Jump to content

Clanky

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    1090

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Clanky

  1. Clanky
    Ummm so because you don't have any read on me that makes your (lack of) suspicions unbiased? I'm not sure how to respond to this..... ummm sorry I guess? Also the reason that the thread is being steered towards SD is because that is who most people are suspicious of and we kinda need consensus to have any hope in this lynch. By the way how is it unbiased to change your vote from your main suspicion to their main suspicion? Do you just suddenly trust Lopen now? One more thing, In case you haven't noticed absolutely nobody has caught an eliminator yet not just you so I wouldn't be too hard on yourself for that.
  2. Clanky
    Kyn is the one player that I have been suspicious of all game, I didn't just throw him in on a whim (which I may have kinda done for Elbereth cause I couldn't really think of who else fit with the other three). In fact my whole list is basically based upon Kyn being a trader. You and another trader who is also influential moved both the votes off of Kyn last cycle. Now that I think more about it one of the trader influentials could be out of uses by now if they did one of the earlier vote changes as well. Also why would it be impossible for the traders to start with two messenger aviar? It isn't the most powerful aviar and since you can't do the trader kill at the same time as use aviar that would also limit how much they would even use it. If it were death sight, mind force or observant I could understand but messenger isn't that important that the traders can't have two. EDIT: Lopen SilverDragon. I don't mind lynching SD instead as long as enough other people go along with it.
  3. Clanky
    Klyn was sitting at the bar again when he heard about Embers death. He hadn't really known her, just seen her for the first time the previous night so naturally his first instinct was to have a drink. However to his dismay he realized it was empty. How does this keep happening? I swear I've told the bartender to not let this glass ever go dry! Well now that it's empty I should probably change drinks. Perhaps something strong to mourn the death of Ember? But everyone is also talking about how successful the mission was last night so I should get something celebratory! Hmmm, such a tough decision... Well I guess there really is only one option then. "Bartender, I would like a glass of your finest whisky, neat, and also a bottle of champagne for us to celebrate the successful mission!" ----- So no real thoughts to add at this point, sorry for not voting day 1, had to study and then kinda forgot about it. Not surprisingly at all the mission succeeded.
  4. Clanky
    just thought The reason I voted for Lopen was because he already had two votes on him. It's fine to have discussions divided. You can't just agree on everything then there would be nothing to promote discussion. All I'm saying is that when the final votes are set we hopefully will all be on the same page. I would be fine with lynching SD also but with lopen already having two votes on him (one by PK a proven good) I figured that was where most people were thinking especially since I think they are both traders it doesn't matter too much which is lynched first. easily
  5. Clanky
    @Lopen. Wow you really don't have very much on me at all. So because of one post that was defensive of SD you have decided that me, SD and Hellscythe are all traders. Here is the post that he is talking about by the way. In that post I called out Elkanah and Lopen for some shoddy reasoning for their votes. The only reason SD was up for lynch at the time was because lopen said he was "supposedly lurking". That was the only reasoning he gave in that post even though you had time for a major discussion on a bunch of players that same cycle you couldn't think of a better reason than that. I think it was valid to question why someone was getting lynched based on someone saying that they "supposedly lurked" or that "there was a two vote bandwagon" on maill. just thought think promote easily might I will say that I do find it likely that SD is a trader who gave away all the aviar to teammates so he didn't have to worry about hiding his code and could just skulk around all game. However I think that you are also a trader Lopen, along with Kyn and I suppose Elb works best with that. So my main problem with this is that you chose me as the one of your trader lists as the one to try and lynch. Other than the personal reasons of not wanting to die this would be a troubling choice for a trapper to make. Firstly we need a consensus on who to kill today, we can't have a split vote. So you chose the player that nobody has voted for all game as the one you think you should try and kill? Instead of someone like SD who people have been suspicious of all game? However since as a trader you only need one more kill and have two more uses of vote manipulation left you only need to have the opinion split between players in order to win the lynch. Voting is key this cycle everyone, we need a consensus to have hope of even winning this lynch. I believe that Lopen is trying to split the lynch cause he knows that they can easily take over the lynch if we don't have a consensus. So please vote everyone. Also I was going to post this last night but I kinda forgot about it and went to sleep instead, I think it might have been said already but I figured I'd place it anyways. Except the Trader kill takes up an action. So he can't hide and use the kill on the same cycle. Also In order for us to win we need one of the traitor kills to be blocked. If Ada has Hidden and there are four traitors left the best way would be to force him to use hidden when he is the last one left specifically so that he can't use the kill and has to hide. If we do that now a different trader can use the kill instead of Ada while he is hidden @ SilverDragon: That post was decidedly unhelpful if you are actually going to change anyones mind about you being a trader you will have to do a bit more than that. EDIT: Somehow I missed SD saying he was sick/busy in RL, sorry about that. Hopefully you get better soon. EDIT2: Vote Colour
  6. Clanky
    So you had two uses of influential then. @Lopen did you also have two uses? The thing is that if he is an eliminator and does have Hidden than lynching him will basically guarantee us a loss. Assuming there are 4 traders (hopefully there's not) that means there are only 5 trappers left. So if we fail this lynch and they succeed with the kill then it's over. just thought I am still suspicious of Kyn and all that vote movement makes me almost certain that there is a influential trader out there. The only influential we know of other than PK who is cleared is Lopen. So I think that there is a possibility that they are both traders and probably just hoping to split the vote between them to make a tie with what's left of the influential (if any is) or they are just planning on splitting the votes so the whole team can come on at the end of the cycle to all move their votes to someone else? I don't really know and since this lynch is of utmost importance I think it might be best for me to wait a bit to place a vote.
  7. Clanky
    I'm not sure why you shouldn't. There may not be too much we can actually gain from it since there's a possibility that their might be lies in their if he's an eliminator since there's the possibility he used the Trader kill instead of the messenger aviar and claimed to have just contacted another traitor so that you wouldn't know he actually didn't message anyone.
  8. Clanky
    At least at the beginning they will. When we near the end game they will probably use it to get the extra kill but that's a problem for another time (when most of us will be dead anyways).
  9. Clanky
    I'm not sure how I feel about cycling the mission players in a predetermined fashion. I know that in resistance it is a terrible idea but this is a different game completely. I still am not sure on the best way to use it. I do know that if the eliminators know ahead of time when they will be on missions they can plan accordingly which is something that I don't want. Also I will volunteer to go on the mission since I have a midterm tomorrow anyways so probably won't be too active even if I'm not on a mission.
  10. Clanky
    Ah, that makes sense. The way she worded it made me think that you had guessed her code not the other way around. just thought Sure I guess that makes sense, but by that logic everyone who ever places a second (or third, or fourth etc) vote is a possibility. I did state my own reasons back on cycle two as to why Kynedathand the whole Sori claim seemed off. Anyways, hopefully it never comes to that.
  11. Clanky
    I do still think that Kynedath is especially suspicious from the whole Sori thing back on cycle one but everyone else just seemed to agree that both him and STINK were good. My posts from al the way back on cycle two still stands about all of his posts seeming quite scripted and very calculated. While I don't really agree with Ada saying to kill me if Kynedath is good since everyone is wrong about lynches all the time and I think it might be a bit presumptuous to assume I'm evil because of that. Howevever I do think Kyn is my top suspect at the moment and if he is evil it will promote a lot more useful discussion then someone who has been fairly inactive recently, not that I'm talking about anyone specific. Cough, cough mailliw, I'm still expecting that more discussion tomorrow that you promised yesterday, hopefully that is still a possibility. I just thought i could easily take a look at something like that. Sorry if i missed something earlier but how do you know it was Hellscythe who took your aviar? Did he mention it in the thread at some point? especially
  12. Clanky
    Klyn, didn't look up from his drink when the fight started or when the coins started flying around the room. It was a nice stout that he had never tried before but it tasted like something that would be brewed by Heron Industries. Say what you want about the megacorps but they do make some good booze. Klyn hadn't decided to become HISSless because he hated the Megacorporations or thought they were evil. Nope his reasons were much more important then that. The Megacorporations don't allow you to have anything from any of the other Megacorps. That meant he had been stuck with only the possibilities of trying one tenth of all the alcohols out there! It was absolutely ridiculous. How could anyone expect to retain the loyalty of their "employees" if they had such oppressive restrictions! Klyn noticed that there was some sort of video playing at the end of the bar but only caught the last part of the speech: "......I wish to note that I will require any participants in tonight's attack to be sober, and that being drunk all the time will not endear me to you. We have ways of sobering you up, and they are not pleasant. I trust you will not disappoint me.” Attack? Sober!?! what kind of party is this! I'm just here cause I heard about the free bar! ------ Just thought I'd actually get the character introductions going on since I hadn't even chosen a name yet. I think that the whole Resistance aspect of this game will definitely be interesting but we can't use mission passes or failures as our only way of finding players. There will only be four out of all the players even participating in them. So that could cause some major assumptions that may not be right especially since the traitors are likely to pass the first few missions regardless. I will ask that whomever is making the parties that they need to pick active players since If somebody doesn't respond they will vote for the mission to fail, assuming they are loyal. EDIT:That is the most important thing especially since we will not be notified as to why the mission fails.
  13. Clanky
    Firstly some thoughts about Lopens plan: just thought I might continue to promote highlighting especially through white text code hiding. While I can see how it can easily maximize the "coverage" of players so to say. I actually think it might actually be more helpful to the traders. If people actually follow this plan then the traitors can choose which aviar they wan't to have to deal with. If they are worried about being discovered/or people being partly cleared by being shown to have protection then they can just attack players in the Mind Force section since they won't be observed or have a failed attack revealed. I'm not sure I want the traitors being the ones who can make the choices like that. Also there is always a chance of the traitors encountering those aviar anyways. we just haven't had much luck with it yet except for maybe Adas hidden. Also I will be placing my vote on Maill. He has really been out of the spotlight all game which I find quite odd. HE hasn't been posting much recently and all of his recent posts have barely had any content at all. Just a bunch of one liners especially since he had that vote moved off of him. EDIT: Vote colour
  14. Clanky
    Not really much true discussion. Does anyone actually want to talk about alcohol" Anyone a beer connoisseur? Or whiskey? I just really like talking about beer so I don't consider this really a lot of discussion about alcohol. I have played resistance about 10 times but IU have never been a spy! It's so annoying So I don't really have much actual important discussion to put here but I just thought I would let people know I'm actually paying attention to this game. I will agree that this is what I expect from Kyn since he has done the same things in MR11. I also haven't quite come up with a character yet but I will soon. Hopefully when I've done my midterm I'll have the time to do some real RP.
  15. Clanky
    Well these codes are really not helpful/useful to anyone else but I understand why they are happening. I think it might be best to just ignore it. If Kyn and Lopen were both traders they wouldn't need to discuss with codes if they could just easily talk in a doc. just thought helpfully especially promote Also I just thought that I could promote some discussion by doing a code sentence, especially since I've never tried to hide my code in something like that before. Aka the only reason for doing this was to get my code in here and hopefully get people to guess incorrectly on one of my three fake words if they do decide to take a look at this. take a look please, just don't guess my code wrong unless you are a trader.
  16. Clanky
    might It's not necessarily that an eliminator would try and prove an innocent to be innocent, but that they are claiming a guaranteed good role and if Water were to die then he would be a bit more innocent seeming. promote Why is everyone just so fine with lynching polking without really discussing anything else? Nobody seemed especially keen on lynching STINK or Kyn for Sori claims but now everyone easily agreed on polking and nobody thinks something like that is weird. thought just While I think it might be a good thing to confirm some good players but I'm just wondering about other players change of heart and if anyone actually thinks polking is a trader.
  17. Clanky
    just thought Sorry that last sentence didn't come out like I thought it did. Well I don't necessarily believe that you aren't influential it was supposed to say something more likethatthis: "I do find it odd for Maill to have had a vote moved off of him to Hell instead of Elkanah if the true purpose was only just to help him survive."
  18. Clanky
    like that I'm no GM but I highly doubt two roles are possible. I would not be surprised to find that one or both of Mail/SD are influential. It is easily the best way of explaining things especially since it's impossible to prove anything at the moment. I do find it odd for Maill to have moved a vote off of him to Hell instead of Elkanah if the true purpose was only just to survive. think
  19. Clanky
    promote I'm pretty sure that you just answered your own question there. Maill isn't the kind that will just lay down and let you easily kill him. Besides if I recall correctly I think your vote had something to do with "SD supposedly lurking", voting to save ones self sure seems like a more reasonable vote then supposedly lurking. This does tempt me to put a vote on you but there's not really any threat to you at this point and I have an equally guilty player of the same thing as you down below who happens to already have a vote on them. Once again I would say the reason is because Dragon probably doesn't want to die either, also Maill had just made a cryptic post about waiting to kill him. I wouldn't say that this is any sort of bandwagon really, It is two people tied with a relatively small amount of votes (3) with another player at 2 votes. At the time Maill voted there was only one other vote on SD, how is two votes a bandwagon? I find that the word 'bandwagon' is starting to just get thrown out more and more as a way of scaring people away from voting. If you really want to stretch the term bandwagon to someones vote I would say take a look at yourself Elkanah.easily promote EDIT: While I think it might be a little too late in the cycle for this I would just like to point out that we have 12 out of 15 people voting this cycle! That's a pretty good percentage so kudos to everyone on that but I would really like to see everyone placing a vote this cycle. I can't recall a time I've seen everybody vote with this many people left but I personally would enjoy it. So last three people lets see some votes! Yay for voting and white text!
  20. Clanky
    So I'm back much earlier and also way more sober than I expected tonight so I will be able to participate a bit more than expected. Probably You should actually probably red Maills name if you want to put a vote on him. Just thought I'd let you know it would really suck to get lynched because of something like that.
  21. Clanky
    I'll be joining this game, I don't have any sort of name or anything thought up yet so I will be back in the future to hopefully fill some of that stuff in.
  22. Clanky
    just thought easily Lurking is bad because we can't really figure out what someone is thinking easily if they don't talk. Talking helps us find out whether you are good or not, so really it doesn't help yourself and it doesn't help anyone else either. Probably The Arraenae lynch didn't really have much basis as far as suspicions go. She said something about a Sori with a messenger being unlikely and about the possibility of all three of STINK, PK and Kyn being traders. Hell jumped on her because of those two things and Lopen did next because of that same post being suspicious. PK didn't really say much about his reasoning for his vote and I think it might have been partly because he doesn't want one of his Sori claimers to get killed. So there is at least some basis behind the lynch and I don't think we can assume any of the voters on it are eliminators unless we find out that either STINK or Kyn is a trader. They were the two players most likely to get lynched prior to Arraenae coming up so I could possibility of one (I doubt more than one would risk themselves) trader having voted for Arraenae to protect their teammate like that. I won't be placing a vote right now because I haven't really had time to look over too much of the end of last cycle or the beginning of this one too much, I also might not make it back online before the end of the cycle if I need to change my vote. like that
  23. Clanky
    Isn't the first Ideal of the GM order "I will do everything possible while maintaining the integrity of the game to troll the players so that they accept nothing at face value but also know that absolutely anything can and is possible."?
  24. Clanky
    May I ask why exactly Kyn and STINK are proven? Also the lynch definitely isn't set yet. It's just that all the discussion has been around PK and his Soris so that is also where all the votes have went as well.
  25. Clanky
    Ok so I have decided to put my vote on Kynedath. While I know it is possible for there to be two Sori's and that theoretically they could both have the same mentor the odds of that coming up from randomly choosing mentors are pretty steep. That's not enough for me to think he's evil but it's still weird. Also the main thing I immediately would think to do if I were a trader with a Messenger aviar this game would be to claim Sori to someone, especially with their being no seeking roles to check any of this. Also I know that I've played a few other games with Kynedath but I can't really recall his normal play style but in this game all his posts have seemed to be very polished as if he was working very carefully on them as not to slip up. If we kill Kyn then either PK would be cleared or we would've found a trader, still a win-win. EDIT: Sorry about that kyn
×
×
  • Create New...