Mystfall

The majority is just that one post about his reads. I don’t buy his reason for the slip up. And there definitely is a part of me that was slightly annoyed, but I’m reasonably confident I’m being mostly rational. As for the part of Qian being elim, that’s just me assuming that an Elim would try to v!read another Elim. Plus I don’t like how Qian’s situated in the post. Plus there’s the assumption he made that inactivity = Elim and activity = village But yes, I might be tunneling a bit. It’s a fault of mine(just ask Coco)

I’m still confused by Hopper’s post. I’m leaning TUC as village, more so with how both Qian and Grub are on him. Agreed that Illwei should not be exed As for tying the two, my votes already on Qian, so… ask someone else I guess? Not really much I can do. I’m currently not reading Wahr as anything. One thing I would like to note though is that with a thief ( @Archer can you confirm whether we have one? The part in the write-up about PMs happening until one gets exed seems to suggest that but it’s not clear), someone acting weird may not be E!indicative. I don’t actually know how to play with/around a neutral role. The only time I ever played with one was Hoid’s conversion where Archer and I got killed C1 and only managed to not lose by converting Doc

What? Why me? Anyways, I personally don’t like the train on TUC. Especially given that both Qian and Grub are on it. (I’m leaning village on Illwei, and it would be super weird if all three of them are Elim.) Hmm? Oh, your amount is fine. I don’t care for your number of posts. The problem was that Grub called you active - 4 posts is not the number I would call that at, especially since he called me inactive, when I had over 4 times your post count at the time.(edit: the actual numbers like 3 times) It’s just not something I liked. I had other issues as well. And I can’t go after Grub right now, so I may as well get you. (Edit: plus if you flip Elim that, to me, suggests I’m on the right track) …. What? I know I have nothing on the first page, and half the second, but literally after that I’m all over the place. I highly doubt you missed that. That does not seem likely

His joy was so great then When he saw Mayor beyond the fen For he had seen the letter Mayor had made And knew at once that his quest was saved So he went up to Mayor with his big request And made sure he looked his best For if Mayor he could not impress… Off alone he’d be back, disappointing his sweet empress

Yes I’ve been here longer(first game was the Andor one with Drake as GM) but that doesn’t mean I’m necessarily good or experienced. You’ve seen how wrong I can be *here’s a opening for you to post next* edit: though wow, this is my 10th game I’ve played. Time flies.

Yeah, of course okay, just going in order. He’s lumping Qian in with you and Hoid, and remember my very first read skim? You two were the names that jumped out, I think Qian’s posted like 3-4 times, and so I first have problems with that. After that he says TUM and I are inactive. So aside from that I have more posts than he does inactivity does not say anything about alignment(it can if it suddenly changes without an irl reason but that doesn’t apply here). In fact I don’t like that he’s basically saying active = village and inactive = Elim. Because that’s literally what the reads are saying. Especially after he then goes through the people who have posted 1-2 times and says he has no read on them. Overall I don’t like the way he’s deciding who’s Elim, I don’t like that he seems to have slipped Qian into the active group. and I don’t like that he’s being inconsistent with inactive = Elim when it applies to everyone else. As for the part about me going to the people he’s was saying we’re village that’s just Elim Strat. You try to slip in someone Elim with someone people agree with to make them more likely to agree. Add that to the fact that I didn’t like what he was doing with Qian and that’s how I got there

Y’all’s reads are interesting, and somewhat similar(parts of it at least IMO) so I don’t like that. Seems like bandwagoning. Not saying everyone is. But it wouldn’t surprise me if someone is. Gimme a sec to try and figure out the vc … Okay that did not help, Anyways, I surprisingly want to vote Grub. He’s doing the exact same thing Archer was doing back in Hoid’s conversion game. But newbie status says no. As such, I go to people he’s been reading village. Qian Honestly I feel like I have lots of problems with the reads he(grub) just posted.

I’d like to be offended by this, but considering my previous games this is fair My second game is still probably my best one

That’s a different playstyle than I’m used to, huh Interesting

I think you’d prefer me thinking that who I’m voting could be Elim over just throwing out a vote

Pretty much yeah I was going to take the vote off anyways, and I didn’t see a reason to change that even though I didn’t have an idea of who to change my vote to And yeah, I didn’t really get a reaction from him, but my plan was to change the vote as soon as I had a better idea of what was happening. I wasn’t going to get a reaction either way

That incredibly nerfs shardbearers and allows for the play of Elims self NKing in order to make it so we don’t get the benifit of exing them

@Archer, can you confirm this? That’s not how I interpreted that and I think that matters quite a bit edit: Illwei’s interpretation means that if a Shardbearer hits a Elim it doesn’t count towards emnity and that seems off to me

Made me think of a in person game I played recently. I was Lurcher, and after the first round I went three for three with protects(we also got all three Elims out by C4) but I will never get as lucky as I did that game with that

When have I not been trustworthy?

Poke votes are for reactions. If I can’t read your reaction it’s not very useful to me. I very quickly skimmed the previous page, saw your two names, and picked the one I thought would be more useful. And fair, but I did take it off, I do intend on voting someone. Not sure who yet though. And no, I’m not, but I’m never sure C1. In this case I just didn’t see a reason to keep it there. My original plan was to do Hoid, and then once I’d gotten a better handle on the thread switch to someone else. I didn’t really learn much, it’s C1 after all, so I didn’t have anyone to switch to. And I was planning on taking it off anyways, I didn’t see a reason to not do that

I saw yours and Illwei’s name come up the most, and idk how to read Illwei yet so… Fair, I generally hold off PMing everyone immediately. you’re welcome It was a game where Araris was GM, and it was FFA with the killer changing each night, but you could follow someone as an action, and that person you followed would get told they got followed, so everyone just followed each other and the killer either had to A. Kill someone and have everyone know it was them B. Not kill anyone and die because of it So yeah, it wasn’t fun.

Oh, he asked for someone else to get the treasure That means he’s not an officer. He then asked if there was someone who could get it. If he was Elim he’d (most likely*) have a teammate who’d have coached him better. Plus he probably would’ve had a teammate who could use it. To me there’s quite a few things that wouldn’t make sense if he was Elim. Plus this is his first game, so I’m discounting him trying for a derp clear

Idk you so I’m not sure if I count in that or not. Anyways hi though, I don’t think you have to worry about me not being vocal.(edit: I’ve been playing since last October( wow has it been that long?)) Okay, though now that I’ve read through this, I didn’t miss much. No PMs so far(fair since I wouldn’t have been able to answer) so I don’t have much. First I would like to Hoid though. After seeing what happened with the FFA game, I don’t want that again. All I got so far is a derp clear on Grubberfly. I’ll go start some PMs(gotta get through my D1 list) and go from there. @coco.pudding I’d better be able to trust you this time. Okay?

Okay, I’m here now Hoid I’ll be back in a sec after I review rules/the thread and I’ll get something better in then

It’d just be a first of the sun scenario

And of course they only laughed Asked if that was the best letter he could craft. Now Mayor simply smiled at their faces For the Townsfolk soon were put in their places The letter e Its power beyond you me Could control the rules of grammer And change the air into a hammer But the townsfolk got off lightly that day Compared to the rest I’d dare say Twas quick and free of pain A far cry from the coming blood rain

Okay, I’m not gonna be on the shard till some point July 2nd. Don’t kill me while I’m gone if you don’t mind. After that I’ll be back to my normal active self(I should at least) so you’ll have plenty of time to get a read on me. If I’m Elim I’m sorry in advance edit: ack, I almost forgot to change my name. @Archer, I’m Mystic now