Bejarden

Amaram

Roughly the same LoTR spoilers still don’t understand why they gave the ring to a slightly overweight weakling halfling who’s never held a sword before or why they didn’t take the stormin eagles to Mordor Or why Gollum conveniently falls off a cliff to complete a quest And how did Sauroman exactly just forget about the giant tree people who if they wanted to could reck Orthnak And Sauramon is just randomly killed at the end It makes it complete its like saying a book without its ending is good because the ending didn’t do anything except solve everything they were trying to do

This was not the first time I’ve read it I read it a few years ago to He changed, change doesn’t need to be monumental it can be slight, he was resolved in his decision after Edgedancer She still never liked them

I read LoTR last week I read Brandon a month or 2 ago I know which is better Just because something is the first of its kind doesn’t mean it’s the best If this was a fundamental part of my life that I had spent 20 years researching I would say, yes it did She thought they were going to stormin’ eat her

To be very contrarian...Yes We Have Brandon Is The Best Oh Storms they were horrible I have a much larger rant that I won’t post yet Oh ok didn’t think about that Just that the OG village Eragon is in is an exact copy of Rands village but whatever that’s a much more pedantic topic Well that’s change She was more understanding and didn’t feel as much animosity towards the Government

Yes, we have far surpassed it Tolkien was a bad author, using my first amendment rights here, he was bad every 2 seconds another song, no fights and a lot of poetry and Frodo is bad Sam is bad Legolas and Gimli is ehh and Aragorn could have been done better but enough of my LoTR rant Well Eragons more of a WoT knockoff and is better than LoTR an a unbiased level We have Nale realizing he was wrong Lift seeing the world growing and seeing people as more fuller she swears an Oath and stuff

It’s a comic for 10 year olds I’ve actually never seen them Also were not talking about arcs just growth I’m assuming there’s a point to the comic/movie I’ve never watched other than “a guy went around and fought some other guy” What good book has no character arcs? The only thing I can think of is possibly LoTR which is bad and more of a history book Yeah I’ll just say we are looking for completely different things in books

A man that his family dies and vows revenge or something like that Alien that gets adopted and has to learn to use his powers to save his home between beginning and end of story there is a growth of character Would you be content if we never got Hoids backstory? The only thing interesting about him is that he was at the Shattering Im waiting for his arc so I can see his journey So in your dream book nobody changes nobody learns it’s just problem after problem with no meaning to their character? OB was a big world builder that’s why it was dry, no action and not a lot of meaningful growth until the end The character moments were very interesting to me and probably a lot of other people

A story without character growth is missing a key component Without that growth there’s not a journey

Pretty confirmed from Brandon he says he wants to do it 1119

Granted But unfortunately you are plagued by hunger pains for the rest of the day I wish for a 100% on my history test

Roshone

Well the Stormfather would just end the Bond right? Unless you somehow get Hemilurgy involved...

Welcome to the Shard!!! Whats your favorite Non-Cosmere book? Discussing Brandon, his works, and the Cosmere!

You might want to avoid bumping a thread if you don’t have something to add to a conversation

Want to also do some sort of broken magic system like Elantris? 1113

I guess I’ll do Kaladin @Frustration any developments?

I’ve never done one of these before but I guess I could try?

It’s his Surname his given name is not known @Kingsdaughter613

Nazh

It’s all the Shardswe don’t know the names of+Zahel Wyrn

I asked and Tani said Yes But Ok I guess if anyone has questions go to “Scadrian VS Rosharan Post RoW” Thread

Invention or Mercy Or Valour Or Whimsy Or Zahel

Kaladin 100% RoW spoiler

How would a Mistborn get through 4th Oath Plate? If would have to be a Duraluminum push with a heavy metal that the Mistborn has to lug around to even crack the plate And the Mistborn would also need to carry lots of vials And a Radiant that gets within 6 feet of a Mistborn is going to be hit with the Shardblade and a Windrunner is going to outrun a Coinshot