The Young Pyromancer

So wait. As it stands, am I getting lynched? Because I got to go soon, but I have I have an emergency ace-in-the-hole.

Please! VOTE ON 5TH SCHOLAR! He wants to be voted on!

Read 5th scholar's post, sart

I apologise, 5th scholar.

I gave you an upvote. Does that make you feel better?

He said he didn't have enough time in blue text. I think we gotta lynch him, as harsh as that sounds.

Okay.... Now I don't want to lynch you... No Lynch 5th Scholar.

It did plenty, mage. I can retract and vote on 5th, and you can do the same. Then they would be tied as well, and maybe they could be lynched.

I guess I have to retract. 5th Scholar. No lynch. I'm counting on you not to kill me. The choice is in your hands now. I take back my earlier statement that Straw was guilty. He might be, but I overreacted. Please, in the name of the Survivor.

What do you guys think is going on with straw? @Orlok Tsubodai Help!

Thank you too! EDIT: NINJA'D Why do you think that? New theory: 5th is Khriss. They convert Straw / Vice versa. Straw is making a desperate attempt to save their faction from losing. Hence the weird and unprovoked vote. Any help, guys?

Thanks

You say it is incriminatory to go for Odium, but you admit it anyways. I think this is an attempt to gain trust. Plus, bagging a kill action "because you thought it might be useful" is suspicious by itself. Again, you seem to be overemphasizing that you just wanted a kill action. It is OK to want the shard, dude. However, your repeated denial is fishy. You focus on Khriss a lot here, and you get inside her head, which you haven't done with others. You show knowledge here of elims that is a little too strong. Also, in another post, you stated that you think Odium is a major problem, but we shouldn't focus on them right now. That is a contradiction. However, both times you tried to draw attention away from Odium. Also, if Odium went to a villager, that villager probably won't stay village for long. Again, you switch to saying Odium is bad for the village. Then you switch back, IN THE SAME POST! Come on! You again seem very sure of what the eliminators did. Plus, you seem very chummy with HH, before stabbing him in the back later. You seem not very knowledgeable, where earlier on you seemed like you had thoroughly read and thought about the elims. This. You also make this very same argument 2 posts later, conveniently ignoring that it applies to you as well. I am not sure if you are Odium, Hoid, or Khriss, but this whole thing is very suspicious. Fifth Scholar Did I do a good job on my first in-depth analysis?

I sound so suspicious, don't I? I am even giving myself a bad gut read! I meant in the first one that the reason for saving Cultivation was invalid. The reason for keeping my plan secret still applies. Gosh, this would be so much easier if I didn't have to be careful about what I say! Drought, I may follow your advice. EDIT: Can someone make a vote tally? I know our votes are all over the place, I just don't know who is up for the lynch. Also, have we all just forgotten about 5th Scholar?

Nah. It would necessitate revealing another plan I wish to keep secret for now.

Quantum phasing. You now become Kitty Pryde!

I am not willing to reveal it to everybody. I am willing to reveal it to maybe 1 or 2 people. If you knew my reason, you would know why I wouldn't want it revealed. It isn't really a big reason anyways. More of a "Possible out in a bad situation". Wait. I think the reason might be invalid. Let me check. Yeah I misread the rules. Never mind.

1. Yes 2. They both can only convert twice. Plus, Shards are immune to Hoid + Khriss's conversions(I think) 3. Everyone just is more suspicious about PMs than normal 4. Autonomy Also, see 2

@Seonid, if someone held a shard, and was converted to that shard's wincon, and then got another Shard, would they be immune to that Shard's conversion? If so, then Odium would just need to go to a shardholder. Actually, Odium going to Hoid would be GREAT! Hoid cannot make any kill actions, and if he has 1 teammate, if he passed it to them they would be converted. Well I guess it wouldn't be great, but it would be okay.

We can make do without Culty, I just don't think we should. I want to keep Cultivation alive for another reason that I cannot say in-thread. I believe that the "Eliminators" in this game are actually less of a threat then the Shards. No, just because I said this doesn't mean I'm bad. I'm just concerned that we will overlook the side with kills. The elims have a small number of converts, and without Odium's investiture, it is really hard to kill in this game. Hence we should focus on cleaning up the rest of this mess first. Devotary, you actually misinterpreted my OTHER post. I do not have any investiture

There is the fact that you could Roshar-exchange investiture for Cultivation's. That is what I am attempting to do.

You could have some crazy sports with unsealed gold metalminds. 100 people VS Hoid... HOID WINS!

Probably neither.

Last post continued If we eliminate Odium and free nice shards, we are able to have any and all nice/neutral shards reveal themselves, and we can support their win cons in exchange for them helping us find the elims. Also, Odium, if you blow up Cultivation I will hunt you down. 5th Scholar already promised the same. Go after other shards first, pass Odium, or return it please.

The problem is, if we support Odium, we make enemies of every other shard. This could turn the game into vanillas + Odium VS Hoid, Khriss, their converts, and every single other shard. We would drastically increase the size of the elim team. Sure, they wouldn't have a doc, but they would have Cultivation.