Jump to content

Elkanah

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    733

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Elkanah

  1. Elkanah
    Wow. That helps a lot. I'm not sure how helpful discussing who to scan will be in the future. With only two people to scan, I don't think it would make much of a difference, but now that there are five and counting, the scholars need to investigate in private. Sorry Kynedath, I had intended to respond to your post in my last one. I appreciate your earnestness. Like I said before, I don't blame you for voting for me. I didn't follow through on a commitment. however, I am not the enemy right now. I'd like to help in any way I can. I'd be willing to roleclaim if I thought it would help. Fortunately or not, I don't think the claims so far have helped us very much. Also, I'm sorry if my posts seem angry or defensive. I promise I'm not. Writing in thread is still new for me. double ninja'd
  2. Elkanah
    The only reason I see fit for him to wait to reveal the scan is we need whoever is checking him to come out first. Not the Scholar mind you, but the proxy. To make sure the other "scholar" doesn't just copy whatever PK says. They have to tell the proxy first. Then when a proxy comes foreward and says they have been told the result, We ask PK to claim. At that point the proxy will say yea or nay. That is the only way we can hold both of them accountable to not just copying the other. Problems with this: 1 We are putting a lot of trust in the proxy to not be an eliminator 2 We are trusting an anonymous claimed scholar who will receive no repercussion from killing PK over a claimed Scholar who is on the wire. 3 Anyone could claim to be in contact with a scholar just to either kill or save PK Overall, We may as well just take PK's info where we can and have him reveal. It sounds like the result was changed anyway and I'm ready to hear the troll. Funny, I started out this message to discourage PK from revealing yet, but as I weighed all the other options, it seems like it wouldn't spare us any grief. ALSO What has Maill done to be suspicious that you didn't do in thread as well? I realize that you won't be able to see this until near the end of the cycle, but I'd like a response when you're back. Some Parallels: Revealing factions Having Heated discussions over lynches Changing who you are voting for frequently. Frankly, I don't see any of these as inherently evil, I just want to show that anything Maill has done that is suspicious, you have done on a grander scale.
  3. Elkanah
    I concede. You're right. I should have posted yesterday. I wish I had. I'm even fine with you leaving your vote on me until you find someone who has done something more suspicious Than not posting for one cycle. What I would like to know is why are you going after me after I've become active as opposed to calling me out when I wasn't
  4. Elkanah
    You're right, Kynedath. I had expected to be active yesterday, and I don't have an adequate excuse. Partially, I didn't want to get involved in the shouting match that was going on, and partially I didn't have anything to add. I suppose most notably from yesterday my opinions would have been that I doubt the attack on Venture was a WGG. Also, I'm more interested in the people who voted for PK after it became a train than in the three who were to be lynched. I apologize for my inactivity. Although I do like to think more and talk less, I plan on helping the people of Urithiru in any way I can. And with as little information as we have that means posting. Edit: accidentally used the wrong name for the wgg.
  5. Elkanah
    Wow, three people were poisoned again? Why are the cooks so intent on killing people this game? I'm willing to guess that Stink's cook killed to prove their role. That may have been the Mace Windu cook. I'll bet the evil cook went after Adavantos. Which could mean whatever cook was upset at Maili last cycle might have gone after Hellscythe for the same reasons. Also I'm just about done with finals so I'll be able to contribute more now. I think something that bears going through is the four lynch trains from yesterday. I'll bet we can find a diagrammist or two lurking in the votes. Edit: 3 ninjas
  6. Elkanah
    Hey Everyone. I want you to know that I am trying to keep up with the thread. I had a final yesterday and two today, but after that I will have finished and can devote more time to this. Right now my I think there is at least one evil person actively involved in the discussion about Creccio, but I don't know who it is. It seems like too good a red herring to not try to push a lynch train... Unless of course Creccio is evil, then I'm probably wrong. Also, Maili, I thought your play was hilarious. Thank you for that. Sorry I know this doesn't add much, but I need to get back to finals.
  7. Elkanah
    I see your play. role block the mistborne and pin it on the hemalurgist. I don't expect to make it through the night, but when I die, everyone take note of who it was who was trying to turn the HI.
  8. Elkanah
    I'm becoming more suspicious of Fattemer. If he's evil it would make a lot of sense for him to be coming after me. If I die, the HI will subvert, which would give the evil team another vote. I'm also suspicious of Lopen. Looking back through the last couple of cycles, he was the one who posted the kill vote on Alfa and yesterday after leading the lynch on Burnt Spaghetti, he changed his vote to Biggoron. I think we should have the mistborne target phattemer. That way if he is a voidbringer, we'll have evidence of it and we can move on to other targets. If he's the biochromancer, then we may have killed the last traitor.
  9. Elkanah
    Yes you have my role wrong. I can't blame you though. I've been trying to stay out of sight to protect the HI, but we're to the point where that can't last any longer. I didn't know very many roles before the reveal, but based on my role and those the kandra has checked I'd say I trust Lopen's list. I've been thinking about this. Since there are only two people unchecked and we're of one consensus that there are only two traitors left. That means that if we kill one of the two and they are innocent, then Burnt is evil and we can kill her. But if She is on our side, then we just expedite the process by killing the only two traitors left. Either way we achieve the same results, the difference is I think Biggoron is more suspicious than Burnt Spaghetti because Biggoron lied about his role.
  10. Elkanah
    I agree with Lopen and Steph. Once we know if the Hemalurgist is good, we'll know about the HI. Also I was roleblocked tonight. I'm half honored and half afraid that I'm going to die.
  11. Elkanah
    This. Sounds. Awsome! Kael of the Forge has emigrated to this city eager to start a new life (and may get caught up in a new war).
  12. Elkanah
    I'll vote for Kipper. I was trying to hurry and post between two classes on my phone so I couldn't get the red. You are also right that we'll need any extra votes we can get so anyone who reads this, please vote. Edited for spelling.
  13. Elkanah
    Hey everyone, sorry for not being active. Thanksgiving was hectic and I spent what little time I had for SE trying to salvage QF: 11, which turned out to be a massacre anyway. So far this game and in the other game, all of my suspicions have been wrong so I'm kind of afraid to place a vote. My top three suspicions are probably not useful, but here they are: Kipper Alfa Arraenae The reason Kipper is at the top is the coincidence in his voting pattern. Other than that, Alfa hasn't responded really to being up for the lynch, and I would like to have him scanned. Arraenae is just a gut feeling. I guess there is also a lynch train on Araris right now, so maybe I'd put him fourth. Sorry it's short. I'll try to get back on and place a vote before the day's over.
  14. Elkanah
    I agree with meta that lopen has been very suspicious. he hasn't been marked as inactive yet, but there have been multiple cycles wherein he hasn't posted anything. Even more suspicious to me is how he's stayed active, but hasn't defended himself. My vote is on Lopen today. Also there's only half an hour left. Please everyone post something.we can't afford any more inactivity deaths... unless you're a traitor, then I'm happy not to hear from you.
  15. Elkanah
    Wow, three kills one night, four the next. Who needs cultists? The weather will kill us all.
  16. Elkanah
    The only other people who have posted a list of suspicions were Clanky and Creccio. Both of them listed me and Jain in different orders. Both of them died that night. Since those were the only lists I've seen and you mentioned via PM that you felt the same, I thought others may have been like minded. I was going to do an analysis on a possible wgg, which led me to suspect Clanky, but before I posted it, Clanky died and was proven innocent. I mostly wanted to point out that just because they were protected didn't mean they were proven. However, with the excitement of activity Meta has provided and with the lack of counterclaiming for protecting himself and Clanky, now I'm almost sure he is good. I've already said that Jain is my first suspicion. My other suspicions have been killed or lynched, so I'm working on getting a new list. It sounds like Alv is the next popular vote followed by Lopen. I haven't seen enough of them yet, but I will be watching them more closely. Edited for Clarity
  17. Elkanah
    Sorry Meta you're right to be frustrated. We all know everyone's excuse. We're lucky it didn't turn out worse. I don't know which rulo suggested we look at number 14 through 17, but it seems like they knew something. I know that points to me. I know I'm good, but I'm also at the top of most lists. With me aside, that leaves Lopen, who was just saved, and Jain, the only person who is more suspected than I am. Several of the people who have died have also voted for Jain. That isn't certainty, but it's enough to gain my vote this cycle
  18. Elkanah
    Wow, this is my first quick fix and it feels like it's speeding through without us. For my vote, I wasted most of my time on the code and not enough time analyzing the thread. Near the end of the cycle I voted for Ostrich because I hadn't heard anything from them. I didn't realize they were going to die anyway. Sadly, we may end up losing several traders to the freezing conditions. I would guess with the words of mod we've received, that the cultists probably have a soldier. I don't know why else Maill would be so adamant at reminding us that there are other possibilities. If it was incorrect why wouldn't he just let us fool ourselves. Also, if he balanced the game off of that it could mean there are fewer cultists than we might expect. I also realize it was this line of thinking that slit Hellscythe's throat last cycle. I may be wrong. I don't think I am. What does that mean for us? I'll bet the cultists kill and save one of their own to clear them. I wouldn't lynch Meta or Claan over that, but I also can only soft clear them. At the same time, if Hellscythe was right, the traitors may have had a hand in lynching him. I'll look at that more closely in the morning Edit: ninja'd twice. Also Ooklah save us!
  19. Elkanah
    After much study and wasted time, I have determined that the code is not an anagram and I can't think of an acronym for the four bolded letters. The carriage returns are what I thought would help the most, but I don't have any more time to try and crack it. Kudos rulo. Your skills are beyond me. Also Yes, I voted hastily yesterday I feel like a lynch gives us more info than no lynch.
  20. Elkanah
    I think Meta is just mad that Creccio ate all the stew. Seriously though, I probably will be voting for Creccio today. As for the Seon holders, It almost seems like they benefit the traitors more than they benefit us. If the traitors can't PM to coordinate kills or blocks or whatever else they have a severe handicap. They either have to start speaking a language from star wars in thread or find another way to code their moves. Edited because I need to learn how to spell
  21. Elkanah
    I agree that we need a lynch Day 1, but I have no leads. From the few posts we've had so far, the only people that have struck me as odd are Meta and Creccio. I'm willing to believe that Meta is just trying to get people to post, which almost makes him a valuable asset. I am suspicious of Creccio, but I'm suspicious of everyone. It's very possible that these two only stand out to me because they have played a prominent part in the conversation so far, while the cultists lay low. Haha, That is unfortunate. Lesson learned I won't do that. XD I will hold on to my vote for now, but I want to place one before the end of the cycle.
  22. Elkanah
    Sorry, thanks for correcting me. I'll tie up the vote in the interest of holding on to a hemalurgist then. At least until we can scan him. (3) Alfa: Stink, PK, Adavantos, Kipper, Hellscythe 2, (0) Stink: Rae 1 (0) Phattemer: Hellscythe 1 (3) Bort: Hellscythe 3, Rae 2, Elkanah Edited for phone autocorrect
  23. Elkanah
    The HI can only scan for roles. Although, If he could scan for alignment that would be awesome. Here are the votes so far: (3) Alfa: Stink, PK, Adavantos, Kipper, Hellscythe 2, (0) Stink: Rae 1 (0) Phattemer: Hellscythe 1 (3) Bort: Kipper, Hellscythe 3, Rae 2 We are currently tied and I'm almost inclined to leave it that way. If Alfa is a hemalurgist, it is important that we check his alignment. I’m submitting him for the kandra scan tonight, but I've been suspicious of Bort since day 1. It was too much of a coincidence for him to save Bridge boy one day and then Wilson the next. Edited to include my vote in the tally (3) Alfa: Stink, PK, Adavantos, Kipper, Hellscythe 2, (0) Stink: Rae 1 (0) Phattemer: Hellscythe 1 (4) Bort: Kipper, Hellscythe 3, Rae 2, Elkanah
  24. Elkanah
    It may be late in the season, but AL doesn't mind a little snow. Sign me on if it isn't too late.
  25. Elkanah
    For now I'm going to retract my vote from Orlok. While he is still certainly not cleared, I don't feel like him disagreeing with other people's playstyle is worthy of death. I apologize for the hastyness of my vote. While it is regrettable to kill Badger, he hasn't helped us out very much (to my knowledge). As I understand it, he was next on the mistborn list anyway. I'll save my vote though, until we get more information.
×
×
  • Create New...