Jump to content

Clanky

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    1090

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Clanky

  1. Clanky
    I'm not too sure about that. You did have some pretty powerful roles yourself. That said I did expect there to be 7 traitors.
  2. Clanky
    Thanks Wyrm for the great game and your welcome to the Traitors for helping you with your WGG. One thing about this game that I wish would've been changed was how quickly the Forgers died. I was looking forwards to seeing more of what they could do and the Havoc it would cause.
  3. Clanky
    Since nobody was lynched this cycle I would say it stays as a tie with no death.
  4. Clanky
    I never mentioned this last cycle but I normally do at the beginning of all SE games but I don't like Village Kill roles attacking so early. There isn't enough done in one cycle for one person alone to decide who should die. I know that not everyone agrees with me here but I'm sticking with it. As for the three kill attempts: Mailliw: Understandable even though it is rude. Arranae: Voted several times so maybe someone didn't like being voted on? Voted for Me, Kynedath, Orlok and Creccio. Venture: Two players claimed Runners. One talked a lot and would be more likely to garner protection. The other (Venture) didn't do much other than the claim making her an easier target if the Diagrammists want to shut down PMs. Also for today I guess we don't need to worry about getting multiple dead people scanned by a scholar so that's a plus.
  5. Clanky
    Yep it was me who protected burnt that cycle. I had revealed my role to Ada after he was scanned and I was asked to protect her because she had been role-blocked and the last person role-blocked had also been killed by the traitors.
  6. Clanky
    I had said why creccio was suspicious in an earlier post here. Asking how to catch the Diagrammists is in no way helpful to anyone. Do you expect people not to say anything unless you ask? All it does is make it seem like you are trying to catch an eliminator when you aren't actually doing anything. It isn't a big thing but it is one of those things that I feel is an eliminator type of statement. EDIT: Ada is also missing my vote on Creccio in the tally
  7. Clanky
    Except Lopen was among the "Proven-by-Kandra" group. So why would we have focused on him instead of the not cleared group? I understand Burnt allowing herself to be lynched at this point because she couldn't really continue without eventually giving someone a guilty reading. Unless she wanted to give up another of her teammates we would've found out very soon that she was lying to us. EDIT: Fixed missing punctuation
  8. Clanky
    Now this is an interesting vote. You are voting for Ada because he voted for Mailliw based on his vote on Hellscythe. Where Mailliw voted for Hellscythe because of his vote on STINK. Cool Anyways I will be putting a vote on Creccio who seems to be more suspicious then any of the other suspects put forwards so far.
  9. Clanky
    If Elkanah is a traitor we can safely say Lopen is not since I doubt an evil HI would've claimed that. If Elkanah is a traitor and the game doesn't end I will be looking at Orlok and Steph in that order.
  10. Clanky
    "So does that mean that you accept my challenge for the mudbeer duel? I feel that it would be a greater challenge then any of your silly duels where you hit people with sticks" Slalassalas So they can choose any role they want to give to the dead player? Aside from the most important part of this post which I bolded for easy viewing I will say that I will be treating this game more as a typical factionless game. You can still win the primary (more important) win condition even if your team loses. That said if I find two people equally suspicious you might see me gravitate towards the non faction member of mine first.
  11. Clanky
    It does make sense yes. I also don't like how he got you to waste your attack last cycle. But why was he so for having Burnt get lynched? Like the game is far enough along that the traitors probably could have delayed having burnt lynched based on her being a Kandra. If I were a traitor planning on lynching my Kandra I would say that I found a traitor first. Then upon lynching the false traitor they would continue on to kill Burnt but we would have been down one more loyal player.
  12. Clanky
    The best way to find the eliminators is to talk. Same in this game as every other game, In this game it is made more important given the severe lack of knowledge. There is almost always someone who asks this every game and the answer is always the same. That person who asks also ends up a bit more suspicious in my eyes. Honestly I am thinking that people overestimate the power of Thadikar and Restares. If there was PM communication down the line then sure they would be valuable but all they really can do is slightly direct kills to help their teams secondary Win condition. It wouldn't be that devastating for them to die.
  13. Clanky
    What use does a diagrammist have for knowing peoples faction?
  14. Clanky
    I am also wrongly placed on that list. If I were a betting man I would say that Mailliw is a Commander so knew half of the players in his faction and guessed for the rest.
  15. Clanky
    Hmm I assume no because it specifically states in progression "Including Lynch" but in the surgeons description it just says kill attempts.
  16. Clanky
    That is a possibility that they targeted you phat but I doubt it. Assuming you are loyal the Traitors would have no reason to beleive you were lying about being a voidbringer especially assuming that they have already attacked you once on the cycle you claimed Hemalurgist. That leaves you as the unkillable even compared to me and Biggoron since we both could've potentially protected others. Perhaps you were supposed to be roleblocked but they forgot to send the order in? Or perhaps this is just a way of making you look innocent in a very roundabout WGG? EDIT: Ninja'd by Elbereth
  17. Clanky
    Well that was an odd night. Did anyone get roleblocked last night? I will be putting my vote on Elkanah. As I explained during the last Cycle there are only two options for the biochromancer and I trust Lopen most of the two.
  18. Clanky
    Yes multiple Scholars per faction is something that I suspect is actually likely given how crucial they are and how difficult it will be to get the info out. We can't really plan for it unless they get in contact with each other some way. Also Thadikar and Restares only know whether they are SoH or GB not if they are also a diagrammist so that doesn't really help anyone. There isn't really a need for runners to get in contact with their superiors since knowing Factions of people isn't really necessary. One thing that I realized from my original plan is that we won't really need a scan on the Diagram kill since we know they are village aligned, barring some crazy dissent or ridiculous strategy amongst the Diagrammists. So we could change the plan to SoH scans Lynch and GB scans Cook kills. That is assuming that they are discernible from each other in the write-up. EDIT: Ninja'd by Arranae. My vote on PK was solely for RPing reasons. I have no suspicions at this point so I decided I would vote for something based upon in character reasons.
  19. Clanky
    "Slalassalas, I hear that you are a great swordsman and that you have defeated many Horneaters. That doesn't impress me. Fighting is not something to be proud of. Now perhaps if you were to best me at a mudbeer drinking contest then you would have my respect." ----- So we really need to use the Veristitalian Scholars properly in order to gain any info from a death. So I propose that in order to not have them all looking at the same person we should have the Son of Honour Scholar examine the Lynch kill and the Ghostblood Scolar examine the Diagrammist kill. The faction doesn't actually matter but I feel like we should designate somehow to avoid repetition. I know that this doesn't cover stuff like the Cook kills but it will hopefully prevent too much repetitive scanning. Now as for making the scans public that is just as important and more difficult. I'm not sure exactly how to go about that. EDIT: Vote colour
  20. Clanky
    I'll be signing up as Cla, a horneater who barely made it to Urithiru among a group of refugees whose numbers were decimated by Radiants and Diagramists alike.
  21. Clanky
    Most of this has to do with the small amount of people we have left and that if someone was lying about claiming responsibility for an action that they would probably have been called out on it by now. Unless both players are traitors and then it doesn't really matter either way.Specifically as to each of your questions He was very open about wanting to lynch Alvron and a message was put in the write-up calling for Alvrons lynch. I was scanned by the HI when he was for sure still loyal. With you it could be that Lopen is actually the mistborn and you are covering for him but we know there is a mistborn out there and the common opinion is that they are loyal. If someone else was the mistborn I feel like they would have spoken up by now. Yes I didn't protect Biggoron so that's why I say he is proven. Basically I consider all the roles that we know for sure to be out there to belong to the players who claimed it. At this point in the game it is the most likely possibility by far. Also as you can see some of it can't be technically proven without me or Biggoron dying.
  22. Clanky
    Remaining Players: 1. Gaius Tekiel (Orlok)- Surgebinder proven 2. Obsidibus Caesis Dormiam (phattemer) Voidbringer-not proven 3. Volke (TheMightyLopen)-uninvested- no proof 4. Doctor McClay (Clanky)-Elantrian proven 5. Elby (Elbereth)- Proven Mistborn 6. HELLSCYTHE (DeathClutch19) - Uninvested - HI 7. Steph (QueenSteph)-Proven Feruchemist 8. The High Priest of Elkanah (Elkanah)- hemalurgist- no proof 9. Biggoron (Biggoron)-proven Elantrian So based on what I can tell this is what I have for what is left of the traitor team: 1. Bovinus (The Cow) - Uninvested 2. Ember Ghetti (Burnt Spaghetti) - Kandra 3. Arandar (Araris Valerian) - Hemalurgist 4. James T Slade (Bridge Boy) - Forger 5. Wynde Wilson (little wilson) - Voidbringer 6. Unknown Biochromancer-Can only be Elkanah or Lopen. 7. Potential other Traitor- (most likely not a power role) Gives Lopen, Elkanah, Orlok or Steph I would be most suspicious of Lopen except for how he was integral for pushing for Burnts death. That leaves Elkanah as the Biochromancer meaning that the HI has turned. As for the potential other traitor I think Orlok is most suspicious.
  23. Clanky
    I highly doubt they have three with the amount of powerful roles they had. I would say that beyond the Biochromancer it wouldn't be that odd for them to have another weaker role. Say perhaps a Surgebinder?
  24. Clanky
    Well the reason I hadn't voted for burnt was because if we lynch Biggoron and then everyone can find out that he is an elantrian so it wasn't me who protected him. Even if Burnt is evil I will still be under suspicion until we find out that Biggoron is an Elantrian. Since people know that I am an elantrian then they will want to lynch me after the night attack fails so that I can't stop it again. So in other words I am still likely to die if Burnt is a traitor unless Biggoron is killed first which is unlikely given that people don't believe he is an elantrian.
  25. Clanky
    Huh well that's interesting. I almost wish that I were a traitor just so that I wouldn't be killed for no reason. Honestly I was trying to figure out how we could still have a traitor Elantrian and Biochromancer but wasn't exactly sure. Elbereth, I had already figured out that you were the other Mistborn before Lopen gave it away but the traitors may not have. Now since I know that I am not a traitor I will put out what will actually happen with lopens plan: 1. lynch Burnt, = 6:2:1 2. attack someone with our Mistborn(but will be blocked as I will protect myself and Biggoron will protect himself), eliminator kill, = 5:2:1 3. lynch Clanky (Because you will kill the person you think you cannot kill with a mistborn) = 4:2:1 4. attack Biggoron at Night(Get blocked), eliminator kill, = 3:2:1 5. lynch biggoron. = 3:1:1 6. Attack ??? at night, eliminator kill= 1-1-1 Lose!!! or 2:0:1 Win!!! Now this could go differently if I decide not to protect myself at night to allow you to kill me but you won't trust that I would actually leave myself unprotected. I also have a new theory of Biggoron being a loyal elantrian, Lopen being a traitor biochromancer and Burnt being a traitor Kandra! It's one of the only ways that I can see this actually working. I know that no-one will take anything that I say seriously but I figure that I should try anyways. For anyone who also played in LG14 I will just put out there how similar this is to what happened to me in that game.
×
×
  • Create New...