Jump to content

Mat

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    7773

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    10

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Mat

  1. Mat
    Alv Fae
  2. Mat
    Would vote tbh
  3. Mat
    How much of this vote is because Araris voted Illwei in the post immediately above yours?
  4. Mat
    I think it was also that you were passing Kas a mask but I guess that doesn't have to be true, technically
  5. Mat
    Very quick thoughts on a few players as I think to give them-- Ash: There were one or two posts from them yesterday where I was like, village mindset. Or tone wise I v read them. Don't remember where or what about but I don't think I e read them as much anymore? Still would exe tbh but I think his early game was a lot more e than current game if that makes any sense. I guess he did have that DeTess vote D1. Fae: I might actually vote here before Ash somehow but it's just a few things, like the thief claim + reclaiming over and over to get the point in yet not having any evidence towards the claim whatsoever (plus even if true works with e!Aman fake claiming thief as he was dying) and then there have also been moments where their votes felt very intentionally placed before almost immediately being retracted with no explanation. Alpha: They passed a mask to Devotary, correct? If so, almost certainly village imo. You could argue it was for village cred, but what elim, when faced with a player list that shows more flipped red players than green ones on day four, and no longer having a surefire protect ability, would pass away a mask to the confirmed roleblocker who already successfully found an elim. Maybe if the elims were in a better spot, but I just straight up don't see it. If we're theorizing a 4 person team, they have an outnumber wincon, meaning that they'd need to get it down to a 2v1. Giving Devo a mask seems like literal wincon suicide to me :P. JNV: I guess is up for the exe because of PoE? They haven't really done anything either way, right? As far as tie breaking and such. I feel extremely vanilla about this exe, if it happens, okay, if it doesn't, sure. Araris + Alv: Lumping them together because they aren't e/e unless it was a 5p team start, right? Due to the spellbook + RB combo. Or one of them had a mask I guess. But anyway, these two sorta feel like JNV to me. Like options that aren't especially pulling either way. I know Araris voted Archer early on but I don't remember how sticky that vote was. I don't like Alv just VitCing and then saying it was for some reason yet there being no outside benefit for the mechanic anywhere in the rules. It feels like an excuse to not participate in the exe. I'll start on Alvron but that's not by any means set. I'd vote anyone on this list besides Alpha tbh. I think everyone else is in my 'won't vote' pile. Maybe I'd vote Illwei or Steel, idk. Edit: Forgot TJ somehow... I think he's hovering around where Illwei is for me. I feel like there was some reason I should be reading him more village but I have no idea what that reason would be lol
  6. Mat
    You got replaced by your roommate lol
  7. Mat
    Did you protect there? Don’t answer that. Actually wait no one died, so I guess that’s a no. Devo, RB target? DeTess, did you have silver bones or a mask? Maybe Steel and JNV are the remaining elims >> Two writers still, cool. Would appreciate a pm if you don’t mind, I’m kinda bored
  8. Mat
    Technically, it can
  9. Mat
    That’s what I was saying, yeah. Still a little confused but I don’t think it matters much.
  10. Mat
    9 names, 10 votes.
  11. Mat
    Probably none, but I also don’t see one where only three of them are.
  12. Mat
    In what world can any elim team overcome a 7 vote train?
  13. Mat
    I mean, if Archer really is e, then what happened/didn't happen D1 clearly isn't my fault :eyes:
  14. Mat
    Yeah. I mean it makes sense, but my brain didn’t not consider e!TKN I don’t think there’s any reason for e!TKN to out himself to kill Archer seeing as the elims are losing anyway though.
  15. Mat
    All this mech catching feels too good to be true but I’ll take it lol Archer
  16. Mat
    I don't think that's how thieves work? They just find items, not steal them, if I'm reading the rules right.
  17. Mat
    You put them literally second highest out of everyone, seems pretty high to me
  18. Mat
    Dunno how much stock I put into that given an elim team consists of more than one elim and Aman was the elim that actually put in the kill :P.
  19. Mat
    @Kasimir if you’re able can you briefly explain why JNV is so high?
  20. Mat
    Are you saying your claim would have been different had you seen Aman’s?
  21. Mat
    Oh, I remember! xD It was a comment on everyone snap reading Fae for claiming— my feel is that having the new player claim the same thing Aman was fake claiming is an Aman move. I think I agree it’s village leaning but I’d be wary of a clear there. New player derp clears only go so far, imo.
  22. Mat
    I don’t think so, no That would’ve been fun, though.
  23. Mat
    It's like you said earlier-- I saw an insane Kas, no kill, and I remembered Broken Survivors before I remembered the retaliatory lurch mechanic. There wasn't really much of a thought process, just some instant assumptions. I think I'm living proof that one can be both elim and annoyed There was one more post I wanted to quote something from but now I can't find it. Oh well :P.
  24. Mat
    Why the heck is Kas not in the first group
  25. Mat
    I think there's a very low liklihood of this given you went insane. Elan confirmed that attacked/protected and attacked/RBd kill both lead to the same result (attacked person going insane), right? Aman seems like the best bet here. Ninjad, I think
×
×
  • Create New...