Doc12 Posted April 24 Posted April 24 Verna quirks a smile under her veil at young Tims. "Very well then, Child, I am willing to follow your plan if everyone else is." She looked to Mabel, Patrick, and Luminair. "If all agree to declare someone to follow, I will be @Miss Fallenshadow through the house." "If a consensus is not reached, however," she paused, "I reserve the right to follow my original plan.
Mint11 she/her Posted April 24 Posted April 24 47 minutes ago, Miss Fallen said: This is also making me a bit suspicious of why doc is pushing for a different plan- to reveal the hero. Doc should know better than anyone that this plan would work, having received a follow notification the first night. I think doc has the gun right now. do you mean because doc didn't work out that your plan would work, or because you find doc's plan inherently suspicious? 2 hours ago, Doc12 said: If you're the Hero, you've already won, and nothing can take that away from you, unless you are a Hero with a gun, and shoot the gun. So our scenarios right now are 1) hero doesn't have the gun. That narrows down the pool to 3 people, 2 for me. 2) hero has the gun, but doesn't shoot it - you die, but become the first winner, guaranteed 3) hero has the gun, and shoots it, which is objectively the worst solution because you're lose the hero status and then lose the game when you die. So from my perspective, there is no downside to confirming who the Hero is. If the hero is still alive the next day, we know that they didn't have the gun, and can look at the other 3 people. If the hero dies, then it's a little more complex because it could be 1. the hero had the gun and didn't shoot it, or 2. That they were killed. Still, logically, for the first possibility, the hero could just inform us if they have the gun. For the second, shooting the hero is a dumb choice because it narrows down who has the gun. Does this logic check out? There's literally no downside to one of us four claiming to be the hero? the logic's sound, but I don't think this is going to work out because I'm not the hero and the rest of you are also claiming not to be the hero lol as for fallen's plan, I'm happy to follow someone to clear myself. I'll follow @Verdance
Verdance he/him Posted April 24 Posted April 24 6 minutes ago, Frozen Mint said: do you mean because doc didn't work out that your plan would work, or because you find doc's plan inherently suspicious? the logic's sound, but I don't think this is going to work out because I'm not the hero and the rest of you are also claiming not to be the hero lol as for fallen's plan, I'm happy to follow someone to clear myself. I'll follow @Verdance I am once again asking my GM for items
Miss Fallen she/her Posted April 24 Posted April 24 6 minutes ago, Frozen Mint said: do you mean because doc didn't work out that your plan would work, or because you find doc's plan inherently suspicious? I mean Doc received a followed notification, so he should know that players are in fact capable of holding each other accountable for our night actions, which is how we determine who used their action on the gun. Doc’s plan about revealing the heroes actually can work quite nicely with my plan, especially during the analysis of information that will come in day 3.
Doc12 Posted April 24 Posted April 24 @Fizz9 @Through The Living Star Don't follow someone who's already a suspect. If I or Fizz turn out to be the gunner, all we would have to do is say we didn't get a notification that we were followed, and you'd be the one under suspicion instead. Don't follow someone who is motivated to lie. Pick someone who cannot have the gun. 1
Fizz9 Posted April 24 Posted April 24 I am not going to be here for the end of the night, so good luck everyone! Wait no, sorry, I just got an email, it was canceled, so I can be here. Nevermind ! 1 minute ago, Doc12 said: @Fizz9 @Through The Living Star Don't follow someone who's already a suspect. If I or Fizz turn out to be the gunner, all we would have to do is say we didn't get a notification that we were followed, and you'd be the one under suspicion instead. Don't follow someone who is motivated to lie. Pick someone who cannot have the gun. Who should I follow then?
StrikerEZ he/him Posted April 24 Posted April 24 Forgive me if I’m wrong, but if I was following everything correctly, we know Frozen Mint should be the Hero, right? Doc came up with the claiming Hero plan, so presumably he’s not the Hero. And both Fizz and Star have claimed to not be the Hero. I see no reason, if you were a Hero, to not claim so. So @Frozen Mint: are you the Hero?
Doc12 Posted April 24 Posted April 24 3 minutes ago, StrikerEZ said: Forgive me if I’m wrong, but if I was following everything correctly, we know Frozen Mint should be the Hero, right? Doc came up with the claiming Hero plan, so presumably he’s not the Hero. And both Fizz and Star have claimed to not be the Hero. I see no reason, if you were a Hero, to not claim so. So @Frozen Mint: are you the Hero? 1 hour ago, Frozen Mint said: The logic's sound, but I don't think this is going to work out because I'm not the hero and the rest of you are also claiming not to be the hero lol Mint claimed not hero. I can only assume at this point that the hero is deciding they want to shoot the gun, because there's no other reason not to claim hero. If you're the hero, you've already won. You win even if you die tonight. And if you die, it narrows down the pool for the next group. So yeah. Hero to villain arc immediately I guess. 11 minutes ago, Fizz9 said: I am not going to be here for the end of the night, so good luck everyone! Wait no, sorry, I just got an email, it was canceled, so I can be here. Nevermind ! Who should I follow then? I know I just said this in PM, but here so Star sees it to: Striker, Mippo, Qian, Conure, Akimiko. Please declare someone from this list before you have to go for the night 1
Miss Fallen she/her Posted April 24 Posted April 24 1 hour ago, Frozen Mint said: do you mean because doc didn't work out that your plan would work, or because you find doc's plan inherently suspicious? the logic's sound, but I don't think this is going to work out because I'm not the hero and the rest of you are also claiming not to be the hero lol as for fallen's plan, I'm happy to follow someone to clear myself. I'll follow @Verdance Mint claimed not hero same wavelength here
Mint11 she/her Posted April 24 Posted April 24 @Fizz9 @Through The Living Star preferably pick someone who's likely to be active, and also ping them when you announce your choice here. we want them to be around on the next day turn to confirm aaand y'all jinx'ed each other. pick different people xD
Fizz9 Posted April 24 Posted April 24 4 minutes ago, Through The Living Star said: Okay! I will follow @Conure1243! Why Star? How did we choose the same person?
Through The Living Star She/Her Posted April 24 Posted April 24 Just now, Doc12 said: @Through The Living Star @Fizz9 Sorry, what is the picture of? I can't see it lol
Fizz9 Posted April 24 Posted April 24 Just now, Doc12 said: @Through The Living Star @Fizz9 It's a meme about how we both choose Conure
Through The Living Star She/Her Posted April 24 Posted April 24 Well, anyways, I'm gonna follow @StrikerEZ. That good?
Miss Fallen she/her Posted April 24 Posted April 24 Yep, I think we’re good… K. Tims looked around the group. There had been a strange amount of confusion, repetition, and mirroring. But it had brought them together in this House that seemed determined to trap them all. K noticed Verna shuffling Brax’s precious deck of cards. She seemed to have adopted the trait. “Could I perhaps draw one?” Tims inquired. @Doc12
Mint11 she/her Posted April 25 Posted April 25 28 minutes ago, Qianweilian said: I will follow @Akimikoisthecutest you don't need to follow anyone, you're not under suspicion. only people who voted for mist can have the gun rn since this is most likely scenario 2, the only action you can take that would be helpful to you is to search for an item. there's no point in confirming where players were on N0 since that's irrelevant to who has the gun now
Through The Living Star She/Her Posted April 25 Posted April 25 2 minutes ago, ___ said: Mann no-one wants to follow me I mean if you really want... I haven't sent in my action yet
Recommended Posts