Jump to content

Burnt Spaghetti

Members
  • Posts

    1108
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Burnt Spaghetti

  1. Sure, I get that, i'm just saying that initially it surprised me.Tbh i do feel like i cooled off on my tunneling as we discussed it. My initial pm was definitely pure tunnel though. But then you poked holes in my argument so i revised it and it became much less of a tunnel. I suppose that's true enough. I would hazard a guess about my assuming that being due to my tunneling on Wilson. But you do have a good point. Tho i was more saying that Wilson would be more annoying to try and kill otherwise but ok. Though i guess, for all we know, they could both be good... Hm. That is true... I will say that my pms with her sound much the same. She definitely sounded genuinely annoyed. Does this make me think she's a villager? Sure, maybe a little, doesn't change the fact i'm suspicious of her though.
  2. Well, I have a few things to say. Firstly, i'm a tad suspicious of Wilson currently. I was trying to work out why someone would redirect a kill to me, and I realised that I had told Wilson that I had an alerter. She was the only one i had mentioned any of my items too so the fact someone redirected a kill to me instead of attacking directly makes me really suspicious, even though she has denied knowing about anyone being a kill role. Although, sure, it could have easily have been someone redirecting it to someone at random, and i'm reading into my attack too much, but hey, it's a theory. I haven't had many of those yet. It might not be the case but it's something. I had other arguments against her but i've since resolved them after discussing them with her in pm first. Oh, and i can confirm that no one else could have known about my role/items. I had an alerter on, and Joes blade was the first thing to target me. Added on to the fact that i feel like i've had a suspicious read on Wilson for a while does make me think that this could be a likely situation. Added on to the fact that for the majority of the game i've read DC as probably being good. Though I will say that in my pm with her, Wilson did seem reasonably genuine, which made my suspicion of her falter a bit, though, when i initially accused her in pm, I will say that her reaction did surprise me a bit, and did make me a bit more suspicious initially as she didn't want to defend herself that much to me and more just demanded that i accuse her in thread already... Another thing is that Wilson has claimed shardplate. If we lynch DC and are wrong, we are going to have to wait until the next lynch. If we kill Wilson, and are wrong, DC can probably just be hit by a vig. Also, i think that this duel is a good thing. I feel like our past lynches haven't been that substantial, and whatever the outcome of this duel, we will learn much useful knowledge imo. (and its kind of about time the DC/Wilson thing was resolved...) So, yea, I know i haven't exactly mentioned many thoughts about DC in this post, but i'm really not that suspicious of him, so my votes going on to Wilson.
  3. Hm. So I was attacked by Joe's shardblade if you hadn't worked that out from his death cry (reason why i didn't die was cause i had a half shard). I find it interesting that it was redirected though... I have some thoughts on the matter, but i'm somewhat curious as to why people may think that someone redirected a kill onto me. I wasn't exactly the most active in thread, so i understand someone vig. killing me to cull an inactive, but, that was a redirect.
  4. Just a heads up, idk how active i'm going to be over this weekend, I had a lot of homework that needs catching up on and not much time to do it. If you ask me a direct question, i'll probably try and respond, otherwise no guarantees. I have been keeping up with the thread (ish). I may end up posting my percentage list later this cycle but we will see. Anyways, i thought i should just pop in and say that. Now i need sleep.
  5. RIP the longest PM I've ever had. Those 32 pages of greatness were great fun. With 9 counts of Elb telling me to go to sleep. (Only 9... I was sure there were more than that... Ah. I think you may have told me to go to sleep in another pm at one point though. idk.) Anyways, this game was great fun I got to experience what it might be like to be a villager scanner for once
  6. hrmph fine. I just don't like being lynched without much obvious reasom but fine. I didn't comment on your vote in thread because there wasnt much to comment on. you had a gut feeling. thats fair enough. nothing to defend against. I achnoledged the vote in the pm and left it at that. I didn't ask you to remove it, merely accepted it and moved on. I dont have an issue with your vote. I have an issue with strawman making the lynch fatal just cause. I would have just been left behind before hand. he made the lynch fatal, claiming that he didn't want the eliminators to control the lynch. that, I find infuriating. He is sitting at about 62% in my list currently.
  7. strawman unless that's a poke vote (cause I have been quiet, but that's not exactly unusual for me) I don't approve of random votes. And the fact that you don't seem to care who dies, provided someone dies is starting to sound eliminatorish to me. Sure, making sure the eliminators don't control the lynch is good, but how do we know you aren't an eliminator trying to control the lynch? and how am I meant to defend against either of the votes on me? one is a gut feeling, so no logic to correct, and the other is just cause. Gah. (disclaimer- I just woke up. might be cranky) edit: hadn't seen trelagists vote. see, he at least gives me something to work with.... gives me a reason. thank you. that's a vote I won't frown at. though, would still prefer more reasons so I can at least have a chance to defend myself....
  8. technically the spanreeds arent lost. They would have gone to the persons killer or heir, so they arent lost entirely. However, we do know that if they both went to their killers (cause I dont know who chose heirs or not. people could have done that at night as one of their actions), then one is probably currently being held by a ghostblood. oh and sorry for not posting earlier. I am trying to finish catching up on all my homework this week, so that when classes start again, next week, I'm all up to date. I have a decent amount to do...
  9. Normally it would take more than one action, but Araris is a mistborn savant with duralimin. His savantness means his one action soothes two people. The Duralamin enhancement on top of that means he can soothe three people with one action. I could only currently soothe two people.
  10. Elodin is definitely the one I'm currently most suspicious of but he already has 4? votes,. hm. So far none of our lynchs have gained us any info because they were merely left behind. I feel like we could at least learn something by lynching Elodin. I know last minute votes are typically frowned on, but give me some slack-I only recently woke up.... Elodin (if you are good, then I'm sorry.
  11. hmm im debating that right now. Thing is, I'm pretty sure there's no way,to protect against a conversion spike so,I'll be rather annoyed if you spike araris before he kills you... eh, I guess araris also can't soothe votes if we don't vote, so I guess ultimately its up to him. SilverDragon
  12. I agree that it was likely a conversion. Arraenae also knew you had been scanned. Lopen, Arraenae and I had a pm that we discussed the scanning in. We were going to open a new one to include people who had now been scanned but the she died... I'm now in C2. though, only thing with revealing locations is that the spiked can find us but eh. I'm going to come out now and say that I'm the last living scanner (zinc). I think that technically everyone except Araris has been scanned some way or another? However, note that Arraenaes scanning wouldn't pick up any hemalurgic scans if a converted never used their new ability. I was the one to scan Mark so I know its not him who is the spiked. Im going to trust that Araris is good. so I personally think that it is either Lopen or SD. More SD though as I heard a rumour that they spiked themselves. I dont know how true that it's though, but that's my only lead. Lopen, sorry if you wanted to keep the scanned group quiet but at this point, there's no point being secretive I think.
×
×
  • Create New...