could Alcatraz break a shardblade?

[Kaladin Stormdepressed she/her]

i think breaking an 'alive' shardblade would essentially be breaking the nahel bond, since shardblades are just spren manifesting in the physical realm

[LewsTherinTelescope]

12 minutes ago, Kaladin Stormdepressed said:

i think breaking an 'alive' shardblade would essentially be breaking the nahel bond, since shardblades are just spren manifesting in the physical realm

Probably kills the spren (as in, actually kills, not deadeye, because it destroys it)

[EmulatonStromenkiin he/him]

On 2/7/2019 at 1:48 AM, Rossamund said:

What we fail to consider is that most shardblades are already broken. Being manifestations of non-sentient deadeye spren. This would seem to indicate he can break a shardblade. But can he break something that is broken? 

If you break something that is broken, is that multiplying or dividing by zero?