Necessary Eagle she/her Posted March 6, 2020 Posted March 6, 2020 Let's make teams of Radiants from other franchises! Silmarillion: Spoiler Windrunner: Cirdan Skybreaker: Mandos Dustbringer: Feanor Lightweaver: Luthien Edgedancer: Olorin Truthwatcher: Galadriel Elsecaller: Celebrimbor Willshaper: Aredhel Stoneward: Hurin Bondsmith: Finrod Discworld: Spoiler Windrunner: Vimes Skybreaker: Auditors Dustbringer: Ridcully Lightweaver: Moist Edgedancer: Tiffany Truthwatcher: DEATH Elsecaller: Susan Willshaper: Leonard da Quirm Stoneward: Granny Weatherwax Bondsmith: Carrot Order of the Stick Spoiler Windrunner:Roy Skybreaker: Miko Dustbringer: Thor Lightweaver: Haley Edgedancer: Sigdi Truthwatcher: Odin Elsecaller: Vaarsuvius Willshaper: Elan Stoneward: O-chul Bondsmith: Durkon 1
SwordNimiForPresident the sword/that sword Posted March 6, 2020 Posted March 6, 2020 (edited) I’m curious about what your criteria for the characters from The Silmarillion was. They’re the only ones I’m familiar with. Edited March 6, 2020 by SwordNimiForPresident
Frustration Posted March 6, 2020 Posted March 6, 2020 2 hours ago, Necessary Eagle said: Let's make teams of Radiants from other franchises! Silmarillion: Reveal hidden contents Windrunner: Cirdan Skybreaker: Mandos Dustbringer: Feanor Lightweaver: Luthien Edgedancer: Olorin Truthwatcher: Galadriel Elsecaller: Celebrimbor Willshaper: Aredhel Stoneward: Hurin Bondsmith: Finrod Spoiler Hold up Feanor is an Elsecaller and Meadhros(I don't have the book on me my spelling is probably off) is a way better bondsmith Silmarillion
Necessary Eagle she/her Posted March 6, 2020 Author Posted March 6, 2020 58 minutes ago, SwordNimiForPresident said: I’m curious about what your criteria for the characters from The Silmarillion was. They’re the only ones I’m familiar with. Spoiler Windrunner was the hardest, but Cirdan is the longest-lasting non-isolationist leader in Beleriand, so there's Leading and Protecting. Mandos is in many ways like Nale, a near-emotionless arbiter handing down Judgement. Dustbringer spren, ah, seem to be less morally discriminating (see: Malata); Feanor is super-passionate and already fire-themed. Luthien is really good with illusions. And moving Mandos to tears requires one heckuva Performance check, so to speak. Olorin is said to be the most subtle maia, going around invisibly giving people hope and courage. He seems to be all about the small things. Galadriel is an enigmatic seer. Celebrimbor is a nerd- er, a genius scholar-inventor who establishes a whole university city. Aredhel is a restless wanderer. Hurin last-standed so hard his freakin' axe melted, and then he was tortured by Morgoth himself for seventy years without giving in. Finrod just... gets along. With everyone. Friend of Men, Friend of Dwarves, Friend of Every Elf Not Named Curufin or Celegorm. 1
Necessary Eagle she/her Posted March 6, 2020 Author Posted March 6, 2020 48 minutes ago, Booknerd said: Reveal hidden contents Hold up Feanor is an Elsecaller and Meadhros(I don't have the book on me my spelling is probably off) is a way better bondsmith Silmarillion I disagree. Maedhros is certainly more diplomatic than his brothers, and he did gather his eponymous Union- but then he led two more Kinslayings. He did not fall and then rise a better man; he fell and fell and continued falling, until he literally jumped to his death.
Frustration Posted March 6, 2020 Posted March 6, 2020 1 hour ago, Necessary Eagle said: I disagree. Maedhros is certainly more diplomatic than his brothers, and he did gather his eponymous Union- but then he led two more Kinslayings. He did not fall and then rise a better man; he fell and fell and continued falling, until he literally jumped to his death. He kind of held the elf-folk together for the entire Siege of Angband, at least four centuries. This was after the first kinslaying. Also his brothers lead the second and third Kinslayings not him. I will admit he failed at the end, but so did the Stormfathers last radiant so I say that that's not a total disqualifier.
Frustration Posted March 7, 2020 Posted March 7, 2020 (edited) Beyonders(Brandon Mull) Spoiler Windrunner: Jason Skybreaker: Aram Dustbringer: jasher Edgedanncer: Corinne Truthwatcher: * Lightweaver: Ferrin Elsecaller: Rachel Willshaper: Nedwin Stoneward: Drake Bondsmith: Galloran *can't think of these at the moment I'll come back later when I think of them. Edited March 10, 2020 by Booknerd
+ILuvHats he/him Posted March 8, 2020 Posted March 8, 2020 I have just want alteration I want to make to your list on the Order of the Stick. On 3/6/2020 at 8:09 AM, Necessary Eagle said: Order of the Stick Hide contents Windrunner:Roy Skybreaker: Miko Dustbringer: Belkar Lightweaver: Haley Edgedancer: Sigdi Truthwatcher: Odin Elsecaller: Vaarsuvius Willshaper: Elan Stoneward: O-chul Bondsmith: Durkon Ah, much better. Spoiler Not that Thor wouldn’t make a good Dustbringers, but c’mon, it’s such a good opportunity, especially since Belkar doesn’t fit anywhere else in the list. I mean, Dustbringers break stuff, and Belkar just likes to break everything as long as they happen to be living creatures.
Frustration Posted March 10, 2020 Posted March 10, 2020 (edited) Star Wars(Prequels because the're the best[don't start an argument]) Spoiler Windrunner: Obi-wan Skybreaker: Anakin Dustbrinnger: Mace Windu Edgedancer: Ki Adi Mundi Truthwatcher: * Lightweaver: Padme Elsecaller:* Willshaper: Qui-gon jinn Stoneward: * Bondsmith:Yoda *I'll come back to these when I find the right ones. Edited March 10, 2020 by Booknerd
BasementDwellingRadiant Posted March 11, 2020 Posted March 11, 2020 Harry Potter - Windrunner or Edgedancer
clockworkspider Posted March 12, 2020 Posted March 12, 2020 I've said it before, and I'll say it again: Stannis Baratheon from A Song of Ice and Fire would be an amazing Skybreaker. I could also see him as a Stoneward, based on the little we know of them. 2
Recommended Posts