Amethyst Scorpion Posted January 6, 2024 Posted January 6, 2024 2 hours ago, Coral Swan said: Something about this reaction makes me think you are village. Maybe because a Spiked wouldn’t react quite so strongly? Speaking from experience, this is false :p. 1 hour ago, Salmon Meerkat said: ah, yes. that makes sense, thank you. you have allayed my first suspicions. Vulture ok, lemme give a quick thing: Village: Iguana, mouse. vulture Null: most everyone else Spiked: rhino Vulture, i was just testing you a bit. im gonna say you passed. You don't think that thing makes them elim, therefore they jump to your top three villagers? That thing about you testing them is the fakest thing I’ve ever heard haha Pls CS Meerkat if you exist 1 hour ago, Pearl Chameleon said: will be trying to post less, since posting too much has appeared to have confused others. AKA people are elim reading you now? Edit: Also @Salmon Meerkat what are your reasons for Rhino being evil? If you’ve said them already just link that post. And why aren’t you voting them if you think they’re evil?
Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 5 minutes ago, Amethyst Scorpion said: Speaking from experience, this is false :p. You don't think that thing makes them elim, therefore they jump to your top three villagers? That thing about you testing them is the fakest thing I’ve ever heard haha Pls CS Meerkat if you exist AKA people are elim reading you now? Edit: Also @Salmon Meerkat what are your reasons for Rhino being evil? If you’ve said them already just link that post. And why aren’t you voting them if you think they’re evil? look, do you want me to or something? why you coming after me, man? i dont understand.
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 12 minutes ago, Amethyst Scorpion said: Speaking from experience, this is false :p. You don't think that thing makes them elim, therefore they jump to your top three villagers? That thing about you testing them is the fakest thing I’ve ever heard haha Pls CS Meerkat if you exist AKA people are elim reading you now? Edit: Also @Salmon Meerkat what are your reasons for Rhino being evil? If you’ve said them already just link that post. And why aren’t you voting them if you think they’re evil? People are elim reading me because I'm changing my mind too often. Thus, I must stop posting my thoughts so often. Besides, I'm fairly certain no one even reads my reads anyways so ig they don't matter that much
Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 1 minute ago, Pearl Chameleon said: People are elim reading me because I'm changing my mind too often. Thus, I must stop posting my thoughts so often. Besides, I'm fairly certain no one even reads my reads anyways so ig they don't matter that much i read them! 18 minutes ago, Amethyst Scorpion said: Speaking from experience, this is false :p. You don't think that thing makes them elim, therefore they jump to your top three villagers? That thing about you testing them is the fakest thing I’ve ever heard haha Pls CS Meerkat if you exist AKA people are elim reading you now? Edit: Also @Salmon Meerkat what are your reasons for Rhino being evil? If you’ve said them already just link that post. And why aren’t you voting them if you think they’re evil? can put someone as spiked and not vote them? is that wrong or something?
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 9 minutes ago, Salmon Meerkat said: i read them! can put someone as spiked and not vote them? is that wrong or something? No, I agree with Amethyst that you just made a bad move and are attempting to salvage it by saying it was a reaction test.
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 I mean ideally you want the Spiked to be removed, most easily via voting :9 but also I’d like to see your reasoning as well if you could.
Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Just now, Pearl Chameleon said: No, I agree with Amethyst that you just made a bad move and are attempting to salvage it by saying it was a reaction test. fine. scorpion is likely also testing me here. Rhino
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 So you think scorpion is town? What about chameleon?
Salmon Meerkat Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Just now, Saffron Iguana said: So you think scorpion is town? What about chameleon? for now. chameleon? he's kinda null for me right now, tending to lean to elim, although i cant put into words why.
Sage Kangaroo Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 4 hours ago, Saffron Iguana said: Can you cite this? ie where you got this opinion- which posts of chameleon making you think that way? I flipped through my notes searching for the evidence Iguana was asking me. Yes, there it was - "It seems like they're a worried villager but the reaction feels fake. The second sentence feels more authentically matched to be 'There better NOT be whole load of Mistborn or Seeker', Spiked mentality but masking it as village-sided. "Why do they mention vote manipulation here? Comes off as worried about it even after the wrong vote count was corrected almost 1 night prior. Hints at the fact that they might know something more [something like Spiked distribution being complementary balancing to lots of village vote manipulation] if they're STILL thinking about it." I turned away, confident in my answer. Memories stitched themselves together a lot better now and I could speak with more conviction. Thinking about the recent discussion, I realized I really liked Vulture's case on Flamingo. I took out my book and made an immediate note about it.
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 5 minutes ago, Sage Kangaroo said: I flipped through my notes searching for the evidence Iguana was asking me. Yes, there it was - "It seems like they're a worried villager but the reaction feels fake. The second sentence feels more authentically matched to be 'There better NOT be whole load of Mistborn or Seeker', Spiked mentality but masking it as village-sided. "Why do they mention vote manipulation here? Comes off as worried about it even after the wrong vote count was corrected almost 1 night prior. Hints at the fact that they might know something more [something like Spiked distribution being complementary balancing to lots of village vote manipulation] if they're STILL thinking about it." I turned away, confident in my answer. Memories stitched themselves together a lot better now and I could speak with more conviction. Thinking about the recent discussion, I realized I really liked Vulture's case on Flamingo. I took out my book and made an immediate note about it. Yeah I'm never doing live reactions to flips ever again fwiw.
Sage Kangaroo Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 9 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: Yeah I'm never doing live reactions to flips ever again fwiw. "I'm sure it wasn't deciding to live react but the content of the reactions themselves. For example, I find myself particularly confused as to why you'd mention 'lots of vote manipulation' in a cycle that gave us the night flip."
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Just now, Sage Kangaroo said: "I'm sure it wasn't deciding to live react but the content of the reactions themselves. For example, I find myself particularly confused as to why you'd mention 'lots of vote manipulation' in a cycle that gave us the night flip." I hate vote manipulation. Makes Lynches way too difficult and uneasy. But really, I was just disappointed at the distro, since I expected there to be a Coinshot (which, there still could be, but I didn't thinknof that) Having a Coinshot is a luxury, not a need, I suppose.
Chartreuse Penguin Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Spoiler Amber Vulture 2 (1 V!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Amethyst Scorpion 5 (2 V!Read, 1 NV!Read) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 V!Read) Azure Mouse 3 (3 Quote) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 V!Read) Charcoal Hyena 3 (1 Vote) Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Chartreuse Penguin 2 (2 V!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 E!Read) Coral Swan NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Cream Tuatara NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 NV!Read) Fuchsia Ostrich 1 (1 ??!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Indigo Weasel NA Falcon - 1 (1 NE!Read) Magenta Albatross 3 (1 Vote) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 E!Read) Mauve Crocodile NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Melon Dingo NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Mint Heron NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Onyx Flamingo 1 Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Opal Lion NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Oxblood Beagle NA Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Pearl Chameleon 7 (1 Quote, 3 V!Read, 1 ??!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 V!Read) Plum Rhinoceros NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 N!Read) Quartz Zebra NA Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Saffron Iguana 14 (2 Quote, 1 ??!Read, 1 NE!Read, 4 E!Read, 1 Vote) Falcon - 3 (1 Quote, 1 E!Read) Sage Kangaroo NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Salmon Meerkat 7 (4 Quote, 1 Vote, 2 NV!Read, 1 N!Read) Falcon - 8 (5 Quote, 1 Vote, 1 N!Read) Sapphire Elephant NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 NV!Read) So apparently the way I made that, I can't write above it, so we'll work with this instead. Interactions with Falcon and vice versa. Falcon made an all-inclusive reads list at one point, so no one has no interactions, but there's a lot of players with no interactions with Falcon starting from themselves: Coral Swan, Cream Tuatara, Indigo Weasel, Mauve Crocodile, Melon Dingo, Mint Heron, Opal Lion, Oxblood Beagle, Plum Rhinoceros, Quartz Zebra, Sage Kangaroo, and Sapphire Elephant. About half the total players. Most of those aren't surprising, but the italic ones kind of are. Tuatara because they had multiple PMs, Beagle because they've posted more in depth than the others, and Plum Rhinoceros because they were early active + had multiple Falcon-started interactions. Anything else surprising in here? Saffron Iguana reinforced their E!Read of Falcon an odd amount, but it seems consistent with how they've been playing and how much they've been posting. Similar case with Salmon Meerkat, though Meerkat's opinions changed over time a bit more. Pearl Chameleon is notable for the changing reads, but that's also been consistent with their own style, somewhat. And Azure Mouse honestly has less interactions than I'd expect. Doesn't leave much to work with, but if anyone with less of a sieve-brain wants to look at it, it's there. And it leaves Hyena with more of a reason for the kill. A lot of posts while I was making this so I'll just submit and go from there.
Azure Mouse Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 35 minutes ago, Chartreuse Penguin said: Reveal hidden contents Amber Vulture 2 (1 V!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Amethyst Scorpion 5 (2 V!Read, 1 NV!Read) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 V!Read) Azure Mouse 3 (3 Quote) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 V!Read) Charcoal Hyena 3 (1 Vote) Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Chartreuse Penguin 2 (2 V!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 E!Read) Coral Swan NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Cream Tuatara NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 NV!Read) Fuchsia Ostrich 1 (1 ??!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Indigo Weasel NA Falcon - 1 (1 NE!Read) Magenta Albatross 3 (1 Vote) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 E!Read) Mauve Crocodile NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Melon Dingo NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Mint Heron NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Onyx Flamingo 1 Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Opal Lion NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Oxblood Beagle NA Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Pearl Chameleon 7 (1 Quote, 3 V!Read, 1 ??!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 V!Read) Plum Rhinoceros NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 N!Read) Quartz Zebra NA Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Saffron Iguana 14 (2 Quote, 1 ??!Read, 1 NE!Read, 4 E!Read, 1 Vote) Falcon - 3 (1 Quote, 1 E!Read) Sage Kangaroo NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Salmon Meerkat 7 (4 Quote, 1 Vote, 2 NV!Read, 1 N!Read) Falcon - 8 (5 Quote, 1 Vote, 1 N!Read) Sapphire Elephant NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 NV!Read) So apparently the way I made that, I can't write above it, so we'll work with this instead. Interactions with Falcon and vice versa. Falcon made an all-inclusive reads list at one point, so no one has no interactions, but there's a lot of players with no interactions with Falcon starting from themselves: Coral Swan, Cream Tuatara, Indigo Weasel, Mauve Crocodile, Melon Dingo, Mint Heron, Opal Lion, Oxblood Beagle, Plum Rhinoceros, Quartz Zebra, Sage Kangaroo, and Sapphire Elephant. About half the total players. Most of those aren't surprising, but the italic ones kind of are. Tuatara because they had multiple PMs, Beagle because they've posted more in depth than the others, and Plum Rhinoceros because they were early active + had multiple Falcon-started interactions. Anything else surprising in here? Saffron Iguana reinforced their E!Read of Falcon an odd amount, but it seems consistent with how they've been playing and how much they've been posting. Similar case with Salmon Meerkat, though Meerkat's opinions changed over time a bit more. Pearl Chameleon is notable for the changing reads, but that's also been consistent with their own style, somewhat. And Azure Mouse honestly has less interactions than I'd expect. Doesn't leave much to work with, but if anyone with less of a sieve-brain wants to look at it, it's there. And it leaves Hyena with more of a reason for the kill. A lot of posts while I was making this so I'll just submit and go from there. Spoiler Spoiler 2 hours ago, Amethyst Scorpion said: You don't think that thing makes them elim, therefore they jump to your top three villagers? Spoiler 2 hours ago, Salmon Meerkat said: fine. scorpion is likely also testing me here. Rhino Spoiler 5 hours ago, Salmon Meerkat said: what in the name of the Lord Ruler is that supposed to mean? what do you mean "i want more village-like actions from you"? what am i supposed to be doing with that? Im doing my best, alright? Amber Vulture i feel like something is up. Spoiler Spoiler
Chartreuse Penguin Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 5 minutes ago, Azure Mouse said: Reveal hidden contents Yeah that's pretty much what I'm getting out of it. (Did that quote work? Hopefully. Can't tell.)
Sapphire Elephant Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Well, I read D1, which drained my energy faster than a Hemalurgic spike. Here's my reads based on that. Will read more later Spoiler V+ Amber Mouse, Pearl Chameleon V- Charcoal Hyena, Plum Rhinoceros, Chartreuse Penguin N+ Opal Lion, Magenta Albatross, Melon Dingo N- Salmon Meerkat, Sage Kangaroo, E+ Onyx Flamingo, Saffron Iguana, Amber Vulture E- Amethyst Scorpion Everyone else is null, for now.
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 11 minutes ago, Sapphire Elephant said: Well, I read D1, which drained my energy faster than a Hemalurgic spike. Here's my reads based on that. Will read more later Hide contents V+ Amber Mouse, Pearl Chameleon V- Charcoal Hyena, Plum Rhinoceros, Chartreuse Penguin N+ Opal Lion, Magenta Albatross, Melon Dingo N- Salmon Meerkat, Sage Kangaroo, E+ Onyx Flamingo, Saffron Iguana, Amber Vulture E- Amethyst Scorpion Everyone else is null, for now. Who's amber moose? 1 hour ago, Chartreuse Penguin said: Reveal hidden contents Amber Vulture 2 (1 V!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Amethyst Scorpion 5 (2 V!Read, 1 NV!Read) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 V!Read) Azure Mouse 3 (3 Quote) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 V!Read) Charcoal Hyena 3 (1 Vote) Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Chartreuse Penguin 2 (2 V!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 E!Read) Coral Swan NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Cream Tuatara NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 NV!Read) Fuchsia Ostrich 1 (1 ??!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Indigo Weasel NA Falcon - 1 (1 NE!Read) Magenta Albatross 3 (1 Vote) Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 E!Read) Mauve Crocodile NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Melon Dingo NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Mint Heron NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Onyx Flamingo 1 Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Opal Lion NA Falcon - 1 (1 NV!Read) Oxblood Beagle NA Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Pearl Chameleon 7 (1 Quote, 3 V!Read, 1 ??!Read) Falcon - 1 (1 V!Read) Plum Rhinoceros NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 N!Read) Quartz Zebra NA Falcon - 1 (1 N!Read) Saffron Iguana 14 (2 Quote, 1 ??!Read, 1 NE!Read, 4 E!Read, 1 Vote) Falcon - 3 (1 Quote, 1 E!Read) Sage Kangaroo NA Falcon - 1 (1 Inactive!Read) Salmon Meerkat 7 (4 Quote, 1 Vote, 2 NV!Read, 1 N!Read) Falcon - 8 (5 Quote, 1 Vote, 1 N!Read) Sapphire Elephant NA Falcon - 2 (1 Quote, 1 NV!Read) So apparently the way I made that, I can't write above it, so we'll work with this instead. Interactions with Falcon and vice versa. Falcon made an all-inclusive reads list at one point, so no one has no interactions, but there's a lot of players with no interactions with Falcon starting from themselves: Coral Swan, Cream Tuatara, Indigo Weasel, Mauve Crocodile, Melon Dingo, Mint Heron, Opal Lion, Oxblood Beagle, Plum Rhinoceros, Quartz Zebra, Sage Kangaroo, and Sapphire Elephant. About half the total players. Most of those aren't surprising, but the italic ones kind of are. Tuatara because they had multiple PMs, Beagle because they've posted more in depth than the others, and Plum Rhinoceros because they were early active + had multiple Falcon-started interactions. Anything else surprising in here? Saffron Iguana reinforced their E!Read of Falcon an odd amount, but it seems consistent with how they've been playing and how much they've been posting. Similar case with Salmon Meerkat, though Meerkat's opinions changed over time a bit more. Pearl Chameleon is notable for the changing reads, but that's also been consistent with their own style, somewhat. And Azure Mouse honestly has less interactions than I'd expect. Doesn't leave much to work with, but if anyone with less of a sieve-brain wants to look at it, it's there. And it leaves Hyena with more of a reason for the kill. A lot of posts while I was making this so I'll just submit and go from there. What do the numbers mean?
Opal Lion Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 15 minutes ago, Sapphire Elephant said: Well, I read D1, which drained my energy faster than a Hemalurgic spike. Here's my reads based on that. Will read more later Hide contents V+ Amber Mouse, Pearl Chameleon V- Charcoal Hyena, Plum Rhinoceros, Chartreuse Penguin N+ Opal Lion, Magenta Albatross, Melon Dingo N- Salmon Meerkat, Sage Kangaroo, E+ Onyx Flamingo, Saffron Iguana, Amber Vulture E- Amethyst Scorpion Everyone else is null, for now. Can you elaborate on specifically Iguana, scorp, and meerkat?
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Tuatara Really want to hear more from you.
Chartreuse Penguin Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 16 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: What do the numbers mean? Number of interactions / times they brought up Falcon (or Falcon brought up them) in thread. So Scorpion mentioned Falcon 5 times, 2 of which offered reads. (There were a few things I didn’t count, mostly VCs and un-votes.)
Azure Mouse Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 Vote Tally Charcoal Hyena (3): Amethyst Scorpion, Azure Mouse, Fuchsia Ostrich Amethyst Scorpion (1): Mint Heron Chartreuse Penguin (1): Quartz Zebra Cream Tuatara (1): Pearl Chameleon Mint Heron (1): Opal Lion Onyx Flamingo (1): Amber Vulture Pearl Chameleon (1): Sage Kangaroo Plum Rhinoceros (1): Saffron Iguana Salmon Meerkat (1): Oxblood Beagle
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 17 minutes ago, Chartreuse Penguin said: Number of interactions / times they brought up Falcon (or Falcon brought up them) in thread. So Scorpion mentioned Falcon 5 times, 2 of which offered reads. (There were a few things I didn’t count, mostly VCs and un-votes.) Have you done this for ivory dragonfly? Or just falcon?
Saffron Iguana Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 8 minutes ago, Azure Mouse said: Vote Tally Charcoal Hyena (3): Amethyst Scorpion, Azure Mouse, Fuchsia Ostrich Amethyst Scorpion (1): Mint Heron Chartreuse Penguin (1): Quartz Zebra Cream Tuatara (1): Pearl Chameleon Mint Heron (1): Opal Lion Onyx Flamingo (1): Amber Vulture Pearl Chameleon (1): Sage Kangaroo Plum Rhinoceros (1): Saffron Iguana Salmon Meerkat (1): Oxblood Beagle These sure are wagons! Who're the nonvoters atm?
Sapphire Elephant Posted January 7, 2024 Posted January 7, 2024 27 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: Who's amber moose? ? 23 minutes ago, Opal Lion said: Can you elaborate on specifically Iguana, scorp, and meerkat? Iguana is giving me general Bad Vibes(TM). I originally gave them village points for contribution and lack of rules knowledge, but their attempts to foster engagement feel disingenuous and performative. I thought there was more than that, but my notes aren't helping :< Scorpion is subtly defensive through much of D1, which I don't like. They're the 3rd person to jump on the Dragonfly train, upgrading it to something more serious, which is suspicious, especially given the scattered vote distribution D1. Their D1 vote on Hyena is also weird -- voting someone for voting on a gut read is "in poor form" itself, I think. (I might take my vote off them later, but I don't like the Hyena train, so.) Meerkat was just giving me bad gut vibes. Not much more to be said on that.
Recommended Posts