I say we lynch her next day cycle unless she gives us a good reason not to. In fact, at this point, I say we take every scan with a grain of salt.

No. What if: N2, the Derethi tried to attack Meta, but he went on a business trip. The Jeskeri did a WGG with Cloud defending Elbereth and someone else (Straw?) submitting the attack. The following night, the Derethi killed Meta because he had already used his business trip (because he did not appear in the write-up).

I don't trust Straw at all. He isn't confirmed good because the only person who could verify Straw's word was Cloud. Thus, Straw's innocence depends entirely on Cloud's innocence. Plus, he seems to be way too overeager to get into the Senate. Scan Mailliw. @Amanuensis From the rules for Kesegan Monk: " You can use this action on yourself, but the identity of your attacker will not be revealed should you be attacked in this case."

1. Kelsier 11 HP 2. Kaladin 10 HP 3. Vin 10 HP 4. Elend 9 HP 5. Shallan 12 HP 6. Dalinar 7 HP 9. Adolin 9 HP 14. Marasi 7 HP 15. Wayne 5 HP 16. Sylphrena 10 HP 17. Lightsong 8 HP 20. Marsh 12 HP 24. Hoid 7 HP 25. Jasnah 8 HP

1. Kelsier 12 HP 2. Kaladin 9 HP 3. Vin 10 HP 4. Elend 9 HP 5. Shallan 11 HP 6. Dalinar 7 HP 9. Adolin 8 HP 14. Marasi 7 HP 15. Wayne 7 HP 16. Sylphrena 10 HP 17. Lightsong 8 HP 20. Marsh 12 HP 24. Hoid 6 HP 25. Jasnah 9 HP

@Sart, you just posted in the other thread half an hour ago. With the three Senate poke votes, you have quite the incentive to post here. Edit: Oh yeah, and @Straw--I won't trust you until you invite one other person to your doc...of the Senate's choosing! @The Young Bard--if you don't want to lynch Sart, I would vote for an alternative in the Senate and in the thread.

Patience, Straw. Cloud could be lying and you could be on the same team. Let's wait until we see if the Jeskeri continue to go after Senators. No use hurrying the process along.

Log #645234 It seems that the local politics have overrun this town, and they're talking about nothing else but whom to lynch next. That Ashkelon character yelling from the rooftops wasn't exactly helping. Another body turned up in the streets last night. The local gossip says that Meta had belonged to the evil Jeskeri cult and had been killed by a member of Shu-Dereth. I recovered some blood from the attacker, accruing no small amount of distrust in the process. Hopefully the clues I gather through my research will be able to help us defeat this Derethi menace once and for all... -Aeleus Come on, folks, get your roleplaying on! It's more fun when there's a story to be had.

I'd say we don't investigate anyone in the senate. The proposal right now is Elbereth, but given that cloudjumper and Elbereth have the same alignment, that's a 2/5 chance our scan means nothing. I personally think we should scan Maill (who we were going to scan the other day) or maybe a semi-active such as Orlok or Kipper.

Let’s look at some of the things Meta said and did throughout his [rather short-lived] life to see if we can gather anything useful from them. My comments are bolded; quotes from Meta are not. “you [The Young Bard] don't want people trusting Maill all that much because you already know that he's not a Derethi due to you being one.” He poke-voted Lime because “Why vote when you're just going to tell the person what they need to do to get out of it?” Now is when he said the thing that made me a little suspicious of him from the start (in fact, my next post said “I'm a little suspicious of Meta, but I think I'll hold back on putting a vote on him for now.” Meta said “Does everyone vote for a Senator and a Recall at night or is it just the Senate? Because that changes how we should go about making sure that the Cultists can't maintain a majority there.” The sort of phrasing on that question made me think he really meant to say “how we should go about making sure that the Cultists can maintain a majority there. “First of all I'm just not seeing why everyone is so assured of Bard's innocence; especially people like Aman and Elenion from the Senate Doc.” I guess this means Bard is not Jeskeri, since it appears Meta really wanted Bard to get lynched. Or it could be Meta playing mind games again. “Lynching an inactive tells us very little in comparison to lynching someone who has been active.” Tidbits of advice from an eliminator are best not followed. Keep in mind that Conquestor was on his team. Meta first voted to lynch Elenion and then voted to remove Elenion from the Senate. This clears Elenion of Jeskeri status in my book. Edit: Actually, back then, the requirement for Senate removal wasn't 2 votes, so Meta could have been busing. After his birthday hiatus, he hopped on to say: “I am suspicious of El[bereth]” and “I don't trust Elenion or Aman all that much either.” Hey [ Seonid ], what have you got to say?

Thanks, Derethi!

Hurt Hoid, Heal Sylphrena 1. Kelsier 11 HP2. Kaladin 8 HP 3. Vin 10 HP4. Elend 7 HP5. Shallan 11 HP 6. Dalinar 6 HP9. Adolin 9 HP14. Marasi 7 HP15. Wayne 8 HP16. Sylphrena 12 HP17. Lightsong 9 HP20. Marsh 11 HP24. Hoid 7 HP25. Jasnah 9 HP

It seems to me like you're looking for any excuse to accuse Elbereth, @Elenion Edit: 'd

You're getting way too suspicious of everyone.

@Mckeedee123 Is a player immune the night they are recalled, or just the night they are elected?

Magneto?

They just came out of the tests, and are 100% E. coli free!

All right, fine. 1. Elbereth ^ 2. Mailliw I’m actually fairly suspicious of him, although as a very experienced player he could just be leading me on. He did say “Though, I don't think I'm as dangerous as Orlok, Meta, or Aman, but that's probably just a personal bias. Go ahead and scan me if you want.” Number one strategy of people to avoid a scan seems to be to offer specific alternatives with reasons why they’d be better scan targets, as well as saying “go ahead and scan” when they’re not likely to be scanned that turn. 3. Cloudjumper Soft-cleared claimed Village Duelist. If Elbereth is legit, Cloudjumper is legit as well. 4. The Young Bard Bard started the game off by poking everyone. Elodin called him out for being too aggressive, and I agreed. (I mistakenly called my vote a “poke-vote”; it was really just to get Bard “up on the stand”, so to speak.) I was curious why everyone suddenly jumped off him. At this point in the game, we know that either he’s legit, or he and Aman are both allied eliminators. 5. Ecthelion III Village. Scan me if you want. (I know, that sounds eliminator-y, but seriously, I’m fine if you scan me. If anything it’ll prove another villager we can put in the Senate.) 6. Orlok He claims to have had very little time these last few days and hasn’t posted much at all. This makes it hard to draw conclusions, which is exactly what he wants if he’s not trustworthy. It might be beneficial to scan him. 7. Elodin Dead villager. He believed that Bard’s actions “seemed a bit off”. 8. Straw Confirmed Village Acolyte, unless he’s in league with Cloudjumper. He seems to just throw votes on people, but I’ve been told that that’s just what Straw does. 9. Conquestor No thoughts, given he’s, well, dead. 10. Eramit Dead Gyorn. Enough said. 11. Metacognition Said that the Derethi probably had a hand in the bandwagon at the beginning. I’m not really suspicious of him anymore, after reviewing the thread and everything. 12. emilylime Started out by poking eramit; could very easily have been a bus. 13. Eolhandras My gut is suspicious of him for some reason. (I’m sorry, that sounds ridiculously suspicious of me to say that.) Dunno why, just the gut. 14. Elenion Claimed Village Landlord and said who he would submit his vote on right before rollover. The vote showed up so my suspicions are off him a tiny bit; HOWEVER that person was the most likely person to get voted on by any other Landlord. Even if he is a Landlord he could still be a Jeskeri or Derethi. He loves bandwagons but attacks others who join bandwagons (?) I don’t really know what to make of him right now. 15. Sart Basically see my thoughts on Orlok. Few posts make it hard to draw conclusions on you. Why don’t you post your observations about this game so far? 16. Jaimelecee Rest in peace, Jaime. It’s a tough world out there. 17. Amanuensis Posts lots of charts and in-depth analyses. Claimed duelist. He’s neither suspicious nor unsuspicious in my book. 18. Seonid Oh, he’s been on all right, (he’s on as I’m writing this) but is rarely active in thread. He’s probably a powerful good role (like Monk) or a bad guy. I know it’s kind of late in the game to be poke-voting him, but he deserves a poke-vote or two. What do you have to say? 19. Kipper See Sart.

Am I the only one here who liked Elantris more than Mistborn?

Noooo, I was 13 minutes too late to save Him... 1. Kelsier 10 HP2. Kaladin 8 HP3. Vin 9 HP 4. Elend 7 HP5. Shallan 11 HP 6. Dalinar 6 HP9. Adolin 9 HP14. Marasi 7 HP15. Wayne 9 HP16. Sylphrena 10 HP17. Lightsong 9 HP20. Marsh 11 HP24. Hoid 9 HP25. Jasnah 10 HP

That just makes me more suspicious of you, Bard, that eramit decided to "bus" you when it was obvious he would get lynched. I agree with scanning Mailliw73.

Master Hand & Crazy Hand

"informal document" You know that I signed a certain very important legal document with part Sindarin, right?

Eramit, of course.

Heal Syl, Hurt Marsh 1. Kelsier 8 HP 2. Kaladin 5 HP 3. Vin 8 HP 4. Elend 8 HP 5. Shallan 6 HP 6. Dalinar 4 HP 7. Vivenna 4 HP 8. Siri 4 HP 9. Adolin 7 HP 11. Sazed 6 HP 12. Raoden 6 HP 13. Wax 2 HP 14. Marasi 6 HP 15. Wayne 7 HP 16. Sylphrena 10 HP 17. Lightsong 6 HP 20. Marsh 8 HP 24. Hoid 8 HP 25. Jasnah 8 HP