Sup Guys

[Aon Tia she/her]

2 minutes ago, StealthPrincess said:

Ahahahaha wise not to get your hopes up

I actually like that through her Brandon is showing that acquiring surgebinding is not a solution to all the problems a person has. 
I am totally down with it, if he chooses to take shallan even more down the spiral and if it is shown that she is not able to solve her issues! 

[StealthPrincess she/her]

1 minute ago, The traveller said:

I actually like that through her Brandon is showing that acquiring surgebinding is not a solution to all the problems a person has. 
I am totally down with it, if he chooses to take shallan even more down the spiral and if it is shown that she is not able to solve her issues! 

I'm fine with all of that, and interested to see how Brandon will handle it in the next two books.

I just stopped liking her after she thought the world's stupidest plan (aka stealing Jasnah's soulcaster) was so clever and ingenious 

[Aon Tia she/her]

1 minute ago, StealthPrincess said:

I just stopped liking her after she thought the world's stupidest plan (aka stealing Jasnah's soulcaster) was so clever and ingenious 

So basically from the very beginning 
 

I agree though steal the soulcasters from the princess of Alethkar! Great idea !!! instead of the very reasonable plan of gaining her wardship and eventually her trust and then asking for jasnah’s help with the soulcaster. 
Her soulcaster is not sanctioned by the Ardentia, Jasnah is not going to care that yours is as well!! 

[Honorless he/him]

For me it was the boots, then her reaction to the eye-color changing equipment of Tyn, her conversation with Adolin calling Kaladin a peasant wasn't very nice either after everything they had been through in the chasms together. She was very insensitive towards Kaladin while Adolin started to become better towards him, but now at least she has started admitting her problems. Hopefully with more Truths she'll become a better Radiant and a better person.

[Aon Tia she/her]

1 minute ago, Honorless said:

For me it was the boots, then her reaction to the eye-color changing equipment of Tyn, her conversation with Adolin calling Kaladin a peasant wasn't very nice either after everything they had been through in the chasms together

My dislike of her was well set by the time book 2 and 3 came out. I confess that I too have disliked her in book 1 also.
But I agree That I disliked it when she called Kaladin a peasant but I also disliked her when she was mean to Renarin! Calling him creepy and weird! 

[Honorless he/him]

Just now, The traveller said:

My dislike of her was well set by the time book 2 and 3 came out. I confess that I too have disliked her in book 1 also.
But I agree That I disliked it when she called Kaladin a peasant but I also disliked her when she was mean to Renarin! Calling him creepy and weird! 

That one I can let pass, she was under a lot of duress and later on, in Oathbringer she defended him against what's-her-face very well

[StealthPrincess she/her]

3 minutes ago, The traveller said:

My dislike of her was well set by the time book 2 and 3 came out. I confess that I too have disliked her in book 1 also.
But I agree That I disliked it when she called Kaladin a peasant but I also disliked her when she was mean to Renarin! Calling him creepy and weird! 

How could I forget her being rude to Renarin! If anything, she's the weird and creepy one 

[Aon Tia she/her]

1 minute ago, Honorless said:

That one I can let pass, she was under a lot of duress and later on, in Oathbringer she defended him against what's-her-face very well

Yes she defended him later but at that time she was being very mean to the poor boy! I find her Veil persona to be very irritating. 

[StealthPrincess she/her]

2 minutes ago, The traveller said:

Yes she defended him later but at that time she was being very mean to the poor boy! I find her Veil persona to be very irritating. 

I like Radiant the least

[Aon Tia she/her]

Just now, StealthPrincess said:

How could I forget her being rude to Renarin! If anything, she's the weird and creepy one 

Exactly !! I agree! I was like look who is calling him creepy and weird! Shallan the most weird and creepy character!
 

[Honorless he/him]

Poor Shallan 

A lot of people have taken notice of her less likeable aspects, don't worry

[Aon Tia she/her]

I have actually never visited this particular thread

[Honorless he/him]

It's actually a bit too toxic, so I've refrained from reading further down it myself

Let's leave Shallan to her stick, shall we? 

@StealthPrincess, what's your favourite Shardworld? Where in the Cosmere would you choose to live if you had the choice?

Edited December 17, 2019 by Honorless

[StealthPrincess she/her]

1 minute ago, Honorless said:

It's actually a bit too toxic, so I've refrained from reading further down it myself

Let's leave Shallan to her stick, shall we?

@StealthPrincess, what's your favourite Shardworld?

Ohh interesting question! I'm most intrigued by Taldain

Can I please visit?

(Although, I really want to visit Kharbanth, especially the library, so I have to say Roshar as well)

What about you?

[Honorless he/him]

6 minutes ago, StealthPrincess said:

Ohh interesting question! I'm most intrigued by Taldain

Can I please visit?

(Although, I really want to visit Kharbanth, especially the library, so I have to say Roshar as well)

What about you?

Definitely Roshar, it seems so scenic! I want to see the Reshi Isles and Urithiru and the Highstorm!

I'd be very curious about Taldain too, especially Darkside!

Scadrial (post Final Empire), Sel and Nalthis would have some comfortable living, again Taldain does too, huh you made a very good choice, I see

Strangely enough I want to visit First of the Sun, seems I don't have very good survival instincts 

I wouldn't want to visit Threnody though (seems too dangerous)!

I'm very curious about Yolen & Vax, also the other planets in the same system as First of the Sun.

Edited December 17, 2019 by Honorless

[StealthPrincess she/her]

1 minute ago, Honorless said:

Definitely Roshar, it seems so scenic!

Anywhere that isn't the Shattered Plains though. I think after Kharbranth, I'd want to visit the Purelake. And stay there.

 

2 minutes ago, Honorless said:

Strangely enough I want to visit First of the Sun, seems I don't have very good survival instincts 

Eh, who needs survival instincts when you have investiture

[Aon Tia she/her]

Favourite shard world is Roshar! Would definitely love to live there! I would love to visit Era 1 Scadrial but the current one, mah!
But I am curious about Yolen too! 
 

8 minutes ago, StealthPrincess said:

Anywhere that isn't the Shattered Plains though. I think after Kharbranth, I'd want to visit the Purelake. And stay there.

 

Oh I would love to see the shattered plains! I want to see the highstorm too. 

 

13 minutes ago, Honorless said:

I don't have very good survival instincts 

Nothing is more dangerous than Roshar though

Edited December 17, 2019 by The traveller

[Honorless he/him]

Okay, now we get down to tacks of brass *cracks knuckles*

@StealthPrincess, if you had to kill one Cosmere protagonist and save one antagonist, who'd they be?

[StealthPrincess she/her]

Just now, Honorless said:

Okay, now we get down to tacks of brass *cracks knuckles*

@StealthPrincess, if you had to kill one Cosmere protagonist and save one antagonist, who'd they be?

Bring it on!

I'm assuming that the antagonist is dead right?

[Aon Tia she/her]

5 minutes ago, StealthPrincess said:

Bring it on!

I'm assuming that the antagonist is dead right?

I think They could be already dead or some antagonist who might be in a deadly situation in some future book. 

[Honorless he/him]

6 minutes ago, StealthPrincess said:

I'm assuming that the antagonist is dead right?

Dead or otherwise disabled

[StealthPrincess she/her]

I think I'd kill Dalinar. Just to see what happens

And I'd bring back Straff, so someone could kill him again 

(Does Hrathen count as an antagonist by the way?)

How about you guys?

@Honorless great questions by the way

 

[Aon Tia she/her]

1 minute ago, StealthPrincess said:

I think I'd kill Dalinar. Just to see what happens

And I'd bring back Straff, so someone could kill him again 

(Does Hrathen count as an antagonist by the way?)

Oh no!!!!!!! Not Dalinar!! Poor Navani! 
 

ok I think I can let shallan die. Adolin will get over it. Right? He will, won’t he? 
 

Sadeas just so he could be killed honourably in a duel by Adolin in front of everyone!

[Honorless he/him]

1 minute ago, StealthPrincess said:

I think I'd kill Dalinar. Just to see what happens

And I'd bring back Straff, so someone could kill him again 

(Does Hrathen count as an antagonist by the way?)

How about you guys?

@Honorless great questions by the way

 

Thanks! I like putting new members through an emotional wringer 

 

I would kill Ais the Trackt and I would save Zane

[StealthPrincess she/her]

Just now, The traveller said:

Oh no!!!!!!! Not Dalinar!! Poor Navani! 
 

ok I think I can let shallan die. Adolin will get over it. Right? He will, won’t he? 
 

Sadeas just so he could be killed honourably in a duel by Adolin in front of everyone!

But imagine the drama and chaos that will ensue

He deserves much better, I hope he would realise 

Oh good one about Sadeas! Ok, what about an antihero that you'd bring back, just so you could see more plotting and scheming from them