So, I'm suspicious of Gaea.
The elims have failed to make kills multiple turns in a row. If Gaea is the inactive, that makes a lot of sense.
They've also stated that they do take actions at night (though they haven't for the past two turns), showing that they are doing something.
But this only works if there really is two elims left. If that's true, I'm worried.
On the other hand, we have Elandera. Bard says Drake passed on this information to him. I was suspicious of an Elim!Bard in the past, but with a Village!Drake, I don't think it's gonna happen.
So I'm going to trust the information Bard got, and place my vote on Elandera.