Jump to content

Stick.

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    3863

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Stick.

  1. Stick.
    Hm okay well I scanned Silho and found that no one targeted him but I’ve asked if I’m informed of whether my action got redirected. If I wasn’t redirected, we know for sure that Silho did not get converted nor was he targeted by an Augur/Lurcher/Thug. Was hoping to catch the elim kill there but well. No, I was expecting death tbh. Since the mobborn recruitment comes before the exe, we can rule out the possibility of Araris having been their attempted conversion as that would have reflected in the write up. I can confirm that Alpha did not submit the elim kill, unless they are the tineye.
  2. Stick.
    I’m half asleep but hey I’m the skaa seeker do with that what you will edit: archer and araris can still be paired imo
  3. Stick.
    Now that’s the elim Mat I know! Allergic to breaking ties Im curious to know what’s making you village read Archer though
  4. Stick.
    VC: Stick(1): Mat Aman(2): Alpha, Silho Archer(2): Stick, Araris Alpha(2): DeTess, Aman Araris(1): Archer @Shining Silhouette how do you feel about Archer and Araris currently?
  5. Stick.
    No that's not it either omg xD They shield the player whose vote gets soothed off, and it's a random voter voting for the soother cuz beggars cant be choosers. At least that's my understanding.
  6. Stick.
    Is that how the soothe works? I’m pretty sure the conversion target being soothed prevents the conversion
  7. Stick.
    @Amanuensis Alpha was implying you’re Mobborn, who actually just can not die in a tie Admittedly I’d completely forgotten about that lil bit and am a little nervous about the state of the votes now.
  8. Stick.
    This doesn’t track because my vote retraction was an Edit, meaning that it wasn’t a spur of the moment decision and I’d taken the time to think. Am on mobile right now but you can check the exact time stamps of that post to see exactly how much time I took. And then I had time to rethink, and then rerethink. You yourself have pointed out in the past (in LG91 I believe) that E!me prefers to enter the thread with well crafted cases against villagers I want to push with pre-planned alternatives lined up. Oh no! There seems to be a misunderstanding here. You’re not a burden no as far as I’m aware everyone’s having fun playing with you! And we enjoy answering questions. Analysing players’ posts and picking apart usage of words and phrases like I did yours is just part of the game and is completely normal. Edit: It’s normal in the sense that it’s a common form of analysis - it helped me solidify my village read of you, for instance
  9. Stick.
    You…believe my claim? Edit: and as you should But when you say you think I backed off Mat too easily, can you explain what reason E!Me would have to do that at all, given that Mat was the only viable CW at the moment assuming we aren’t paired?
  10. Stick.
    Woah my post was like, after yours for a second and then they switched places o.O
  11. Stick.
    Hm…the larger number of players involved in the tie as we approach EoD, the smaller the pool of converts/NK targets to choose from. However, there is vote manip which the elim team may or may not have.
  12. Stick.
    @Amanuensis why the Archer vote, btw?
  13. Stick.
    Did people know that Augurs can target other players to learn their untrue role+alignments? Noticed this in the OoA and just got GM confirmation. Edit: This is actually great cover for elims sending in the NK. Beware.
  14. Stick.
    Oh wait, are we claiming? In that case, I'd also say that the Slowfooted Lurcher is the coolest of the roles.
  15. Stick.
    tfw informers and mobborn are alignments not roles Useless Augur is clearly the coolest role
  16. Stick.
    And yet this is more of a tunnel than I've seen you push in any of your elim games, if memory serves. I'll take that Why my vote's off Mat? E!Mat is almost always extremely passive when it comes to the exe (especially D1) and never tunnels or presents strong opinions. Why Archer? I'm voting from my PoE which is <Mat, Archer, Araris, JNV>
  17. Stick.
    It started on page 1 with my clear comment and has lasted 5 pages with increasing momentum. Let me be relieved in peace
  18. Stick.
    Wait...IT'S A MAT TUNNEL. AFTER SO LONG. I'm now considerably more confident and will be moving to Archer
  19. Stick.
    It's a little early for self pres No, I reread the cycle then reread some of LG92 and got myself confused again. What do you make of archer? I briefly considered throwing a vote on JNV just to see what happens.
  20. Stick.
    no Mat
  21. Stick.
    No I got that My question is how me trying to "find reasons to trust Mat, not become more convinced he's evil" points to an elim mindset. To me that sounds like a villager's approach to the game. What reason would v!me have to be more convinced he's evil without considering v!Mat at all? Looks like you missed my edit, but I pointed out that Alpha does tend to ask questions about these things. If I'm making a post outlining who I'm ruling out of my voting pile (especially given they have a vote already) then yes? Wouldn't go out of my way to say it. Yeah, I pointed that much out. But he's since then alluded to his role in a more explicit sense so I was wondering if you bought that. Edit: I can't decide if I want to village-read Archer for the exchange above or elim-read it. But the point about Mat and the lil linguistic analysis is convincing enough for the time being.
  22. Stick.
    That thought crossed my mind. Are you saying it’s TWTBAW? Interesting in what sense? The implication was that I would not expect E!Alpha to use the term lightly as they’d be aware of what it means from their doc, especially because the term had been thrown around in-thread prior. (Edit: ALSO. U_U Ninjad is, im pretty certain, not just an SE thing but more of a Shard thing. If you take a look at LG93 you’ll see that Alpha was VERY inquisitive about the SE lingo (e.g. asked what bolded names meant, what NAI meant, etc). So this observation just doesn’t hold. END OF EDIT) It’s important to mention when it’s relevant to me explicitly placing someone outside of my D1 exe options :P. This is not consistent with your earlier light village read of me and it’s too explicit of a defense for me to say Archer/Mat E/E. Why are you buying Araris’ claim? Was it even really a claim?
  23. Stick.
    I think at this point I'd be okay with any exe that isn't Silho, Alpha, and potentially (DeTess, Aman). Archer had a point about some of DeTess' comments seeming to display some TMI but I'll note that they had Mobborn-related queries during signups as well so evidently they've had a good read of the rules especially where the Mobborn are concerned so I'd say that stuff is NAI from them. In any case, DeTess should be left alone today on account of them being a returning player. Aman I'm getting slight not-elim vibes from but I'm afraid a lot of that is me giving derp-cred. That leaves (Mat, Archer, Araris, JNV) for today. Not sure what the vote count is, but I think it's currently tied between Mat and Araris.
  24. Stick.
    Also as far as I can tell Araris criticised an entirely different thing from DeTess’s posts: I don't like this. There's not really any practical way to distinguish between the two alignments, so this feels like the sort of theorycrafting an elim would do to look village, rather than an actual villager strategizing how to win the game.DeTess. Welcome back! Edit: I’ll also note that the word ‘clear’ is rather strong to be using in this context and for some reason this makes me feel even better about Alpha.
  25. Stick.
    Some thoughts on Alpha: These couple of phrases caught my attention as I'm unsure if V!Alpha usually is self-conscious about their how their posts may be perceived. I went through Alpha's LG93 to see if I could find some similarities/dissimilarities. This is usually Kas' job smh. Well so there's this post, where they add: Which...almost isn't the same? But there's this: And this: Which does seem in-line with their post style this game. They weren't doing much heavy theorising in LG93 like that Aman take here but that might just be the result of having gained some SE experience. So...I'm probably okay with my positive read on Alpha. The converted player gets a free PM with the Mobborn that converted them. Thoughts on the exe? It's a 9-player game I have less suspects to sift through. We'd barely hit rollovet. Plus, most of my vote changes occur as a result of real-time interactions so for example had Silho done something particularly off during our exchange I would've insta voted on him. One point in your favour is that E!Mat always v!reads me. But I'm pretty sure I called you out on that in your last elim game so it's probably not a tell I can reasonably rely on anymore. Five times* xD
×
×
  • Create New...