Jump to content

Burnt Spaghetti

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    1108

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Burnt Spaghetti

  1. Burnt Spaghetti
    Well huh. Congrats to my fellow pass winners! I look forward to that Zelda game, Striker Ping me when that happens xD I've never gm'ed so, we'll see if i make use of it, but I may have an idea in the works with Kas soo I might actually get to make use of that Thanks to the peoples who voted for me though <3 Also Striker, Stick, and Elkanah, be ye warned that I've added you to my 'must pm asap' list for future games I really enjoyed our pms and i'm excited for future games. Also Elkanah! feels like forever since we last played together! Also Maill! Shame you died so quickly though Hope to run into you two more often in future games Also everyone post so I can upvote you on your main account in honour of all the awesome rp that everyone did!
  2. Burnt Spaghetti
    Apologies for not posting earlier this cycle Firstly- very glad kas ended up being villager after straight up asking me to drop a vote on him in pms. Secondly- thoughts on Kas' mega post in case striker happens to be evil. Which, I admit is becoming a legitimate concern of mine given that if he's villager, its game( - village would have had 4 of their own nominated, leaving elims with a max of 3 of their own on the team). It really really bothers me that there's only one vote not on him. Perhaps the elims got unlucky and are full of inactives, but i suspect otherwise. If strikers good, then yay! woo! Celebrations! But if not. Then there be problem. would be very telling though! But then its also like, if striker was evil, why no hammer on his direction? Probably because the elims were probably either asleep, or had already voted. Additionally, Kas being nominated wouldn't be a huge loss to the elims since he a good chatty player. So kas was super suspicious of fifth. I admit after talking to kas in pms, I was quite suspicious too. If striker is evil, that'll shed good light on fifth, but I feel like regardless there'll still be a lot of uncertainty around them. I do acknowledge though that confirmed good doesn't mean confirmed right so we could've very well been very wrong about fifth, i guess time will tell? Given the arguing between fifth and striker, i get the impression that they are definitely highly likely not evil together so there's that. So yeah. not many thoughts but thoughts never the less. Looks like strikers the one being nominated unless something drastic happens in the next hour heh. but yeah. Im worried that strikers going up too easy. waaay too easy. This game is also weird in that theres what. 11 players left? But it's like there's only 6.
  3. Burnt Spaghetti
    Vote Tally: Striker (3): Bard, Kas, Straw Kas (1): Wonko, Wonko (1): Fifth -------- So, if i'm honest, i'm more than happy with a striker nomination. My current thoughts- The corrupted either need to get one of their own nominated this cycle, or ensure they all become trusted enough peoples that they can guarantee they can get one of their own in each cycle for the rest of this game. My thought process: If striker is village, then primarily fifth, and secondarily now Wonko, are the players who are directing attention elsewhere with votes atm. Which has a suspicious feel to it. Now that being said, if striker flips evil i'd probably be a little more inclined to trust them both considerably more. And again, all that being said, I'm cautious about Wonko, but both striker and Kas I personally trust. And if a striker nomination is going to net us info, my head goes "well how can we maximize the amount of info we gain?" and for some reason, the answer was "lets make it a closer match and see what happens!" soooo yeah. Kas
  4. Burnt Spaghetti
    Okay weekend of chaos done, now to try to actually analyse stuff! Okay so I've been tracking peoples votes just as an ease of access thing, so figured i'd share that: Player | Who they have voted for (in chronological order) (colours to show the alignments we currently know) Rath: Aman Aman: Aman, Aman, Rath Burnt: Bard, Pejidot Kas: Wibble, Xino, Stink, Fifth, Aman, Fifth, Straw, Bard Fifth: Striker, Burnt, Rath, Burnt Striker: Striker, Aman, Aman, Rath, Aman, Kas Wonko:Kas, Bard, Rath, Fifth Bard: Bard, Stink, Wibble, Aman, Striker Coda: Bard, Kas, Bard, Fifth Pejidot: Aman GoWibble: Stink Straw: El, El, El At this point I'd be content with either Kas fifth or Striker being nominated tbh. To be decided later though. I am exhausted and need sleep >> Again apologies for my major drop in activity over the last two cycles- I should have a bit more time to try focus on the game from here on out now the assignments are out of the way.
  5. Burnt Spaghetti
    Sorry for not resoonding fifth, im currently a little overwhelmed with getting final assessment stuff done which is all due shortly after this cycle ends so, tad busy >> im fairly certain i dont have time to do much analysis until after thats done but if i find a moment where i can afford to procrastinate a little ill try but i may not get to posting again this cycle. Ill try but yeahhh....
  6. Burnt Spaghetti
    Well then. Hey, At least it was only one this time and not three >> welp. but hey, information is gained! Now we can vote in more informed manners! siiigh okay well that makes bard a tad suspicious considering that last minute vote then. blarh im tired and don't want to think through all the implications this means >> ill comment tomorrow >>
  7. Burnt Spaghetti
    Vote tally: Aman(2): Rath, Striker Kas (2): Wonko, Coda{2} Stink (2): GoWibble, Kas{3} Burnt (1): Fifth{2} Elbereth(1): Straw Pejidot (1): Burnt{2} Bard (0): Burnt{1}, Coda{1} gowibble(0): Kas{1} Striker (0): Fifth{1} Xino(0): Kas{2} Post counts! Kas: 5 Aman: 4 Bard: 4 GoWibble: 3 Striker:2 Fifth: 2 Coda: 2 Burnt: 2 Straw: 1 Wonko: 1 Rath: 1 Stink: 1 No posters: @xinoehp512, @Pejidot, @Aragorn --- Okay thoughts: current concern is that the two current candidates for being put inot the fellowship? They talky players. In fairness, talking is what helps us get to trust people but. There's a concern yknow that getting rid of talky people thiiis early? ehhhh thats dangerous. Also Bard. I'm trying to decide what i want my vote doing. Admitably i'm very very tempted to roll a dice and choose someone entirely random which may be a terrible idea but, eh. EH. EEH! Or just someones whos not spoken at all hmm. Cause are there people i trust ish right now? Yeah! But I don't want to 'kill' off those trusts right now its a problem. Hm. Yeah lets go with.... Pejidot! I'd love to hear if you have any thoughts about this game and if theres anyone you trust so far or if theres anyone that makes your eyes narrow a smidge in suspicion
  8. Burnt Spaghetti
    Alrighty then, round 2, here we go! With the changes, i think it'll still be quite important that we all do our best to vote in ways that don't allow for any hammering. At least the soothe isn't going to interfere now but yeah. I think it would be good to see nominations with perhaps 3+ votes on them so that when they go through, theres more information. Idk lets just see how it all goes heh --- This was a task of great importance. Tinuial would happily give her aide to the success of the mission, but they had been requested to nominate others. She did not yet know those around her, so her eyes were drawn to another Elf who stood amongst the gathering of people. The messenger representing the Mirkwood Elves "Myself I am no great fighter. Yet It is my wish that amongst those that take upon themselves this quest, there is a mix of all races in attendance. As such, I propose that Phellom, a fellow elf, may be granted a place with those travelling as the representative of our kind. They have done well to travel here on there own, and so I have faith that they would do well on this journey as well."
  9. Burnt Spaghetti
    Well that was an interesting and unexpected cycle. Enjoyed the time i had with that team, and i'm looking forward to what this means for round 2! Definitely still playing and since Tinuial didn't actually do any evil stuff herself i'll be keeping her as my character. Also many thanks to kas for the rp times in the pms- really enjoyed that. Sad to see you go but its understandable given your workload and the sheer amount of effort you were needing to dedicate to this. Tinuial wishes Kavan all the best
  10. Burnt Spaghetti
    A mottled gathering of wanderers, gathered from near and far. Gathered together around a small piece of metal with a power and weight greater than the dwarven army combined. Decisions to be made, a journey to attain. From humble hobbits and wanderers to dwarves and elfs. A strange bunch to be candidates to take this ring of power to be destroyed. Tinuiel pulled her journal out of her satchel and opened it up to a new page. In it she began to write her thoughts surrounding those who spoke. Beren - a bold man. First to speak, first to nominate himself. A leader in nature perhaps. Evidently a fighter. There will certainly be times in this journey where such a thing will be needed. But men lust for power, who can say a creature like himself would not fight to take the ring for his own. Scar - Hobbit. A strange creature. Drunk. Violent. Unpredictable. Current bearer of the ring. Concerning. Questionable motives. Has the ring already taken effect or is this their usual state? Kavan - A brave man wishing aide for his home. He possesses wisdom that is born from experience. His priorities lie with his King and his homeland which may be problematic however his reluctance to participate make speak well for his ability to resist the draw of the ring. Coda - They have an admirable enthusiasm although may be a bit too eager. Their passion could be good for keeping up the moral of the group. Skill with stealth may also prove useful. Dronlir - Attendant of the large dwarf. His strength may prove useful and his willingness to help someone else as an attendant may be a positive indicator of his nature Bombur - The entirely too large dwarf. Would be a poor edition to the party. No horse should have to deal with carrying him, and being able to ration food on a long journey is crucial for survival. Is proving to have a nature of greed, at least when it comes to food so may be a risk to have near the ring. However, is the first of us to nominate a name other than their own which is quite admirable The Sane one - the first to begin inquiring into the genuineness of those around them Striker - A honest sounding man. Amnesiac- may be a boon or a bane. We shall have to see. Tinuiel realized that no other soul had spoken than those she had listed so far. Only half. She was sure that the others would speak soon though. Perhaps she should speak herself. But no. For now she wanted to observe so her decisions may be informed ones.
  11. Burnt Spaghetti
    Oh yeah, my character btw: Cosmetic role: Clandestine Attendee Tinuial is a Elven woman of a solitary nature. She is never seen without her note book, in which she keeps her thoughts, both reflective and creative. I may or may not have plans to try write parodies for once in a long time. We'll see if that actually happens or just poetry. We'll see
  12. Burnt Spaghetti
    Hellooo I be joining! I'll be rping but still have to decide on a character so that'll come later
  13. Burnt Spaghetti
    Elbereth was the handler. Elbereth. Wilson being spy, okay sure- good job btw and all that. But el was the handler? Wait what??? O_o that. Huh. Okay. Well then. Well that was a great game, thanks hael and kas for running this. I had a lot of fun being evil, got to be evil with alv for longer than one cycle, which is a record! Now just need to be evil together again and both survive past cycle 2! Also love that we all forgot that we only had to outnumber village and were planning for the scenario where they all needed to be killed >> definitely read the rules i swear >> Definitely love the assasination round. Giving village the opportunity to have a cycle where they can be trolls is awesome Love love loved the writeups and the rp that came out of this game. Even though being a qf doing a lot of rp was a bit challenging, this game as a whole and the people in it and all the rp kinda felt like being back at home in the eaarly days. Though also it blew my mind at one point when i realised Elandera had never played with Wilson before and that people existed who hadn't played with the players i played with when i was still a kid in school and now im like. Woah. Im an old player. And old player still terrified of voting in thread and being vocal Anyways i need sleep as usual so if i remember thouhts theyll come but yeah Twas a fun week. I wanna go again can we have a part c lol
  14. Burnt Spaghetti
    Oh my appologies! Striker ------ On a serious note, I will be going with Stink because i don't have any better ideas
  15. Burnt Spaghetti
    To be fair wilson, if you call this cycle 6, then you've participated in 3 cycles, which is half the game. Quick games are very quick! If this were a midrange or long game, I'd have wanted you to survive a lot longer than 2 cycles for sure. And even though you were only alive two cycles, you did an amazing job of reading whos evil and whos not and was really refreshing to see you in thread again. I really do hope to see you ingame again <3 Okay so here are my thoughts: 1. Wilson: right out of the gate she was suspicious of not only one, but two of us eliminators. That being said, i consider her a legendary tier player- it would not be out of character for her to simply be that right so quickly. Additionally if she was the spy i think shed have put attention on a villager as well and not have come out and talked about only elims that quickly. Although perhaps her goal was to remove alv then be stealthy after but i don't think that is the case. So i think she was just being a very good player, and not the spy. 2- stink was the only villager to ever vote for me. While elandera and alvs names were getting thrown around mine never was mentioned until stink. Who then died. 3- following on to that i feel like the spy may have died fairly early on- again basing this off of the fact that no one was coming after me. There was definitely no spy in the last 6 players. Elanderas name got thrown around a lot, and this may have been the result of the spy handler so id say the spy would be someone who at least mentioned elandera, and that may being agreeing with someone elses view on them -not necessarily initiating the discussion them If its not stink then its definitely an early death person
  16. Burnt Spaghetti
    Elbereh was my favourite villager. Definitely the spy ;P
  17. Burnt Spaghetti
    Okay... So current votes are one vote on elandera by rath, and two votes on rath by el and rae... Kay let me preface this with im tired again as per usual >> I've been out all day doing things like meeting Daniyah and Am going out again this evening to be social again with other people. Elandera: Rath, Rath: Elbereth, Rae Non voters: Myself, Bard, Elandera I'll echo rath here, even tho its late. Everyone voting is somewhat necessary right now. Im really quite exhausted atm so bear with me as i ramble potentially nonsensically El has sorta been the only one defendign elandera at all in a way, could be allied. Rae been main person against elandera- probably not teammates. Peoples votes across the whole game El: rath devotary wilson venture striker Rath: elanderax2 Elandera: devotary venturex3 Bard: devotaryx2 venture Rae: rath elandera striker Does this mean stuff. Elanderas focused on one person a lot, els been bouncing around to a new person each cycle, rath only looking at one person, rae bouncing around, bard focusedish on one person till they dead and plus another. uhh hm. current living people have voted for elandera more than anyone else. Rath coming in second there. if we were lynching for info id say elandera. too late. much too late. too few people. far too few. danger. danger will robinson. we in the danger zone. Mayday. Roll over, roll over, so they all rolled over and one fell out. one less people in the tea house. 6 people left in the teahouse and someone said "you're evil! you're evil!" so they all voted and one guy died. 5 people left in the teahouse. unless protection. also night kill. IM TIRED. can you tell? what was i saying *hums* uhhh and everyone died and the little one said "oh no now i miss my friends" and they were under a table and they said "come over, come over" so the little one joined them and they all cheered up "good night, goodnight!" i want sleep wait wheres the colour for text... am i blind? Oh. no just with a small window it poofed. okay Elandera Why am I out of chocolate. Also you havent voted. badness. youve been talky this cycle, ya hsoulda vote. you listed me and rath as neutral to elim so why havent you voted on one of us? the bardy bardy should vote Oh right i was trying to analyze who i thinks teams Elandera+Elbereth cause of el defending the elandera, vs Rae. at this point surely one of the three has gotta be evil or something. like. idk. theres 6 of us. so theres at most 3 elims i think cause win cons so chances of all those 3 being good is low so thats why im voting elandera cause El ive read as good, though could be influenced by her apparently trusting me ( <3 ) and id rateher vote on a candidate already voted on thatn a new one cause new one isnt useful at this point right? Even though ive ben npretty on the fence with elandera I DUNNO uhhhhh yeah ill stick with that cause ive been also reading rath pretty village this cycle tbh. they seem the most concerned about the game hitting lylo right now which seems genuineto me so thats why im not voting htem and goin with elandaera did you know im tired and canst spell and why do i have nursery rhymes rolling over around in my head im tired and have been out and been social all day hello good bye, i sleep.i need slep.
  18. Burnt Spaghetti
    Thats fair. Thanks for answering. Id be suspicous had your vote been changing the lynch target, but as it was on the already leading candidate, thats fair enough. I dont think id expect an elim to vote so last minute like that and risk revealing themself if the lynch was already settled. And tbh i feel like it may be safe to say whoever had the vote manip may have already died since weve not seen it in a while? Unless its an elim and theyve just had noneed to yse it because were so bad at picking correct lynch targwts...
  19. Burnt Spaghetti
    Eyy congrats Kas! And guys? Im worried that we're running low on villagers. Well i said id try my pm methods so here we go @Elandera you are not having much luck with your vote choices. So my question for you is not who you dont trust, but rather, who do you trust and why, if any? @Young Bard that was a very very last second vote there. Why wait so late? @Rathmaskal if you had a kill and could kill any one player off without having to worry about forming a lynch argument, who would you choose? @Elbereth for now i just want to know how dev flipping village affects your suspicions @Arraenae im going to give you the same question as rath but tweak it a little- who would be your second choice if you had a kill you had to use? Did i miss anyone? Blehhh thats too short a list >> Additional notes -still no evidence of protection roles, still no thugs hit, or survivors, whatever theyre called -no more evidence of vote manip -elim kill seems to be targetting people who arent going to give us tonnes of info from their death. Stinks last vote was on me so i cant really comment on if that means anything from. I dont recall other things stink has done this game at this point other than voting alv, and then bard, and then myself. I dont recall if there was any more votes there - at least half of us have gotta be evil right? Someone whos more awake than me pls go and analyse whose interacting with and/or defending who because any teaming might be indicative at this point.
  20. Burnt Spaghetti
    Sorry for taking so long to respond to this >> been a busy busy day that resulted in a long nap that i just recently woke from Yeahhh I'm bad at committing to suspicions >> I fully accept that. Alright i dunno if i'll vote (specially not this late in the cycle- I greatly dislike last minute votes, or votes that don't give someone the chance to respond) but at least ill throw in my suspicion list and see where that goes? Though I guess to a degree thats still speculation a bit hm. we'll see >> So who we got alive here... Not a long list is what we've got.. Alright the higher the percentage the more i distrust them Me- Can't comment on the percentage. As stink pointed out i've been commenting on things but have been very noncommital which he'd like to see change. El apparently trusts me ( <3 ) Elandera- 62% So. I feel like Elanderas name keeps getting thrown around, if not as a lynch target as a suspicion. And they haven't died. As El pointed out, there's not been pushback on this at all really. This could be a case of Eliminators sitting back and letting a villager take up the heat, it could be a case of Elandera being evil and their teammates letting it happen? Because at this point with the numbers getting low I could see an eliminator team letting one member get attention and potentially lynched and use it as a way to distance themselves and stay hidden themselves? I mean. Super helpful analysis burnt. Hey guys! Elandera is either good or evil! no kidding sherlock >> That being said as Rae mentioned elanderas vote came first and alv added his vote on top that puts it in a slightly better light. Am I convinced of Elanderas evilness? No, otherwise i'd be voting on them. If I had a kill role and was going full chaotic vigilante would I take a shot at them? They would definitely be shortlisted for the dice roll. Take from that how you will Bard 44%- seemed genuinely surprised about the alignments of wilson and alv and also surprised about the choice of killing wilson. Also had commented about wanting alv to live longer than once cylce, but given that alv had died cycle 1 in side a, that understandable and i'm not viewing that as alignment indicative Rath- 40% Haven't been greatly active. Elbereth 39%- If I was going off tone and my gut, El would be someone i'd trust. I've been reading her as pretty genuine. Stink - 25% hm. Stink is a really interesting player. Chaotic in nature, but observant. Stink voting for Alv is definitely a strong point in his favour Devotary - 58% Seems to like tying up lynches? Rae- 50% Has been focusing on elandera for defending Alv a little which is fair enough but apparently has retracted that now. Ehh thats a terrible list >> siiiigh i should try interrogation mode in thread maybe cause i find it easier to get ideas when its questions ive asked them myself otherwise brain is like ".....*slow blink*...." Yes my brain blinks shush. So i find elandera the most suspicious apparently. The thing is is that to me that feels like theres one scratch against their name which has stuck which makes me second guess that a bit. I guess its that we've only hit one eliminator currently, and there weren't that many interactions with alv to learn from concerning people who are still alive. *rubs forehead* I dont know what to think. I miss pms. why can't we have pms...too many words in threads to try parse Also Re: Good question! Asking people questions help. As much as i don't like being voted on, I appreciate the vote on me prompting me to talk suspicions. just didn't help that you did it on my busyiest day of the week where i only now had time to sit and type Votes- so we got 2 on dev, one on elandera and one on me. Not a lot of votes. I'll try vote tomorrow, someone hold me to that pls. as i mentioned before- I don't like doing late cycle votes Bleh I wanted to add more to my lists and flesh them out but cycle is ending soon >> tldr: I have no clue whos evil or not and i miss pms!
  21. Burnt Spaghetti
    Oh yikes. 1- thats a lot of death. This is concerning. Its a really good thing rath posted at the end of last cycle then o_O inactivity filter. Fun. Okay. Right 2- so theres what 8 of us left? Two or three of which are evils, someone else being the swapperoonie role. Oh. Cycle 3. Oh. Thats a good point. They just had an opportunity to choose a side. Hum. Well then. I dont know what to think bout that other than I am concerned because someone may have flipped alignment. Or might not have. We dont have a way of telling do we? Anyways i was more about to think about death rates and player counts but that also reminded me of something: 3- we havent seen anyone survive an attack yet. I hope the protect person isnt dead already... but havent seen any of th double lifers yet either. 4-also havent been seeing any more vote manip? Another potentially already dead role? 5-the dead people: xino dont think theres much to look into theres since they were pretty quiet. Itiah kill: well then. They went from killing prominent people to less prominent. Wondrr if thats indicative of anything? Ran out of prominent people? Trying to not be predictable incase of apparently non existent protection? Maybe itiah was onto something? Random dice roll? I dont know? All i know is im tired >> something to look into more later or if people want to add thoughts so i dont have to that would be cool too kthnx. Uh so the venture mislynch. A villager. Hm. I coyld be tired and musremembering (and unable to spell) but i feel like i dont remember much arguing over the votes. Could be that was something the elims just let happen? Does this reflect on the bard option at all? So venture was the alternative to the alv lynch and vulture e ded up good- that mean anything? I think we mentioned distancing maybe or something i dont recal. Okay so the reasons venture got lynched: Jumping on alv lynch last minute, saying alv lynch would get info then saying there was no info, Bards self preservation and since a possible candidate for sometone whod kill wilson off early. I get self preservation, but if im honest, i'm not a big fan of looking into the meta of who would kill who. I mean sure that can be indicative. But i've seen returning players killed off early by old friends before, usually something done with good reason though so idk. What am i saying. I dont' know- i need sleep and ill review stuff later maybe if im not busy *big yawn* yknow i should write posts when awake, that would probably help much sorrys for spelling
  22. Burnt Spaghetti
    Somi leant against a wall, fingers toying with the hem of her top nervously. So much death was happening. People were just mobbing together agaisnt each other and others were dying in the night. She was scared to join in with the discussions as she was just a kid. No one listens to kids like her. Plus they may think her unimportant or sumthin. At least at the wall there was an illusion of safety. She could see everyone and was less like to to get sneaked up o- "Have you seen Ellira?" Somi squeaked and blinked. Who, what, wha?... A well dressed and well groomed gentleman had walked up to her. No amount of good positioning was going to make up for how easily she gets distracted with her own thoughts. Ellira... hm. She hadn't met this lady, at least, she assumed she was a lady- most people here were fancier folk than Somi by far. The man continued speaking "Pretty girl, green eyes, navy blue dress?" Oh. That lady. Hm. Somi climbed up on top of a table to get a better view point, pushing some cups out of the way as she did so. "Oh uh, hi sir pal guy. Blue dress ya say? Uhhhh yeah shes like, over thattaway." She gestured vaugely. "Yeah at a table by the cooking stuffs! Want me to wave at her or something? She might be able to see me if i jump!" @Arraenae
  23. Burnt Spaghetti
    But.... its bedtime... why u do this to me el :[ i followed so id have notifications to wake up to and worry bout tjinking when im actually awake darnit >> Current thoughts: Aww rip wilson, was good to have you back ingame even though it was only a short stay. Though that was long enough for you to catch out an evil so very well done there! A great write up though from kas as per usual! Sorta poetic that both wilson and alv died at the same time. Sad though. We're losing a lot of good players quite quickly. Wilson was quite rightly paranoid it seemed. Her comment on alv maybe being evil and killing the person he voted for seems to be the case. Good to know Wilsons intuition is still as sharp as ever! She was suspicious of elandera wasny she? Or did that change. Ir was that someone else. I dont remember. Something to look back on. Hm. The last minute vote is always a ehhhhhh thingy. But to me makes sense as far as venture was concernd as he was the runner up and who knows if someones gonna manipulate the votes so that esentially guaranteed lynch safety for them. Is it alignment indicative? Hm. Im honestly leaning village especially since alv voted for them. Though could be distancing... hm. Hrm. Curious on more peopels thoughts conceringing that And i dont believe there was vote manipation this cycle I need sleep though so goodnight!
  24. Burnt Spaghetti
    Vote tally: Alvron (3) - Stink, Wilson, itiah Venture (2) - Elandera, Alvron Wilson (1) -Elbereth Bard (1) - Devotary ------ Okay so I should probably do something more than just reflect on the last cycle so lets take a look at this cycles votes so far - We got Elandera voting on Venture as a questioning vote to hear why they voted rath and what they thought of their vote being manipulated (Side note- The vote manip being out there is something to keep in mind: a lynch may not be guaranteed, and we don't know if thats a villager or eliminator who messed with the vote so its something to keep in mind) -Elbereth voting wilson as a question as to why wilson was withholding her vote, refers to past play style -Stink voting alv because... he misquoted a saying? -Wilson votes alv cause he's toying with her -Alv votes Venture because... it was either them or wilson? Mentioned maybe voting xino earlier cause quiet so I assume probably the same reasoning here but venture already had a vote? (/conjecture) -Devotary votes Bard for defending striker then supporting the striker lynch -itiah votes Alv for voting Tess based on gut who died and was good, and because we'll learn stuff from lynching alv (oppose to someone like venture) My thoughts? Alv lynch has reasoning! Venture lynch is killing off a quiet person. Learn less from this lynch but is an alternative for anyone who doesn't like the alv lynch And two straggler votes that probably won't go anywhere further this cycle, but the reasoning for the bard vote intrigues me and has more reasoning than the venture lynch imo. Current Non Voters: Xino Bard Rath Venture Rae And meee! I know I probably should but I don't personally feel strongly on any of the candidates. I'm half tempted to vote venture so the lynch gets to be a rng matter which is always fun but we learn more from the alv lynch. Though would make things interesting for seeing if the vote manipulator made it flip a particular way tbh. I dunno
  25. Burnt Spaghetti
    Firstly- Love that you did this with analyzing the different reactions people had to it. Might have to steal that one day Secondly- You're not wrong that i basically ignored it completely heh. As useful as D1 lynches are I rarely participate in them myself as i don't really like voting for anyone unless i really do want them lynched and D1 thats hard. I will say that I kinda feel bad for striker getting insta lynched in both the a and b sides of this game, thats some bad luck. My tldr version of events with the striker lynch cause I need that: 1- Striker brings up the probabilities of old elims being new elims again and gives rae a welcoming poke vote 2- Rae pokes back 3- El votes striker asking for his reasoning on the rng of the eliminators probability- same team unlikely, but could easily have at least one member repeat because thats rng 4- striker clarifys but then votes elbereth due to her using Tess as her example and not itiah and is reading into that 5- El responds, explains it was example 6- Rae suggests we not metagame the distribution too much 7- DeTess chimes in here to agree with El about the rng and distribution 8- Striker again clarifys his take on the rng stuff, responds to rae, says a trust on Tess 9-El says that shes keeping her vote on striker even though he responded, because his responses didn't sit right 10- rae says her vote is staying cause striker voted on her first so she isnt removing hers first 11- Striker removes vote on el, points out that no one is defending him which is concerning and should point out to people that he probably isn't an elim. Asks bard about his vote on stink 12- Striker votes on alv 13- DeTess votes on Striker due to the talk on probability feeling like a pocketing attempt 14-Striker is annoyed hes up for lynch again and gets lynched --- So. To me I think that had Striker changed topic after his first clarifying post, all would have been fine. I think that because whenever someone commented on it, he felt the need to respond again, even though he was somewhat repeating on himself just in different wording, it dragged the conversation regarding the rng stuff on a lot. Striker seemed defensive. especially after his first response to El (which i believe would've been sufficient to close off that discussion there) he then accuses El of maybe being evil due to her using Tess as her example. To me that was a pretty weak argument but idk. For me, that was the point where I went from "oh alright fair enough" to "uuuhh okaay...". I don't know if i've explained that very well. Analysis posts aren't exactly my strong point I word bad. So do I think anyone involved in that lynch was suspicious? To be honest, not really. To me it felt like a case of Striker defending himself too much and drawing too much attention. Els and Raes votes on striker make a lot of sense to me. Tess' vote reason re the pocketing i don't fully agree with but thats kinda a moot point anyways given that their, yknow, dead and not evil... So yeah, thats my take on the lynch
×
×
  • Create New...