Amanuensis
-
Posts
5932 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
6
Content Type
Profiles
News
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Amanuensis
-
I'd love that tbh, would be nice to use my role at least once this game >>
-
This discounts player's ability to thread control (such as myself) or the most important thing, role distro. This matter could be solved fairly easily with an alignment scan on Drake and/or a Pinchhitter check on Tani
-
That requires them to have a better option. What do you know about the elim team that I don't?
-
I'm not not going this route. It's more likely than e!Ash and e!Silho imo. Obviously e!Stick wouldn't plan to shoot e!Tani without foreshadowing it in thread for her claim. And no, Devo claimed RPer who RPed Steeldancer, grabbing the role of PH.
-
For village cred. Obviously. Several of us were sussing Stick from D1. Why are you taking a known elims word for it? RPer was one of like three known roles when she claimed it, and it was immediately after v!Devo!NK claimed RPer. We have no evidence to believe Tani ever had a good role and I'd bet she didn't ED1T: Yeah, that's what I think happened D3 too. Drake came in to pinchhit and made a slippy
-
According to what I've heard in PMs, Drake attacked Archer actually, just didn't announce it in thread. Archer's "Didn't Read the Rules" Role caused it to fail, supposedly. It's part of why he started pushing Archer yesterday. No. Stick was the one who killed Tani. Stick was also the one who asked Tani if she was an elim. Stick was also the one who Tani replied to saying "Yes, I am an elim" Then Stick revealed she was Tani's Killer. And, as Ash just said: You realize where I'm going with this, right?
-
Okay so... First tie: 2 Elims In: Archer Ashbringer DrakeMarshall Matrim's Dice Shining Silhouette Steeldancer TJ TNK Second tie: 2 Elims in: Ashbringer DrakeMarshall Matrim's Dice Shining Silhouette + Biplet + The Wandering Wizard + Orlok Tsubodai + Amanuensis @Steeldancer do you know if Wizard's vote still counted, even tho Silho moved it? (You would be told 2 elims and 5 villagers instead of 2 elims 6 villagers, I think?) RandBy's scan (if maybe @Araris Valerian and @Biplet are willing to confirm it and each other by both Troll Checking him) should help give context too, since if scans flips red we know he was one of the original 2 and only need to look for 1 more in the original grouping + this would basically confirm e!Biplet or e!Orlok/Araris Ashbringer DrakeMarshall Matrim's Dice Shining Silhouette Biplet If Biplet is a new Elim in the group, that means we still have 1 elim between Ash, Drake, Mat, and Shining and can concentrate there. Potentially 2, which gives us 50/50 odds of killing one. I will say, I'm beginning to entertain my paranoia of e!Coinshot!Stick/Drake again. I actually don't believe giving the elims a second kill role is too insane this game, considering the fact players can still talk afterward and there's lots of ways to interfere with it (troll, roleblock, protect) + not to mention Goalkeeper Troll Kills to give us NK power too
-
It's very unlikely an elim added themselves other than Biplet (which no one but me suspects apparently). Possible Wizard/Biplet/Fae world tho, assuming the SE Buddy thing was a lie. (Infitesimally low chance) ED1T: The only other possibility would be Orlok/Araris on a team, since Araris claimed Bookwyrm wasn't trolled N2 when scanning Orlok
-
If you're willing to, you could Troll me again and I could shoot myself
-
Sorry if you felt explicitly targeted @Biplet. You still were my best suspicion up 'til the end. At first I had thought you accepting the tie as village alligned, but then when things went sideways, I saw your vote on Ash as you attempting to disrupt the tie or pollute it's results, not save it. If I'm wrong and the elims saved v!you last night accidentally or unintentionally, which now seems to be the case, then hopefully Steel's results will prove it.
-
Let me break this down. Last night, Orlok found out there were 2 elims and 6 villagers among Mat, Ash, Silho, Steel, Drake, Archer, TJ, and TKN. We removed Archer, TJ, and Steel, and added Wizard, Orlok, and me (all Village scanned) and you (unknown). If there are no elims in our tie group, we have 7 proven villagers, barring a role like Fadran’s. That means we know that two are between Archer, TJ, and Steel, and Steel is being scanned by RandBy. If there are still 2 elims, then we know TJ and Archer are clear and can work out Ash, Mat, and Silho. So yes. The death of one villager gives us a huge amount of information to actually figure this game out. This isn’t very different than executions in another game, except we have to rely on roles and not flips to solve
-
I valued the tie more than the actual execution target and still do. Killing Silho because he used his manip to save himself and break the tie means we lose out on the chance to solve the game
-
No. I repeatedly suggested Sart and said leave Silho alone because he would be incentivized to save himself
-
@Random Bystander has Bookwyrm’s role and will submit an order to scan Steeldancer. If you can make sure he wasn’t Trolled and Steel is Village, then we can 100% trust the list he got from the ties ED1T: @StrikerEZ I have been very clearly wanting Biplet dead for cycles and have been consistently extending Silho grace because I do in fact think he is Village. Again, problem??
-
I just explained it. The plan had always been Biplet, who I am still suspicious of and will remain so until I have actual evidence to believe otherwise, and not Silho. I posted that count before Biplet self-pressed and everything went kayana. And I explicitly mentioned Drake to switch to Biplet to make sure her vote was in the lead, simultaneously dissolving the shining wagon. What on earth is the problem?
-
Why is it a question though? What does that question accomplish?
-
Yes. We needed 5 of the 8 players scanned in the last tie. Orlok, Wiz, and I participated because we all had village clears from roles, so we would show up as village on the scan. The only thing that technically didn’t matter was if we voted Silho or Bip. Regarding them being close, I told both of them why voting Silho was moot since he was getting scanned and proving his role
-
I left out the shining votes because they were irrelevant to the tie. I had faith Wiz and Drake would switch back, but was ready to ask when necessary. We needed them specifically in the group to scan ED1T: That would also require me to have three roles
-
So assuming Orlok' vote didn't vanish because of role shenanigans, @Steeldancer should know how many elims are in this group of 7: Ashbringer, Matrim's Dice, Orlok Tsubodai, Biplet, The Wandering Wizard, Amanuensis, Shining Silhouette, DrakeMarshall
-
Yeah sorry about that, I was equally confused by rollover and slightly disappointed in our organizational skills, but all jests were in good faith
-
I thought it might've been an open wolfing thing, but Sart technically wasn't meant to vote in the tie at all. Possible his quick reaction was him realizing that. Possible it was e!him sacrificing himself to prevent a bunch of clears
-
You're taking jokes too seriously, it was a false alarm. All is chill
-
Fortunately, if there's ever been a game where an execution could be rolled back / switched, it's this one
-
Ah, that's why I got confused and thought Bip self-pressed suspiciously. I was counting Orlok's vote, so without Silho's vote manipulation removing Wizard's vote, it put Ash in the lead by 2 rather than 1
-
I blame Drake for his miscount!
