Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
13 hours ago, Kingsdaughter613 said:

Shouldn't Nicrosil steal enhancement powers and Electrum hybrid ones? Why would Duralumin and Aluminum steal powers? None of the others work that way... The others seem to work: base steals attribute and Alloy steals powers. Could someone lead me to the words of Brandon explaining this?

I have not found an explanation for why, but I have found evidence that Aluminum stealing powers is right. Marsh has an Aluminum Spike(its in the spoiler tag).

Posted (edited)
24 minutes ago, The One Who Connects said:

I have not found an explanation for why, but I have found evidence that Aluminum stealing powers is right. Marsh has an Aluminum Spike(its in the spoiler tag).

But the MAG isn't canon right ? For example I remember Marsh said to Vin in TFE He had 11 Spikes...There are also some weird contraddiction between Hemalurgy in books and MAG, I tried to recive a precise explaination from Peter but I didn't recive nothing more than a vague one

PS: I have a theory on Khriss who made errors in HoA's Ars Arcanum trying to fit the power stolen with the knowed metals...But I have no proofs

Edited by Yata
Posted
Just now, Yata said:

But the MAG isn't canon right ? For example I remember Marsh said to Vin in TFE He had 11 Spikes...There are also some weird contradiction between Hemalurgy in books and MAG, I tried to receive a precise explanation from Peter but I didn't receive nothing more than a vague one

Well that's up for all kind of debates. The last time this discussion happened, Argel brought up this:

Quote

Series author Brandon Sanderson has even provided commentary and original fiction, and approved this as an official expansion of the setting, making this the biggest addition to the canon outside the novels themselves.

which would technically make it canon. On the other hand, things in the Books overwrite things in the MAG, which weakens the canonocity. Inkthinker said that it was run past Brandon, which makes it seem largely canon, but... and it just keeps going.

  • Chaos locked this topic
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...