Aisur

You're right, I got my acronyms mixed up. Yeah, I meant Shadows for Silence. I'll edit it.

I meant that since the shades of the departed appear on Threnody and not on Scadrial, there's likely some weird Physical/Cognitive blending going on on Threnody that doesn't happen on Scadrial, so the fact that cognitive shadows on Scadrial don't appear in the physical realm (as in SH) shouldn't necessarily pertain to Threnody. I may be misunderstanding something from SfS, though, and the shades may not be cognitive shadows at all, but at the moment I think they are.

Is SH really relevant here? On Threnody we have shades of normal people lingering and causing physical damage to the living. Aren't they cognitive shadows that got stuck before passing into the beyond?

Enjoyed reading this post, and looking forward to the results.