Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 11 minutes ago, Amethyst Scorpion said: Hi can you finally answer my questions from the first post of this page? yes. i dont have a top three, i have a top two as of right now: Mouse and Iguana. rhino is mostly a gut feeling.
Oxblood Beagle Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 35 minutes ago, Salmon Meerkat said: partly, yes. but those were my actual thoughts, and the test was to see how vulture would react to an entitled me. How would an elim have reacted, in your opinion?
Coral Swan Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 12 hours ago, Quartz Zebra said: Am I correct in thinking voting doesn't come naturally to you, is a question I ask! I would like to know what compelled you to vote D1! Isn't voting how the game is played? We vote each turn to try and catch the Spiked. I actually feel kind of bad that I haven't voted this turn, but RL has got to come first. I'll vote as a placeholder on Hyena. I haven't really read the end of the first day but I know Hyena was up to get killed and didn't die.
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Salmon Meerkat Just answer the questions, please. 1 hour ago, Oxblood Beagle said: How would an elim have reacted, in your opinion? This is a good question. Reads Spoiler Amethyst Scorpion is Village Azure mouse is village Fuchsia Ostrich is village Oxblood Beagle is village Chartreuse Penguin is village Quartz Zebra is Village magenta Albatross is village Charcoal Hyena is elim Salmon Meerkat is elim Cream Tuatara is elim Mint Heron is elim Saffron Iguana is elim As you can see, I'm trying out a new kind of reads. Amber Vulture, Flamingo (of all people) and Sage Kangaroo I'm not ready to say are completely villager to me, but they're really close.
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 (edited) why am i an elim again :[ bro my rolecard cant keep up with all these conversions... edit: wait do you seriously have enough of a read on tuatara to confidently call them an elim? Edited January 7, 2024 by Saffron Iguana
Mint Heron Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 (edited) Yesterday I went on a 6 mile hike and we took a wrong turn, making it a 14 mile hike so I didn't have the time planned last night to contribute. So for now I'm just going to quick read day 2, give my thoughts, and go from there as it's much better to have discussion. Thoughts: I can't decide if iguanas reaction to my post feels weird good or weird bad. To anyone refuting my large reads post, I did say that it was only up to page 4, so it wasn't exactly conclusive of the entire game… Idk how I feel about zebra either Beagle feels fine based on response ig? Cham feels vil I'm sure mouse is vil I don't understand iguanas rhino vote Something feels off about swan I feel like I had gut Elim read on scorp earlier on and it hasn't faded. Trying to decide if it's tunneling or not. They are talking quite a bit which is always good. Vil reading penguin Can someone explain to me the Hyena votes? It seems like there's a train there and likely at least one Elim who hopped on later. That includes swan, vulture, and scorp, mouse, penguin and ostrich on hyena. Swan and vulture are the latest on that train. I'm going to vote on Swan for now, as their reasoning is simply because Hyena was up to die before but didn't. @Coral Swan Note, I'm not necessarily reading Hyena as village (null, really) but the train is obviously leading on them so me adding a vote there will do nothing. Edited January 7, 2024 by Mint Heron
Amethyst Scorpion Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 3 hours ago, Salmon Meerkat said: yes. i dont have a top three, i have a top two as of right now: Mouse and Iguana. rhino is mostly a gut feeling. Does village reading Vulture not by default grant them that third position?
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 11 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: So for now I'm just going to quick read day 2, give my thoughts, and go from there as it's much better to have discussion. Honestly, fair. I might be here a bit if you wanna chitty chat~ 11 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: I can't decide if iguanas reaction to my post feels weird good or weird bad. 12 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: To anyone refuting my large reads post, I did say that it was only up to page 4, so it wasn't exactly conclusive of the entire game… I kinda realized midway through thinking it that i had to reconzider the fact it was still not up to date tbh. uhm honestly it may be better for the now to just read the last page or two of d1 and then come back to us here? 13 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: I don't understand iguanas rhino vote bideo bame 13 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: I feel like I had gut Elim read on scorp earlier on and it hasn't faded. Trying to decide if it's tunneling or not. They are talking quite a bit which is always good. wdym by bolded? did you or did you not have an elim read there? also do you think you could explain what caused this gut read a bit? ie what post or so (apologies if you have, i am very lazy) 15 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: Can someone explain to me the Hyena votes? It seems like there's a train there and likely at least one Elim who hopped on later. That includes swan, vulture, and scorp, mouse, penguin and ostrich on hyena. Swan and vulture are the latest on that train. its there based off wagonomics from d1. who of those names do you think is most likely elim, and do you think there could have potentially been more than one elim on there? can you give me a gth read on vulture and ostritch? 17 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: I'm going to vote on Swan for now, as their reasoning is simply because Hyena was up to die before but didn't. @Coral Swan Note, I'm not necessarily reading Hyena as village (null, really) but the train is obviously leading on them so me adding a vote there will do nothing. are you aware of swan's seeker claim? why do you feel the need to state bolded? @Mint Heron
Amethyst Scorpion Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 19 minutes ago, Mint Heron said: Can someone explain to me the Hyena votes? It seems like there's a train there and likely at least one Elim who hopped on later. See my detail spoiler box from this post. Also wagonomics yeah
Fuchsia Ostrich Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Really wish I could contribute more this cycle but I've been slammed w/ work. If anyone wants to pitch me a wagon beyond Hyena, I'd appreciate the @. Will check thread every hour or so until turnover (sadly I'll be at work past it)
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 3 minutes ago, Fuchsia Ostrich said: Really wish I could contribute more this cycle but I've been slammed w/ work. If anyone wants to pitch me a wagon beyond Hyena, I'd appreciate the @. Will check thread every hour or so until turnover (sadly I'll be at work past it) I'm probably going to swap off rhino later, do you want to keep my seat warm? (ie slip there for #wagonomics), otherwise croc, heron, weasel, meerkat i think could use some pressure but will be able to be managed train wise.
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 2 hours ago, Saffron Iguana said: why am i an elim again :[ bro my rolecard cant keep up with all these conversions... edit: wait do you seriously have enough of a read on tuatara to confidently call them an elim? No, actually I'm inclined to think otherwise on Tuatara, but I have my theories. Currently, one of the inactives fits that slot. It could be dingo, or rhino maybe, but more likely Tuatara. I'll admit that you voting Tuatara and then their subsequent retaliation vote doesn't look e/e, but it could just be a distancing strategy. As for you, I believe you are elim simply because of your lack of conclusions. Similar to Meerkat, although less annoying, and more discussion oriented. 58 minutes ago, Opal Lion said: Well if hyena is an elim Mint is a villager Other way around, If Hyena Elim, I'd be looking at Heron next. 2 hours ago, Mint Heron said: Can someone explain to me the Hyena votes? It seems like there's a train there and likely at least one Elim who hopped on later. This is exactly what subtle defense entails. You try and make people reconsider why they're reading Hyena as Elim, and the last portion is suggesting "If you vote on Hyena you're elim." Standard Elim strategies. Not saying this means both Hyena and Heron are elim, just saying that this comes off to me as an E/E interaction
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 12 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: No, actually I'm inclined to think otherwise on Tuatara, but I have my theories. Currently, one of the inactives fits that slot. It could be dingo, or rhino maybe, but more likely Tuatara. I'll admit that you voting Tuatara and then their subsequent retaliation vote doesn't look e/e, but it could just be a distancing strategy. hmmm. can you explain how you both do and dont think tuatara is a hit? and why over the other inactives you list???? 15 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: As for you, I believe you are elim simply because of your lack of conclusions. Similar to Meerkat, although less annoying, and more discussion oriented. boo i think im more annoying! i dont lack conclusions, i have fluid reads, something that i find quite ironic to hear from you. 16 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: Other way around, If Hyena Elim, I'd be looking at Heron next. 2 hours ago, Mint Heron said: Can someone explain to me the Hyena votes? It seems like there's a train there and likely at least one Elim who hopped on later. This is exactly what subtle defense entails. You try and make people reconsider why they're reading Hyena as Elim, and the last portion is suggesting "If you vote on Hyena you're elim." Standard Elim strategies. Not saying this means both Hyena and Heron are elim, just saying that this comes off to me as an E/E interaction I do actually agree with this tbh- thats exactly the type of distancing typical of elims.
Chartreuse Penguin Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 2 hours ago, Saffron Iguana said: are you aware of swan's seeker claim? why do you feel the need to state bolded? Uh... Swan claimed Smoker, which is quite different than openly claiming Seeker. Unless I've missed a reverse-claim, because that would majorly change things. Not sure what I feel about Heron being asked to move off Scorp and then starting a brand-new train.
Opal Lion Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Oh lol didn't see that those together looks not great I was going purely from votes
Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Rhinoceros hasnt said much lately, imma let off. 23 minutes ago, Chartreuse Penguin said: Uh... Swan claimed Smoker, which is quite different than openly claiming Seeker. Unless I've missed a reverse-claim, because that would majorly change things. Not sure what I feel about Heron being asked to move off Scorp and then starting a brand-new train. that being me? also, Scorpion is giving me weird vibes now, dont know why.
Chartreuse Penguin Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 (edited) 6 minutes ago, Salmon Meerkat said: that being me? also, Scorpion is giving me weird vibes now, dont know why. That being... what? Mint voted Swan. And now you're voting Scorpion. Did you claim Seeker? Edit for Drake Tallybot Votecount: Spoiler Vote Tally Charcoal Hyena (6): Amber Vulture, Amethyst Scorpion, Azure Mouse, Chartreuse Penguin, Coral Swan, Fuchsia Ostrich Salmon Meerkat (3): Onyx Flamingo, Oxblood Beagle, Pearl Chameleon Amethyst Scorpion (2): Salmon Meerkat, Sapphire Elephant Azure Mouse (1): Mauve Crocodile Chartreuse Penguin (1): Quartz Zebra Coral Swan (1): Mint Heron Mint Heron (1): Opal Lion Pearl Chameleon (1): Sage Kangaroo Plum Rhinoceros (1): Saffron Iguana Edited January 7, 2024 by Chartreuse Penguin
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 34 minutes ago, Saffron Iguana said: hmmm. can you explain how you both do and dont think tuatara is a hit? and why over the other inactives you list???? Because they PMd everyone at the start of the game and have done nothing since. 35 minutes ago, Saffron Iguana said: boo i think im more annoying! i dont lack conclusions, i have fluid reads, something that i find quite ironic to hear from you. Why do you find it ironic to hear something like that from me? 36 minutes ago, Chartreuse Penguin said: Not sure what I feel about Heron being asked to move off Scorp and then starting a brand-new train. Depends on Hyena's alignment. If Hyena is elim, I'd definitely vote out heron next. If Hyena flips village, I'd say that Heron's light cleared to a small degree.
Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 8 minutes ago, Chartreuse Penguin said: That being... what? Mint voted Swan. And now you're voting Scorpion. Did you claim Seeker? Edit for Drake Tallybot Votecount: Reveal hidden contents Vote Tally Charcoal Hyena (6): Amber Vulture, Amethyst Scorpion, Azure Mouse, Chartreuse Penguin, Coral Swan, Fuchsia Ostrich Salmon Meerkat (3): Onyx Flamingo, Oxblood Beagle, Pearl Chameleon Amethyst Scorpion (2): Salmon Meerkat, Sapphire Elephant Azure Mouse (1): Mauve Crocodile Chartreuse Penguin (1): Quartz Zebra Coral Swan (1): Mint Heron Mint Heron (1): Opal Lion Pearl Chameleon (1): Sage Kangaroo Plum Rhinoceros (1): Saffron Iguana no. i was talking about the second train being me. im the second train.
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Just now, Pearl Chameleon said: Because they PMd everyone at the start of the game and have done nothing since. Why do you find it ironic to hear something like that from me? Depends on Hyena's alignment. If Hyena is elim, I'd definitely vote out heron next. If Hyena flips village, I'd say that Heron's light cleared to a small degree. Eh, but that’s kinda agendaless. I don’t disagree there should be pressure there, but something is seriously wrong with your worldview if that’s the scummiest person in the thread for you. because you’ve commented a lot this game about like. Different styles of reads and attempting more fluidity. So when I’m also touting a similar playstyle and being scumread by you, it’s mildly annoying to scummy from you to do so, FMPOV. why would you clear heron, then? I’d almost admit that v!hyena means nothing to heron’s alignment because there’s nothing to that.
Chartreuse Penguin Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 5 minutes ago, Salmon Meerkat said: no. i was talking about the second train being me. im the second train. Oh. No, Heron made a brand-new train, when there were a few existing trains (like Rhino) that already existed if they didn't want to join you or Hyena.
Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 1 minute ago, Chartreuse Penguin said: Oh. No, Heron made a brand-new train, when there were a few existing trains (like Rhino) that already existed if they didn't want to join you or Hyena. oooooohhhhhh i mustve misread that. apologies. ok, got it.
Mint Heron Posted January 8, 2024 Posted January 8, 2024 2 hours ago, Saffron Iguana said: Honestly, fair. I might be here a bit if you wanna chitty chat~ I kinda realized midway through thinking it that i had to reconzider the fact it was still not up to date tbh. uhm honestly it may be better for the now to just read the last page or two of d1 and then come back to us here? bideo bame wdym by bolded? did you or did you not have an elim read there? also do you think you could explain what caused this gut read a bit? ie what post or so (apologies if you have, i am very lazy) its there based off wagonomics from d1. who of those names do you think is most likely elim, and do you think there could have potentially been more than one elim on there? can you give me a gth read on vulture and ostritch? are you aware of swan's seeker claim? why do you feel the need to state bolded? @Mint Heron I did have elim read on scorp before. Closer to null now. Swan claimed smoker not seeker. I was just noting that I'm not not voting Hyena because I think he's village, I just don't have thoughts about them. 1 hour ago, Opal Lion said: Well if hyena is an elim Mint is a villager How? If anything it would be the other way around, as I'm not voting for them? Meh. 1 hour ago, Saffron Iguana said: I'm probably going to swap off rhino later, do you want to keep my seat warm? (ie slip there for #wagonomics), otherwise croc, heron, weasel, meerkat i think could use some pressure but will be able to be managed train wise. This does not sit right at all with me. If you're maybe planning to switch your vote later, why is it even on rhino in the first place? 1 hour ago, Pearl Chameleon said: No, actually I'm inclined to think otherwise on Tuatara, but I have my theories. Currently, one of the inactives fits that slot. It could be dingo, or rhino maybe, but more likely Tuatara. I'll admit that you voting Tuatara and then their subsequent retaliation vote doesn't look e/e, but it could just be a distancing strategy. As for you, I believe you are elim simply because of your lack of conclusions. Similar to Meerkat, although less annoying, and more discussion oriented. Other way around, If Hyena Elim, I'd be looking at Heron next. This is exactly what subtle defense entails. You try and make people reconsider why they're reading Hyena as Elim, and the last portion is suggesting "If you vote on Hyena you're elim." Standard Elim strategies. Not saying this means both Hyena and Heron are elim, just saying that this comes off to me as an E/E interaction Bruh. It's almost never the case (in my experience at least) that there isn't at least one Elim on trains like this. There's obviously going to be villagers on the train to, but I was just pointing that out. If a villager is too afraid to vote on someone they actually think is elim because they think it'll make them look elim that's just silly. Villagers don't worry about their votes looking elimy. They just vote who they think is more suspicious. 19 minutes ago, Salmon Meerkat said: Rhinoceros hasnt said much lately, imma let off. that being me? also, Scorpion is giving me weird vibes now, dont know why. Bruh what? Do you have any thoughts about anyone more than just vibes? And why vote scorp only after I unvote them? Anyway I'm down to switch vote to iguana or meerkat if people want to go that way.
Recommended Posts