Jo and the Bush all/any Posted October 11, 2025 Posted October 11, 2025 37 minutes ago, Araris Valerian said: Can you explain to me why, after I’ve championed Hoid as my strongest village read, e!Hoid moves to execute me on D3? Because it totally fits with a paranoid villager. That, along with the PM we had, is the starting point for my analysis. He knew that TwinStor would flip village, so maybe he wanted to get village cred for leaving a village train at the last minute? Or possibly he wanted to target another Novice? We had lost only Novices up to that point. Not sure if that is a coincidence or not with today's thread name.
Amanuensis he/him Posted October 11, 2025 Author Posted October 11, 2025 On the topic of thread name, I did mistakenly misremember thOmAs' rank and plan to change the title once I finish the write up, which I will have time for tonight. Neither titles or write ups will give clues or hints, however.
The Unknown Medallion he/him Posted October 11, 2025 Posted October 11, 2025 4 hours ago, A Jo in the Bush said: think you're village, but to answer your question, E!you would have done it to ask that exact question today, or because you got outvoted by your teammates at the last minute. You can say that for anything villagery. My point was it's not sound logic to use. 2 hours ago, Hoid Slayer said: Here me out The Unknown... SURVIVOR Did I cook? Total cookage
Araris Valerian he/him Posted October 11, 2025 Posted October 11, 2025 1 hour ago, A Jo in the Bush said: He knew that TwinStor would flip village, so maybe he wanted to get village cred for leaving a village train at the last minute? Or possibly he wanted to target another Novice? We had lost only Novices up to that point. Not sure if that is a coincidence or not with today's thread name. The elims would know that if they got off a mis-exe on D3 then they'd only need one more. At that point, trust is the most valuable commodity, and I trusted (and still trust) Hoid. It's a losing play for the e!Hoid to make that switch, especially because if his move caused me to flip village instead, he'd essentially guarantee being on the chopping block D4.
Hoid Slayer He/Him Posted October 11, 2025 Posted October 11, 2025 @STINK@RoyalBeeMage care to weigh in?
The Unknown Medallion he/him Posted October 11, 2025 Posted October 11, 2025 3 hours ago, Hoid Slayer said: @STINK@RoyalBeeMage care to weigh in? They're busy discussing in the elim doc
RoyalBeeMage he/him Posted October 11, 2025 Posted October 11, 2025 6 minutes ago, The Unknown Hammerer said: They're busy discussing in the elim doc rude... i'm busy re reding the past few turns to try and figure out who's acting the most suspicious... had anyone claimed to have crimsioned hoid or coder dragon? does anyone have a VC for Coder's health or for the actual vote?
Hoid Slayer He/Him Posted October 11, 2025 Posted October 11, 2025 12 minutes ago, RoyalBeeMage said: rude... i'm busy re reding the past few turns to try and figure out who's acting the most suspicious... had anyone claimed to have crimsioned hoid or coder dragon? does anyone have a VC for Coder's health or for the actual vote? I think the actual vote stands at: Jo (3): Me, CD, Araris Me(Hoid) (1): Jo As for Coder’s health, not sure on specifics, but I’m pretty sure the only person who wants him dead is Jo
RoyalBeeMage he/him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 23 hours ago, STINK said: I don't have long and I'm genuinely kind annoyed about that and this isn't ironic but I'm not allowed to say how I would really wanna express myself so Feel like this Hoid Slayer wound is lowkey personal against me 'cause like I've wanted them dead but now it's a group proposal about it and isn't that just the best way to kill a villager and then we're back into double-bluff territory I'm also at the point where I don't like Jo calling me Columbo and expecting me to solve stuff when like I don't straight up do anything man I don't know where that came from I just thought it was gassing me up for no reason but now I'm expected to randomly call someone out when my callout was ignored for like 2 cycles? Like if I'm wrong it's nothing new really but now it has impact which is new for me why does anyone do this stuff? Yeah no-one talked to me about game-related stuff in PMs which is kinda usual but also like theres no way they all didn't care about PMs so someone from TUH/jo/Araris is an elim and oh doesn't feel like it's the whole game being set out. Be nice if anyone else PM'd me but I don't have any kinda thing going on anymore do I so don't know what I was expecting really. Don't worry gamers I'm mainly annoyed at myself it's not like I do thread posts that make people think I'm worth giving a good yonder to. I am annoyed at how like today was Friday and I was busy doing stuff with my fellas but like also mathematically do we just lose today if HoidS!asVillager and another villager die 'cause I guess I wanna see like 3 different people's maths about that and if we need to save HoidS even if they're evil which like it's a random kill going through? Surely a vig did the maths about making it happen or it's an elim scheme I just apparently don't have the brainpower for this anymore lol if it was a day cycle I'd be wanting to vote Jo now 'cause I do nothing and they hyped me up like others should be acting Roberto didn't even get to do anything this post I can't even RP what's going on like you'd think I'd commit to either game-focus or RP but you love to strike the middle I was gonna add more but low-key / high-key I gotta head back off again Sorry gamers maybe I'll see ya next cycle if its happening Ciao this reads to me as extreamly genuine so proberbly going to lean towards a V!Stink for now and it also mad me pause for a second about Hoidslayer. at this current point in time i dont think him or joe can be anything apart from elims... however i am leaning more towards one or the other... i dont think both could be elims... that just doesnt feel right to me at the moment... On 10/10/2025 at 10:43 AM, A Jo in the Bush said: Ughhhh, I hate this. K+V!Hoid: If the elims successfully get off a kill tonight, and Hoid is a Villager (Unlikely) we lose. K+ ?!Hoid: If the elims kill, and we save Hoid just in case, we go into tomorrow 3-4, without knowing Hoid's alignment. F+V!Hoid: If the Elims fail their kill, and we don't save Hoid, but he's village, we go into tommorow 3-4 with a fresh start. F+?!Hoid: If the elims fail their kill and we do save hoid just in case, we go into tomorrow 3-5 and probably just execute Hoid. KV sucks, but honestly we'd deserve the loss at that point. K? sucks because we've effectively wasted a pseduo Execution. FV is honestly preferred to K? because we'll have 48 hours to actually find and discuss someone. F? is better than K? for obvious reasons, but we can't count on it. I vote to let Hoid die @Araris Valerian — Armiel — Novice @Belandrius Ohhmar — thOmmAs — Apprentice @The Unknown Hammerer — Illi — Master @CoderDrag0n8 — Sozar — Apprentice @RoyalBeeMage — William Thorne — Apprentice @STINK — Roberto — Apprentice Please Vote to let Hoid die. If you want him to live, please provide a dang good explanation for who the 3 Elims are if Hoid isn't one of them. @Hoid Slayer — Shifter — Novice Hoid. If you are a villager, and you want to win, please spend your energy trying to figure out who should be targeted with a Verdant/Roseite pot instead of defending yourself. Unless you think you can defend yourself really easily, it's not worth the effort. If you are a villager, you can do the most good by helping prevent the Elims killing one of us. If you're a villager, the 3 elims aren't going to vote to save you, and I'm not going to vote to save you, so you'll have to convince the three other villagers besides you and me. If you are an Elim, can I recommend Open-Wolfing? It's really fun. i hate to say it but i kind of agree with joe here... we should have let hoid die... it would have been cleaner for us all... oh well. On 10/11/2025 at 4:50 AM, Hoid Slayer said: It would be my honor to serve as elim alongside you @Amanuensis the writeups are incredible btw Okay, let's see what I got *crunches knuckles* Day two rollover summary, paraphrased partially from Jo: With seven hours left in the day, the VC stands as: (2) TwinStorm: IcedOutPenguin, Belandrius Ohhmar, (1) STINK: CoderDrag0n8, (1) ThatOneWorldhopper: Araris Valerian, (1) CoderDrag0n8: A Jo in the Bush, (1) IcedOutPenguin: TwinStorm, (1) Hoid Slayer: STINK, I vote TOW without good reasoning, just to test waters Jo moves vote off CD for some reason and switches it to me - Jo, still not sure why you seem to have a vendetta against me, would be nice to know Araris also switches vote to me, with the argument that I'm not acting on my analysis VC: (3) Hoid Slayer: STINK, A Jo in the Bush, Araris Valerian, (2) TwinStorm: IcedOutPenguin, Belandrius Ohhmar, (1) ThatOneWorldhopper: Hoid Slayer, (1) STINK: CoderDrag0n8, (1) IcedOutPenguin: TwinStorm, I make an analysis post that convinces Araris to move vote back to TOW with me Bee votes TwinStorm CD votes TOW TwinStorm votes TOW for the sake of self-preservation VC: (4) ThatOneWorldhopper: Hoid Slayer, Araris Valerian, CoderDrag0n8, TwinStorm, (3) TwinStorm: IcedOutPenguin, Belandrius Ohhmar, RoyalBeeMage (2) Hoid Slayer: STINK, A Jo in the Bush, TUH votes TwinStorm Bee takes vote off TwinStorm and shifts it to TOW TUH takes vote off TwinStorm and moves it to me Final VC: (5) ThatOneWorldhopper: Hoid Slayer, Araris Valerian, CoderDrag0n8, TwinStorm, RoyalBeeMage, (3) Hoid Slayer: STINK, A Jo in the Bush, The Unknown Hammerer (2) TwinStorm: IcedOutPenguin, Belandrius Ohhmar, Retrospective analysis of D2: First off, wherever they were hiding, the elims were sitting real nice, with three village trains. Second, I am beginning to see a potential tie between Araris and CD (they both switch votes to TOW in a short time period) What really stands out to me though is all the chaos with no real threat to the elims. A lot of people - namely Araris, Bee, CD, and TUH - were scrambling around somewhat when elims would have no real reason to do so. This subtly implies to me that the elims were hiding under the radar D2 This implicates Jo, BelOh, and Stink It's possible that that's the elim team right there; that seems a little too simple, though. The weird bit is that that would then imply that the elims were taking actions they didn't need to D2, which is somewhat weird elim behavior - unless they were trying to push for a specific exe. In that case, the most likely option I see is TOW - the elims might have rightly noticed that by exeing TOW D2, they set up TwinStorm for D3 (and if this was the elim's plan, it worked beautifully) Such a possibility would most implicate CD, Bee, and TUH - I wouldn't include Araris in there because when he shifted to TOW there were better options (namely keeping the vote on me) for an elim Day three summary: Jo votes Twin, says happy to vote Twin or me Twin votes Araris Araris votes CD I vote Twin BelOh votes Twin Not much happens until nine hours before rollover, when CD votes Araris Current VC: TwinStorm (3): Hoid, Jo, BelOh Araris (2): Twin, CD CD (1): Araris Hoid (1): Stink Minutes before rollover, TUH votes TwinStorm I vote Araris Final VC: (3) TwinStorm: A Jo in the Bush, Belandrius Ohhmar, The Unknown Hammerer, (3) Araris Valerian: TwinStorm, CoderDrag0n8, Hoid Slayer, (1) CoderDrag0n8: Araris Valerian, (1) Hoid Slayer: STINK, Analysis of D3: Well, this was much more uneventful - perhaps we should have taken the hint earlier that TwinStorm was the wrong idea I think the flow of this cycle is pretty obvious; elims set out with intention to exe TwinStorm, and succeed Alone, this day really doesn't tell us much. However, we can combine it with D2's - and we've been quite lucky that most players have been quite active Based off of vibes, the most sus players in my eye are CD, BelOh, Araris, and a tentative Stink, who has done practically nothing all game but occasionally pop in to vote me If we pardon BelOh for being new, then we can see a clear potential tie between CD and Araris. The problem here is that D3, they both voted for each other - however, CD was never in any real danger, and there was no way for them to predict my last-minute switch other than some messages I sent Araris pre rollover. It would've been a risky maneuver on their part, but not impossible to imagine In a world where CD and Araris are elim together: I'm looking at TUH as their third. His vote for Twin yesterday was what kept Araris alive, and D2, his switch from Twin to me would cement the TOW exe while avoiding keeping all elims on the same train AAAAAND I just realized how unlikely this is since the three people I just accused are the three people voting to save my life In a world where Araris is elim, but not with CD: Looking at Bee and TUH as at least one of them a teammate, based on my analysis for D2 Final elim could be anywhere In a world where CD is elim, but not with Araris: Looking at Bee and TUH as at least one of them a teammate Probably both teammates on Twin train yesterday, implying Jo and BelOh as well In a world where Jo, BelOh, and Stink are elim: We're all screwed Honestly, I just spent a load of time on an analysis only to realize that I can envision basically anyone in a team with anyone But that's all unimportant, because, while doing my research, I stumbled upon this absolutely heartless comment from Jo Thus, we can conclude that Jo is evil /s Also can someone please explain to me what everyone means when they say ninja? It's confusing me a little Wait Just thought of something I doubt there's more than one elim on the train voting to save me; sooooo there go all my theories of Araris, CD, and TUH being evil together Sorry, guys I just wasted an hour of my time i dont know why (i could just be reading way to much into this) but this just doesnt sit right with me at all... the entire end part of it just reads to me as an elim desperately trying to throw anyone under the bus to save their own skin. if joe and hoid are both elims (which i dont think i the case) then it does look as if there is major disagreements between the elims and they're both trying to hang the outher out to dry. i still have no idea who the 3rd elim is which is not great considering we're running out of time... i'm fairly sure we're in the endgame at this point... now might be the time to cash in all of your roseite pots
Araris Valerian he/him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 (edited) 53 minutes ago, RoyalBeeMage said: i hate to say it but i kind of agree with joe here... we should have let hoid die... it would have been cleaner for us all... oh well. Maybe a cleaner win for the elims, and a "clean" death for the village, but I don't really give much weight to either of those. What is your evidence that Hoid is elim? Can you provide an explanation for why e!Hoid would have switched off of TwinStorm and onto me, the player advocating for his village alignment the most, at the end of D3? Really the only argument I'm getting for Hoid being elim is that he was up for the exe D2. Which is pretty sad given all that's happened in the meantime. Given the low amount of evidence pointing toward e!Hoid, why should we have given up 48 hours of discussion time to risk losing if he's village? Also, why hasn't the "villager" that wounded Hoid claimed? If someone gives me a convincing argument, I could probably be persuaded to vote for Hoid. Yeah, I'd need a fair bit to be persuaded. But nobody really seems to be engaging with the points I'm bringing up. Edit: And if anyone thinks I'm a villager, you need to convince me to vote with you, or the village vote will be split and the elims win. Edited October 12, 2025 by Araris Valerian
Jo and the Bush all/any Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 Day 2 Votes: Spoiler Vote 1 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Vote 2 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (1): Iced Out Penguin Vote 3 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar Vote 4 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon Vote 5 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 7 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon(1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Vote 8 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, That One Worldhopper STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Vote 9 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Belandrius Ohmar (1): That One Worldhopper Vote 10 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Vote 11 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 12 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 13 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 14 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 15 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, Araris Valerian Vote 16 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 17 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 18 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (3): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 19 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 20 Twin Storm (4): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 21 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 22 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, The Unknown Hammerer In Vote 14, do you really think I would vote alongside a fellow eliminator on a player than no villagers were voting on? Day 3 Votes: Spoiler Vote 1: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 2: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Vote 3: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 4 Twin Storm (2): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 5 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 7 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 8 Twin Storm (4): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 9 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (3): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK @STINK did you use a Crimson Pot on Hoid Slayer? I ask because you twice voted for Hoid Slayer, and didn't vote to heal him. Night 3 Votes: Heal Hoid Slayer (5/4): Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Araris Valerian, The Unknown Hammerer, Royal Bee Mage Let him die (3/5): A Jo in the Bush, STINK, Belandrius Ohmar Day 4 Votes: Spoiler Vote 1 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer Vote 1.5 Heal Coder Dragon (1/4): Araris Valerian Vote 2 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (1): Araris Valerian Vote 3 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (2): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon Vote 4 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Vote 4.5 Heal Coder Dragon (2/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Vote 4.75 Heal Coder Dragon (3/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, The Unknown Hammerer Vote 5 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Hoid Slayer (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 5.5 Heal Coder Dragon (4/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, The Unknown Hammerer, Coder Dragon Vote 5.75 Heal Coder Dragon (5/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, The Unknown Hammerer, Coder Dragon, Royal Bee Mage Vote 6 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Hoid Slayer (2): A Jo in the Bush, Royal Bee Mage Alright, whatever. barking up this tree is doing nothing. You all think Hoid Slayer is a villager. At this point I am tunneling on him, but I'll pretend he's a villager. From my point of view, that means the Eliminators must be 3 of Coder, Stink, Araris, Hammerer, or Royal. Spoiler Day 2 Vote 4 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon Vote 5 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Vote 11 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 15 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, Araris Valerian Vote 16 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 17 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 18 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (3): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 20 Twin Storm (4): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 21 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 22 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, The Unknown Hammerer Day 3 Vote 3: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 7 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 8 Twin Storm (4): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Day 4 Vote 2 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (1): Araris Valerian Vote 3 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (2): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon Vote 6 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Hoid Slayer (2): A Jo in the Bush, Royal Bee Mage Day 2 makes sense in that world. Any of them can basically vote however they want without worry, because none of the 5 of them receive more than a vote at a time. We're in a V/V/V world, which sucks from an analytical perspective. Day 3 also makes sinse in that world. Again, any of them can vote, however they want. Twin Storm effectively gets executed by villagers only. The only think of note that I could analyse here is that Coder and Araris probably aren't Eliminators together. Day 4 is the first time the Elims have to actually lead an execution, on me. In the V/V world of me and Hoid, I basically have to believe the game is over. There's no one but villagers up for exectuion, and 5/7 players have voted. Take a walk down my world now. The Eliminators are Hoid Slayer, Royal Bee Mage, and Coder Dragon Spoiler Day 2 Vote 1 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Vote 4 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon Vote 6 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 13 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 14 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 15 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, Araris Valerian Vote 17 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 18 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (3): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 21 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 22 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, The Unknown Hammerer Day 3 Vote 3: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 4 Twin Storm (2): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 5 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 7 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 8 Twin Storm (4): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 9 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (3): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK First Note, none of them, have ever, voted for eachother. They have consistently voted in defense of eachother. They have consistented voted to heal eachother. Royal Bee Mage in particualar has voted to heal both fo them when there was already 4 votes to heal each of them. @Araris Valerian Pretend I'm an eliminator. Pretend the votes don't change after this point. I get executed. Coder lives. You have 2 eliminators left among TUH, Coder, Royal, Hoid, and STINK. Who are my teammates? Who's working with me? 14 hours ago, Araris Valerian said: Can you provide an explanation for why e!Hoid would have switched off of TwinStorm and onto me, the player advocating for his village alignment the most, at the end of D3? Really the only argument I'm getting for Hoid being elim is that he was up for the exe D2. Which is pretty sad given all that's happened in the meantime. Given the low amount of evidence pointing toward e!Hoid, why should we have given up 48 hours of discussion time to risk losing if he's village? Also, why hasn't the "villager" that wounded Hoid claimed? Hoid voted for you because you had voted for him and then switched off of him (Day2, Votes 15/16), and he knew that he was in a V/V world. If you got executed, he would have TwinStorm, a master, in his pocket for saving him. If Twin got executed, he would keep you in his pocket to protect him. This is the last time I'm doing analysis this game. I've spent too much time on this game at this point. If anyone switches their vote off of me onto Coder, Royal, or Hoid, I'll vote with them. Otherwise, unless someone asks me a direct question, I'm not going to post again. GG Elims.
Hoid Slayer He/Him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 1 hour ago, A Jo in the Bush said: Day 2 Votes: Hide contents Vote 1 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Vote 2 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (1): Iced Out Penguin Vote 3 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar Vote 4 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon Vote 5 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 7 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon(1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Vote 8 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, That One Worldhopper STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Vote 9 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Belandrius Ohmar (1): That One Worldhopper Vote 10 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Vote 11 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 12 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 13 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 14 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 15 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, Araris Valerian Vote 16 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 17 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 18 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (3): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 19 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 20 Twin Storm (4): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 21 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 22 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, The Unknown Hammerer In Vote 14, do you really think I would vote alongside a fellow eliminator on a player than no villagers were voting on? Day 3 Votes: Reveal hidden contents Vote 1: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 2: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Vote 3: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 4 Twin Storm (2): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 5 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 7 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 8 Twin Storm (4): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 9 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (3): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK @STINK did you use a Crimson Pot on Hoid Slayer? I ask because you twice voted for Hoid Slayer, and didn't vote to heal him. Night 3 Votes: Heal Hoid Slayer (5/4): Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Araris Valerian, The Unknown Hammerer, Royal Bee Mage Let him die (3/5): A Jo in the Bush, STINK, Belandrius Ohmar Day 4 Votes: Hide contents Vote 1 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer Vote 1.5 Heal Coder Dragon (1/4): Araris Valerian Vote 2 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (1): Araris Valerian Vote 3 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (2): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon Vote 4 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Vote 4.5 Heal Coder Dragon (2/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Vote 4.75 Heal Coder Dragon (3/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, The Unknown Hammerer Vote 5 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Hoid Slayer (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 5.5 Heal Coder Dragon (4/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, The Unknown Hammerer, Coder Dragon Vote 5.75 Heal Coder Dragon (5/4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, The Unknown Hammerer, Coder Dragon, Royal Bee Mage Vote 6 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Hoid Slayer (2): A Jo in the Bush, Royal Bee Mage Alright, whatever. barking up this tree is doing nothing. You all think Hoid Slayer is a villager. At this point I am tunneling on him, but I'll pretend he's a villager. From my point of view, that means the Eliminators must be 3 of Coder, Stink, Araris, Hammerer, or Royal. Reveal hidden contents Day 2 Vote 4 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon Vote 5 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Vote 11 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 15 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, Araris Valerian Vote 16 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 17 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 18 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (3): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 20 Twin Storm (4): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (4): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 21 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 22 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, The Unknown Hammerer Day 3 Vote 3: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 7 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 8 Twin Storm (4): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Day 4 Vote 2 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (1): Araris Valerian Vote 3 The Unknown Hammerer (1): Hoid Slayer A Jo in the Bush (2): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon Vote 6 A Jo in the Bush (3): Araris Valerian, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Hoid Slayer (2): A Jo in the Bush, Royal Bee Mage Day 2 makes sense in that world. Any of them can basically vote however they want without worry, because none of the 5 of them receive more than a vote at a time. We're in a V/V/V world, which sucks from an analytical perspective. Day 3 also makes sinse in that world. Again, any of them can vote, however they want. Twin Storm effectively gets executed by villagers only. The only think of note that I could analyse here is that Coder and Araris probably aren't Eliminators together. Day 4 is the first time the Elims have to actually lead an execution, on me. In the V/V world of me and Hoid, I basically have to believe the game is over. There's no one but villagers up for exectuion, and 5/7 players have voted. Take a walk down my world now. The Eliminators are Hoid Slayer, Royal Bee Mage, and Coder Dragon Hide contents Day 2 Vote 1 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Vote 4 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon Vote 6 Araris Valerian (1): Hoid Slayer Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Araris Valerian Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Vote 13 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): A Jo in the Bush Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 14 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 15 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (1): Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (3): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, Araris Valerian Vote 17 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage STINK (1): Coder Dragon That One World Hopper (2): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 18 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, Royal Bee Mage That One World Hopper (3): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon Iced Out Penguin (1): Twin Storm Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 21 Twin Storm (3): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush Vote 22 Twin Storm (2): Iced Out Penguin, Belandrius Ohmar That One World Hopper (5): Araris Valerian, Hoid Slayer, Coder Dragon, Twin Storm, Royal Bee Mage Hoid Slayer (2): STINK, A Jo in the Bush, The Unknown Hammerer Day 3 Vote 3: Twin Storm (1): A Jo in the Bush Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 4 Twin Storm (2): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 5 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Vote 6 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (1): Twin Storm Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 7 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 8 Twin Storm (4): A Jo in the Bush, Hoid Slayer, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (2): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK Vote 9 Twin Storm (3): A Jo in the Bush, Belandrius Ohmar, The Unknown Hammerer Araris Valerian (3): Twin Storm, Coder Dragon, Hoid Slayer Coder Dragon (1): Araris Valerian Hoid Slayer (1): STINK First Note, none of them, have ever, voted for eachother. They have consistently voted in defense of eachother. They have consistented voted to heal eachother. Royal Bee Mage in particualar has voted to heal both fo them when there was already 4 votes to heal each of them. @Araris Valerian Pretend I'm an eliminator. Pretend the votes don't change after this point. I get executed. Coder lives. You have 2 eliminators left among TUH, Coder, Royal, Hoid, and STINK. Who are my teammates? Who's working with me? Hoid voted for you because you had voted for him and then switched off of him (Day2, Votes 15/16), and he knew that he was in a V/V world. If you got executed, he would have TwinStorm, a master, in his pocket for saving him. If Twin got executed, he would keep you in his pocket to protect him. This is the last time I'm doing analysis this game. I've spent too much time on this game at this point. If anyone switches their vote off of me onto Coder, Royal, or Hoid, I'll vote with them. Otherwise, unless someone asks me a direct question, I'm not going to post again. GG Elims. In the following silence, Shifter looked at him. Looked at the resignation in Emmett's face. And smiled. It was not a happy grin, but one of acceptance. After everything, this was how it ended. Minutes passed, and nothing happened. Then Shifter reached down to his waist, and drew his blade. As it left its sheath for the first time in weeks, it released a smooth grating sound, quivering in anticipation. As Shifter held it up, it refracted the light, the ebon blade seeming to absorb it. It was beautiful. Void, the blade was named. It had belonged to the Red Wizard, before Shifter had killed him. Tonight, it would taste blood once again. "Emmett." Shifter rose his gaze from the blade, and met the other man's eyes. Then, carefully, he raised the blade to point at him. "Let's dance." In the following silence, the two men would meet. Minutes would pass, and everything would shatter.
Jo and the Bush all/any Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 (edited) 1 hour ago, Hoid Slayer said: In the following silence, Shifter looked at him. Looked at the resignation in Emmett's face. And smiled. It was not a happy grin, but one of acceptance. After everything, this was how it ended. Minutes passed, and nothing happened. Then Shifter reached down to his waist, and drew his blade. As it left its sheath for the first time in weeks, it released a smooth grating sound, quivering in anticipation. As Shifter held it up, it refracted the light, the ebon blade seeming to absorb it. It was beautiful. Void, the blade was named. It had belonged to the Red Wizard, before Shifter had killed him. Tonight, it would taste blood once again. "Emmett." Shifter rose his gaze from the blade, and met the other man's eyes. Then, carefully, he raised the blade to point at him. "Let's dance." In the following silence, the two men would meet. Minutes would pass, and everything would shatter. Emmett sighed. This charade from Shifter was ridiculous. They looked around the deck. There weren't many students left. None of them believed that they was innocent. They all accepted Shifter's words, despite the man's lies. The only one pretending to back them at this point was William. Emmett didn't understand what his plan was. It hardly mattered. Emmett drew from their back a long hollow rod, flute like, carefully coated in Celeste Spores. They held it upright, and pulled a small cord from it's base, and then swung the rod in an arc. Inside the metal, water that had been contained behind the cord sprayed up the length of the rod, mixing with Spore and shooting outward in a series of jagged icicles. Emmett gripped the hilt of their Frostrime Blade with two hands, and stared at Shifter. "You are a liar, and a traitor. I know you slew thOmmAs. Why do you accuse me of your own crimes?" Edited October 12, 2025 by A Jo in the Bush
Hoid Slayer He/Him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 33 minutes ago, A Jo in the Bush said: Emmett sighed. This charade from Shifter was ridiculous. They looked around the deck. There weren't many students left. None of them believed that they was innocent. They all accepted Shifter's words, despite the man's lies. The only one pretending to back them at this point was William. Emmett didn't understand what his plan was. It hardly mattered. Emmett drew from their back a long hollow rod, flute like, carefully coated in Celeste Spores. They held it upright, and pulled a small cord from it's base, and then swung the rod in an arc. Inside the metal, water that had been contained behind the cord sprayed up the length of the rod, mixing with Spore and shooting outward in a series of jagged icicles. Emmett gripped the hilt of their Frostrime Blade with two hands, and stared at Shifter. "You are a liar, and a traitor. I know you slew thOmmAs. Why do you accuse me of your own crimes?" Shifter's smile spread a little bit wider. "We both know whose hands committed the murders. And they weren't mine." Shifter observed Emmett's blade. A design so intricate it could not be found in the more civilized seas. But neither Shifter nor Emmett were prone to civility. Shifter took one last look at the novice, and lunged. Straight for Emmett's chest.
Araris Valerian he/him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 (edited) 3 hours ago, A Jo in the Bush said: You have 2 eliminators left among TUH, Coder, Royal, Hoid, and STINK. Who are my teammates? Who's working with me? STINK and RBM are likely your teammates, though I’ll consider a world where #3 is TUH instead of RBM. In the e!Hoid world you proposed, I find it odd that all 3 elims voted on TOW during D2, when Hoid only had 2 votes. That seems at least as weird as you and STINK both voting on Hoid during the same day. 3 hours ago, A Jo in the Bush said: If you got executed, he would have TwinStorm, a master, in his pocket for saving him. I’m not convinced that TwinStorm would have been pocketed by that result. 3 hours ago, A Jo in the Bush said: First Note, none of them, have ever, voted for eachother. They have consistently voted in defense of eachother. They have consistented voted to heal eachother. Royal Bee Mage in particualar has voted to heal both fo them when there was already 4 votes to heal each of them. Maybe I’m just too prone to bussing as an elim, but IMO a competent elim team should occasionally vote for itself to distance. And the healing doesn’t really say much. I wanted to heal Hoid regardless of his alignment. I’ll grant that if Hoid is elim, these are probably his teammates. That still leaves me wondering who chucked a pot at him, and why they never claimed. And why a second pot got chucked at CD of all people. From my perspective, any pot attack against a villager today needs all villagers to support the healing. Prior to today, I was advocating to exe CD, so the attack on him looks like it aimed to use my lack of support to end the game in favor of the elims. I can see the Doc kill coming from a Hoid team. But I’m not so sure about the Penguin kill, or the Belandrius one. Edit: Really what this is coming down to is that I have a very strong village read on Hoid. His engagement with me despite my initial antagonism, his unwillingness to let a train sit unopposed, and an apparent lack of strategy are all pointing at him as a villager. I’ll do some rereading (focused on Hoid’s potential teammates), but that’s where I’m at now. Edit 2: Now might be a good time to claim our actions. I know Joe advocated for that early on in the game, but at ExLo it can’t really hurt us. The only notable night action I took was attempting and failing to sprout a novice sunlight pot on Belandrius during N2. I forgot my N3 action. I have lots of sunlight things, so I’m either going to see what happens when you incur the failure, or reveal someone’s alignment on D5. The former being 15 times more likely . Edited October 12, 2025 by Araris Valerian
Jo and the Bush all/any Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 8 minutes ago, Araris Valerian said: STINK and RBM are likely your teammates, Yeah that's fair, especially with RBM voting on Hoid with me right now. Tell you what, we both think Royal Bee Mage is an Eliminator. I'll vote him if you do. 10 minutes ago, Araris Valerian said: Maybe I’m just too prone to bussing as an elim, but IMO a competent elim team should occasionally vote for itself to distance. And the healing doesn’t really say much. I wanted to heal Hoid regardless of his alignment. I’ll grant that if Hoid is elim, these are probably his teammates. That still leaves me wondering who chucked a pot at him, and why they never claimed. And why a second pot got chucked at CD of all people. From my perspective, any pot attack against a villager today needs all villagers to support the healing. Prior to today, I was advocating to exe CD, so the attack on him looks like it aimed to use my lack of support to end the game in favor of the elims. I suspect that Twin Storm or STINK hit Hoid with the Crimson Pot. Twin died, and STINK doesn't seem likely to reveal himself. OH! WAIT! It's a WGG! Hoid was hit by Twin Storm, got healed, and they realized how useful that was, so CD crafted a Novice Pot, wounding himself to buy village Cred! That's why no one has claimed.
Hoid Slayer He/Him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 3 minutes ago, A Jo in the Bush said: OH! WAIT! It's a WGG! Hoid was hit by Twin Storm, got healed, and they realized how useful that was, so CD crafted a Novice Pot, wounding himself to buy village Cred! That's why no one has claimed. Just gonna pop in to point out novice crimson pots don’t exist They had to be used by apprentices or masters
CoderDrag0n8 He/They Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 6 minutes ago, A Jo in the Bush said: Yeah that's fair, especially with RBM voting on Hoid with me right now. Tell you what, we both think Royal Bee Mage is an Eliminator. I'll vote him if you do. I suspect that Twin Storm or STINK hit Hoid with the Crimson Pot. Twin died, and STINK doesn't seem likely to reveal himself. OH! WAIT! It's a WGG! Hoid was hit by Twin Storm, got healed, and they realized how useful that was, so CD crafted a Novice Pot, wounding himself to buy village Cred! That's why no one has claimed. Actually, Quote Apprentice: If your target leaves their cabin, inflict a Wound. Master: If your target leaves their cabin, inflict a Fatal Wound. Fatally Wounded require 3/4 of active players to vote for them to be healed or they will die at the end of the Day. Expert: If your target leaves their cabin, kill them! It has been confirmed by @Amanuensis that you cant target yourself (on account of Verdant confusion and the wording of Rosite)
Araris Valerian he/him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 3 minutes ago, A Jo in the Bush said: Tell you what, we both think Royal Bee Mage is an Eliminator. I'll vote him if you do. Honestly, this is tempting, and I even thought of offering it to you when writing my previous post. I guess I’m curious what other folks think. And honestly, I’d like to hear more comprehensive thoughts from @CoderDrag0n8, @RoyalBeeMage, @The Unknown Hammerer, and @STINK. If I’m wrong about Hoid, it’s going to be one of you that convinces me, not Joe. And if I’m wrong, you need to convince me, or we lose. Unless you think I’m evil of course, but I don’t think anyone actually has an elim read on me right now. 4 minutes ago, A Jo in the Bush said: OH! WAIT! It's a WGG! Hoid was hit by Twin Storm, got healed, and they realized how useful that was, so CD crafted a Novice Pot, wounding himself to buy village Cred! That's why no one has claimed. Do we know TwinStorm hit Hoid, or is that your guess? Because I’m not giving any credit to CD for getting wounded. Honestly, I’d be interested in a scenario where e!Hoid got wounded by a teammate, but I don’t see a WGG on CD as likely. To the folks talking about Crimson Pots, you can intentionally wound yourself by crafting the lowest level, given my reading of the rules. You don’t make a pot or target anyone, you just hurt yourself.
CoderDrag0n8 He/They Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 1 minute ago, Araris Valerian said: Honestly, this is tempting, and I even thought of offering it to you when writing my previous post. I guess I’m curious what other folks think. And honestly, I’d like to hear more comprehensive thoughts from @CoderDrag0n8, @RoyalBeeMage, @The Unknown Hammerer, and @STINK. If I’m wrong about Hoid, it’s going to be one of you that convinces me, not Joe. And if I’m wrong, you need to convince me, or we lose. Unless you think I’m evil of course, but I don’t think anyone actually has an elim read on me right now. Do we know TwinStorm hit Hoid, or is that your guess? Because I’m not giving any credit to CD for getting wounded. Honestly, I’d be interested in a scenario where e!Hoid got wounded by a teammate, but I don’t see a WGG on CD as likely. To the folks talking about Crimson Pots, you can intentionally wound yourself by crafting the lowest level, given my reading of the rules. You don’t make a pot or target anyone, you just hurt yourself. ohhh wait yeah My reads are currently RBM (lowest) and Joe (Highest) If I had to throw in a 3rd elim read, it would be stink.
Jo and the Bush all/any Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 9 minutes ago, Hoid Slayer said: Just gonna pop in to point out novice crimson pots don’t exist They had to be used by apprentices or masters 6 minutes ago, CoderDrag0n8 said: Actually, It has been confirmed by @Amanuensis that you cant target yourself (on account of Verdant confusion and the wording of Rosite) . . . 1 minute ago, Araris Valerian said: To the folks talking about Crimson Pots, you can intentionally wound yourself by crafting the lowest level, given my reading of the rules. You don’t make a pot or target anyone, you just hurt yourself. Thank you Araris, for reading the rules. I am guessing that TwinStorm hit Hoid. Or maybe STINK did. as I said, those are the only two villagers that I wouldn't expect to reveal that by now. (Because Twin died before he could.) Not sure about STINK
Hoid Slayer He/Him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 17 minutes ago, Araris Valerian said: Honestly, this is tempting, and I even thought of offering it to you when writing my previous post. I guess I’m curious what other folks think. And honestly, I’d like to hear more comprehensive thoughts from @CoderDrag0n8, @RoyalBeeMage, @The Unknown Hammerer, and @STINK. If I’m wrong about Hoid, it’s going to be one of you that convinces me, not Joe. And if I’m wrong, you need to convince me, or we lose. Unless you think I’m evil of course, but I don’t think anyone actually has an elim read on me right now. Do we know TwinStorm hit Hoid, or is that your guess? Because I’m not giving any credit to CD for getting wounded. Honestly, I’d be interested in a scenario where e!Hoid got wounded by a teammate, but I don’t see a WGG on CD as likely. To the folks talking about Crimson Pots, you can intentionally wound yourself by crafting the lowest level, given my reading of the rules. You don’t make a pot or target anyone, you just hurt yourself. I'm not budging off Jo I know I'm villa, so he has to be elim
Araris Valerian he/him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 1 minute ago, Hoid Slayer said: I'm not budging off Jo I know I'm villa, so he has to be elim That’s why I didn’t ping you
Amanuensis he/him Posted October 12, 2025 Author Posted October 12, 2025 (edited) Not confirming or denying anything, but Exe/MCK come at the end of OoA, so someone being executed could pop off a last minute pot Double post but... CoderDrag0n8 isn't actually Wounded... my bad everyone Just over 7 hours remain in the day to vote Edited October 13, 2025 by Amanuensis
Hoid Slayer He/Him Posted October 12, 2025 Posted October 12, 2025 7 minutes ago, Amanuensis said: Not confirming or denying anything, but Exe/MCK come at the end of OoA, so someone being executed could pop off a last minute pot Double post but... CoderDrag0n8 isn't actually Wounded... my bad everyone Just over 7 hours remain in the day to vote Wait What?
Recommended Posts