Jump to content

Stick.

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3863

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Stick.

  1. Stick.
    Agree Way too long Welcome back, Fifth! Interesting xD Did they say something suspicious in PM? Oh dang you're not wrong IKYK :notlikethis: I don't think she did xD
  2. Stick.
    illwei and quin definitely not elim-elim unless they're just incredible at distancing you're welcome
  3. Stick.
    The vote was there long enough for Books to provide an actual read on Striker instead of not picking a side at all, which I'd say is a win Ah, well, I don't really know her playstyle so I'll give this the benefit of the doubt Said coaching could've been 'vote on one of us for distancing, and then switch your vote to someone else' xD Which would point to Mat/Tani's interaction as elim-elim but I'm probably reaching xD
  4. Stick.
    7 hm it'd be nice to hear more from @The Unknown Order and to hear at all from @Daisy
  5. Stick.
    I actually kinda love how the votes are so close together - this would make for a very interest end-of-turn Unless all three of us are village, in which case it'd just be sad Anyway Tani's votes are fascinating to say the least, but ngl I'm not receiving great vibes edit: all four*
  6. Stick.
    1. At this point I probably trust pyro and striker about the same amount, although I'm a bit sceptical about Matrim now that I know they're reading me village - I'm paranoid and it feels like poketing 3. Not Books, you mean Randby 7. What leads you to believe illwei's vote had anything to do with it? I provided reasoning for my vote right below the actual vote 8. I'm sure you realise that was a joke :-P 9. The reason I took the vote off Books was because I didn't want to tunnel - I know that can get annoying I explicitly said so. I remain suspicious of Books and would not mind lynching them if enough people agree to. However, focusing on one player limits discussion and doesn't provide a lot of info to analyse later in the game which is why I think it's a good idea to express multiple reads - make the thread s p i c y yknow what im saying. Vote Count: Reading (1): Araris Striker (2): Pyro, Matrim Stick (2): Illwei, Experience Illwei (3): Quinn, Mailliw, Striker Quinn (1): Dannex Pyro(1): Bard I'm not feeling super great about illwei, but I hesitate to vote on her because she's the leading vote right now with three votes and if she were an elim I would expect more people coming in to defend her. Granted, there's still a lot of time left till the end of turn so perhaps I'm quick to judge. If we were near the end of the turn right now, I would be almost certainly be convinced that she's village. Right now, though, it's iffy. About Dannex...This post right here set of elim alarms in my head, particularly this bit: But later on they go to say this: Which I feel is something that they would've asked in their doc, were they an elim. But IKYK possible yes. Overall I'm leaning slight village I think. I'm currently reading Quinn as village as well - it's mostly just gut, but also this: It just seems like a very village train-of-thought. I don't see an elim being so passively confident in their false village identity that they go ahead and read other players village purely for sharing a mind-meld moment.
  7. Stick.
    depends
  8. Stick.
    OH princess bride excellent
  9. Stick.
    What's WIFOM? xD Yeah it's more suspicious that they're now reading striker village imo because I had already pointed out how it was elimy for them to dance around a read. But in the spirit of not tunnelling, FlyingBooks I'm still keeping an eye on you though haha
  10. Stick.
    *sweats in Vanilla Village* kidding (or am I ) Well you could, if you correctly predict the night’s elim kill AHAHAHAHA for suree The only vote manip that would be ineffective is that which targets a player who has been smoked/is a smoker with the coppercloud on so all other vote manip would work just fine as long as it doesn’t target those specific players Oh my bad I definitely did mean smokers sorry xD I understand what you’re saying in the first point, it’s just rubbing me the wrong way because an elim usually would hesitate to read someone village when there’s currently a train building up on em but now you say he seems village so hmm
  11. Stick.
    The timestamps say you posted 5 minutes after the thread started, so this checks out Wait so...you agree? jk I getchu You assume it's gonna be a villager I think this is a dangerous assumption to make because I'm p sure I've been falsely lynched in the past just for being a smoker lol sometimes the GMs be sneaky and straight up do not give the elim team any Smokers at all. mmmmMMMmmm FlyingBooks Because of your hesitation to provide a firm stance on Striker plus the stuff about the smokers just seems like an elim planting a seed of suspicion for later against seekers coming up with vanilla village. Apologies if that seems like a stretch or too nit-picky, but it's D1 and I gotta do what I gotta do Might change vote if someone more suspicious appears
  12. Stick.
    But RP doesnt necessarily mean analysis too xD They said 1000 words RP and 400 words analysis
  13. Stick.
    Fair enough @Gears was that analysis pre-game written? xD It would be cool to have an answer to that, but anything Gears says about that now would be completely non-alignment indicative at this point wouldnt it
  14. Stick.
    Could you elaborate on the bolded part? As in what parts of the post stood out to you as bad ideas? I do agree with the reasoning, but encouraging the coinshot to kill N1 is kinda useless because how much interaction could you really even get within one cycle? I think the coinshot shouldn't kill until N2 unless theyve got some solid suspicions Are you suggesting he's some kinda secret neutral role? we didnt have those in the other runs of this game I dont think
  15. Stick.
    An early D1 train is always great to analyse in hindsight after an elim or two have been outed in some way Good content Oh yeah, definitely a possible IKYK always I can see how that may have gotten very confusing xD I was gonna vote on you for this until I realised you're a new player xD so some hesitation in voting is warranted I think everybody else should definitely vote or at least voice their opinions regarding any suspicions Right now I'm ever-so-slightly suspicious of Shard of Reading, but this is 70% gut and 30% the confusion with the whole Pyro role claiming stuff - something about which just doesn't sit right with me. No solid reasons though, which is why I'm not casting a vote on them (yet). I'm also going to be keeping an eye on FlyingBooks - they have posted once so far and it was solely to jump in and defend Gears. Nothing wrong with what they said - just something I'm going to be thinking about edit: I have been ninjad
  16. Stick.
    I assumed they meant someone had role claimed cuz of this bit: I guess they technically could be referring to Kas XD but why would the GM lie haha
  17. Stick.
    You've heard of Fallion’s Tears. Now get ready for: Sunny's tears ;-; As much as Sunny had enjoyed her first time experiencing the ash falls, she was immeasurably disappointed when she found her most recently baked cake covered in ash. (image in spoiler) She encouraged the townsfolk to taste it anyway, for she would've hated for it to go to waste. (image in spoiler) ------------------------- Anyway Hi everyone! I'm excited to get started; there's so many players here I've never played with before! PM role claiming going on already? Interesting You should definitely not trust every person that scans as Village because of the smokers, yes, but I dont think an elim would make a slip-up like this one so early in the game as I'd expect them to be way more cautious of their words than some villager
  18. Stick.
    Always Danke!:P It is MS Paint yes
  19. Stick.
    hiii I would like to sign up as...Sunny Sunny the Dolphin is a worldhopper (but that's a secret) visiting Scadrial because she'd heard of the ashfalls and they sounded wonderful She likes to bake as an anger management strategy; it's extremely effective. Despite common belief, she is not a mistborn however she has a very particular sense of fashion (yes that's a hastily drawn mistcloak (I decided to go all out :P)). I've obviously come up with my own cosmetic role Each cycle Sunny will bake y'all a cake. SEcret ingredients used maybe probably.
  20. Stick.
    Congratulations to Rae, Striker and Burnt! I'm looking forward to yalls non-sanderson games. lol don't worry about it I'm just glad I didn't die to the lynch...That would've messed up my stats. I had the privilege of witnessing one I was already 95% sure of your identity before that, though. Def. I really enjoyed it as well. And the PM with @Elkanah too @CadCom as if your RP name didn't make your identity fairly obvious... Finally, thanks are due to El and Fifth for the running the game! Your writeups were just great.
  21. Stick.
    @BrightnessRadiant thanks for the running the game, it was really fun! Yeah going off our PM convo and general gut read, I figured it would be safest to just send em back to you. I would’ve been REALLY surprised if an elim had started off with supposedly the only pair of binoculars! :0 And good game, elims! I feel kinda stupid for defending Sart so vehemently D1 xD I still think that vote looks very village...
  22. Stick.
    One unconfirmed action means an almost guaranteed outed elim, while more than one unconfirmed actions means uncertainty and doubt, so it wont be odd for two elims to decide not to reveal their actions.
  23. Stick.
    hm alright fair Okeey I guess I'll put CadCom aside for now as I'm not getting much elimy vibes. I don't think we should be lynching any of the Big Three today because Kidpen's like, almost guaranteed dead anyway. We can decide where to go from there next cycle. Plus I believe Elkanah on how RL things prevented them from submitting an action. @Butt Ad Venture Is there any reason other than gut that makes Tinu the highest on your suspect list? I too wanna focus on DeTess and Tinu. Both seem suspicious to me (DeTess more than Tinu), and that's mostly because they don't have alibis for their actions last cycle. also because I don't like how DeTess is still fixated on the Three. Granted, there was an error in a GM clarification and that does justify them going after the Three earlier this cycle, but now it's just odd. I won't be surprised if Detess and Tinu flip e/e. EDIT: Of course Kidpen shows up at the worst possible time and ninjas me xD Regardless, I maintain my village read on him from last cycle. He seems genuine enough.
  24. Stick.
    @DeTess @Twibanu Why didn't you take any actions last cycle? You could've chosen to guard your items, or steal from somebody you suspected of being an elim if you started with no items. Why did you steal from her then? Was it just a lucky shot in the dark? Why didn't you choose to PM her and maybe confirm whether she even had an item so that you won't be wasting your action? Also, if there's someone else who stole from Lemon and would like to refute CadCom's claim, please send me a PM or just state it in thread. Out of interest, was that info info that isn't public knowledge by now?
  25. Stick.
    I can confirm that this is exactly what I’ve been told by these players, except for Twibanu, who I haven’t talked to in PMs since last cycle.
×
×
  • Create New...