Jump to content

Mat

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    7773

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    10

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Mat

  1. Mat
    Excellent, thank you >:) I probably will go for it in a few hours. I want to hear input from my team. And see reactions from everyone else.
  2. Mat
    Don't Praise the Ja >:| ...Anyway: I've narrowed it down to two. Anyone want to help? Edit: @Araris Valerian, when I accuse someone of being the Witness do I do it the same way people make accusations of the crime?
  3. Mat
    Nah, I'm just messing with you. Carry on everyone.
  4. Mat
    I suppose your mind is one with Araris' :P. Tbh I was feeling good yesterday and today I think we were gonna muddy the waters with one of us guessing like Mat/Highstorm/Mug to throw people off with the 'no' but we... did not get that far xD Yep! :D. And there's a doc. It's not very long, and half of it is charts :P.
  5. Mat
    I mean. Araris did take it out, to be fair. I really thought Hut/Shack would throw people off (especially when compared with literally every other location title) and Naked I didn't think would be connected either. I thought that picking two unrelated things would benefit me, but in picking the clues, Araris went for individual ones (such as Manmade for DW, Accident for HS) instead of trying to combine them. I think you got lucky in picking DW over the many other Manmade things I have but I guess there was Archer's point that Mug of Ale and the like would have more naturally been paired with Feast. It is fitting that I would be bested by a tunnel :P. But it isn't a tunnel if it's right, eh? :eyes: Anyone want to guess my teammates?
  6. Mat
    :|
  7. Mat
    The Heck
  8. Mat
    Fits the other rituals as well. Though I think if it was a ritual Araris probably wouldn't have removed the In Progress tile over, like, 'Noon'. That to me suggests that the time of day is more important than the religion clue. As Kas would say, potayto potahto difference for me. I think the more important distinction is 'not intact' as opposed to 'not altered'. And what Ash said. What clues would you think that points to?
  9. Mat
    Yeah, I was going to say, it's possible but calling MaiPon Sticks religious items is a bit of a stretch Hey @xinoehp512 @Cinnamon @The Wandering Wizard @The Bookwyrm @Shining Silhouette come do something
  10. Mat
    So that specific combination is wrong, but it still could be, like, Striker/Acid/MaiPon Sticks or Striker/Rope/Shu-Korath Pendant. Is that how this works?
  11. Mat
    I could see xino, Kandra Digestive Acids, and Words Inscribed in Steel. I also like Explosion (Cinnamon's) as an option but none of their evidences fit all that well to me. It's a similar thing to Aman's Fire, none of his evidences fit super well imo. Fifth's Midnight Essence could fit the Naked clue I guess, in the same way Acid does, with Aon Reo as the evidence. Does Mistwraith fit Naked? Looking at that from Shining paired with A'kar's Symbol which sounds religious but idk what it is exactly. I guess Mistwraith doesn't really work with Noon being the time of day. Kas' Booby Trap works if it's an acid or fire type of booby trap, and then I guess... Mastrell Sash? Black Sphere? That's a super messy paragraph sorry xD
  12. Mat
    Ah, okay. But Hut/Shack is so vague >> I guess that means we can rule out the ones with specific other links. Which... is what you've been doing? :P.
  13. Mat
    Only now I realized that I just forgot to include 'Noon' in my graphic >> But that's okay, as that one seems not super helpful to begin with, right? :P. I can add it in, but it seems like most people didn't actually look at my chart (at least, no more than I did, which was minimal) so maybe I just won't bother I'd argue that's a stretch to include Naked as being linked with Highstorm, but I suppose it's more that the Highstorm rips the victim's clothing? But as I (and a few others) mentioned, acid/fire fits that better. Adding Noon is also a stretch but you do you I like a good pun as much as anyone I am sad now That was a quality ten minutes of effort well spent /jk I would say that Tia indicates Supernatural and Drowning indicates Suffocation. I don't think we should try to convolute a hypothetical death story too far, and should take most things at face value. I doubt Araris would want to put his faith in us finding the one random connection. I personally would completely take Drowning out of consideration because Araris would have just put Suffocation, but I wouldn't take Tia off because I think Religious Worship has a potential connection with all the Aons. I would say that Tia could have been used to transport the victim to a remote Hut, where they died, but that's doing the convoluted thing I said not to do so idk That was my thought, yeah. I like your thought about the item being the religious thing but... we'll see I guess xD Do we know this is actually how this works? I didn't read the rules super carefully or anything but my general impression was that he RNGd between the four tiles and then picked out of the given options, same as the orange ones.
  14. Mat
    There's so much data wow Not sure this is my type of game xD Will try though @StrikerEZ what made you cross-reference worship with evidence over any other combination? Here's all the methods with color codes for the ones they work for: Blue: Accident. Notated on anything that could have been marked as an accident. Yellow: Hut/Shack. Notated on anything that I think Hut/Shack fits the best out of the given options. Differently marked than the others because quite honestly idk how Hut/Shack fits anything well. My interpretation is like, wilderness fits in this category (I'm thinking about how I would have marked Nightmaw etc for Location and I would have probably landed here) but it's also possible Location is a better thing to check with the Evidence Left Behind. Red: Manmade. Notated on anything that could have been marked as manmade. Perhaps less useful than the others because it is listed as referring to the evidence, not the method, but I think it's safest to check it anyway. Green: Naked. Notated as any situation that could fit with a naked victim. Up for interpretation :P. I went with more indoors things (and acid because it burns clothes, plus other burny things) since I wouldn't think you'd be naked outside, but idk. Another one that could fit better with ELB. Purple: Religious Worship. Notated as anything that could happen during a religious setting. It's possible the murder didn't happen, like, literally during the religious ceremony or whatever but this clue being included specifically makes me think that it did since anything else likely has better options. If you have a question about any specific tally mark or my overall method in making this graphic, just @ me. I think I could actually explain anything. Doesn't mean it'll be a good explanation, but there you go Don't have time to make conclusions based on that, unfortunately. I'll make a similar graphic for the ELB tomorrow morning, hopefully.
  15. Mat
    I think that the clues we get from Araris can fit both, and do fit both. So we could make more charts using those if we want to. What do people think about when we all should guess? In past runs it was pretty spread out.
  16. Mat
    I'll do the thing:
  17. Mat
    Moood xD Got track practice but I’ll be back in a few hours. Not much to do today though.
  18. Mat
    If TKN can’t run it I’ll make up an easy ruleset for me to run and throw up signups in a few days. But if anyone else below me wants to, feel more than free.
  19. Mat
    I think it’d be an LG but I might be wrong there. If not, I could whip up a really light sort of game that I could do rollover in a couple minutes with.
  20. Mat
    I’d rather not, to be honest. I’d need to come up with a full ruleset and am pretty busy outside of that. But I technically can if I have to.
  21. Mat
    I’m pretty busy this summer, so I’ll have to turn down the nomination. Thanks though, and good luck to whoever goes!
  22. Mat
    I’ll nominate StrikerEZ @StrikerEZ
  23. Mat
    I would recommend to anyone who is confused to read through the original run of this game. I just did, and everything makes a lot more sense now
  24. Mat
    Yes please Praise the Ja!
  25. Mat
    In as Jatrim
×
×
  • Create New...