Myst

Yeah, it did not… no one came forward to start a train or tie up the votes or anything, so Honor’s Ghost. It’s not as weird for me, I haven’t put like a single vote on you. But fair, I did not expect you to change your mind. again, I’m agreeing with Doc, A Jo in the Bush it is very weird that you keep claiming “vibes ” it’s too easy to hide literally anything behind that.

You have a few options, you can: a. Try and convince us that what we’re using against you is a misunderstanding, or something b. Convince people that someone else is and Elim and they should vote that person c. Vote someone else and try to get a tie d. Be a thug. e. Hope people change their votes I believe those are your options, I think. But sometimes it may be inevitable. In this case, you have about 4ish hours to try, but idk

Do you want in PM? Or just in here again? What’s in here is currently what I’m doing. And I’m in

Basically he asked me about when Mippo said Honor’s Ghost was mistborn, and he agreed that it was weird and strange, and we decided to vote Honor’s ghost to see what happens. It’s not really a turnaround, I will vote you the next day, unless something comes up.(assuming we’re both alive) But for now I’m seeing what’s up with Honor and Mippo.

I did, I just fixed it. Also, it’s a three-way tie and there’s 6 hours till rollover

Yeah, I actually do. One is just not participating. The other is not knowing what to do and leaving it up to chance. Votes are how you make progress, a refusal to do that doesn’t make sense as that’s how you do this. WorldHopper is refusing to play the game, refusing to make progress. That said, after PMing Doc, I’m changing my vote. Honor’s Ghost All I have to go in is your votes… until you do, there’s not much I can do. Edit: VoteCount Ksauce(1): Stick Doc (2) Unkown, Jo Honor’s Ghost (2): Broken, Doc Broken (2): Honor’s Ghost, Ksauce

Yall wanted more analysis, so here we go. Some of this won’t have changed because I haven’t seen anything new from them. Unknown: same read as last time, he hasn’t posted since then, so I don’t really have anything new to go on. v!lean Walfacer: same as last time, nothing new has come up: I’ll look through Stick’s analysis/record of what he did though, and see if that changes anything Doc: is going after me. But has continually, that’s nothing new. Seems a bit tunnel-visioned though. Thanks for the explanation, it was helpful, and makes some sense to me. V!lean Wanderer: hasn’t posted or PMed since I last did this, so still V!lean. Mippo: I thought E!lean yesterday, but Honor PMed me saying that she trusted Mippo. So idk what to make of that situation. It’s is possible that they’re both Elims and Honor is covering for her. But in that case, I don’t see a reason for Mippo to say Honor is the Mistborn. worldhopper: in response to my last analysis, said they didn’t want to vote off of vibes. Which doesn’t make real sense to me, that’s all we have on that first day. So it could be nervousness over lack of info, but voting is how you play this game. So I’m not sure. Alvron and have Unkown have been voting, despite hanging back, but WorldHopper hasn’t. This is weird to me, and I’m not sure what’s happening. So, to be safe, continuing with E!lean Jo: keeps saying he’s voting off of vibes. I’m not sure what to make of that. At this point you should be able to have some analysis. He claimed he wasn’t soother. Idk here Alvron same read as last time, I haven’t gotten any new PMs from him nor has he posted. This will probably change as we vote and ties emerge. Stick: I haven’t looked that closely at her analysis/record of Ksauce. But her previous analysis has been good. This might change depending on that, but V!lean. Honor: hasn’t given a lot of analysis, which, as Doc said, gives E!lean, as an Elim doesn’t have much to post about. I’m not sure if that’s the case. If she’s Elim, there’s no reason for her to cover for Mippo, unless Mippo is Elim, and I already said why I don’t think that’s the case. Basically V!lean because it doesn’t make sense if she’s Elim, if she is Elim, she made some very weird decisions. There were some people I didn’t add to on the analysis, that’s because I haven’t seems anything from them in the last 12-ish hours. So if you want to see my analysis for that, it’s in Night 2. For now, based on this, I’m going to vote Worldhopper

I’ve posted a lot, you should have something to go on, but if not, here’s some more Can you explain why you think TMI is Elim? It seems to me that the more information we all have, the better. I’m not understanding why you think it is, other than you did something like that as an Elim in a past game. Also, I want Syl pictures. votes: IHAT (1): Doc Ksauce (1): Stick Doc (2): Jo, Honors Ghost

Oh, so they targeted the same person then, right? Edit: my worlds don’t matter now. But at least we know that it’s not an E!Coinshot world

Wouldn’t it be, if the Lurcher exists, they know who’s confirmed Villager. how would they know who to target?

Okay… so the Tineye was worried about being voted out…. Something made them worried. the real thing we need to pay attention to is the fact that only one person got killed. There’s a few scenarios where this happens. 1, we have a lurcher, or we have a mistborn who happened to get lucky. The other option is that they both did the same person. if they both did the same person, that pretty much debunks E!coinshot. There’s no reason for them to do that. now, if we have a lucher, or a lucky mistborn, the same logic applies to either on. E!Lurcher E!Coinshot (Blocked Coinshot) -this can’t be it, no stealing both Coinshot and Lurcher E!Lurcher E!Coinshot (Blocked Elim) -this can’t be it, same reasoning E!Lurcher V!Coinshot (Blocked Coinshot) -this would mean that the coinshot got the right person, and should do it again. E!Lurcher V!Coinshot (Blocked Elim) -This can’t be it, there’s no reason for them to block their own kill. V!Lurcher E!Coinshot (Blocked Coinshot) -Lurcher, you got very lucky, now you know who they’re killing, figure out why. V!Lurcher E!Coinshot (Blocked Elim) Same here, figure out why. V!Lurcher V!Coinshot (Blocked Coinshot) idk, here it’s an accident, the Lurcher has to block a different person, so the it should be fine if the Coinshot tries again, this was an accident V!Lurcher V!Coinshot (Blocked Elim) here, Lurcher, you know who they are trying to kill figure out why the problem is that the Lurcher doesn’t know if they blocked the Coinshot or the Elim. Not only that, but they don’t even know whether or not the Coinshot and Elim didn’t just hit the same person. the Coinshot and Elim are the only people able to tell if who got blocked, and only maybe. If the Coinshot didn’t kill counter, than they know they got blocked, but don’t know if the Lurcher is Village or not. This post is long, so I’ll post it as is, though I have more to thoughts to share later. However, I don’t know how we can tell which world we have without the coinshot or Lurcher(or mistborn) coming forward, which would then let the Elims kill them. I’m not even sure if anyone can know for sure

Finishing the reads from earlier: Counter: idk here. Blamed himself for losing our seeker, did he know that TJ was seeker? Does that mean he’s soother? Voted TJ based on PMs yesterday, if he knew TJ was seeker that would mean hard Elim. Something’s going on here, and it could easily be village or Elim, so no definite read, but E!lean just in case Unknown: idk much. I haven’t PMed Unkown, he’s voted to maintain and make ties just like Alvron. However, he has given thoughts and opinions and such. He’s promised analysis, so I’ll have to wait for that to know more. No read for now. Stick: voted for counter yesterday based on counter’s analysis of the Tineye message. Made some good points. So far, the analysis given has been good in my opinion, but I’d like to see some more. V!lean Story: I don’t have much to go on, but yesterday Story basically tried to say Honor’s ghost was a mistborn based on an offer to role swap when they’d already claimed smoker. This is weird to me. Why mistborn? Was the role-swap before or after smoker was claimed? And why didn’t you just ask her? It seems like Story is trying to throw suspicion on Honor’s ghost, and I can’t tell why. E!lean Edit: for those observant, we have a problem, I’ve now said about 3 E!leans and about 2 others idk about. That means I’m missing someone or something. Or the 4th Elim is doing a really good job

We don’t know when they used their soothe, it’s possible they used it to get ookla counter out, and then people started voting. edit: but you are right, the soother should tell someone edit 2: I’d like to know why ookla the counter said it was his fault. It’s a weird thing to say.

Okay, reads: Day 1, TJ, WorldHopper and Wallfacer didn’t vote, but we know TJ is villager. Day 2, WorldHopper didn’t vote. So, I don’t like how WorldHopper didn’t vote. So E!lean for that. Doc and Wanderer haven’t been very active, but they’ve been clear about that, and life getting in the way, so V!leans for both of them. Ksauce: I’m not sure here, it seemed like he was protecting TJ during the Day, which I interpreted as Elim action, but now that I know TJ was a seeker, that’s obviously not it. Did you know TJ was seeker? Honor: new, has voted off of vibes and feelings, makes sense as an unsure new player, V!lean Jo: I agree with Ksauce’s analysis that he’s the soother and probably village. V!lean Alvron: has stayed back, voted to maintain or create ties. Seems a bit weird to me, but when I asked, he said it was just part of his playstyle and how he doesn’t usually vote with reasons for a bit. I’m not sure what to make of it. It could be village not trying to exe out other villagers, it could be Elim trying to stay out of spotlight. Idk, no read for now. I’ll do some more later, but this is it for now Edit: I completely forgot about this, but TJ voted for Ksauce. Idk if he scanned him yesterday, but this might mean Ksauce is semi-confirmed Elim? Idk how to read that. We don’t know who he scanned, so…. It may not mean anything, idk

Your fault? Doc and Alvron voted later than you. Unless your the soother?

Yeah, we don’t know when the soother used their ability, so there’s not much to gain from that. Losing the seeker is bad. Idk if everyone would’ve trusted him is he said he was a seeker and pointed to someone as an Elim, but we don’t even have that option now.

This seems off to me, not the vote count, but that you suddenly don’t like ties after TJ gets something against him. When I questioned something TJ said, you voted me, when TUO votes TJ, suddenly you don’t like ties. Again, this looks like Elim covering Elim

So a tie, it’s up to the dice it seems, unless someone votes in the next hour and a half Edit: or the soother gets involved

I mean, they might be fine with how things are. A few votes would be a problem, but that’s not something they have to deal with right now. Which implies that the situation right now is good for them. So I’m going to switch my vote to Ookla the Counter partly to see if people suddenly start voting, and partly because I don’t want to be voted out Edit: this should cause us to tie

The 8 smokers came up from there being 9 power roles, (8 + original smoker) and so that leaves another 7 normal villagers without roles, who if all got gifted smokers would be a total of 8 smokers I’ve expressed my problems with that number, I think there may be more than 8, as there’s no way to verify thug or Lurcher until someone doesn’t die, ie, only 1 kill during Night or something like that.

Nah, it’s good, there’s nothing really to go on. Me being nice isn’t any worse than other options. I wasn’t trying to guilt-trip, promise : )

Like, I suppose I can get that, but part of me is like, “being helpful is a crime?” As for all the vibe votes, that’s fair, we don’t have much to go on otherwise

He never said, “max smokers” but he pretty much did. He said that if 7 smokers were given after removals, and then says there must not have been any removals. I’m pointing out that the Elims may have removed roles, and only gifted 7 smokers, we don’t know if they gifted the maximum amount of smokers. He’s using the existence of 7 added smokers to mean we got gifted max Elims, with all nine power roles staying or being stolen. We have no way of knowing they all exist. This is based on the assumption that the max amount of smokers was gifted, which I’m calling him out on. I will say, this sounds like and Elim protecting and Elim. But I’d like to hear your response before making judgements Edit: My vote has been discussed, I think the consensus was that the Soother soothed me to prove that they were the soother. The conversation was in Night 1, if you want to check that out

So I’m assuming you’re using the coinshot as an example and not just assuming they stole the coinshot. The problem is that there’s a lot of role combinations they could’ve stolen or removed. Also, we don’t know if they actually gifted max smoker’s, we could be missing roles and don’t know it yet. So this is giving E!lean to me. There’s a lot of assumptions that I don’t think have basis

So it basically comes down to whether or not we have a V!tineye or or E!tineye. And either way there’s suspicioun. With Elim, one of them is Elim, with V!, it’s pretty much just reasoning. Im hoping that the seeker found something and is telling people about it. Because that’s kind of where we’re at. Edit: I’ve probably PMed more than half the people here, but I’ll go do some more