+Oltux72 he/him Posted February 7, 2020 Posted February 7, 2020 3 hours ago, Karger said: I don't believe in perfect understanding. The world's greatest experts on morality still learn new things or how to consider new situations. As such I do not think anyone would actually achieve the 5th ideal if that was true. You don't have to understand everything. You have to understand your choices or ways. Like Szeth, should he swear the 5th ideal, will need to understand why he picked Dalinar and chose to cleanse Shinovar. And then he would need to act as Dalinar and his crusade would require him to act even without their explicit guidance. However, I would caution to reason based on one example extending to the other orders. For all we know the underlying principle behind 5th ideal could be as simple as: Understand the reason behind the ideals and act accordingly.
Karger he/him Posted April 3, 2020 Author Posted April 3, 2020 On 2/7/2020 at 3:36 PM, Oltux72 said: However, I would caution to reason based on one example extending to the other orders. For all we know the underlying principle behind 5th ideal could be as simple as: Understand the reason behind the ideals and act accordingly. That is essentially what I have been trying to get at but a much better way of putting it.
Skaromas he/him Posted April 5, 2020 Posted April 5, 2020 I really like the theory and I completely works with the shown oaths. It also fits the way each order is shown so far.
Karger he/him Posted April 5, 2020 Author Posted April 5, 2020 1 hour ago, StoneBound said: I really like the theory and I completely works with the shown oaths. It also fits the way each order is shown so far. Thanks! 1
animalia Posted June 19, 2020 Posted June 19, 2020 For fourth ideal of Windrunners, how about "Be a hero to the one you can save"? 1
Karger he/him Posted June 19, 2020 Author Posted June 19, 2020 2 hours ago, animalia said: For fourth ideal of Windrunners, how about "Be a hero to the one you can save"? That could be it although my pattern suggests otherwise. Also wouldn't have Kaladin have already sworn that? 1
animalia Posted June 19, 2020 Posted June 19, 2020 2 hours ago, Karger said: That could be it although my pattern suggests otherwise. Also wouldn't have Kaladin have already sworn that? Not if he thinks it’s along the lines of “I will accept I cannot save them all” while they are technically the same thing the feeling of it is different. It would make a big deal, ESPECIALLY to Kaladin. 2
Karger he/him Posted June 21, 2020 Author Posted June 21, 2020 On 6/19/2020 at 7:50 PM, animalia said: Not if he thinks it’s along the lines of “I will accept I cannot save them all” while they are technically the same thing the feeling of it is different. It would make a big deal, ESPECIALLY to Kaladin. Well reasoned. 1
rosin_the_beau he/him Posted July 8, 2020 Posted July 8, 2020 @Karger Since we have new information about the orders of Knights Radiant, and a way of "sorting" ourselves into them, we should have members of each order review the Oaths as you present them, all in the framework of your pattern of oaths. Having people whose mindset aligns with the order talk about the Oaths will help shed a little bit more light about how the orders think and what they would want to do. I've taken the liberty of applying my Truthwatcher views to the Truthwatcher ideals already, anyone else onboard? 2
Ascendance Posted July 8, 2020 Posted July 8, 2020 (edited) On 6/19/2020 at 5:50 PM, animalia said: Not if he thinks it’s along the lines of “I will accept I cannot save them all” while they are technically the same thing the feeling of it is different. It would make a big deal, ESPECIALLY to Kaladin. I completely agree. However, the last Ideal ended with "so long that it is right." I think it's logical to assume that the next Ideal would show what is right or why it is. In the end, I believe that the Fifth Ideal of the Windrunners will be "I will protect." He wouldn't need a reason to protect anyone. Edited July 8, 2020 by Ascendance 1
Karger he/him Posted July 8, 2020 Author Posted July 8, 2020 32 minutes ago, rosin_the_beau said: @Karger Since we have new information about the orders of Knights Radiant, and a way of "sorting" ourselves into them, we should have members of each order review the Oaths as you present them, all in the framework of your pattern of oaths. Having people whose mindset aligns with the order talk about the Oaths will help shed a little bit more light about how the orders think and what they would want to do. I've taken the liberty of applying my Truthwatcher views to the Truthwatcher ideals already, anyone else onboard? If you can find reps from the other nine I will be open to them. I enjoyed your work on Truthwatchers. 2
Chiberty Posted July 9, 2020 Posted July 9, 2020 5 hours ago, Karger said: If you can find reps from the other nine I will be open to them. I enjoyed your work on Truthwatchers. I could help with the Skybreakers, although since we already know their oaths, I'm not sure what you'd want me to talk about specifically.
Karger he/him Posted July 9, 2020 Author Posted July 9, 2020 41 minutes ago, ChickenLiberty said: I could help with the Skybreakers, although since we already know their oaths, I'm not sure what you'd want me to talk about specifically. Say what you think is important.
Recommended Posts