-
Posts
950 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by PorridgeBrick
-
Easier to just post the WoB I guess.
-
Spiritual Realm mechanics of Scadrial's magic?
PorridgeBrick replied to CWS's topic in Cosmere Discussion
Hmm. I suppose you could read it that way, but I don't think an Inquisitor would be in any fit state to burn anything after taking out their eyespikes. Still, it might be worth asking again in some way for clarification.That does sound pretty suggestive. Interesting. I just think we shouldn't say "They can do this, they just think they can't." If it's something anyone can do easily, they're going to find out and use it. And I'm sure they'd notice if they took in Investiture, because the signs tend to be rather flashy. They only feel available reserves, Investiture to use, when they have metal inside them. Besides, being able to just draw power into them without metals any time they feel like it kinda breaks Sanderson's Laws of Magic. There'd be no limit to it– just draw from it whenever you want, and boom, you're all glowy and heal-y and bleh. I agree with CWS. I've been visualizing the process as a circuit of sorts the whole time. Without metal, you and Preservation have nothing connecting you, no way for power to transfer. Add a metal, and now you're 'plugged in' to Preservation's power. Liking the battery speculation here. On Sel, symbols (under certain regional systems) seem to be the battery. In Dakhor, for example, you keep your magical effects even far from your homeland, so there must be power stored in those bone twists that is being used there. -
Could Allomantic mettles be treated as drugs?
PorridgeBrick replied to High prince of geeks's topic in Mistborn
I'm not sure if Spikes count as foreign any more. Once you receive one, it becomes a part of your Spiritweb. So whatever mechanism that checks for part of me/not part of me might just breeze past it. Same way Feruchemical gold probably wouldn't just eject your Spikes. -
Could Allomantic mettles be treated as drugs?
PorridgeBrick replied to High prince of geeks's topic in Mistborn
Hah, great minds think alike. IMO, an Allomantic chromium/Feruchemical tin twinborn is the perfect Scadrian doctor– Feruchemical tin for diagnosis, Allomantic chromium for removing poisons, infections, lodged bits of material in wounds, etc. -
Brandon didn't specifically say savant however. He just said that at high power levels, Aluminum cleanses foreign Investiture and other impurities.
-
Spiritual Realm mechanics of Scadrial's magic?
PorridgeBrick replied to CWS's topic in Cosmere Discussion
He changed his mind on this one I think. Inquisitors can burn their own eyespikes, but it's an excruciatingly painful process. I can find the quote if you want. Ooh, really? I must have forgotten about this one. Can I see the original wording on this one? This seems pretty unlikely to me. You might as well say "Surgebinders can actually draw Stormlight from Honor and not have to inhale it, but they don't because they don't think they can". They probably didn't think they had magic powers in the first place, so if perception was that limiting no one would ever discover Allomancy at all. -
Shardic Number Theory Revisited (Part One - Shards)
PorridgeBrick replied to Tempus's topic in Cosmere Discussion
Wow, that's so full of spoilers. We need more 'shshshshsh' in there.Anyways, I heartily dislike the idea of each shard having a number. It's the planets that all seem to have numbers associated with them. For example, Roshar seems pretty tied to ten, not just Honor. There's thirty magic systems, or three sets of ten. There's the Ten Deaths, the Ten Fools. I very much doubt all those magic systems come from Honor. If each one had their own number, each one should have a different number of powers, but they don't. It's the same in Mistborn, where both Allomancy and Hemalurgy are based on sixteen. For each shard to have a different number, it would mean that only one of the shards gets to have his own number in the magic system. How would that even be decided? Not by power– Preservation is weaker than Ruin due to spending it on the humans, yet Preservation has stronger ties to sixteen that we've seen than Ruin does.- 13 replies
-
7
-
- theory
- numerology
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Check your metalminds. The alloy might be a little off. You probably need a better metallurgist.
-
Of course, aluminum savants can't actually happen due to how aluminum automatically cleanses itself out. So to be powerful enough, you'd need Reverse Compounding in some form or just a spike to boost it up.
-
Could Allomantic mettles be treated as drugs?
PorridgeBrick replied to High prince of geeks's topic in Mistborn
We don't know anything yet that can steal Temporal Powers, but I very much doubt it's a God Metal Alloy. All the other allomantic abilities of the main 16 are stolen by one of the metals in their respective block, so the same should apply to temporal ones. We only know 1 of the Hemalurgic powers stolen by metals in the temporal block, so there's still three metals there as candidates for stealing temporal allomancy. Judging by the patterns of the other abilities, I'd guess hElectrum. -
Current Factions/Guilds
PorridgeBrick replied to Lurthemir's topic in Social Groups, Clans, & Guilds
The Fandom Monster and the forces of Chaos are joining forces. The end is nigh. -
You Know You're a Sanderfan When...
PorridgeBrick replied to Shardbearer's topic in General Brandon Discussion
Huh. That's a good question. I wonder if you'd just get the effect of whichever has the larger charge– if there's a larger Feruchemical store in terms of total Investiture, then you get its normal Compounded effect, while a large Hemalurgic charge would have the normal splicing effect. -
KR power really depends upon the opponent. An Elsecaller will beat any single opponent in an instant, but stack on enough mooks and they're out of gems and Stormlight. Stonewards are wonderful against anyone who tends to fight physically– large numbers of Thunderclasts, humans, Chasmfiends, they can rip apart with no chance of physical harm to themselves, but add a single energy weapon (laser) or magical equipment (Shards) into the equation and all their abilities are useless. Windrunners, actually, seem a little more flexible, not as specialized for one kind of fight but pretty good against most opponents. In your specific case of a KR civil war, I'd put my money on Windrunners. They don't have the instant win buttons of Elsecallers, but I think their numbers should win out, and there's a good chance Plate will block the death rays.
-
Is Renarin the 1st to have Two Shard blades!?
PorridgeBrick replied to metaldragon's topic in Stormlight Archive
Flamestance is pretty bad for dual wielding actually. Yes, you have a one-handed grip, but the way the stance works is that you have your other hand acting as a support underneath the midpoint on the blade, allowing for pretty stable overhead blocking. Here's a pic of the posture. For dual-wielding, what you want is Smokestance. Smokestance is actually specifically meant for two weapons, with a longsword in one hand and a dagger in another. You could probably adapt for the extra length, especially since weight isn't an issue with Shardblades. Here's a pic for that one. -
You Know You're a Sanderfan When...
PorridgeBrick replied to Shardbearer's topic in General Brandon Discussion
Here's a WoB. -
Perhaps it's related to which of their aspects is leaning towards the Cognitive– Listeners could have entirely Physical bodies, but their minds are way off in the Cognitive and need a spren to bridge the gap, while Aimians could have entirely Physical minds, but their bodies are very strongly in the Cognitive, like a more extreme Lift.
-
The Observer's Guild
PorridgeBrick replied to Lightsworn Panda's topic in Social Groups, Clans, & Guilds
Loyalty officially bought. You have your first new member! (Until someone else has a better offer.) -
The Observer's Guild
PorridgeBrick replied to Lightsworn Panda's topic in Social Groups, Clans, & Guilds
Hmm. Kiwifruits and pomegranates. Intriguing... Any chance of mangoes? -
The Observer's Guild
PorridgeBrick replied to Lightsworn Panda's topic in Social Groups, Clans, & Guilds
What's the pay like in this guild? Do you pay in kiwifruits? Why am I asking? No reason. -
The Shroomies
PorridgeBrick replied to SmurfAquamarineBodies's topic in Social Groups, Clans, & Guilds
*takes a bite from a kiwifruit* Aye aye, sir. Anything you command, sir. *takes another bite* -
Uh, wasn't Forgery something he thought up fairly late (after he already wrote Warbreaker)? Could be wrong on that front though. Even so, Forgery is most definitely region specific, and would need a ton of jury-rigging to work. Plus, if Brandon's adding worldhoppers, he's not going to make their magical abilities so overtly known. And Forgery isn't actually any good for forging papers, as these forgers are known for doing– you need a giant seal, a plausible history, and you're going to have to restamp it anyway after a while.
-
SA's colors, I think, will likely be from each of the three moons. The moons are blue, green, and violet, colors that should never occur naturally on a moon. Since we know their orbits are also wonky and artificial, it makes sense that their colors are artificial too. Edit: Ninja'd by Weiry.
-
To avoid metal poisoning, have a Chromium savant on hand. Even if it isn't a metal they can burn, it's still an impurity, and since Aluminum savants can remove any of those from themselves, the same should work for Chromium on others.
-
Witspines?
-
From the little bit we get in the MAG, Feruchemical nicrosil seems to be untyped. If they store Allomantic iron Investiture, they can use that same Investiture to fuel Feruchemical gold, or Allomantic steel, or anything. But they can't just tap and get Allomantic iron– they have to have some Allomantic iron Investiture there already for their Feruchemical nicrosil to fuel. So in you example, the Soulbearer would just get generic Stormlight, unable to use Lashings without a Nahel Bond.
