Onyx Flamingo Posted January 13 Posted January 13 3 minutes ago, Violet Axolotl said: Hah yeah Awwwww Who do y'all think I am violet axolotl who do you thunk i am?
Sunburst Toucan Posted January 13 Posted January 13 7 minutes ago, Melon Dingo said: If you're not lying, I'm very excited about what my new follow-up guess for you is xD. I mentioned them under my thoughts trying to figure out Dragonfly Well, you didn't get prio-ed for real account guesses. You got prio-ed for thread control. I tried to challenge you, but my long post where I spent a lot of time working hard to actually throw sus on you got deleted... So I went "oh whatever I'll wing it" as I wasn't willing to duplicate that effort, and you came down so hard on me I was just like... storms... not prepared for that... Then every time I tried to match your posting for control you'd immediately respond to what I said and I just kinda gave up as I didn't have the time (or analysis speed) to contest you at that point... Hence the kill = ) Though I was originally trying to kill you mid tunnel as I feel like that looks villagery. (I try to push an exe and the elims kill that target.) Another musical theater fan? I do believe my backup guess for you is also a fan... Lol Umm... I definitely think this game was more broken than I feel like you're admitting here... but I also agree with Jo that this game wasn't as broken as it appears on first glance. Like, if the village hits 3/5 elims at any point in the game it is super snowball-y... and if the elims are winning it looks like a normal game. Even with 2 e!coinshots it's not that snowball-y for elims with 4(or 5) lurchers, and 4 MB who have a 1/4 chance to have a protect role... But this is not a criticism I had fun and that's all that matters. It was also cool watching the thread reactions to all the claims and we wouldn't have gotten that in a different game. I do think that no v!Kandra would have fixed the biggest balance issue. Alternatively, make the e!team= 2 Seekers, 2 Kandra, 1 Rioter. The reason is now with the full team there are always 2 who can submit the NK. Next, less than half the team is seekers (important because of Kandra), additionally, by having 2 seekers and 2 Kandra, what you are implying to the elims is you can spend your Kandra to deny Seeker from village or to aggressively take roles. You then can give village Kandra or not. But I'd say give the elims a single digit Kandra and a double digit gen (and village 1 or 2 in the middle). Then they think (rightly) they can guarantee steal a role or risk it and then there is strategy in which Kandra gets used. to your point though a big part of our problem was no matter what happened on the day cycles, the rollover crew where most of the active players in the game and so we didn't get much of a say how the end of the day went. I finally understand what people on the other side of the world have been complaining about with rollover times lol Same! (I think) Was a crazy game. Exactly what I was looking for. Also frankly ended at a good time too as I'm only getting busier throughout this month... I told Jo and TUM I'd only join if there was a pinch hitter for me just in case... and at the end there I was thinking about if the game continued how much it'd suck to be a pinch hitter and enter as an elim in that game state xD I thought that about Gecko in the last game I played with them xD I also think that about Croc to a little lesser extent What last night tipped it off to you? Oh I normally love thunderdoming but in this game it was kind of pointless as with 15 players left even if I got you to exe flamingo I assume I'd just be shot the next night. Though if someone wanted to take Fifths honorary elim title maybe someone would be willing to protect me? xD We weren't really able to plan together and the day everyone was roleclaiming I was stupidly busy so it was really challenging to make a plan. Seeker was what I went with purely because I thought I might be able to prove myself with the soft claim and avoid+flip the kandra before they claimed. But then everyone claimed and it was too late imo to change my claim. The funny thing is, I too forgot what a thunderdome was and had to look it up when I saw that lol Wait... you mean my game decisions where I played into who I was to appear less suspicious were completely unnecessary????? I 100% believed your lie. Felt very much like something Jo would do to troll a player lol ED1T: And by popular demand some adorable pictures of Syl!!!! Hide contents AWWWW CUTE CAT so tiny I have absolutely no clue who anyone is Anyone got a guess on me?
Indigo Weasel Posted January 13 Posted January 13 1 minute ago, Sunburst Toucan said: AWWWW CUTE CAT so tiny I have absolutely no clue who anyone is Anyone got a guess on me? Same, other than the people who’ve basically admitted it. I doubt people know who I am, I’ve played every single game I’ve been in a very different way.
Saffron Iguana Posted January 13 Posted January 13 Good game everyone (especially the village)! Playing this game made me aware of how rusty I am. Accidentally voted on a teammate D1 which ended up getting me killed Day 2. Though I was hoping my discussion of Octo would bail me out there. I am still somewhat baffled as to why the village almost exed Octo D2, though in light of the distro it makes a bit more sense. I realized partway through the day that defending Octo 100% would be something of an elim tell once he flipped village CS. I’m not really sure I have comprehensive distro thoughts. Probably the main thing is that I’m not a fan of a setup where villagers can both be unkillable (multiple Lurchers) and have a Seeker. That puts a ton of pressure of inevitability on the elims, where every blocked kill feels extra bad because you know either a villager was cleared or a teammate has been outed. None of that really ended up mattering this game due to our blunders and crazy village competency, but I think removing the village Kandra would go a long way toward making this setup better, while still holding to its essence. The mistborn would still be a potential problem there (being able to scan the CS and Lurcher claims, notably) but I think they would feel more manageable.
Taupe Gecko Posted January 13 Posted January 13 10 minutes ago, Melon Dingo said: If you're not lying, I'm very excited about what my new follow-up guess for you is xD. I mentioned them under my thoughts trying to figure out Dragonfly Well, you didn't get prio-ed for real account guesses. You got prio-ed for thread control. I tried to challenge you, but my long post where I spent a lot of time working hard to actually throw sus on you got deleted... So I went "oh whatever I'll wing it" as I wasn't willing to duplicate that effort, and you came down so hard on me I was just like... storms... not prepared for that... Then every time I tried to match your posting for control you'd immediately respond to what I said and I just kinda gave up as I didn't have the time (or analysis speed) to contest you at that point... Hence the kill = ) Though I was originally trying to kill you mid tunnel as I feel like that looks villagery. (I try to push an exe and the elims kill that target.) Another musical theater fan? I do believe my backup guess for you is also a fan... Lol Umm... I definitely think this game was more broken than I feel like you're admitting here... but I also agree with Jo that this game wasn't as broken as it appears on first glance. Like, if the village hits 3/5 elims at any point in the game it is super snowball-y... and if the elims are winning it looks like a normal game. Even with 2 e!coinshots it's not that snowball-y for elims with 4(or 5) lurchers, and 4 MB who have a 1/4 chance to have a protect role... But this is not a criticism I had fun and that's all that matters. It was also cool watching the thread reactions to all the claims and we wouldn't have gotten that in a different game. I do think that no v!Kandra would have fixed the biggest balance issue. Alternatively, make the e!team= 2 Seekers, 2 Kandra, 1 Rioter. The reason is now with the full team there are always 2 who can submit the NK. Next, less than half the team is seekers (important because of Kandra), additionally, by having 2 seekers and 2 Kandra, what you are implying to the elims is you can spend your Kandra to deny Seeker from village or to aggressively take roles. You then can give village Kandra or not. But I'd say give the elims a single digit Kandra and a double digit gen (and village 1 or 2 in the middle). Then they think (rightly) they can guarantee steal a role or risk it and then there is strategy in which Kandra gets used. to your point though a big part of our problem was no matter what happened on the day cycles, the rollover crew where most of the active players in the game and so we didn't get much of a say how the end of the day went. I finally understand what people on the other side of the world have been complaining about with rollover times lol Same! (I think) Was a crazy game. Exactly what I was looking for. Also frankly ended at a good time too as I'm only getting busier throughout this month... I told Jo and TUM I'd only join if there was a pinch hitter for me just in case... and at the end there I was thinking about if the game continued how much it'd suck to be a pinch hitter and enter as an elim in that game state xD I thought that about Gecko in the last game I played with them xD I also think that about Croc to a little lesser extent What last night tipped it off to you? Oh I normally love thunderdoming but in this game it was kind of pointless as with 15 players left even if I got you to exe flamingo I assume I'd just be shot the next night. Though if someone wanted to take Fifths honorary elim title maybe someone would be willing to protect me? xD We weren't really able to plan together and the day everyone was roleclaiming I was stupidly busy so it was really challenging to make a plan. Seeker was what I went with purely because I thought I might be able to prove myself with the soft claim and avoid+flip the kandra before they claimed. But then everyone claimed and it was too late imo to change my claim. The funny thing is, I too forgot what a thunderdome was and had to look it up when I saw that lol Wait... you mean my game decisions where I played into who I was to appear less suspicious were completely unnecessary????? I 100% believed your lie. Felt very much like something Jo would do to troll a player lol ED1T: And by popular demand some adorable pictures of Syl!!!! Hide contents Okay the more people post the less sure I am of who is Doc and who is Fura so I'm just giving up 4 minutes ago, Sunburst Toucan said: AWWWW CUTE CAT so tiny I have absolutely no clue who anyone is Anyone got a guess on me? Gonna throw a somewhat (but not completely) random one since I have genuinely no idea Coder?
Oxblood Beagle Posted January 13 Posted January 13 5 minutes ago, Melon Dingo said: The funny thing is, I too forgot what a thunderdome was and had to look it up when I saw that D1: My guess on you was correct because of the energy plus going for the chaotic tie lol D2: It shifted to Gecko because I thought Gecko would have been the one going harder against Heron haha D3: Began suspecting you because I was still thinking you were Gecko and like it's very much within my impression of Gecko to be bussing their teammate N3: It shifted back when I figured that even if you forgot what a thunderdome was, you probably would have looked it up first before asking in-thread, and I was like wait a minute, did I get it wrong... 10 minutes ago, Melon Dingo said: to your point though a big part of our problem was no matter what happened on the day cycles, the rollover crew where most of the active players in the game and so we didn't get much of a say how the end of the day went. I finally understand what people on the other side of the world have been complaining about with rollover times lol Haha yeah, this is one of those few games where rollover times really works out amazingly for me, and it's not in a rather awkward time where I'm like barely awake to be thinking thoroughly
Violet Axolotl Posted January 13 Posted January 13 13 minutes ago, Onyx Flamingo said: violet axolotl who do you thunk i am? Honestly? Spirit 12 minutes ago, Sunburst Toucan said: AWWWW CUTE CAT so tiny I have absolutely no clue who anyone is Anyone got a guess on me? Nada 8 minutes ago, Taupe Gecko said: Okay the more people post the less sure I am of who is Doc and who is Fura so I'm just giving up Gonna throw a somewhat (but not completely) random one since I have genuinely no idea Coder? You saying coder confuses me as to your identity
Taupe Gecko Posted January 13 Posted January 13 Just now, Violet Axolotl said: You saying coder confuses me as to your identity Bruh I thought everyone knew my identity by now
Violet Axolotl Posted January 13 Posted January 13 1 minute ago, Taupe Gecko said: Bruh I thought everyone knew my identity by now Not I Maybe I don't interact w/ you often I do know that that's definitely not coder tho
Indigo Weasel Posted January 13 Posted January 13 14 minutes ago, Taupe Gecko said: Okay the more people post the less sure I am of who is Doc and who is Fura so I'm just giving up Gonna throw a somewhat (but not completely) random one since I have genuinely no idea Coder? If it is, I’m gonna be sad I missed my shardbuddy
Melon Dingo Posted January 13 Posted January 13 9 minutes ago, Oxblood Beagle said: D2: It shifted to Gecko because I thought Gecko would have been the one going harder against Heron haha Hahaha 9 minutes ago, Oxblood Beagle said: N3: It shifted back when I figured that even if you forgot what a thunderdome was, you probably would have looked it up first before asking in-thread, and I was like wait a minute, did I get it wrong... That's quite a nuanced and detailed read to get of me lol. Maybe I was right about you? I didn't write down that read of you anywhere in the elim doc but I was trying to figure you out... If you're who I'm thinking atm you played different this game than I think I'm used to which threw me 12 minutes ago, Oxblood Beagle said: Haha yeah, this is one of those few games where rollover times really works out amazingly for me, and it's not in a rather awkward time where I'm like barely awake to be thinking thoroughly Ok no you lost me again... unless YOU are my backup guess for Heron which could make a lot of sense
Mint Heron Posted January 13 Posted January 13 (edited) 31 minutes ago, Indigo Weasel said: Same, other than the people who’ve basically admitted it. I doubt people know who I am, I’ve played every single game I’ve been in a very different way. Man. Maybe I don't know who this uce is 30 minutes ago, Saffron Iguana said: I am still somewhat baffled as to why the village almost exed Octo D2, though in light of the distro it makes a bit more sense. I realized partway through the day that defending Octo 100% would be something of an elim tell once he flipped village CS. If you're who I think you are uce, fog-of-war as usual. But I admit I was not completely sold on Ocho and more or less acceded to the train thinking Weasel could be right and being too tired to fight it. 19 minutes ago, Taupe Gecko said: Bruh I thought everyone knew my identity by now Welcome to anon games, we hope you've enjoyed the ride! 41 minutes ago, Melon Dingo said: If you're not lying, I'm very excited about what my new follow-up guess for you is xD. I mentioned them under my thoughts trying to figure out Dragonfly It's an interesting guess, I'll give you that! Fair shout on thread control, I get that. 41 minutes ago, Melon Dingo said: Wait... you mean my game decisions where I played into who I was to appear less suspicious were completely unnecessary????? Uce I don't even know your village play, let alone your elim play I was riding on about 95% vote analysis and 4% post reads this game. Zebra's the only guy I think I know fosho, enough to actually try to read on that basis. Edited January 13 by Mint Heron
Oxblood Beagle Posted January 13 Posted January 13 33 minutes ago, Saffron Iguana said: Good game everyone (especially the village)! Playing this game made me aware of how rusty I am. Accidentally voted on a teammate D1 which ended up getting me killed Day 2. I never expected that it ended up that every elim except Meerkat would coincidentally have their first vote be on a fellow elim 14 minutes ago, Melon Dingo said: I didn't write down that read of you anywhere in the elim doc but I was trying to figure you out... If you're who I'm thinking atm you played different this game than I think I'm used to which threw me Ok no you lost me again... unless YOU are my backup guess for Heron which could make a lot of sense Hehe, even I am uncertain if I actually played differently the last time we were in the same game
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 13 Posted January 13 ...well, I was correct that the Seeker/Coinshot pool was too big and needed resolving. I was correct that there actually really was just 4 village Lurchers. I even sussed Dingo as one of my, what, 2 suspicions of the game, with the other also being on a Seeker claim. And correctly guessed the Smoker was fake. And y'all SHOT me for it. TWICE SMH /hj
Scarlet Octopus Posted January 13 Posted January 13 5 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: And y'all SHOT me for it. TWICE You're welcome
Pearl Chameleon Posted January 13 Posted January 13 Thank you GMs for running this game. I didn't play that long but it was definitely a memorable day and night. Elims, that's a beautiful 74 page doc. I know things didn't go your way but respect.
Mint Heron Posted January 13 Posted January 13 18 minutes ago, Pearl Chameleon said: ...well, I was correct that the Seeker/Coinshot pool was too big and needed resolving. I was correct that there actually really was just 4 village Lurchers. I even sussed Dingo as one of my, what, 2 suspicions of the game, with the other also being on a Seeker claim. And correctly guessed the Smoker was fake. And y'all SHOT me for it. TWICE SMH /hj Good job though. I think you and Lion got Beagle, Rhino and me considering E!Dingo worlds more, we just weren't gonna call for a hero shot (admittedly maybe it doesn't fully fill the prereqs) on an ostensible Seeker. We weren't emotionally ready for it
Indigo Weasel Posted January 13 Posted January 13 Well, I’m going to log out of this account for the first time in a week or so, and so if I end of posting here again, it’ll be with my actual one(assuming Jo’s fine with that)
Quartz Zebra Posted January 13 Posted January 13 I would assume that everyone knows who I am at this point
Mint Heron Posted January 13 Posted January 13 6 minutes ago, Quartz Zebra said: I would assume that everyone knows who I am at this point Dannnex right? Haven't seen you around in forever man.
Scarlet Octopus Posted January 13 Posted January 13 13 minutes ago, Quartz Zebra said: I would assume that everyone knows who I am at this point I have no clue so...
Ivory Dragonfly Posted January 13 Posted January 13 6 hours ago, The Unknown Medallion said: Melon Dingo was Seeked by Onyx Flamingo, and then killed by Melon Dingo! xD Analysis, RP, vote timing, roleclaims... I had a lot of fun! Did not expect all those lurcher. Anyone confused about my RP, that's what I was going for. Elim, GM, great game.
Onyx Flamingo Posted January 13 Posted January 13 1 hour ago, Taupe Gecko said: Okay the more people post the less sure I am of who is Doc and who is Fura so I'm just giving up Gonna throw a somewhat (but not completely) random one since I have genuinely no idea Coder? 1 hour ago, Indigo Weasel said: If it is, I’m gonna be sad I missed my shardbuddy Wait Coder is in this game? Wait am I an idiot did he post on the sign up thread? And Weasel, Coder is your shardbuddy? (New info added)
Taupe Gecko Posted January 13 Posted January 13 1 hour ago, Oxblood Beagle said: D1: My guess on you was correct because of the energy plus going for the chaotic tie lol D2: It shifted to Gecko because I thought Gecko would have been the one going harder against Heron haha D3: Began suspecting you because I was still thinking you were Gecko and like it's very much within my impression of Gecko to be bussing their teammate N3: It shifted back when I figured that even if you forgot what a thunderdome was, you probably would have looked it up first before asking in-thread, and I was like wait a minute, did I get it wrong... Okay bro you lost me But yes, I would absolutely be the kinda guy to bus a teammate if I had to, although I would try to avoid a casualty if I could And I did have some slight phases of Heron paranoia once I thought he was Kas… 33 minutes ago, Quartz Zebra said: I would assume that everyone knows who I am at this point 19 minutes ago, Scarlet Octopus said: I have no clue so... Fr me neither 12 minutes ago, Ivory Dragonfly said: xD Analysis, RP, vote timing, roleclaims... I had a lot of fun! Did not expect all those lurcher. Anyone confused about my RP, that's what I was going for. Elim, GM, great game. You played incredibly Whoever you are, you have my greatest respect 4 minutes ago, Onyx Flamingo said: Wait Coder is in this game? Wait am I an idiot did he post on the sign up thread? And Weasel, Coder is your shardbuddy? (New info added) Mine too, although I don’t actually know if he signed up, I’d assume he did
Recommended Posts