Experience

Told myself if you switched, you were more likely evil than if you held your ground. Archer Bort :P

1 elim with kill role is quite unlikely usually because of the chance that they are lynched d1. Bort

Well I joined that shard Feb 2020, so most likely a couple months after then is when I started getting into all these types of threads.

I have no idea when I started posting here.

Good point

Who says it's a worn out competition

Or do you

*pops in to popcorn*

10 hours is pretty long

Oh. I was thinking the percentages were how much of the doubt you had, or how much proof you had. The hardest part in this specific dilemma (in my mind) is the fact that the Lord holds multiple responsibilities. He is not only the Judge. If he were, it would be his responsibility to judge based on known rights and wrongs of the hogmen (and most likely let them go free). But he also has the responsibility as the towns Protector. The Protector would have to kill (or imprison or banish or something else) all four of them. And so he cannot do everything that just a Judge or Protector would do. He must compromise. And it is his duty to compromise in a way that best aligns with that of the Judge and the Protector. I still can't decide what a moral (aligned to my personal morals) decision would be, though my initial reaction is going as close to the Judge as possible.

I don't know if it's possibly to exactly define it in a percentage. Like I'm not sure what the difference between 99% and 99.9% would be. And what instance would fall under 90%? I feel like it is determined by the individual, as your answer has a high likelihood of being different to mine.

Yeah, but I guess this argument is kinda pointless. Yes, I guess you can't know perfectly that someone is guilty, but you can know beyond reasonable doubt and much farther past it in this case which is what we have to judge by in order to actually achieve anything, no matter where you stand on the matter.

Breeze could be a panda. Generally thought of as lazy but strong and fierce when needed.

Welcome to the Shard!!! What's your favorite book by Brandon?

Well we knew Patji was an Avatar before RoW. And pretty sure the Sand Lord in White Sands is as well.

So you're telling me that if you saw someone stab another person right next to you, and then stab themselves, you couldn't be 100% certain that the now dead killer had indeed stabbed the other man?

@Rg2045 Just wondering, do you see this kind of like difference between what is right and what needs to be done for the better of the whole? Or do you think it's 'right' to punish all four? Question also up for others.

...oh

It's the best reason. But sometimes the best just isn't that good.

Bad reason lol