Illwei
-
Posts
3479 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
1
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Illwei
-
Edited. Iit sent out early, very unfinished because I got in the habit of keeping my pinky on the control key... :P.
-
That reasoning seems way too IKYK. Hm, I'm going to vote on Jester. very unhelpful, I know. jester isn't really about to be voted out, and if I think Straw is innocent this doesn't neccessarily help them. I don't think Straw is an Elim though. I don't exactly know much about straw though so I don't have much to go on. Gears EDIT: Gears Jester Sorry @Experience
-
I was going to wait, because I thought that @CadCom was writing something....I guess not... I don't like what I'm getting from Gears, and that makes me more suspicious about the straw vote. maybe I should vote straw and then decide after, or maybe I should vote jester and decide after. whichever's easier. someone help me I'm doing my Psych homework I don't have time for this math.
-
Possibly the Elims might have talked about being okay with Voting out Silber, and when that didn't happen they changed their Elim Kill to Silber as he gives the least information. EDIT: Guys I'm getting a bad gut on Matrim because right after I marked Reading as sus Matrim does the same, and right after I basically voted Straw with no apparent reasoning Matrim does the same. @Matrim's Dice opinons?
-
Okay 100% forgot that today is when the cycle ends, as I have been busy with homework. Straw So..basically we're at Jester (1): Straw Matrim (1): Windrunner Straw (1): Matrim ...right? I need to find something to say. uh. people? can you guys talk so I can respond? Accuse me or something that could be exciting
-
I mean, I know? this is my...8th...7th...6th...7th? real game? been playing since LG67 in July.
-
I'm talking about LG 68, you and straw on the Elim team. I'm not saying it is one of you, I'm just saying that I haven't really played with people like that. I assume its more of a Straw thing (I mean, more him than you) but Idk who else thinks like that.
-
TO clarify I was speculating about why he got elim killed, not if he got elim killed. if you look at the top I had already assumed he was the Elim kill for those reasons in the second post this cycle. :P. Because matrim pointed out an alternative I'll say some more I guess The people I've been Elims with haven't really ever been enthusiastic about targeting inactives, which makes me honestly think it might be Straw or Matrim, or Ash, Mint, or Vapor, though that would make more sense to me if they were first time elims... I also don't know CadCom's playstyle, so...
-
I'm wondering if he got Elim killed because I was talking about how we shouldn't kill him, which removes him as a daykill target for the Mafia, and he's the least informational Elim kill. of course, other people seemed pretty okay with voting him out...soo.....idk. adfajsldfdhsaiufjasdfk I hate people saying they found tells on me agh
-
So Silber was Elim killed? I assume? it seems he didn't have an Aviar and I assume that Ghander was killed by traps. @Experience I assume we won't know the difference between a Nightmaw kill and a normal Elim kill? was going to ask this D1 but I was hoping someone else would so I could semi-clear them for it. no one really asked any questions so I can't think of someone who intentionally overlooked it. All I could think is Elk who might ask/intentionally not ask but he hasn't been active so that tells me nothing. :P. -- Assuming 4 Elims that means we're at.. 4/9 ? I'm not going to think about more people dying to traps, so...I guess we can kill two more villagers before being in trouble... but...only 1 if more people are going to die to the traps.... I need to think about the last cycle's votes. I pointed out slight suspicion on Reading, which Matrim and Straw jumped on, then Matrim backed off, then I voted Silber which Jester and Ash jumped on, then Jester backed off, then Matrim voted Ash, then Matrim took his vote off of Ash, then Jester took his vote off of Silber, then Matrim voted Reading, then Jester and Windrunner voted Reading? is that right? I need to think. for now Straw
-
Um doubt I'm going to die but I wanted to jot down that Straw does seem pretty protective of silber IMO, and Jester hopping on the vote seems less suspicious then Windrunner, but still sus.
-
That's an interesting gut feeling but I also understand the feeling lol. You know, Silber Reading I don't like doing this but he is my top read right now. Matrim and Straw don't feel completely village to me though.
-
I think that's the argument for not voting out Silber. IMO inactives help the Elims a lot more than they help the Village in the long run though, and with Silber there will be no way to tell if he's an Elim during the game unless something happens where he can suddenly be as active as Matrim usually is. Do you have any suspicions right now? (er, 40 minutes til rollover...)
-
the thing is my reasoning is it's no fun to die D1, but since reading is basically marked for death D2 there's no reason for me not to vote him now...
-
Yeah, but right now we don't really have any clue of who the elims are, It's D1. if you can explain your vote on Reading I might switch back, but just because there's no point in not voting him D1 if he end up getting voted off D2. Idk. My reasons for not killing people coming back after a break is because who comes into a game and is like "woot I can't wait to play for the first time in a while and get killed D1!" if they wanted that then they would have picked a cpec doc. Straw's read of Reading makes more sense to me, as Reading's view of Straw was basically hasty self defense. a kind of suspicious move. Matrim and Gears wanted to not kill anyone? can you point out where you saw this, because they were both explaining to...Ghander? that not voting only helps the Elims.
-
See now my problem here is voting out Silber doesn't give us really any info, but it gives us more people who will talk. voting out ash also doesn't give us much info, and it leaves us with less people who will talk. it's more likely we find out Ash is an elim in later cycles from them talking then it is for Silber.
-
Why would voting out ash be better than silber?
-
Ash and Jester jumping on the Silber vote doesn't really sit right with me.
-
Cool, I'll wait for your analysis to tell me why you think gears is a good choice.
-
It's not even a consensus it's just me and whoever voted before. he won't be on probably from what I know anymore, but I don't want to kill reading or Gears. (my two top suspicions rn). not sure how I feel about that post Jester, but you're new so- not much I can think from it.
-
Silber Does this work? Im on mobile this is stress. Im probably not going to be on. For a while, maybe until after rollover (hah, yeah right. Ill probably be back within the hour) I normally dont like contribution crusades but i have nothing thats not on new people and gears and reading, none of which i want to vote on.
-
I was 100% about to mark this suspicious before remembering that Experience is the GM
-
He played Sart's Free for all, but also died N1 there. I agree that I don't see the "when i flip village" as suspicious generally, but also you kind of have to take it on a case by case basis. I do think it's weird that Reading gave Straw an Elim read and not Matrim, but Straw was the first to vote. I was the first to mark him as sus though.
-
in what way would it clear Turtle? I mean, the only thing I'm getting off of you is tons of defense, and that's kinda wierd but also not unexpected
-
Im going to @people because im on mobile and its hard to quote posts @Matrim's Dice @Straw uh you do you but i personally dont think reading should be killed because this is his first game back in a while, though i guess you guys in particular would have a better idea of what reading looks like as an elim. I also dont have a great alternative right now so im going to have to look more. I mean right now i wouldnt be opposed to voting silber @Straw you never exactly gave your reasonings for voting reading? @The Windrunner Supreme can you explain what you mean by "lucky you" ? @Elkanah @Ashbringer @Vapor i know the LG is running, but if you guys could take 30 minutes and read through and weite at lest something in regards to who youre voting for that would be nice. @Frozen Mint @Lord_Silberfarben ,? Edit: ninjad by Matrim
