I think it went wrong at the page break. Gargoyle had:
1 Writing Excuses 11 Reading Excuses 7 Sanderson Elimination 18 Stormlight Archive 17 Mistborn
Emerald took out Writing Excuses, but also took two off Reading Excuses. Emerald's should be:
10 Reading Excuses 8 Sanderson Elimination 18 Stormlight Archive 17 Mistborn
Then Kamererite:
11 Reading Excuses 8 Sanderson Elimination 16 Stormlight Archive 17 Mistborn
Then me: someone verify, please?
12 Reading Excuses 8 Sanderson Elimination 16 Stormlight Archive 15 Mistborn