Jump to content

The Unknown Medallion

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    4240

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by The Unknown Medallion

  1. The Unknown Medallion
    So yourself? And I am already voting Lab over Archer. You know what happens when you assume.
  2. The Unknown Medallion
    I really have no idea. I kind of lean towards no at this point, but that's purely because it seems unlikely. At this point, I think the only way to find out is to kill you. I normally don't vote for a combination of two reasons: I struggle to form suspicions early game, and I don’t like being wrong. But something that will always make me vote is mechanics. This falls pretty firmly into the mechanics section, but also, no matter how this turns out, I don't really think it can be wrong. If you flip elim, great, if you flip v, then we get a lot more information. Actually, I would be completely fine with voting Labyrinth (Archer), I'd rather not exe an actually active player this early on. What's the argument if Araris gets exed? Well, he voted based on something I didn't agree with. How is that any more alignment indicative? It's like Mat said, me and Araris aren't any less LHF than Archer and Labyrinth. But what do we get from a flip of Araris that we don't get from a flip of Archer/Labyrinth? Archer/Labyrinth is more likely to reveal that the alignment list is incorrect than Araris, who is much more likely to create a false positive or false negative. This is an 11 person MR. It's kinda hard to wait a cycle. What if the list only changes when one or both of the reds die? Then the cycle is just wasted. Correct me if I'm wrong here, but it seems like you think we don’t know know enough to do anything, meanwhile I don't think we know enough to do nothing.
  3. The Unknown Medallion
    My guess is that there's some underlying mechanic balancing it out, perhaps your rotating alignment theory, or perhaps something else. I don't really know, but I also don't think there's any other way to find out. Well, most importantly, it would show whether or not Archer flips red. It also very well might reveal additional mechanics that otherwise wouldn't be revealed. Here's my question for you. What information would we receive if we don't exe Archer, that we wouldn't receive if we did? I'm still don't understand what you're arguing for, what is your alternative? You aren't voting for anyone as far as I can tell. A no-exe isn't exactly happening, if it's even possible. So what are you trying to do?
  4. The Unknown Medallion
    Blasphemy! Burn it with fire! Dragon fire!
  5. The Unknown Medallion
    @DeTess, well, it's pretty clear that is far from the case. Me and Araris are practically the only ones going after Archer, and everyone else is neutral or against us. Perhaps your point was valid initially, but can you really still say we're stalemating discussion or making an excusable vote (I know those weren't your exact words, but that seems to be the gist)? I doubt most elims would hold up under the pressure me and Araris have been under without hedging. I would argue we will get much more information from exing Archer than we would from not. The list could be effected by all sorts of things, maybe it only updates when a Red dies. I don't actually believe that, but it's possible. I think that any information we would get c2 without exing Archer we will still get, but also we will potentially get more and more useful information as well.
  6. The Unknown Medallion
    The Three-Body Problem is... a lot of firsts for me. It's namely the first translated book I've read (that I know of), and it feels just like any other non-standardly formatted English original book, so it's a pretty successful one as far as that goes. It's also really the first "philosophical" books I've read, even if it doesn’t completely fit that category. I don't really think about morals of stories or complex questions overly much, and this story isn't an exception. I can pretty easily and quickly determine my beliefs on just about any moral dilemma, which does give me a tendency to shake my head at certain people in books like these. Overall though, it was a very good read. Was interested throughout and never really knew what to expect, and when I thought I did I tended to be wrong. Definitely recommend it. Maybe I'll get to it on Treamayne's thing eventually, but I'll probably end up forgetting. Edit: I'm also trying to finish up my audio of A Clash of Kings. I'm really started to doubt if this series is worth the slog. Tyrian is very fun, but basically everyone else is boring or infuriating, except Danaerys, who feels like a fever dream that's too far from the main plot but is at least enjoyable sometimes. This will probably end up being the last book in the series I read, and will just end up watching the show if I ever get HBO.
  7. The Unknown Medallion
    I don't think you quite understand what a poke vote is. A poke vote is a vote placed d1 on someone who hasn't posted, or has only posted once in order to attempt to get more activity out of them. Poke votes are normally removed when the target responds. As such, all evidence points to it not being a poke vote.
  8. The Unknown Medallion
    To those asking what a Merlin is, it is a role that knows the identities of the elims, but if the elims guess their identity, the elims win. In this case, the Merlin would know the identity of the hidden elim. I'm not so sure if this will be included in a game with open PMs however. @DeTess, my logic for my vote is, is there anything better to do? I don’t normally vote d1 because there's to little to base on and I have trouble forming suspicions quickly. But in this case, there are two people that as far as I know, I want to die. If they're village, too bad, we would have killed a villager anyways, but they could actually be elims. So why not? Also, if we kill a non-infiltrator today, then we will only know what happens if we leave the red names alive, but if we kill Archer today, we'll see how he flips, and we'll see what happens to the still alive Labyrinth. I'm mostly just kinda curious why you're so against it, it's not like d1 exes actually normally kill an elim, so why not follow the only lead we have, which will also give us basically twice as much information as the other way around.
  9. The Unknown Medallion
    For me, it very well could be, this is a blackout after all. I kinda figure there's one hidden Infiltrator and maybe a Merlin. But we'll see.
  10. The Unknown Medallion
    I voted Archer just because Araris was already voting on him and he is labeled as an Infiltrator. My wincon is to kill all Infiltrators. It kinda worries me that that isn't as obvious to you as it should be if you had that wincon.
  11. The Unknown Medallion
    Not exactly the person to ask for this. @Experience may provide one, or perhaps @Araris Valerian. Unfortunately, not too many crazy vote trackers this game.
  12. The Unknown Medallion
    Still not an elim. It's been too long. Not counting Jabberwocky, because that was like one day long.
  13. The Unknown Medallion
  14. The Unknown Medallion
    I don't know. I think Devo has a sadistic streak running under there. And that's basically exactly what my wincon says to do. Therefore: Archer.
  15. The Unknown Medallion
    You during Secret Project 3: Edit: Don't know why there's the random static, sorry.
  16. The Unknown Medallion
    Is there a correct universe for this monstrosity?
  17. The Unknown Medallion
    I'll join as Blake Útt.
  18. The Unknown Medallion
    Oh, I kept trying to read that serious, but I would keep stalling on the second book. Can't even remember if I ever finished it. Always enjoyed it, just circumstances came up. Edit: I'm currently reading Jade City by Fonda Lee, it is a delight. I forgot that people kept talking about "the thing" midway through the book, and was absolutely stunned. Also listening to the Graphic Audio of the Blinding Knife, I'm so in love with Graphic Audio, and I keep getting reminded of how how much I love the Lightbringer series.
  19. The Unknown Medallion
    ???
  20. The Unknown Medallion
    Hey! I think I win on criteria .
  21. The Unknown Medallion

    Alright, so I'm worldbuilding for a book idea right now and I need to decide which way I'm going to describe something. 

    The evil(ish) magic users in this setting have a certain type of deadly assassin creature that are called Smilers in world. That's important, I'll get to ut later. They can look completely like a human, but once they attack they drop their disguise. They have long manipulatable claws on their hands and slightly off proportions, but their main defining feature is their face. They don't have a mouth, but kinda to compensate they have a very large nose and big eyes, topped by bushy eyebrows and a small forehead.

    My main point of contention is deciding what their mouth area looks like. I'd appreciate if you could tell me which option seems scariest/creepiest.

    Option One: Nothing, just unblemished skin. I like this one, but feel it might be a bit too bland.

    Option Two: A painted smile, kinda like the Joker, but without an actual mouth inside. I don't know what it would exactly look like, but just some sort of tattoo thing that is permanently smiling. I like this one too, and it was my original idea, but I kinda think it might be too goofy for the serious tone of the world.

    Option Three: A sort of shriveled up mouthlike line, kinda Deadpool (not the current one, the old one) esque, with stitching appearing to seal it shut. Not so sure about this one, it kinda feels like it would attract attention away from the upper part of the face, which is kinda the opposite of what I want to do, but I think it's probably the creepiest.

    So your input would be much appreciated, this is bugging my mind and I'd really like some extra opinions. 

    1. Show previous comments  1 more
    2. The Unknown Medallion

      The Unknown Medallion

      Hm, maybe. 

      My current plan is that they speak through telepathy, but that would fit with the underlying way that their bodies work.

      If you had to pick one of the three, which would you pick? @The Aspiring Archivist

    3. The Aspiring Archivist

      The Aspiring Archivist

      Um... one or three. Maybe a bit more of a lean towards one because it seems like that aligns a bit more with what you want the effect to be.

    4. The Unknown Medallion

      The Unknown Medallion

      Thank you. I think I'm going to go with 1, though with jaw movements underneath. 

  22. The Unknown Medallion
    I'm currently reading the white doc, and so far it's using the exact same colors and it's so funny but also messing with my mind.
  23. The Unknown Medallion
    I'll take a tie, though judging from the rest of this game, time travel will take it away somehow. My condolences. Edit: What the Fifth is that rules doc
  24. The Unknown Medallion
    TJ
  25. The Unknown Medallion
    Same. Archer.
×
×
  • Create New...