Jump to content

Kynedath

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    1051

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Kynedath

  1. Kynedath
    Uhhh . . . I'm not sure what to think right now. You could be telling the truth, but flipping your vote like that sets off a lot of alarms in my head. It doesn't seem right. STINK, What you are saying about Rae could also be a good lead, but it also seems like something is off there. I know that I can't count anything out with you since you're the most erratic player I know of, but that seemed like a deflection. Besides, yes, Rae did have the same reasons to vote on Alv as for me, but I am the one on the chopping block and I hadn't played very well before that either. I kind of expected the heat that I received. I'll probably get accused of trying to save Rae, but I'm not. I just don't see your logic in this. But why would you all of a sudden defend me? Would you be trying to distract people from something I said? Did I strike a flaw in the logic of your teammate? Oh! Here we go, what if Arinian made a mistake due to their inexperience (i recall them saying this was their first game) and then you had to do something to save them.Your call to change the vote and Arinians vote swap seem to line up with each other suspiciously. It would be possible for you to have told them what to do in a doc and then shortly thereafter give them an out. You couldn't just vote for me, because that just would have proved the point that I made. You had to somehow keep me from dying and convicting your teammate, so you tried to swing the vote completely. Ballsy move, but I would expect nothing less from the mighty STINK. You guys are all going to accuse me of trying to deflect attention away from myself, but honestly, at this point, if I die and prove to you that I'm innocent, and therefore give you guys proof that these guys are eliminators (if they are) then I'd call that a win for me. I could be wrong in every aspect of this, but if I'm not, then I'd be proud of myself. I am going to keep my vote on Arinian. If my theory is correct, then they are still an eliminator, and they are a lot closer to a lynch than STINK is.
  2. Kynedath
    So you accept the statement that you and I have the same alignment, and you choose to lynch me, knowing that if I'm an assassin, the village is coming after you next. Now me, knowing that I'm innocent, thinks that there are a couple options. Either you are malicious and don't want to die, or else you are an assassin and this is an easy way for you to clear yourself with the rest of the village and kill one of us off at the same time. But let's entertainthe idea that I am an eliminator. If that was the case, then my role would be revealed as such and the village has soft decided that Arinian would also be an eliminator. So therefore Arinian would die too. At least if you guys acted on that. So what good would it do for an eliminator to kill another eliminator if it meant they would die too? It makes no sense! Arinian I know that it's one of the first two options that I stated, and I think it's probably the second one. And yes, I am voting to save myself, but I'm not JUST voting to save myself. My arguments are valid enough to base a vote off of. If I was an eliminator I would lay low. That's what I found as an eliminator. I can't prove it, but it's logical. Going after people just for the sake of killing them isn't what I would do. I know that isn't a proper defense, but I don't know how else to defend from that.
  3. Kynedath
    Yeah, I figured I'd draw some fire from all of this. Let me clear something off first. I'm not good at SE. I've never claimed to be. I make a metric ton of mistakes all the time. I know that this isn't an excuse, but I just want to make that abundantly clear. Now to actually defend myself. If my accusations feel forced, it's because I think that we need information. I felt that we need to have peoples reactions and therefore reached for something to accuse someone of. It was not very well founded I will admit, but I just wanted more information. My initial vote on Ecthelion was because of his items, but when the counter-evidence was presented, I didn't retract my vote. I did that because, again, I thought we needed information. Based on Ecthelions innocence, I would have been able to form suspicions. That is what happens on Day 1. Most likely an innocent villager will die and we try to go from there and lynch eliminators based on the information collected from people's reactions and interactions. My posts felt weak and forced because I'm not used to Day 1 lynches. I've said that before. Under normal circumstances, I am avidly against Day 1 lynches. Then again, we don't have any roles this game, so we need to gather information another way. I defended my vote as facts and analysis before the info came out that that wasn't true. I had looked over the details that were later put out. I had made a mistake. But I didn't update my vote because, again, we need information and I felt like lynching Ecthelion was going to give us the most of that. If you want to lynch me for info . . . go ahead I guess. I can't really deny that since that is the entire base of my argument. But I didn't try to save Arinian. At least not on purpose. I just didn't see everyone's reason for trying to lynch them when all they had done was not say anything yet. May I ask why you find me suspicious? Is it just for the reasons Doc stated? Or is there more to it? I would just like to know so that I can defend myself from it if I haven't already.
  4. Kynedath
    Yeah, it is kind of a forced suspicion, but it's not because I'm an eliminator. This is Day 1 in a purely discussion based game. I like to normally wait and get a solid read on people, but we can't do that in this game. If we don't get discussions going really quick, then we are at a severe disadvantage. I know that I was reaching a bit far for something suspicious, but it was, and still is, a possibility, even if it is a small one. About it not being "like a natural gut read", in all honesty, I don't have very many gut reads. I go off of mostly facts and analysis. I'm not used to contributing to Day 1 lynches either. Yeah, I dropped my vote. That's because other people came up with real possible evidence against someone that I hadn't noticed. Like I said, I normally go off of facts and analysis, but we don't have very much of that since the game just started. And just something picky about your choice of words, more likely to be an eliminator indicates the probability of the RNG making me an eliminator. I had just as much chance as everyone else did. I think that you meant "I think Kynedath is most likely an eliminator" or something along those lines, indicating the probability of me actually being an eliminator out of all the choices presented. Sorry for being a grammar nazi though. I just noticed it and thought it prudent to say something.
  5. Kynedath
    Back in elementary school, I wrote a short story about a cyborg mushroom who had to save the forest from the trees. He had a giant lazer that could kill the trees in one shot, but there were so many of them that he had to get out his cybernetically implanted cell phone and call up the grim reaper to kill the rest of the trees. I also drew a picture for it. I "lost" that picture. And the story. And my pride.
  6. Kynedath
    It always is!
  7. Kynedath
    I'm keeping my eye on you.
  8. Kynedath
    Why? Why all of a sudden retract your vote with no reason?
  9. Kynedath
    Thanks. I thought I had pulled out of the game before it started, but apparently not.
  10. Kynedath
    Yeah, I guess it is a bandwagon, but we have a lead on someone in cycle 1. The sooner we find an eliminator, the easier it will be to find the rest. At least in theory. Since there is an actual reason to suspect them, I'm wondering why you choose to even out the vote. There isn't a clear reason as to why everyone is voting on Arinian, at least to my knowledge. They just haven't responded to this thread when people have called them out. So why try to save Ookthelion? Are you an eliminator with them? Are you trying to save them?
  11. Kynedath
    Yeah, that's the premise of my, if not everyone elses, accusations.
  12. Kynedath
    Agreed. When I was describing my character, I said that he wielded two long daggers and a bow. I got those exact items in my inventory. Looking at the evidence others have put out, I would also like to hear Ookthelion's story. I guess that means I give up my pursuit of Lopen. Oh well. Maybe we can continue later. Well Ookthelion? Where did you hear about these tenets?
  13. Kynedath
    Yeah, I'll try this one. I've never played one of the shard games before since they seemed way too complicated at the time (or I just wasn't there) but I think that I might be able to keep up with this one. Maybe not. Who knows? I'll sign up as Desten Kyde. Starting out on Roshar please.
  14. Kynedath
    Yeah, I didn't really word that well, but you still drew attention away from yourself and tried to gather trust by giving out that list. You didn't have any suspicion, but you were setting yourself up to be more trusted and less likely to be accused later on.
  15. Kynedath
    @Kasimir I assume that this is a day one baseless vote to promote discussion? Yeah, I was on to check my alignment, but I really needed sleep and so I put off posting until today. As for rp, I enjoy it, but I'm not going to let myself do it. I don't have the time lately. Maybe in some later games when I have less to do, but I just can't afford it right now. For those who remember games played with me, I was strongly against first day lynches. I felt that they were counter-productive and that if there was no basis for the accusations, that they shouldn't be killed for doing nothing. However, since this game is based on discussion, I believe that a day one lynch would be useful to us since we need the info as soon as possile. It might also be useful to have a list of players new to SE if there are any. Even just players who have played less than five games. They tend to act differently than veteran players so it would be nice to know what to look for in them. Since I have been gone for some time, I'm not in a position to make that list, but if anyone else would be kind enough to do that, I would highly appreciate it. I vote Lopen for now. You shifted suspision from yourself to others with your list of who had been on but hadn't posted. It's not much, but like I said above, we need to lynch someone and you are my best guess.
  16. Kynedath
    Ah yes. I remember that now. Sorry, I'm not too big a fan of the later eras of Scadrial.
  17. Kynedath
    After some digging, I have realized that I was not correct. That was a different person. I was referencing this post and an interesting system of magic another sharder has made. Unfortunately, I did not bother looking at who had originally posted it when I made my earlier comment. @Darkness Ascendant said something about a reference and I didn't get which reference he was talking about so I thought he was talking about that post.
  18. Kynedath
    Okay. Goodbye friend!
  19. Kynedath
    Oh shoot! You're the logic magic guy aren't you? No, that was completely accidental. Sorry.
  20. Kynedath
    Awww, you care about me! I'm flattered. In all seriousness though, how does that work? Could you please explain your logic in this matter?
  21. Kynedath
    Who you callin' a kid? You don't know me, how old I am, or what I've done. I'd ask for a bit or respect. Just a tad.
  22. Kynedath
    You got it boss!
  23. Kynedath
    Yes it was. An acronym is just a representation of a string of words. Its the same as the letters you used to represent it in the first place. There is no difference between your string of letters and mine. They are just two different representations of the same thing.
  24. Kynedath
    . . . It's an acronym of what's in quotation marks.
  25. Kynedath
    Oh my. You didn't even know what you had said? Goodness gracious me! Of course that was in the quotation marks. I wouldn't dream of suggesting anything else!
×
×
  • Create New...