Jump to content

Quintessential

Members
  • Posts

    1691
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Quintessential

  1. "But... what if one of these unlucky people happens to be bait? I mean, it would make sense for bait to be unlucky, wouldn't it? Because then, the bait have the crossbow and we're reluctant to kill them!"
  2. "Here, on this piece of paper I've written Vote for someone other than myself and announce it tomorrow. I love how we're voting on how we're voting. It's so... bureaucratic! I feel like a real, professional dragon hunger already!"
  3. "I know. I decided to vote for myself, and then realized there was a better plan that involved not voting for myself. So to be clear, I will be voting for someone other than myself."
  4. Given that I was wrong about my guess of the Doctor last game, and haven't the faintest idea what half the players in this one sound like on account of them being new or returning, I figured my guess would be taken with enough grains of salt to not be super harmful posted in-thread. Or at least, it definitely should be, since I'm not taking it seriously.
  5. "I have no reason to trust you yet. So I'll pass, thanks."
  6. "If one of the bait is trusted, then your plan fails too. You realize that, right? And why would any loyal hunter be selfish and vote for themselves when the greater good of our hunting party is at stake? Such treachery should not be tolerated!"
  7. "Not true! Because of the first part. We all agree not to vote on ourselves. So the bait only has two votes, because if they want to win the crossbow then they have to avoid having unexplained votes that would make the person holding the crossbow look suspicious. Two of them can vote on the third, but since all of us loyal hunters will be using our best judgement about who we trust to hold the crossbow, and I would guess there will be someone that more than two people trust, it's only a slight advantage for the bait."
  8. "Okay fine. How about this: Everyone agrees to vote for someone other than themself. Everyone also agrees to reveal who they voted for after the crossbow has been distributed. That way, we probably won't end up having to roll a die to decide, and we discover liars more easily. And there's no chance that the bait will try to mess with our plan because there is no plan!"
  9. "You appear to be missing my point; it applies not just to you, but to anyone we agree on publicly. We can catch the bait if they try to elect one of their own without us knowing, but what if they just convince all of us to vote for one of them? That seems like something those nerds would think of!"
  10. "The problem with this is that if Illwei is dragonbait and we all vote for her, she can then get away easily with obtaining the crossbow, "accidentally" shooting one of us, and keeping all of us loyal hunters from protecting ourselves! Also, if we give her the crossbow and she's bait, how are we supposed to hunt the dragons while she lures them in? Think logically!"
  11. "Well, I'm going to vote for myself to hold the crossbow! Why would I trust it with anyone else? and, Ashbringer, you're awfully quiet over there. You wouldn't happen to be dragon bait, would you?"
  12. When Tesse Mourn arrived home, she realized immediately that something was wrong. The door hung ajar, and the entire inside of the house was a mess. In her study, the large safe hung open, but nothing had been taken. The smaller one, hidden beneath the floor, was still shut. The Eleventh Metal was safe inside it.
  13. My reads as they currently stand, for whatever they're worth (probably not much): Village: Quinn, Ventyl Mild Village: Matrim, Gears, Ash, Illwei, Biplet Null Village: Maill, Dannex, Striker Null: STINK, Daisy, Windrunner, Randby, Fifth, Reading, Elandera, TUO, Burnt, Pyro, Bard Null Elim: Tani, Stick, Devotary, TJ, Araris, Experience Mild Elim: Elim: Explanations:
×
×
  • Create New...