Ashiok
-
Posts
899 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Ashiok
-
Ok, I'm not an Eliminator. I'm telling you this on my oath as a Windrunner. If I told you that I could prove it, will ya'll allow me to? Just give me a target. EDIT: Jain, my vote on Ronald was because of his plan, and how it favored the forgotten, especially if he was one and knew how many there were on the 'block. Tavi hadn't really been suspicious to me yet. From that point on, Tavi began saying more and more suspicious things, but I've come to expect that from him as par for the course. Looking back, there is more weird stuff from him than I thought. Hmm... I'm going to bed now, and in the morning I should have figured something out. I'll be back on around in about nine hours.
-
I wasn't saying that I KNEW it, I was saying that I suspected it, assuming you were forgotten and proposed that plan. That's all. Yeah. Also my problem with the vigor thing is that if there is a single forgotten not on the 'block, it becomes pointless to Vigor anybody but the person about to be lynched. Please, somebody help me explain my thought process!
-
Ok, Araris, what you're saying makes no sense. So if you read my recent post, you'll see why his plan benifits the eliminators unless they are all on the chopping block, which they clearly aren't. Also, reasons for pointing out that there might be two forgotten include: Complacency in Lines of Warding, being able to propose a plan hinging on having two forgotten, and finally gaining trust. But, seing as that is just one productive thing in a long list of things Jain has done that have been Pro-VIllage, we can assume he is clean for now. Where was I going with this again? Oh yeah, right. Araris is being a bit off. More so than usual. However, the information gained from lynching Ronald is greater. I'm gonna want somebody like wyrm to double check, but if my math is right, killing Ronald (and finding out his alignment) would soft-clear me and Araris (if Ronald is a forgotten) Of course, this could all be an elaborate ploy with miss-information between me, Jain and Ronald, but it's not. I'm not collaborative enough to think of that and enact it.
-
We see exposed safehands. (Strange that something so scandalous would be so common)
-
Well I'd have to say... That plan looks nice in theory. But there are what, eight of us left? Worst case scenario, none of us on the chopping block are forgotten, and in the five others, there are two-three forgotten. I'll do my math with two because I know I'm not one (although it's useless for me to keep saying so because I can't copy-paste the Role-PM). S1: none of us are forgotten. Each LoV each other, leaving five others to ward (two or three of which are forgotten). We waste a night, somebody dies. This is bad. Almost as likely as S2. S2: One of us is forgotten. That one won't make the night kill, same result. This is also bad. Most likely S3: Two of us are forgotten. Then it makes sense for the outsiders to LoV, not the inside people. This is unlikely, but would be nice. I hope I'm making sense. Essentially, your plan calls for all the forgotten to be on the chopping block right now. If you're not a forgotten, this plan makes no sense. If you are, not all of your teammates are on the block. Makes more sense for you to be forgotten in this scenario. In conclusion, Ronald, I'm pretty sure you're Forgotten.
-
Oh. got it. So something like: I'm still suspicious of Joe because killing him would make it ten times easier for the forgotten to kill us, but they haven't killed him yet. But killing him wouldn't be productive right now because if he IS the sentry, then we're not in such good shape. No matter how I crunch the numbers, the odds are that we get hit by a chalkling kill tonight. If, instead, we all used forbiddance (assuming three forgotten) one forgotten vigors their target, one kills the target, and one vigors somebody else. In a scenario where everybody but two people and the forgotten were protected, would one of those two people instantly get killed by the chalklings? Or could chalklings try to hit one of the protected people? Would that be shown in the write-up? Did that scenario make any sense? TL;DR: Chalklings are coming, maybe use forbiddance? Unless that just affords forgotten two targeted kills as opposed to one.
-
Not defending Araris, just pointing out something that was pointed out against me a couple games ago under similar circumstances. I honestly have no idea what y'all want me to do. You want me to draw conclusions, then accuse me of "planting the seeds of doubt" when I do. As with all of the games so far, I have difficulty making up my mind, so I throw all the info/suspicions I have out there and see how they are used. Also, if I was Forgotten, Semi-inactivity would be a pretty good cover for me. Just saying. Me coming out with suspicions as a forgotten would just be stupid. Remember MR2? When I had information, I used it to find the problem people. In other games, where I have less concrete information, I hedge around actually placing votes (unless told to do so.) If I was Forgotten, I wouldn't be hedging around. I would be certain about all the votes I made. TL;DR: Not forgotten, Not defending Araris, Don't have any concrete info. That's all.
-
@Jain: I do believe that the roles were RNG'd, and I happen to find that offensive. Oh yeah. Sad but true, but C was the reason for what Aonar said. Wait... Does sentry get to do rithmatics? If so, I have to wonder why the eliminators didn't snap to kill Joel. Hmm... It would take out a rithmatist and a free LoW each night for one kill. Hmm. Suspicion wise... The two easiest places to hide are complete inactivity and leading the pack. I don't mean to call Wyrm out right now, just some food for thought. If the question is between Araris, Twei, and Alv, I'd have to go with Alv. Just a gut feeling and the fact that Jain AND Wyrm have poke votes on Araris.
-
@Jain On cycle 1, Chase was supposed to be scanning, not warding. That's why I was confused. I was the odd person out that time, so I scanned somebody who I was suspicious of. Chase. Turns out she wasn't using chalklings. IDK what was up with that. She wasn't supposed to be scanned that night, but she was (Was I not supposed to do that?) Also, whenever I contribute useful discussion beyond giving information, I have a tendency to be lynched that day. Just saying... Oh. I just did the math for forgotten and chalklings, and I do not like those numbers if Joe dies. Whoops. I guess we give him the benefit of the doubt this cycle, and we'll see what goes on from there?
-
So... The people on the chopping block right now are me, Chase, and Joe, right? Me: I'm not being suspicious, trust me? That's the best I've got. Other than the obvious (I viewed Chase and found protection... Which also semi-clears Chase in my mind. Why would a Forsaken assigned to chalkling duty make a LoF or LoW? It's not like she'd be attacked by a Scholar t1...) Problem there is that y'all would have to take my word for it. Chase: See above. The only reason to lynch her is that she hasn't been very useful so far. I'm 90% certain she's not a forgotten. Joel: Well... I dunno. "Oh, I'm [role that is important yet unverifiable]. Please don't kill me because if you do, the forgotten will get what they want." Seems like a gambit to me. Also, if he's gonna die tonight, it doesn't really matter if we lynch him, does it? Just a thought. Bonus Round!!! Jain: He's not playing like he usually does. And there are two possible reasons. 1. he decided to join the rational people (unlikely) 2. He's finally team evil (SUPER LIKELY) I'm leaning towards Joel right now, but I'll view whichever of Jain or Joe isn't lynched tonight.
-
1. Haven't voted yet at all 2. Didn't check to see if anybody posted between the night and cycle 3 because there was no vote change. Isn't that when that whole thing went down or am I just sleep deprived 3. I'm sleep deprived. Good night.
-
Well... Technically that was once. Most times you make the rant, it turns true, and it's not suspicious to anybody who's played with you before. This way is sorta suspicious... Just saying.
-
School. I won't have more than five mins to read through and make a post at any point till 6 o clock, then I have HW. Chase has been cleared in my mind because no forgotten would use LoF or LoW night 1, especially when they weren't on the list for LoWs... I'm not suspicious of Jain right now, he's playing normally. Also, a breaker right at the end of the cycle would have been suspicious, Oh wait... Just thought of something. Jain hasn't made his customary Grr! Team good again ! post yet. Strange.
-
THis cycle has not been productive, and I'm going to bed. G'night people.
-
I thought I posted four hours ago, guess it didn't go through. I was at school then, so who knows? I voted Dui because he namemewiped. That only happens when you delete your account. Therefore, he wasn't playing. He would only be useful to us at that point to soak up a kill, now or later. I chose now. Action wise, last night I sicced a chalkling on Chase, she was protected.
-
Remember, Dui is no longer here. GM, if he deleted his account, what are we gonna do with him in the game? If he just straight up dies, that puts us to 14. even 7 and 7. I'm number 14, so I'd sic a chalkling on number seven, number 13 on number 6, 12 on 5, ect... Essentially, I agree with the plan and am proposing an addendum.
-
"Hmm... What to wish for? Ok, Rithmatic baseball is my new headcanon. Teams are drawn by one person, and those people are called team-makers or TMs. Well, I would like very much to become a professional Team-Maker and meet all my favorite TMs. On a more serious note, who shall we kill today? Unless the answer to the question below is yes, we should probably go for __________, whoever that is/was..." Roddy said, then blew out the candles. "Also, I'll have to pass on the beer. Underage and all, y'know?" GM: Does the chalking kill prioritize inactives? Or how else is inactivity dissuaded?
-
How about we split the player list in two? Top half goes tonight, bottom half tomorrow? Voting wise, I have been really busy, and haven't caught up yet. Get back to y'all later. EDIT: it was blue... Totally blue
-
Hmm. So I guess that we have to do two things this cycle. 1. Vote 2. Figure out how many lines we need, and who's making them. To this end, Gm, can we please have a player list at the beginning of each cycle? I know I would greatly appreciate it. Also, I'm not starting any inquisitions today, I'm not very good at them day 1.
-
I'm game for interactivity
-
Syl? No, that doesn't make much sense. I dunno...
-
Pattern When Shallan didn't use him on dad, tears When she saved Kaladin, joy.
-
Spikes "Absorb" investiture? Explain, please. Here's what I was told by the man himself. "Spiking is ripping out a bit of the spirit web" I was thinking something along the lines of the disintegration and silver stuff. What if shades were a hive-mind? Would a spike give access to the mind?
-
So yesterday I met brandon, and asked him if you could spike shades. He said you could do lots of stuff, but wouldn't elaborate more other than to say that Hemalurgy was what happened when you ripped out a piece of the spiritweb and tacked it on to something else. What do you guys think you could do if you spiked a shade? Also, can Hemalurgic spikes be made from metals on other planets? If so, the easiest way to kill shades hand to hand would be spiking, because it can be done with different metals. Thoughts?
-
Seems legit
