ZenBossanova

14 hours ago, apepi said:

I believe there was one about Devotion?

There was a line about how special Investiture makes the Charred devoted, though devoted wasn't Capitalized. Of course, the same scientist who said that, had a jar of Dor sitting on the table. 

Gemstone/metal combinations were clearly important for

Why the distinction between blends of metals versus metals and non-metals? Metals blend more uniformly, usually, but not always. (looking at you, Trellium)

Alternatively, we don't put a number on it. No one asks what the total number of molecules is, because there is no limit. 

And what do we do with metal with aether dust in it? Gemstone dust? White Sand? These would not technically be alloys, but they are interesting combinations. 

At this point, we should talk about Fabrial Engineering or Alchemical Engineering, and which combinations have useful properties. 

I have been thinking about combinations of God metals. 

If we sum all possible combinations of 1,2, 3 and up to 16 metals, we get 65535 different combinations, which is a lot of different magic systems for us. 

Unless Discordium exists. Then the number goes way up. Then we have to count the number of connections between shards. The number of connections between n = 16 shards is n*(n-1)/2 = 120.

So the number of God metal alloys from 16 God metals is 2^120 = 1.3 *10^36

Which is the right alloy? If Hoid wants to find one particular alloy, and if he can look at a million alloys a second, and there are about 3*10^7 seconds in a year, then it will take him about 4 * 10^22 years to find the right one. That is  40 million million billion years. Our own universe is about 13.8 billion  years old, so this would be a million million times that amount of time. 

Getting the God Metals might be the easy part. 

There was a reading that I remember from years ago, from the sequel to Sixth of the Dusk, that strongly implied Scadrial and Roshar were in a state of opposition - not all out war, but working against eachother. 

This also brings up the idea of creating hybrid investiture among any of the 16. 

If you could make Honor+Harmony light, what would it do? Could Zahel do something unique with Honor+Endowment light? 

Odium+Cultivation:: "Nature red in tooth and claw" 

On 11/8/2020 at 10:32 PM, Kingsdaughter613 said:

No cheese though... Poor Hoid. Most cheese is made with animal renin.

Not necessarily. 
If we assume there is a Dawnshard of Preservation, or Immortality, then as long as you are not killing something, then it should be fine to eat cheese. 
It really depends on the Dawnshard that affected him. 

My first thought when I read this, was that both Taravangian and Cultivation were, more or less, good guys, and this was good news. But reading all of this reminds me, we don't actually know much about what Cultivation is doing. She isn't Mother Nature or Mother Earth. She is a Dragon. 

Cultivation is more of a puppet master than I realized. I have wondered how much Cultivation and Odium worked together, or were aligned. 

14 minutes ago, Ookla the Shadowed said:

Are we going with the idea of 16 shards and 4 dawnshards?

Not necessarily. Just have a logical arrangement like the Cosmere has. 

I do recommend the metals charts for Allomancy/Feruchemy/Hemalurgy. 

Good News! You have Ascended to Godhood, on par with Adonalsium. 

Bad News! A plucky band of adventurers and their quirky sidekicks have shattered your power into Shards. 

What are your Shards and Dawnshards? 

On 10/13/2020 at 4:35 PM, slipwiz said:

Computer programmer here. My jaw literally dropped when I read this chapter.. To me. BS just stated that logicspren are the equivent of fabrial binary microcode and are used program fabrials ...  The name make sence as computer code. Is often described as logic... 

Does this mean that we can make all the elementary circuit components, using logicspren? 

I think that Dalinar's statement 'I am Unity' was a kind of 6th Oath, for those of stand to replace the functionality of the old Heralds. 

I expect our other main characters, will make similar oaths. 

I have a hard time believing this is only a big capitalistic scam, by the Ghostbloods. 

There has to be more. They probably have their eyes on a Shard, or at least an Unmade. 

Kaladin's "problem" is that the two cardinal virtues of the Windrunners are Protection and Leadership. 

He has focused heavily on Protection - if anything too much. But now that he has been pulled off of active field duty, his growth will involve leading from Urithiru. Kaladin doesn't see it now, but this is a huge growth opportunity for him. He going to have to move from subconcious 'taking charge', to actively leading, not only the Windrunners, but I predict, all of Roshar, as an equal to Dalinar. 

I also predict, that in book 4 or 5, Kaladin will have a "I am Unity" moment, like Dalinar had. Other Key Radiants (Shallan, Venli, Szeth, etc) will have similar moments. 

1 hour ago, SomeRandomPeasant said:

Honestly, this pairing is just so funny, but it will never happen.

Kaladin needs a partner who acts likmye Tien or Syl.  Someone who is a light in his life that can drag him out of his melancholy.  I don’t know what the hell Jasnah wants, whether that be a particular type of person or no person at all.  But I don’t see any type of romance between them, just a healthy level of antagonism.

I never said Romance, but I have a thread about political marriage elsewhere.

On 9/7/2020 at 0:44 AM, ftl said:

 Then Dalinar (or another Bondsmith) would have to apply their powers to make that bond replace the original one, healing the spren.

This is a good point. Why can't Dalinar do that? Isn't that his entire power set? 

15 hours ago, Bliev said:

@Wax I wouldn’t at all rate Jasnah as high on extroversion. Adolin yes, jasnah, no. Also, a .17 correlation is less than 4% variance in sexual activity, and non-causal, so I think it’s more than a bit speculative. The fashion stuff is not really backed up by research either.

just staying textual, I think she’s never shown any sexual interest in anyone of any gender or species, so ace is a reasonable guess for me for her.

I don't see Jasnah as the kind to just flirt for fun. 
If she is going to go for someone, you won't see it until she is 110% ready and "going for the jugular", so to speak. She keeps her plans and thoughts close to her. She doesn't just tell people what she is thinking. 

It shouldn't be so hard for a  spren to move a gem. They are what move the spanreeds in the first place. 

That said, I am curious about the Sleepless and the possibility of a Herald gone Spren-rights Activist, as the culprit. 

Healing fabrials for spren?

I don't see why not, though there must be a reason why not. Would you need to heal things in the Cognitive Realm from a higher Realm, ie, the Spiritual Realm?

The fact a fabrial has not been discovered yet means relatively little. They are in the beginning stages of a technological revolution. 

Roshar has 3 magic systems, Surge Binding, Voidbinding, and Fabrials. 

Dead Shardblades have lost their connection. Brandon has explained it as similar to ripping out a USB port on a computer. If the port is ripped out, you have no way of plugging anything in. 

But, we know fabrials depends on the metals used in them. I specifically suggest Aluminum and Duralumin for Connection and possibly, Identity, could be used to create that missing "USB port". Once, that Connection has been artificially made, it will open the floodgates to both the dead spren who died during the Recreance, but also all that they knew. 

Why else is Brandon explaining the mechanics of fabrials in detail? 

I think Dalinar will direct Lirin to study mental health, and he will become a pioneer in this field. Lirin's son will also be a motivating factor here. 

Physical healing is relatively easy, with Stormlight. Mental is going to become more critical, especially if Odium & Co. are going to be trying to break you at your weakest point, as we saw with Kaladin. 

8 hours ago, NateTheMilk said:

Bro this is such an interesting theory. Personally I don’t think it will happen because Rayse is like the Palpatine of the Cosmere, but reading it gave me some major chilly vibes.

I didn't say I thought he would die. Just that the power would pass to Moash. I imagine Rayse will be a major player with groups like the 17th Shard, or the Ghostbloods. 

I think I misread it. At first I thought Renarin stepped through some kind of gateway. But on re-reading the section, I believe you gentlemen are correct.