BrightnessRadiant

@Hemalurgic_Headshot that is hilarious...and terrifying also where are his ears? lolol @Bridge Boy it's way safer for HH not to claim: 1. If he claims to be honesty than the elims will 100% target him right away. 2. If he claims he's in contact with honesty than they're probably looking for a unicorn who would than be in a heap of trouble. 3. If he is an elim, which doesn't seem likely given that he sacrificed flash without us really having much suspicion of him, than he would be playing a risky game tbh because the honesty pony could literally expose him at any moment. (I don't think that you should press HH to reveal anything else if you really want to protect honesty. If honesty is some other pony than they will be scanning him for sure. If he's telling the truth, you're right, it's a good chance he's already a target so he's in enough trouble already. They may have targeted jon instead of HH to get us not to trust him, or they had already put the order in and the person who did wasn't on at the end of the cycle when HH revealed his info.)

Wow I really goofed the plan, didn't I. I feel horrible rn. @Seonid I'm really sorry! I thought I was supposed to go first and I didn't stop to think before posting.

Prism was back home, painting the moment when they found their first changeling. It was really coming along quite well. She felt a sudden pang of guilt, when she suddenly realized that, if Wormy came in the room, seeing this painting might be very hard for him. She turned her canvas towards the wall, and decided to finish it later. Maybe when Wormy was resting. She was glad that she could give the poor little bookworm a home, after the awful experience he had been through. To find out that your best friend had actually been a changeling? And Wormy was still worried about the real Bracken. He still hadn't been found. At least the changeling had thrown out the white flag at the end. Admitting to his foul play. Maybe he would turn out to be a rare, and friendly changeling. After all, Prism believed that nopony was without hope. Prism started a new painting that wouldn't traumatize her new friend. Her and Razor Shard's first meeting. Not the part where he knocked her down. Or the part where she ignored him, accidentally. The part where he gave her excellent art tips, and she happily took notes on it. Good memories were better than sour ones. ____________________________________________________________ @The Flash asked me to give Wormy a good home in a pm...I figured I would help out the little bookworm. Kindness is always rewarded. Okay so my theories are that there was probably only one evil unicorn, and one of each other kind of pony...but if there are 4 than I would suspect there are possibly two earth or two pegasi elims. Last cycle I thought the elims might be among Flash for the unicorn, Jon or BB for earth, and maybe conatus, Ecth, or Alv for pegasus. Flash is confirmed an elim and gone, and Jon is now confirmed as villager, and gone. That leaves my suspicions on BB for earth, and I'm thinking maybe conatus or Ecth for pegasi since Alv did claim to be the original holder of generosity. (I'm not sure he would have done that if he was evil...it seems too risky to me.) I will join Seonid's vote on Conatus since he's on my suspicions list for now....gotta go eat dinner. I'll be back with reasons for my suspects in a min

Okay I just realized something super creepy I was in flash's very first pm group and I told him it looked like he had placed a lot of smart players in that pm....and now guess what...THEY ARE ALL GETTING KIDNAPPED!! The people in that pm were Joe, Randuir, jondesu, me, and Ornstein! Just saying....look out @Ornstein we seem to be on some sort of kill list! (unless Ornstein is also an elim?)

Okay so wait...pk wasn't an elim? Why in the world did the elims not send in a kill order then?! I don't get it. If it was just to mess with our heads?? Ugh. How are we supposed to figure out who to vote for now? Literally almost everyone voted for pk. Is that why they did it? So they could hide among the villagers for the first lynch? Well I guess we have to do the night cycle before we can vote again anyways so...as I said before this is my first game with day and night cycles, and I'm still a little confused about what we're even supposed to talk about during the night cycle? Who people should use their actions on, I guess? I gotta sleep now, but I'll just wait for others to post and I'll be back on tomorrow to figure out how to join in the conversation from there. Goodnight all!

Yes!!!! Thankyou HH!!...I'm so sorry @Jondesu you will be avenged! I actually thought Jon was evil, but I guess not. In many ways I feel like the village really won this round! @The Flash great write up man! You really had me fooled! Well done for your first game! As many of you probably already guessed by Seonid's defense of me in the last cycle...I was the holder of generosity last cycle. I can confirm that Seonid is village and did indeed pass me the element. I have now passed it on. I won't reveal to who, they will have to pass it on next cycle as well. Thankyou village for not lynching me, and not losing an element!

We all are worried about the elims, but I wasn't saying that I was suspicious of you if that's what you thought. I was just wondering what were your reasons for not trusting the flash? @Hemalurgic_Headshot

@Hemalurgic_Headshot why are you suspicious of flash? you said in your post where you voted on me that you thought if i was village than flash was probably an elim...but why?

@The Flash it would be good if you could defend yourself because I have been leaning village for you for most of the game...I'd hate to lynch you for lack of having a better target and just to break a tie...I would also move my vote to quiver if you can defend yourself.

Okay back to my analysis on a computer this time lol (my neck will thank me!) Cycle two lynch votes: (along with suspicions this time) Randuir says that Drought's asking Straw about his vote on me and then not following it up with a vote of his own on straw looked suspicious. (Kinda elim read on drought for this cuz I agree) PK voted Jon for seemingly contradicting his opinions about pk earlier. (I kinda felt like PK was right here so kinda reading village for him here) I mentioned the fact that we should probably be passing the element of generosity around to the active ponies, so that it wouldn't get stuck with an inactive and then they get lynched for being inactive. I'm wondering if the elims kidnapped Randuir partly because they assumed he might have originally held generosity or that he was passed it because of his plan and how active he was. Although honestly in the last QF where I was evil, I wanted Randuir gone fast cuz he was a real threat to the elims. So, it could have just been because of all of his valuable ideas he was giving. Jon voted on mint for a question she asked about the kidnap. He said it sounded like an elim trying to slip something past the villagers. but honestly why wouldn't she have asked that in her gm pm or in the elim doc? so this vote seems a little strange to me. (this kinda reads elim for me) HH says he would be sad to lose another unicorn if we lynched mint. (This reads village for me because he pointed out that we were losing our unicorns which means we were losing our pms too. So I doubt he would have pointed this out if he were an elim.) HH says that flash's defensive posts where he stated that he was a villager, seemed like an elim who had been backed into a corner. (Flash could just be a new player who hasn't learned the in's and out's of how to react so as not to get skewered lol but HH could be right. Although HH could have been trying to frame a villager by pointing out his mistakes as well so kinda not sure how to read this other than neutral for both unless one turns out to be evil later) After Hero confirms for Rand that there is an elim doc than Jon posts and says that frozen mint could still have asked her earlier question in thread for various elim reasons. (I don't really feel like she would have though. It kinda just feels like he was still trying to justify his vote on a villager. Possible Elim read for this.) Randuir voted for mint because of her odd vote on pk in cycle one where she said that if pk died and was village than she would suspect those who voted for him on cycle one, but then she also voted for him. (this is the vote i was talking about in my last post lol) Flash says he is reluctant to vote for mint just for her looking innocent in a past game and ending up evil( but randuir and Jon hadn't listed those as reasons for there votes. they had just mentioned that earlier cuz they were talking about people looking innocent when they aren't) (Rand also gave me a nice compliment by saying that I was good at that....that might sound incriminating to add that in here but I had to point out that it made me feel good about my playing abilities, especially coming from a more experienced player lol) (but also I would like to point out that this was one of many posts where flash tried to defend mint, and I know he started defending her after she asked him to and said she had the element of laughter, so I'm not really that suspicious of flash.) Of course I defended Ecthelion pretty hard when I was an elim in the last QF just because he asked me to and I wanted to be seen as having tried to save someone I believed was a villager...so Flash isn't completely cleared lol. Just because he is new doesn't mean he isn't smart ;P) Bridge Boy voted for mint for "partly elim-ish actions and partly due to Rand's post about her. (not sure that I really accept those as clear reasons for your opinion on the vote...slightly elim read for this...sorry Razor Shard lol) Okay I'm still going through the thread but here's another partial post since everyone has started posting tons and I want everyone to be looking at as much info as I can give before the time runs down... will continue this post in a bit... I'm placing a vote on flash because he seems a bit suspicious to me, but also because I don't want no tied lynches! Jondesu's posts throughout the game have made me a bit suspicious of him...maybe some analysis of only him will be my next post.

@Hemalurgic_Headshot I don't really understand your vote on me? Is there something I can address that caused your suspicions? I honestly have been doing my best to help the village and I already explained the situation involving mint. Okay I'm trying to go back through the whole thread so I can vote...so far I have finished the first cycle read through and I was looking at who else voted for straw besides me. It was randuir, alvron, ecthelion, and Jon. And before that pk had been voted on (with some people removing their votes) by jedal(removed), BB, me(removed), and mint. Also the people who voted for me that cycle were, pk, drought (removed his vote), and straw. These were the leading lynch targets for the cycle and I feel like at least one elim probably hid among them if not more. Here are all of the votes from the first cycle: Pk voted on jon for supporting rand's ideas. Jon poke voted HH for only posting RP and not any thoughts or opinions yet. Removed his vote on HH after HH responded. Jedal voted pk because he thought pk was suspicious of rand but later removed his vote when pk explained that he was suspicious of jon and that if jon was evil than he would suspect rand cuz jon supported rand. Pk voted on me for supporting Randuir's ideas. And telling him that if he was going to vote on jon just for supporting rand than he had several other people to vote on for the same reasons which wouldn't give him much to go on. (He then switched to a vote on me) Drought voted on me for pretty much the same reason but then removed it when I posted an explanation. BB voted on pk because he said his quick vote on Rand seemed suspicious (but pk voted for Jon not rand?) Straw voted on me but doesn't say why (already mentioned that lol) I voted on pk because I didn't really get his votes on jon, and then me. (I removed this vote later and placed it on straw to prevent a tie) Randuir voted for straw for bandwagonning on me. Mint votes pk for confusing reasons lol...(next cycle she said it was confusing and apologized haha) Ecthelion voted on straw without explaining why. (Besides that he voted for me lol) Jon votes straw for not giving a reason for voting on me. I voted straw so we wouldn't have a tie and lose generosity. Alvron voted on straw secretly with his pegasus ability, but he didn't say why just that he did it. Is that everyone? sorry if I missed any. Okay I'm trying to do this on my kindle and my neck is breaking from bending over looking at it and also my keyboard on here STINKS! lol I will continue my analysis hang on I wanna borrow a laptop from someone in the house lolz I already have this typed on here though so here ya go and I'll be back in a bit...

@Jondesu I was disappointed that I couldn't post about mint earlier than I did, but I had been on SE pretty much the whole day cuz I still had 3 games running (now only 2) and when something came up in RL I needed to put that first. Also I technically did say something about the situation earlier than my last post... in an earlier post I had said that I had reason to believe that she MIGHT be village from pms but that i didn't want to say too much and endanger anyone. I asked mint in a pm to defend herself in thread so that I could see her defence and so could the village...making it safer for her if she really did have an element. I suspected her because she made a pm of entirely newbies and then when she had several votes on her she asked us to defend her in the pm...I was suspicious of her for not defending herself in thread and it seemed like she was just trying to manipulate us. I wanted to get my last post about her out earlier but like I said...RL happens lol I understand your vote on me, because it did look bad on my part. Sorry for not explaining the situation in more detail after she was lynched. I expressed these thoughts and feelings in the pm with mint flash and the other new players so you can ask them to confirm what I've said. I need to read through the thread again, but I'm sad that @Crimsn-Wolf hasn't responded to my earlier post when I saw that she was on today. I don't really want to vote on her without any defence and I also was just trying to prod her to post. I think I'll try to find someone suspicious to place my vote on after I read the thread again. crimsn-wolf

@Paranoid King since I clearly stink at making vote tallies perhaps I shouldn't try hahaha oops....also why are you reminding me of that?? Trying to get me to move my vote by looking innocent with a reminder that you voted for yourself? Sneaky Venture spy

@ryshadium90 haha thanks! Nice profile pic btw lol

I so wish there wasn't a limit on upvotes!!!! These are hilarious!! I think I'll try WoK: I dunno...this is what I got haha And WoR: hehe this is fun Steelheart: Firefight: Calamity: I couldn't help it The Final Empire: seriously though, that's not safe haha Alcatraz vs. the Evil Librarians haha....I still like it though I think I'm done....WAIT! Edgedancer: I love Lift!!....personally she reminds me of Toph from the last airbender

@The Flash oops thanks! I missed cloud's vote! Dalinar-(1) Lopen PK- (9) Orlok, flash, cloudjumper, stick, Elenion, Meta, Ecthelion, Brightness, StrikerEZ Flash-(1) Cluny Ecthelion-(1) sart (vote tally corrected cuz I left out cloud...and I also added Striker's vote from just a few min ago.)

@Seonid thanks! Well that's good at least...Lopen won't be happy though haha (you were really wanting that double or triple lynch in the last QF lolol) @TheMightyLopen

Here is the vote tally for anyone still needing to vote: Dalinar-(1) Lopen PK- (7) Orlok, flash, stick, Elenion, Meta, Ecthelion, Brightness Flash-(1) Cluny Ecthelion-(1) sart Personally I feel like this situation with PK needs to be resolved...I'm not sure what happened on night 0, but his death will give us the best info. I'm glad that it's not close enough for the vote manipulation powers to change it...or cause a double lynch? Is that a thing in this game? @Seonid

I was busy last night....binge watching season 3 of flash haha (not done yet though so no spoilers people! lol) I had to sleep eventually heh. _______________________________________________________ Prism sat in the waiting room of the doctor's office. Another traumatic night had passed, and she had helped add to the trauma. She had been in a bad mood at the party because of what had happened, and when princess Luna showed up and Weaver wasn't taking it seriously she just let loose her wrath by joining everypony in condemning her. It wasn't like me to not forgive a pony like that. She shook her head, sadly. The doctor pony entered the waiting room, and beckoned for her. "Razor Shard is resting now. He should be fine with a little rest, but we'd like to keep any eye on him for a while to make sure. After all, that's a nasty bump he's got there, and he still looks a little pale. How did you say it happened again?" "Somepony pounced on him at Bracken's party." The doctor looked at Prism, over his glasses and asked, "A purple, pony with stars for a cutie mark?" Prism looked at the doctor in bemusement. "Yes..how did you know?" "Trust me, she sends us more than enough patients around here." ___________________________________________________ @Alvron haha you really should be more careful twilight @Bridge Boy get well soon! Okay so... I don't have much of a elim vibe from the people who have been voted for already, so I'd like to throw a vote out there on crimsn-wolf . You haven't posted hardly at all, and while you're doing a great job setting up pms as a unicorn, I'd like to ask you to at least post your thoughts every once in a while in thread...even if it's just a random thought every now and then? (Don't be afraid to share your opinions...everypony is usually nice to newbies lol) It would be nice if you could post who you suspected in the thread as well. I see you reading the thread a lot by your name being at the bottom of the page, and I always feel paranoid when people do that and never post. I'm just trying to get you more involved with this vote, so don't freak out over it lol. I doubt it will come to much, and I'll probably take it off later. But we really would like to hear from you! @Crimsn-Wolf This goes for you too @Conatus

@Evenstar Rose the way of kings is the first book in the stormlight archives series (that's what Lopen meant haha) @Hemalurgic_Headshot we will rule..we will.

@The Flash no kidding here! haha they're all awesome! It's also super fun to have so many siblings who love books, movies, and shows etc. It's really cool

@The Flash away with you, you treacherous fiend! No cookies for my sista! There are 8 girls in our family and 3 guys...and yes I'm serious No problem

Finally a real post for this game! lol Okay here's some of my thoughts about this game: (Night) Couriers should be looking to put trusted villagers in pms so they can work in secret from the elims. (I'm a huge supporter of village pms! The thread is too open for my liking. You can't ever plan anything to trick the elims. Maybe find a tin eye so you can relay his findings and keep him safe?) (Night) Coinshots should be very careful with their targets...we don't want someone being trigger happy lol (Night) 3. It would be awesome if tineyes and seekers could work together! The tineye can see who the target was and the seeker can find out what metal they burned. That way you know the whole story. (Day & Night) 4. Mistborn are awesome (Night) 5. Am I correct in assuming that the metallurgist knows what metals EVERYONE is obtaining!? (but can they really be trusted cuz they are looking out for themselves right??) (Night) 6. Also the thieves have the survival condition too. (Watch them ) (Day) 7. We should probably be careful not to have too close of lynches because they're are a lot of vote manipulation powers...well only two but still lol (who knows how many people have those abilities right?) (Day) 8. The thugs can basically live forever right lol (Night) 9. Lurchers and smokers should probably try to protect the biggest high risk targets...like the people who are pretty much confirmed village or the ones with really great powers for the village. (Night) 10. The hazekillers should probably wait to use their abilities until it's absolutely needed cuz they only get one shot at it. (Night) 11. Captains have an awesome ability to block people we afraid of lol I think I'm gonna vote pk because I don't understand why the elims would risk not putting in their first kill? I've been thinking about it for a while now, and it still doesn't make sense. It does seem weird for us to get that lucky though? Maybe they were hoping someone would get detained and they could frame them, but it seems like a pretty "out there" plan to me. I don't really have any other strong suspicions and the first day lynch is ALWAYS hard and annoying. I want to think maybe we just got really lucky...I hope so!

*Lopen Welcome sis!!!!!! Don't eat any cookies offered to you, ok!?

I agree that the ponies with elements should defend themselves as strongly as possible if they're voted on but remember not to be overly obvious because then the elims might figure out that you have an element and target you...just a warning to use discretion in how you defend yourself. I'm still trying to figure out who to blacklist, but I will try to vote soon. I will be busy tonight so not on too much possibly