Ooh, Higurashi. Umineko, its sequel, is my favorite story ever. Higurashi is a bit more divisive, and can be a bit much (in multiple ways) if you're not prepared, but I hope you enjoy it.
I'd say Higurashi is less of a game of Clue than Umineko. Higurashi isn't as built for you to solve the mysteries yourself. It's not impossible, just less likely