It seems you finally made this poll, also, some points to consider:
Rioting emotion would actually be very bad for most Jedi, the same thing for soothing a sith. Unless you are talking about Revan, then he would win either way.
Also, isn't atium kind of like the glimpse of the future force sensitives see in a fight, except kind of more exact and reliable?
I just realized something, a fight between inquisitors would be interesting, steel inquisitor vs. sith inquisitor.