Jump to content

Stick.

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3863

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Stick.

  1. Stick.
    If Aman isn't what he claims he's probably just the Troll - could still be neutral and the Troll is technically immune to themself if they can't self-target. Raises questions about TKN though. Edit: My stance on Bookwyrm is that their posts in general have been mildly suspicious but them voting (and then unvoting) Devo for role reasons and publicly contemplating a role claim seemed village. But I'm not too confident because QF64.
  2. Stick.
    Hybrid role theory
  3. Stick.
    Well hopefully Striker can log on and post some more so that his alignment is clearer. Pressure is good.
  4. Stick.
    What was his goal while claiming neutral in TJ’s game again?
  5. Stick.
    Go on, share your thoughts tbf striker can uncondemn himself by voting elsewhere
  6. Stick.
    Fine Striker I’m curious about Walin’s role because they could actually just be the Troll (they softed Troll did they not or is my brain making this up?) and I don’t want them dead just yet. Also not quite getting particularly bad vibes from them.
  7. Stick.
    It doesn’t mention Trolls at all? I think he’s talking about Striker’s claim xD
  8. Stick.
    In that case my role name guesses would've gone in the table at the end of my doc Do like hoarding info as elim.
  9. Stick.
    Ha! I also accurately predicted Ash's role's name in MR56
  10. Stick.
    Oh sorry I meant Penalty Kicks. The Striker elim sentence disappeared off your previous post
  11. Stick.
    So you don't give PKs? Also reverse soothe could just be an extra vote added. Also not sure if the Shard is being weird again but your edit disappeared...
  12. Stick.
    Huh
  13. Stick.
    And Goalkeeper makes most sense as a protect action
  14. Stick.
    There's probably also like...a Vote Analyst (maybe with vote manip), a PM Spider (something like what Wiz claims), and maybe a Strategist (insert some cool ability). A Lurker could exist, which Araris' claim would line up with.
  15. Stick.
    Ah so that's the fun interaction you mentioned earlier. Fair I- Perhaps further elaboration is not needed So you can uncover roles but maybe not alignments is what I'm getting off this. Edit: Troll
  16. Stick.
    I wouldn't exactly say Fadran has been inactive? Oh! Cool. Aman should be able to give you a penalty kick. He also probably knows what it does. Edit: @The Known Novel I do want to know what you were hoping to achieve by announcing the game as not role-madness and claiming roleless earlier.
  17. Stick.
    Oh so they weren’t always elim there? That changes things. When did you convert them?
  18. Stick.
    QF62 was an E!Shining game: I went over it looking for Shining posts in particular and I think their posts there were significantly more substantial compared to this game. @Matrim's Dice you were elim with them - don't you think they're almost a little too detached here? Have there been any other E!Shining games? I couldn't find any. Finding this one was a pain too because where on earth is the aftermath
  19. Stick.
    So you're village-reading Wiz. What about Striker and Walin? I think v!Araris knew that using it would eventually reveal his role too. Edit: It's the withdrawals.
  20. Stick.
    Might as well add pressure to Shining
  21. Stick.
    Ngl your wincon seems kinda hard there’s so many ways you can just die. Without this claim, the elims (assuming you are neutral) would have surely NK’d you soon because elims tend to do that. Plus if you hadn’t claimed there was essentially no way you could’ve discerned who had football roles so it would’ve largely been a guessing game/trial and error sorta deal. Unless they claimed outright…which they maybe would’ve, given all the claims we’ve been seeing, had you not claimed to want them dead. OK MOVING ON U_U I’ll take my own advice and leave this matter for now
  22. Stick.
    You also have an extra life But also I think we can just deal with Aman later @everybody voting for him, either way we'll gain some clarity regarding his role soon and MR56!Devo won't happen again because the same trick just doesn't work twice. So I'd urge you (Steel, Sart, I think) to maybe put forward other votes and suspicions.
  23. Stick.
    He also implied he still gets to use his kills after achieving the wincon, which sounds off. Why would the GMs allow that.
  24. Stick.
    And I third it
  25. Stick.
    I'm definitely inclined to believe the claim, but what I'm unsure of is what it means in terms of alignment. @Araris Valerian are you usually pro-claiming D1? ------------------------- I have reread the thread. Thank you for your applause. Being on desktop helps. A couple of things: 1. I'm actually liking the contributions from TKN, like this post. Him actually casting a vote D1 is notable, though - he has previously asserted that he only votes when he's certain of the player's evilness. @The Known Novel why the change in style? It's not bad by any means, but I'd like to understand your thought process anyhow. 2. Xino and Fadran are probably not teamed 3. I'm inclined to village-read this because an elim probably wouldn't just throw this out here without a solid plan. 4. I am NOT liking the contributions from Shining. Agree with whoever said that they seem unusually detached/uninterested in game solving. Would maybe join that wagon. 5. I...think I'm reading Wiz's dispersed role claim as village? Why stagger it out in that manner if elim? E!Wiz would've probably readied a well-crafted post spilling the details all at once? Kind of like Aman's post 6. Playing devil's advocate for this but the game is flipless. It's not too unreasonable to expect us to never realise until it's too late. 7. *Is thinking about what the opposite of creating a 1-1 PM would be* A giant PM with everyone but the two intended recipients 8. Like, dice rolls? 9. Oooo this is interesting. Are the GMs the Trolls? Is it a randomised mechanic? 10. Gut village on this. Unless the elims believe Aman to be a lying villager, exeing a neutral does not help the elim wincon. 11. Hm not really I assume Fae is mostly operating out of gut reads, so... -------------------------- Based on that: Probably village: Mat, Fadran, Fae, Randby, Wiz Could be village: Sart, TKN, Archer, Walin, Bookwyrm Idk: Devo, Orlok, Bip, TJ, xino, Araris Neutral-claimed: Aman Could be elim - : Ash, JNV, Striker, Steel Could be elim + : Shining, Tani, Dannex That should be everyone. Edit: I completely missed that claim from Steel. ._. Flashbacks to MR56 Archer. Edit 2: @Archer said something about there being an alignment scanner mechanism on Page 1 - I think the village almost certainly as a role akin to that because otherwise there’s nothing stopping the elims from claiming to have knowledge of alignments/roles. For instance, an elim could easily claim to have a role that receives alignments/roles of each player that dies and they could use that to assert strong influence on the game. Without a village seeker-like role it’s hard to see balance there.
×
×
  • Create New...