Kingsdaughter613 she/her Posted December 15, 2020 Posted December 15, 2020 So after accidentally detailing another thread, @GroundPetrel and I decided to make this an official thread of its own. This idea started with a simple premise: If Kelsier ever took up the Shard of Whimsy he would be the Q of the Cosmere. Naturally, that makes Hoid Guinan, and from there it spiraled. After all, if Star Treck were Cosmere, who would be Picard? (Jasnah.) Our current NG cast: Kelsier + Whimsy = Q Hoid - Guinan Jasnah - Picard Marasi - Riker? ? - Doc Crusher MeLaan - Wesley Crusher Lirin - Dr. Pulaski Steris - Data Rlain - Worf Azure - Tasha Yar Dalinar - O’Brien Navani- Keiko Gavinor - Molly Ranette - Geordi Adolin - Deana Fourth Bridge - The Enterprise Sequence - Lore Odium’s forces - the Borg. Feel free to suggest your own ideas! Stories and fan art are welcome. 2
Dreamwa1ker she/her Posted December 15, 2020 Posted December 15, 2020 (edited) Love this! Whimsy shard in general does make me think of Q so I like the premise. Hoid as Guinan is perfect. 40 minutes ago, Kingsdaughter613 said: Jasnah - Picard Picard - Jasnah fits in a lot of ways (Renaissance man/woman, rational, enlightened leader, high ideals of equality) but Jasnah seems a tad ruthless compared to tv Picard. Maybe she's First Contact movie Picard Also I submit: Raboniel - that scientist that kills the Crystalline Entity, using a resonance/tone no less Edited December 15, 2020 by Dreamwa1ker 1
GroundPetrel Posted December 15, 2020 Posted December 15, 2020 Still pulling for Shallan as Riker! (because I'm a Shallan/Adolin shipper...and a Kaladin/Adolin shipper...and a Shallan/Kaladin/Adolin shipper...and a Kaladin/happiness shipper...I have a problem) Though less of a jerk obviously. Shallan wouldn't be mean to Barclay. Also Kaladin has a lot of grouchy warrior stoic traits that would go well with Worf, IMO. Oh and when I suggested MeLaan as Wesley, I meant that MeLaan is basically a walking self-insert fanfic of herself, which I adore, and so she'd be what Roddenberry intended Wesley to be (the character who everybody loves just like the creator does because of how cheerfully awesome they are). For DS9: Sazed/Harmony - Captain Sisko, a man of incredible self-control but boundless power, who once punched Q in the face for being an asshole. Vin - Kira Nerys Elend? or TenSoon? - Odo Turi Sebarial - Quark, and unapologetic about it. Spook - Nog (local street kid makes good) Siri? or Sarene??? - Ezri Dax (Marasi or MeLaan could also probably be the Jadzia lol) Renarin? or Raoden? - Bashir Hrathen? or Venli? - Elim Garak, Former Cardassian Oppressor Sadeas - Gul Dukat, walking barrel of ooze the Lord Ruler - "Female" Founder Leshwi - Third Remata'klan (from the episode Rocks and Shoals) Wayne??? - Jake Sisko (I would also have Aesudan be Janeway, but that's just because Janeway is so inconsistently written she commits multiple counts of treason and war crimes and the mostly-male writers tried desperately to cast these as good things because they were afraid that writing a female character with actual flaws that get called out by other characters would get them accused of sexism)
Recommended Posts