Quintessential
-
Posts
1691 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Quintessential
-
I mean, at this point if we ever do end up on the same team we'll probably have to do something like this... aHAH! So you admit it! jk jk lol ik what you mean. Er... yeah no that didn't make sense. Also I have already explained what I meant by that post! In response to you! You misinterpreted because you weren't looking at what Books said smh. Books stated that "an elim wouldn't put something that they know is fallacious or bad reasoning in a post." My response was meant to convey the singular idea that a villager wouldn't put something that they know is fallacious or badly reasoned in a post either. That's not... suspicious? That's just true? Basically my post was an argument with Books' wording more than their conclusion. Um. You posted the vote-switch back when the only people sus of you were Matrim and Liranil, and they were equally sus of each other and of me. Also Ash was your teammate? Like. I thought that was just distancing? Which would have come off as rly odd to me if you were village, because I was reading him as "null elim" and it was literally for being inactive, a thing which he'd said in blue text he would do, so I couldn't very well pursue it with a vote. idk why I'm even quoting this actually lol Sure lol; Illwei PMd me saying that it was too bad I'd rolled elim again (4 of my 9 previous games were elim). That struck me as odd because it reminded me of some of the things that elim!Illwei had said in the MR--like, at one point I voted on Illwei and she was like "Quinn no stop bussing me" or something like that. Obviously that's not much to vote off of and I didn't intend to leave my vote there for long, but then I was rereading the thread and I noticed the other stuff that I mentioned in my reads list (have you gotten to that yet?) and decided I was happy with my vote on her after all. Would also note that I did go back and reread Illwei's most recent village D1s, and her tone is generally much lighter as village? Typically her first post as a villager would be either a random vote with little to no reasoning (or an RNG vote), or a comment that she needs to reread the rules (though in this game I guess that wouldn't be something she'd say lol). This game, her first post was... not that. Which is in line with e!her in the MR, where she voted me early based on tone and participated in the discussion about roles distribution and such, much earlier and much more than she normally would (and don't try to tell me I was imagining that Illwei, because I know I wasn't--you even pointed out at the time that you were acting different than usual). Nah this kind of thing is pretty normal : P tbh I really wish people wouldn't take D1 banter from me seriously because I've jokingly claimed elim as both an elim and a villager... I got sussed for like half of the MR for a single comment I made halfway through D1 that was meant as a joke but everyone took it seriously for some reason? idk, anyway... Okay see this is what I usually expect from v!Illwei but why? Also, you never explained why you removed your vote from Stick, unless I'm blind and didn't see that.
-
not that this matters for this argument but it's not that I'd forgotten you didn't do reads in the LG when normally you do, it's just that I never noticed it in the first place, probably because I was a little busy trying to make sense of the Mat-Striker thing and then I died right after Mat did. As for forgetting what you do in other games... what specifically am I forgetting? Yes, in QF50 you did the vote-unvote thing, but they were purely joke-votes, whereas your vote-unvote in the MR and the one here are not, so it's... not really the same thing.
-
...even though Mailliw is voting you for literally the same reasons as me? Just, not looking at meta. We're voting you for the same post, and the same specific thing within that post, and I happen to have seen other things too but we definitely have at least one of the same reasons? Which should mean my vote is at least "barely acceptable" yeah? Also who exactly was it who caught elim!you last game? I can definitely read you sometimes, though I've honestly no idea whether this is one of them.
-
...you give reads? D1? I've... I mean, I guess you do, but it certainly didn't stand out to me that you didn't in the LG? anyway, I still read Mat village I just... noticed the difference. Figured I'd say so :P. That's part of what I meant when I said I dismissed it because she's new, so no, you're not the odd one out. Why? Come to think of it, why did you vote Stick in the first place... hmmm hold on I'm gonna go reread that post Edit: you voted Stick for... not voting on Randby? Stick said they were going to vote on Randby and then realized Randby's new (well, sort of new--they've played a few games now I think?) and didn't vote after all. And you responded by voting for Stick.
-
I kinda thought it too, but I dismissed it because Tani's new... idk though.
-
This is true. But like. We're all kinda voting on each other? XD if that makes sense. We early actives tend to form our opinions of other early actives before our opinions of anyone else... which is probably part of the problem : P I am genuinely more sus of Illwei than anyone else, for example, but ig you're right that that could be because she's talking a lot. idk...
-
Already done! Yes, well, when I said that I didn't have me in mind specifically but sure, I suppose I'm as good a pick as anyone. Though if we're not careful there won't be a D1 exe, because currently Illwei has 3 votes and me, Striker, and Stick all have 2. It wouldn't exactly take much for that to become a tie : P
-
Why?
-
This is a discussion that gets brought up every game--the reason that we vote on the first day is that this way, we have information to analyze on the second. If we don't vote someone off now, then on D2 we won't be much better off than we are now, and the elims will have had a chance to kill someone. Also, the D1 exe does catch elims on occasion (including myself, once : P)
-
Hmmm this is true why am I complaining? I'm in the second tier, after all, even though you elim-read me...
-
4. This was a joke does no one understand emojis? Seriously? C'mon, people, this happened in the MR toooo 5. Also a joke. 6. That... isn't what I meant? Books had said that an elim wouldn't post anything that they knew had fallacious or incorrect arguments in it (which btw is not true, I've definitely done that before on purpose). I responded by saying that a villager wouldn't do that specific thing either. 7. Just go with NAI : P if it looks NAI from me then it probably is. 10. alsoooo a joke, referencing the start of the last LG. I'm not going to ignore that discussion if it continues seriously. 11. This. Is. A. Joke. hhhhhh please, just assume from now on that anything I say that has a or or in it is a joke, because it is. 12. Also mostly a joke? But seriously, that reaction from Dannex didn't surprise me at all. Made me laugh because it is a very Dannex thing to say. 13. I voted on Striker, and then Mat PMd me asking me why I had to always make him read me elim or something like that. So I explained the vote. 17. It's D1, of course they're partial elim reads. 22. It was a moment of paranoia that went away once Maill explained. Okay? 24. Okay but seriously, v!me has legitimately died because of bad vibes before, and it's not a pleasant experience. 25. that wasn't what I meannnnttttt. What I meant was "hey, you're doing a lot better in your first game than I did in mine!" because that was legitimately a thing I did in my first game Yeah, actually so am I lol Also, would note that Matrim's "reads-list" feels odd to me. iirc Mat normally just does a list labeling everyone null or null village or mild elim or whatnot. What's with the "Tiers of whether I'd exe these people or not"? Feels hedgy to me
-
lol well it is D1 after all
-
I mentioned that I didn't have meta to read Pyro off of. Pyro responded by saying that it's never really possible to read them off of meta. That's why. Well that's helpful : P When I say people are reading me off of meta unfairly, it's generally not that they're pointing out something specific that I'm doing. It's just "Quinn is sus and isn't matching up with her village meta". Which is not what I'm saying for you, notice. Yes you did. Having discovered that my reads are generally quite ineffective and often dead wrong, especially about you or Gears or Ash and such because I want to trust you, I'm focusing on meta. At least this way there's something concrete that my tinfoil brain can't completely corrupt.
-
That's reputation lol "Rank" is the title right below your name, weirdly enough
-
I don't actually know anyone on the site irl, but Ash and I talked on Discord before I joined and he was the one who eventually convinced me too (edit: to, as in convinced me to join. I hate homophones XD)
-
Hey, at least you're not planning to elim-kill the only person you actually know during your first game, right? which is something that I may or may not have been dumb enough to do
-
Oh! That's why I was elim-reading Books XD in the midst of writing up my notes I'd forgotten why. Thank you for reminding me please don't vote me off because of vibes I'm rly tired of dying early as a villager because I give off weird vibes
-
...reasons for the three of us?
-
Ah. Okay. That. Makes sense. Sorry XD I'm a bit paranoid at times... my Rank is definitely well-deserved.
-
Great now I'm reading Maill mild elim too... this post basically... like... : P idk but A. it feels off to me--like, it feels kind of like Books voting Gears in C5 of the MR. My reasons for voting Illwei are more or less exclusive to me? if that makes sense? and Maill just adopting them without at least explicitly mentioning that they were originally mine feels weird. Also (edit: this was supposed to be "And B." in case that wasn't clear : P) this plus the fact that Maill is actually talking to me in PMs makes me feel like he's trying to pocket meeee XDDDDDDD
-
I didn't know any of my cousins were Sanderfans
-
why does that entire post sound like something I would say
-
I do; it was you conceding that this is the second time you and Striker have gotten into a D1 argument, and the last time it didn't work out so great for either of you.
-
Honestly? It basically is every game at this point. Stuff: Current VC in case anyone was curious: Reading (1): Araris Gears (1): Striker Striker (2): Pyro, Matrim Stick (1): Illwei Illwei (1): Quinn Quinn (1): Dannex My current reads of the people who've posted (not any any particular order within a category--so, just because I list Dannex above Pyro in mild village doesn't mean I think Dannex is more village than Pyro, for example): Matrim: village for the sort-of-mindmeld thing with Striker (I read Striker's post, thought it sus, and then continued and realized that Matrim and Pyro had seen it too) as well as for his elim read of me, curiously enough XD because village!Matrim has a history of misreading village!me over little stuff like D1 votes and D1 fake-claims and D1... well, basically everything in D1 lol. Dannex: mild village for his response to my (fake) elim!Rioter claim. That felt like village!Dannex to me--I can remember him bringing up that specific thing in previous games when he was village. Pyro: mild village for the sort-of-mindmeld thing with Striker (only mild because unlike with Mat I have no meta to go off of for Pyro) Striker: null village. Yes, I know I voted him, and I still think his post was odd (shouldn't he know by now how D1!Gears operates?) but I also think his responses to the votes on him seemed villagery, and tbh Stick and Books are... probably right that elim!Striker might have been more careful with what he said? Yeah. Books: null elim for pure hard gut and I have no idea why. Just... feels elim. dunno, you can just ignore this one I think XD it'll probably change. Illwei: mild elim for gut and for following some of the same... I guess I'd call them patterns? That she had in the only other elim game I played with her, but not in most of the village games I've played with her (take this with a grain of salt, though, because the elim game was the most recent one so it's fresher in my mind than all the others). Examples of this: joking about me being elim (which is the first thing I noticed, and what I voted her for), voting me and then unvoting me and voting someone else in the same post (which I probably only noticed because it was me both this game and last game, but I don't think I've ever seen e!her (edit: v!her, mistype oof) do that), more or less ignoring the major discussion going on (Striker/Mat), and so on. Stick, Araris, Gears, TJ, Reading, STINK, Random Bystander, Maill, Elan: null All 13 other players haven't posted yet, so there's no way I could have a read on them in the first place. So yeah, that's a thing I put together. Enjoy? oof
-
OMGUS = oh my god you suck. Basically it's when you vote on someone purely because they're voting on you. LAMIST = look at me I'm so town. (sorry Illwei, now they know) Edit: I'm dying because I just realized that the sentence you made with them actually makes sense XDDDDDD
