Shardmancer

Sooo Fun. Thoughts on the Story: Overall, I appreciate how the writing evolved and how the characters underwent development, Sanderson has always been great at that and you can see the infancy of what evolved to his style today. It’s particularly fun to witness Pre-Kaladin (Jerrick) transformation into supermode, progressing at lightspeed character Arc. Ryalla’s portrayal is also fun—I enjoyed how she merged the slave-version proto-Shallan with nobility, Shallan had the wit that is missing a bit with Ryalla but as a slave I can't blame her. The pacing, a hallmark of Sanderson’s work, remains strong. Although the narrative occasionally jumps between different points of view, it still maintains a cohesive overall arc. Highlights: Hoid: His presence is always captivating, even in his early days. His quirky wit endears him to readers. BatChor: A fun character who I always looked forward to his POV, I could see him going through some Moash style evil arc. Axi and Magic: Exploring the prime version of world magic and the distinct systems within each realm was thoroughly enjoyable. The core principles of the three realms remain consistent but this seemed closer to an open magic system then Sanderson staple of Hard Magic. Areas for Improvement: Worldbuilding: While the world is richly imagined, I’d have appreciated more exploration, especially in Fallamore and the Shattered Plains and Shodel. Slow Parts: Melleran and Yoharn felt somewhat bland. Instead, I’d have preferred additional focus on BatChor and General Tzern. Sho Del: A deeper dive into this aspect would have been welcome. We had 1 POV chapter, it almost felt out of place. Magic System Explanation: A bit more clarity on the power systems—whether it adheres to a hard magic system—would enhance reader understanding. Overall a fun ride and I enjoyed hunting for some pre-cosmere easter eggs!

Nice pick up! I saw that too and just thought in was there for the readers... like a COULD IT? But really, it was probably just a memory and nothing from that interaction can really give us anything more to go off of.

Back after my yearly hiatus and another Stormlight book. Wow! Just finished ROW - tbd I felt it a bit slower than the other Stormlight book thus far but the endings are always worth it with Sanderson. Quick thoughts - Kaladin storyline had me in tears; Another Bondsmith (implications!!), dammm those Heralds can fight, Szeth may need a chill pill, whose this El guy huhhh, Rabionel I kinda liked for a fused sad she is gone-gone, Shallan and Adolin gotta lead a charge of spren back into action, Wit and Jasnah mmmmm (And so much more). Mostly though - 10 DAYS! Man this next book is gonn a be epic.

I don't know if this has been mentioned but maybe this is similar to the unmade and the gem used to trap it inside. Jez is human (the greatest human in fact) and to trap something you need to "understand it" maybe that's why Moash has to do it. They sphere is much like the one Dalinar used to trap The Thrill; Moash uses this special Dagger (with gemstone) related directly to the Windrunners to trap Jez - them both being human is why he can do it. Now that his soul or essence or whatever is trapped he does not go to damnation and repeat the cycle.

Ok! After long hiatus away from the forums "Oathbringer" lashed me right back. Great book keep them coming Brandon *There is always another secret*

Hello! We always love to welcome our new members (UpVote!) *There is always another secret*

Yes, If you would like to get into this series you will have to push through Book 1 - 2 and read 4 -5 as they are very integral to the plot as well, after that you read chapter summaries for the rest of the books leading up to Sanderson- it is worth it if you put in a little time. (if you have it)

Lego my Ego?

We all got dragged back from Bands and also Mistborn Secret History - got dam Brandon!

Its an interesting theory but Kel is not a Shard, he had obtained a portion of Preservation Power - as a sliver. I believe Brandon was referring to a shard holder during this, but I am sure we will all RAFO.

"Rebellium" - I have heard myths whispered in the depths about this rare metal and the Jeh-Di who wield its power. Perhaps these sabers of light come from others worlds such as the shard blades mentioned in the old tales. I believe clones made from breaths with no true life are starting some type of war. We all must keep our ears to the ground and a keen life sense if we want to survive the upcoming trials. May the Force Be With You!

Good Point Tobar - I felt the same way about Rock - as he is completely one sided and Wayne shows a lot of depth

Completely Disagree, Not only is Wayne crucial to the plot he sees things differently from most characters which is a huge benefit. Brandson has also said if he could hang out with one character it would be Wayne (so ++ points) Just check your pockets before you leave!

Passing through time without experiencing it could that be Pulser with Duralumin or Maybe Compounding.?

Yes, lol - it was Kel which made me even more curious as to how he could remove his identity and create this that can be used in the physical realm.

Hey Love to be back, A lot of great points - just wanted to note I saw people saying once a shard is shattered it cannot be remade. I am thinking if shards can be combined (Harmony) why can you not recombine the shattered pieces to make the shard and then recombine the 16 shard to make Adonalsium

Great Story, Reading this and SH back to back brought me back to the forums for some trolling. I was slightly confused as to how anyone could use the LR bracers and wanted to clarify as well with the medallions.. (I assume the LR removed his identity using Fer and than filled the metal mind while having no identity - this would allow anyone to use it?) Also with the medallions a similar thing but allow Nicrosil so anyone can Burn/Tap that specific power. I would appreciate clarification But Great Stuff as always, cant wait for more !

How many wishes am I gonna grant you over here huh? You ask for bend alloy- so I shall give it to you. But unfortunately you now seem to go crazy every time you try and burn metals- and end up with Alzheimers because you don't know your limits. I ask for Infinite Knowledge, For Knowledge is power

Well we do know Tia was an astronaut back in the Nasa days- so I'm sure we will get to see some reckoner style spaceships!

Sorry if this has already been posted I'm just a little confused as to some points on Firefight. One Why did Obliteration not kill David- after he teleported with him I don't understand why he didn't finish the job, or why he just left with another one of his biblical mumbo jumbo. Another issue is if Calamity is this amazing Gifter Epic-why does he just contact Regalia. I think Calamity might has a history with Prof even from back in the hay day, or like always he's not telling us as much as he knows. Lastly if apparently Firefight is reality God twisting epic powers (i know she can't use her powers that well unless just reincarnated) But why does she not fix some major aspects with her reality powers like instead of force bubbling Prof with his own powers-Lock him away somewhere- or automatically bring up his weakness. Whatever. Somethings are just nitpicking-really wanted to know about obliteration??

.

wow-@ Topic- enough said

Very intresting.. I would like to see how you would conenct the overall plot of the sotry arch.. But even as sperate individual stories of different Holmes and Watson's would be very cool. Remided me of a Cloud Atlas feel.. which is something really cool if done properly like in the book- and something terrible if not done properly like in the movie. (haha) Anyway I think its very good idea and would love to hear more in the furture.!

Thanks for the thread- I love MMIO and RPG so..Battle field 4..DIablo 3 and 2 because its still way more badass.. Starcraft and for some computer stuff.. Titanfall, just now for xbox- getting exited for Shadows of Morrdor*, Destiny and the new Dragon Age.>!

Very Intrestign theory about Vivenna being Dalinar's wife.. I havnt seen that before here.. Just to throw some gas on that fire.. She does have royal locks and Adolin has very different hair than most Alethi showing that his mother was not pure blood and probably outside the Alethi circle. This could mean she was probably someone who came out of no-where perhaps.. Seems to me it would take a compelling intresting woman to hold Dalinar's attention and I can certainly see that couple.. Either way it could make sense with Adolin hair and Dalinar wife being somewhere outside the regualr Alethi circles.