bmcclure7

I think your forgetting about ruin.

He did break his oaths

Wouldn't mind being part of the white clocks post last battle.

Read the original post

Paleo (paraphrased) Is Wisdom a Shard? If so, how bad does it want to survive? Brandon Sanderson (paraphrased) There is a Shard with a similar intent. The Shard has realized that survival might not be the most desirable/important. Footnote: Paleo later asked Brandon for clarification on this one because he couldn't quite remember the survival part when he wrote it down. Brandon stressed again what the Shard has realized. When you conclude survival is undesirable we call that suicidal.

Brandon Sanderson has state that the shard that fans call the survival shard is suicidal so this fits with virtuosity comity suicide.

It says specifically That he is a Spren

No he didn't. All he said was Prudence sound like it could be a shard name.

What is a corporate exactly?

I think that all dawnshard but produce the torment. Remember the dawn shards were Comands the universe to create life. Seems to me that taking life would violate there intent.

I think he got it in the end words of radiance remember his dream.

I have had this same theory for a while. I disagree that Dalinar lacks the torment I think we been seeing suttle sighs of the early stages of the torment

Are you say there are two suicidal uninvested shards?

Which is why we know it was so called survival Shard that everyone thinks Brandon Sanderson was talking about. Brandon Sanderson clearly said that the not "survival" shard Has discovered that survival is not desirable ( Which is why I'm confused why anyone thought this was a survival shard) Given that it makes sense that this shard committed suicide. From What Brandon Sanderson described it sounds like she just gave up on life.

Bradon never said it did have anything to do with survival prudence or wisdom that just a fan assumption. Everthing he actually said fits the shard in secret project 3 exactly.

I'll take that bet. Remember despite However they might be now when Hoid first knew them they were all glorious and heroic.

Don't think so Bo Ado Mishram would still be an unmade even if free. More importantly she was a source of forms of power when she was free I don't see how it would be different.

I thought we're all taking for granted that hoid has The stone ward honor blade? I mean he is literally the only one who could have taken it and he hand yet has been collecting powers so why would he pass on a honor blade? I don't understand why people are so confused about this?

Maybe not but that was definitely odium's endgame and and the 1st step of that seemed to be getting him to give up. Perhaps he would have only committed suicide but I don't think odium would have let that happen. I would like to see Kaledin and his father interacting with his Some friendly grandparents. Both him and his father can be so serious sometimes be nice if he had a grandfather That was more laid back and easy going to contrast.

We were already introduced to the name of the survival shard in secret project 3

Shallan would have Stayed behind in Kolinar. Design would have been captured. Kaliden would be Odium champion. Dalinar would have a honor blade.

I don't see how grandparents would change his story.

What if Shallan chose Kaliden over Adolin?

For Shallan: She goes home To offer up the fake soulcaster To the ghost bloods. They quickly tell it's a fake. In the last desperate attempt to save her family she offers herself since she she has figured out she can soulcast on her own. The ghost blood's happily accept and begin training Shallan. After a training montage. She is sent on her 1st mission. Infiltrate the Kolin family And make sure dalinar finds the tower. Disguised as a foreign scholar Coming to the shattered planes to study the chasmfends. She begins datting Dalinar oldest son. She succeeds in finding the tower. But must reveal her nature as a Knight's radiant to do it. Her next mission is to Defeat the midnight mother. After her success Jasnah Returns from the dead forcing shallan into hiding. Shallan next mission is to get contact with The Taker of secrets. To do that she must go to Kolonar. While there she Contact adolin Who is there to save the city. He is reluctant to trust her at first but she tells him the truth and eventually wins him over. The rest of it plays out pretty much like it does in the Books. Until the end of oathbringer. At the end of oathbringer Jasnah Attempts to arrest Shallan but Adolin intervenes allowing her to escape. Is back in the tower her and adolin marry in secret. Jasnah Continues hunting for the ghostbloods and shallan. Shallan's next mission is to assassinate Jasnah. Rhythm of war begins Jasnah and Shallan Have been trying to kill each other for the entire year but neither has succeed. She was given a new mission Convince Adolin to Bring her secretly along on his mission to the honor Spren there kidnapp Kalak. She goes along but at the last minute choses Adolin over the Ghostbloods.

Yes she dose right after the "Lession"