Zizoz

Hurt Secret History; heal Shadows for Silence. 3. Emperor's Soul--7 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 8. Shadows of Self--10 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--3 13. The Way of Kings--9 14. Words of Radiance--10 15. Edgedancer--11 16. Warbreaker--9 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--8 18. Sixth of the Dusk--4

Hurt Secret History; heal Shadows for Silence. 3. Emperor's Soul--7 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 8. Shadows of Self--10 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--5 13. The Way of Kings--9 14. Words of Radiance--10 15. Edgedancer--11 16. Warbreaker--9 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--3 That's good to know about shift+enter Or the two keys, rather. Yeah, we're doing hurt 1/heal 1 until the final 2 or we agree to speed it up.

Hurt Secret History; heal Shadows for Silence. 3. Emperor's Soul--7 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 8. Shadows of Self--10 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--6 13. The Way of Kings--9 14. Words of Radiance--9 15. Edgedancer--12 16. Warbreaker--9 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--2 WRT line breaks, I think it's that the forum software doesn't like a line break without some white space, to prevent walls of text. The only way I actually know how to do it is copy-paste. TBH, maybe we ought to use a proper numbered list.

We're still only hurting by one. So I think White Sand should still have a point. Hurt Secret History; heal Shadows of Self. 3. Emperor's Soul--7 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 8. Shadows of Self--10 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--7 13. The Way of Kings--9 14. Words of Radiance--9 15. Edgedancer--11 16. Warbreaker--8 17. Shadow's for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--2 19. White Sand vol. 1--1

Hurt Secret History; heal Shadows for Silence. 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 8. Shadows of Self--9 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--7 13. The Way of Kings--8 14. Words of Radiance--9 15. Edgedancer--12 16. Warbreaker--8 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--2 19. White Sand vol. 1--3

Hurt Secret History; heal Shadows for Silence. 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 8. Shadows of Self--9 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--7 13. The Way of Kings--8 14. Words of Radiance--9 15. Edgedancer--11 16. Warbreaker--7 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--3 19. White Sand vol. 1--4

Hurt Alloy of Law; heal Shadows of Self. 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 7. The Alloy of Law--0 8. Shadows of Self--9 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--8 13. The Way of Kings--8 14. Words of Radiance--10 15. Edgedancer--10 16. Warbreaker--7 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--3 19. White Sand vol. 1--3

Hurt Alloy of Law; heal Warbreaker. Also added in Elenion's vote. 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 7. The Alloy of Law--3 8. Shadows of Self--8 9. The Bands of Mourning--6 10. Secret History--8 13. The Way of Kings--8 14. Words of Radiance--10 15. Edgedancer--9 16. Warbreaker--7 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--3 19. White Sand vol. 1--2

Hurt Alloy of Law; heal Shadows for Silence. 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--6 7. The Alloy of Law--3 8. Shadows of Self--8 9. The Bands of Mourning--5 10. Secret History--8 13. The Way of Kings--8 14. Words of Radiance--10 15. Edgedancer--9 16. Warbreaker--6 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--7 18. Sixth of the Dusk--3 19. White Sand vol. 1--4

Hurt Alloy of Law; heal Way of Kings. 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--4 6. The Hero of Ages--5 7. The Alloy of Law--3 8. Shadows of Self--8 9. The Bands of Mourning--5 10. Secret History--8 13. The Way of Kings--7 14. Words of Radiance--11 15. Edgedancer--9 16. Warbreaker--6 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--6 18. Sixth of the Dusk--4 19. White Sand vol. 1--6

Hurt Alloy of Law; heal Shadows of Self. 1. Elantris--1 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--5 7. The Alloy of Law--4 8. Shadows of Self--8 9. The Bands of Mourning--5 10. Secret History--8 13. The Way of Kings--6 14. Words of Radiance--10 15. Edgedancer--8 16. Warbreaker--6 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--6 18. Sixth of the Dusk--4 19. White Sand vol. 1--6

Hurt Alloy of Law; heal Shadows of Self. 1. Elantris--3 3. Emperor's Soul--6 4. The Final Empire--7 5. The Well of Ascension--5 6. The Hero of Ages--5 7. The Alloy of Law--5 8. Shadows of Self--7 9. The Bands of Mourning--5 10. Secret History--7 11. Allomancer Jak and the Pits of Eltania--2 13. The Way of Kings--6 14. Words of Radiance--9 15. Edgedancer--7 16. Warbreaker--6 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell--6 18. Sixth of the Dusk--4 19. White Sand vol. 1--5

Hurt Hope of Elantris; heal Warbreaker. 1. Elantris - 4 2. Hope of Elantris - 0 3. Emperor's Soul - 6 4. The Final Empire - 5 5. The Well of Ascension - 5 6. The Hero of Ages - 5 7. The Alloy of Law - 6 8. Shadows of Self - 6 9. The Bands of Mourning - 5 10. Secret History - 6 11. Allomancer Jak and the Pits of Eltania - 5 13. The Way of Kings - 6 14. Words of Radiance - 8 15. Edgedancer - 7 16. Warbreaker - 6 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell - 6 18. Sixth of the Dusk - 4 19. White Sand vol. 1 - 5

Hurt Hope of Elantris; heal Way of Kings. 1. Elantris - 4 2. Hope of Elantris - 3 3. Emperor's Soul - 6 4. The Final Empire - 5 5. The Well of Ascension - 5 6. The Hero of Ages - 5 7. The Alloy of Law - 6 8. Shadows of Self - 6 9. The Bands of Mourning - 5 10. Secret History - 6 11. Allomancer Jak and the Pits of Eltania - 5 13. The Way of Kings - 6 14. Words of Radiance - 7 15. Edgedancer - 7 16. Warbreaker - 5 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell - 6 18. Sixth of the Dusk - 4 19. White Sand vol. 1 - 4

Hurt Hope of the Elantris; heal Shadows of Self. 1. Elantris - 4 2. Hope of Elantris - 4 3. Emperor's Soul - 5 4. The Final Empire - 5 5. The Well of Ascension - 5 6. The Hero of Ages - 5 7. The Alloy of Law - 6 8. Shadows of Self - 6 9. The Bands of Mourning - 5 10. Secret History - 5 11. Allomancer Jak and the Pits of Eltania - 5 12. The Eleventh Metal - 2 13. The Way of Kings - 5 14. Words of Radiance - 7 15. Edgedancer - 6 16. Warbreaker - 5 17. Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell - 6 18. Sixth of the Dusk - 5 19. White Sand vol. 1 - 4

Results: Bendalloy - Champion! Cadmium - lasted 219 votes Atium - 171 Steel - 150 Lerasium - 112 Iron - 92 Bronze - 80 Tin - 70 Nicrosil - 64 Pewter - 62 Copper - 55 Zinc - 49 Chromium - 45 Electrum - 44 Gold - 30 Duralumin - 22 Brass - 15 Aluminum - 12 Malatium - 6 We haven't done any variant of books yet. Rasarr suggested we do Cosmere books/stories first and then non-Cosmere. I'd be okay with that split. The Coppermind has a nice list of Brandon's published work. If we do Cosmere stories, I imagine at least a significant fraction of players will have read everything, so we could take all the stuff highlighted in green through 2016, minus the Elantris 10th anniversary edition and AU (including the stories separately instead) – does that seem right?

Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--3 16. Bendalloy--7

Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--616. Bendalloy--10

You still have to wait for two people to post. Additionally, three extra points were added to Bendalloy here. So it should be Cadmium 9, Bendalloy 13 (taking the numbers from gatorgirl's post and subtracting 3 from Bendalloy). Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--10 16. Bendalloy--11

Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--18 16. Bendalloy--13

Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--18 16. Bendalloy--16

We're doing hurt by 2, heal 1. And I have it as Cadmium 17, Bendalloy 21, since Rob Lucci only hurt Cadmium by 1. Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--18 16. Bendalloy--19

Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--22 16. Bendalloy--20 More people posting, yay!

Heal Cadmium; hurt Bendalloy. 15. Cadmium--2916. Bendalloy--18

Hurt Bendalloy; heal Cadmium. 15. Cadmium--29 16. Bendalloy--21 Since we've reached the final 2, I thought I'd ask: are we doing books next, and if so, which ones ought to be included? (In particular, which ones have most people read? I believe I've read all published Cosmere stories except The Eleventh Metal, Sixth of the Dusk and Edgedancer, as well as Steelheart, Firefight, The Rithmatist and The Wheel of Time.)