Amethyst Scorpion

Because voting wrong is somehow e!indicative? This isn’t a good point until a Hyena countertrain flips e.

I’d be fine with that exe I suppose. I’m hoping the kill on them was a CS and not a MB but the lack of C1 kill does not support that theory. I dunno. I’m kind of at a loss after Hyena was village and I don’t have Mouse to bounce off of so I’m lowkey fine with a point and shoot at anyone in my poe but I can’t tell if that’s my post-wisdom-teeth-sedative wearing off Actually nah Heron I want to revisit them on my own rather than sheeping someone else in my poe lol

Chameleon

Again. I don't think Mouse e!read Meerkat :P. I mean cmon he claimed to half the player list and even if he hadn't a sudoku puzzle over a philosophical quote and some characters come from only one possible player

I don't think there's a player in this game who didn't know Mouse's role :P. Also, they personally told me that they were v leaning Meerkat by their death, so Cham's information is outdated / flat out wrong.

You’re mischaracterizing my post, intentionally or no. I will say I thought you meant that it was a WGG with the elim kill. Did you say e MB in your original post? Probably. But still, I’m not someone who likes to consider possibilities that might have happened just for the heck of it. Or, rather, I love to do that as elim— it’s my number one tactic. Which is why this pinged me. I never said it was the strongest. I said that me not liking your reads might be my weakest. Because I think reads by themselves are subjective and if I disagree with your reads that doesn’t make you evil. I’ll explain more regarding what I meant about the actual reads lists themselves later. Edit: Yeah, you didn’t mention you meant MB. So you can see why I interpreted that the way I did.

I agree that looking at all possibilities is a good thing. I disagree that it’s possible that Mouse was anything but the elim kill. That’s what I don’t like from you. You’re taking something that’s straightforward and unnecessarily convoluting it. That’s not what I meant. Interesting to me that you took it that way. That’s funny, I think it’s my worse reason

Because it’s pretty clear that Mouse was the elim kill, making vulture something else, which is potentially useful information. You bringing up outside edge cases is e!indicative to me because it’s muddling that possibility. Yeah, later. When I have the time. They exist, I’m not a liar :P. Not this game at least. But I’m getting my wisdom teeth out tomorrow so we’ll see if it’s before rollovet >> ideally so. But essentially it’s the kinds of reads lists you’ve posted (one being obviously against the grain whilst that was popular, another appeasing thread consensus) along with what are (imo) some bad takes. I’ll specify when I can.

Again, all it indicates to me is that Swan isn’t paying attention :P. I don’t really think that e!them is in the elim doc all that much if they’re not in the thread enough to even know what the turn is.

Heron Swan night voting isn’t villagery. All it indicates is that they’re not paying attention. Beagle is literally the last person I would kill right now. I don’t like Heron trying to make the kills ambiguous. Plus other things.

>> << This is fine Why assume thug as opposed to Lurcher?

Why is this game two groups of like four players voting each other lol Anyway that’s all from me, I have to go till past rollover so I’ll be back next turn

Because it actually had reasoning. I cased Hyena, Beagle cased Hyena, and there were ample wagonomics reasons for the train. Iguana and I had either gut votes or simply naked ones. Because they're trying to see how committed a historically noncommittal player is to their reads, I would think.

They could. I've done so in the past. But usually it's not something that happens.

Surely Meerkat is too pure to be elim here, though >>

Boooo I guess the nine vote train was our indication there but I actually felt good about that read for once >> But we did need to clear their slot and they did not do anything to help themselves so I can’t feel too bad about it. Certainly elims are among the later Hyena votes. I reeeeeally want to flip the countertrains here, not just Meerkat as I’m leaning more TWTBAW on them as of late.

With manip ya never know i feel like the meerkat wagon vanishing is indicative of v them if anything but at the same time I really hate that conclusion

I like the Kanga vote only because it puts Iguana out of danger

See my detail spoiler box from this post. Also wagonomics yeah

Does village reading Vulture not by default grant them that third position?

Hi can you finally answer my questions from the first post of this page?

I’ve talked myself into v!Flamingo, I think. Meaning I need to examine the Flam push at some point. I hear this has been cleared up but I’ll explain for the benefit of everyone else. Cham opened this turn with saying “No Coinshot”, “Lots of vote manip”, “Things are looking lopsided”, and “Rip Falcon”. There’s no evidence there’s no Coinshot. Multiple other things could have happened. There was only one vote manipped, and even though a lot of manip isn’t inherently bad Cham is framing it like it is. And I don’t even know where Cham is saying things are looking lopsided from a single misexe comes from. And then the rip Falcon feels like an afterthought that’s hollow and obligatory.

Okay. But surely you understand why it looks like you put Vulture in your top three. I mean, you put “most everyone else” into null, so who is your top three? If you know your top three why not just put them all in the village tier? Also, why do you elim read Rhino? You never clarified that.

Because I think you’re suspicious and think those questions deserve answers Neither of which I’ve received, by the way. mobile quoting isn’t working so I’m posting and a merge reply to ele is incoming Interesting how polarizing my slot has become. It’s quite refreshing tbh I don’t know what you think I was defensive about, because literally no one posted anything except a top tier village read on me the entire turn (except for Dragonfly, but I didn’t see that till N1). As for me upgrading them, I don’t think that’s a fair point without knowledge of other trains (aka if the trains were all village it’s meaningless) so that comment looks like tmi from my pov. Again. I don’t think gut reads are poor form. My entire point on Hyena was that I don’t think that was their original motive. Go read my Hyena case if you’re still confused. Do you village read Hyena?

Speaking from experience, this is false :p. You don't think that thing makes them elim, therefore they jump to your top three villagers? That thing about you testing them is the fakest thing I’ve ever heard haha Pls CS Meerkat if you exist AKA people are elim reading you now? Edit: Also @Salmon Meerkat what are your reasons for Rhino being evil? If you’ve said them already just link that post. And why aren’t you voting them if you think they’re evil?