Onyx Flamingo Posted January 9 Posted January 9 21 minutes ago, Plum Rhinoceros said: The issue with this is Joe is a very creative GM, and e!Coinshots have been done to the level that it is not unexpected any more. So, speculating distro here, I do not think there is an e!CS. The possibility of 2 v!CS though.... I would not rule out. Just wanted to point out, it has been speculated that a Mistborn was the CS that shot at Axl, and it has also been speculated that that MB was an e!MB
Melon Dingo Posted January 9 Posted January 9 There were also 3 attacks. Also we shouldnt kill someone on D2 for purely distro reasons in a Tyrian game (or any game for that matter its not fun) Im sus on Octo, but so many people being so willing to vote on them is weird. Also Heron is more sus and I think Herons flip will tell us about Octopus. There has also been no counter wagon attempt at all which does make me think more likely village.
Saffron Iguana Posted January 9 Posted January 9 I think I'll switch from Toucan to Rhino. I have a preference for the former but I'm still not sold on e!Octo, and of the current available options I have a decent village read on Heron, while Rhino is in my POE. I'm also v!reading Alb right now, so I'm not really a fan of Rhino's vote.
Oxblood Beagle Posted January 9 Posted January 9 29 minutes ago, Plum Rhinoceros said: Okay, back at the screen staring the hours of footage - Art's Obs - D1 Cont. -> Weasel shifts from DF to Roo to make it 4-4-3 for DF, Axo and Roo resp. Ig moves off a "poke" vote on Roo towards Octo. Roo down to 2 votes now. Axo up to 5. Refer below; this does not look like an e/e interaction with Croc. Minor village points for Flami. At this point, Heron asks for alternatives as DF has claimed Lurcher. Heron offers Roo as a potential alt. Gecko answers the call, albeit with a different alt in Weasel. Please find the recording attached. Interestingly, it is quite a large post without a single mention about Roo. Bea votes for Axo, it's 6-3 now. Also, important to note that, at least at this point, Heron is proposing Roo as an alternative to CW (DF) and not the main wagon (Axo). They just want DF to survive any emotional allomancy shenanigans. Gecko asks for options again. Bea suggests Roo. Gecko says they will back it and they do. Bea shortly follows. Major village points for both. Axo 5, Roo 4. DF moves from Axo to Roo. Now it's Roo 5, Axo 4. Everyone thinks it's 4-4 due to an error in the VC. Heron holds off on voting to maintain a tie. References -> [3] - Art's Conclusions - D1 -> DF, Bea and Gecko are largely village. Heron to a tiny bit lesser extent as well. Hunch says Weasel is village as well. Roo's last vote on Weasel was not a throwaway in my opinion. It was a genuine answer to the call by Gecko for the Weasel alt train. I just think the thread of conversation was going so fast, she did not realise an alt train had already developed on her. I liked Zebra's content. I liked Flami's behaviour. I'm not liking Tross or Octo. Ig and Ele to a lesser extent as well. I'm actually not sure what to make of Axo. I'm not ruling out an e/e train, nothing really to suggest the train was v/e other than Croc's vote on Axo. And we know Croc was a Rioter, their vote would have disappeared had they used/been around to use the Riot. Don't know about Dingo either. Art's Obs - N1/D2 -> Refer below; again, firstly, there's nothing to suggest that the counter-train (Axo) is v. Secondly, this also seems to be a TMI that the counter-train is v. Thirdly, this could also mean Tross trying to maintain the common consensus that the counter-train (Axo) is village, if Axo is evil with Tross. Negative points for Tross. Refer below; same post, removes Croc from PoE for no reason. I think this post from Flami - particularly in the spoiler box bit, exudes pure villageriness. Agree with Heron re: weird Toucan night vote. Note that D2 starts here. 3 attacks, I would tend to believe both the Lurcher claims for now. Lurcher nerf also hints at the possibility of multiple Lurchers. Octo says they shot Croc because they went through Heron's list and found a mutual suspect. They also say Croc was kind of annoying and did not contribute to much. Skimmed the rest of the D2 References -> [1] - [2] - Art's Thoughts So Far -> I oppose an Octo exe this cycle until we get some clarity. I understand Weasel's argument that they don't think Octo is actually the CS, and that they are baiting the actual CS, but I do think we have hints of CS!Octo quite early in the game. Remember, they asked if Coinshots can attack themselves. My question to @Scarlet Octopus is, why would you ask that question? If you are a Coinshot, why would you want to attack yourself? I also understand Weasel's argument that it is less-than ideal or sub-optimal village play to truly claim CS if you are one. But Weasel, sometimes people play sub-optimally and that is okay. To further convince Weasel, the choice to bait the real CS requires planning and time to discuss with any potential teammate. But here, it looks like they just blurted it out. I really don't think a Saboteur's first reaction on learning that they just lost yet another teammate would be to claim that kill. What exactly are other Octo voters' arguments? Like I said, my biggest problem is the reason they asked the aforementioned question. I'm thinking they are actually a Coinshot. But I am not ruling out some failed WGG scenario because of the question they asked. It could be that someone was supposed to protect Croc but that did not happen for some reason. The issue with this is Joe is a very creative GM, and e!Coinshots have been done to the level that it is not unexpected any more. So, speculating distro here, I do not think there is an e!CS. The possibility of 2 v!CS though.... I would not rule out. I'm not gonna pile on Octo before we get some more info. My highest suspicion would be, as stated above, AlbaTross. Mindmeld moment, thank you for this. This does make me inclined to townread you and I'll read up more on the points you raised regarding Albatross Plum Rhinoceros Something I forgot to add was that Octopus and Kangaroo were both so closely associated during the time when they voted against DF and then later on, when Crocodile prompted Kangaroo to share more of their reads, Kangaroo only cited Octopus as their village read. I don't think as elims they would really want to tie themselves to each other that closely On 1/5/2026 at 4:32 AM, Scarlet Octopus said: "Adonalsium hasn't existed for millennia." "Anyways, who do we think the traitor is. We can send them to Ironeyes for judgment?" On 1/5/2026 at 4:35 AM, Sage Kangaroo said: “I don’t know… I don’t like the way ado talked about Ironeyes but I think he’s just a zealot but on the other hand… (ivory dragonfly, I forgot his characters name) changed his vote without a response… I’m not sure it’s too early to tell” Isabel sighs “I’m sorry fletch, would you like tge rest of my lunch? I will apologize to Ironeyes and you and you may do as you wish too me” On 1/5/2026 at 4:39 AM, Scarlet Octopus said: "I am suspicious of Echo." Their grip on their amulet tightens, "I voted someone at random. And they saw that and switched to voting me, I don't know why, but I think it was as a defense for another traitor. Otherwise, it would be a random vote switch brought on by nothing." On 1/6/2026 at 9:20 AM, Sage Kangaroo said: (Idk abt other players very much I kinda trust everyone but I trust octopus quite a bit I think their reads have made sense and same with their votes, also us silverists have to stick together)
Jo and the Bush all/any Posted January 9 Author Posted January 9 Taupe Gecko (1): Salmon Meerkat Scarlet Octopus (6): Violet Axolotl, Sunburst Toucan, Sapphire Elephant, Quartz Zebra, Mint Heron, Indigo Weasel Plum Rhinoceros (2): Saffron Iguana, Ivory Dragonfly Mint Heron (2): Melon Dingo, Magenta Albatross Melon Dingo (1): Taupe Gecko Magenta Albatross (1): Plum Rhinoceros Indigo Weasel (1): Scarlet Octopus I'm going offline for the night. Rollover is in 13ish hours, and I'll be back in 12ish hours. If y'all post 60 times in the last 11 minutes of the turn again, I'm resurrecting all the dead players. Please figure out who you're executing earlier than that. (For legal reasons, this is a joke. Do what you want.)
Quartz Zebra Posted January 9 Posted January 9 SUBJECT: RE-CALIBRATIN’ THE GEARS Finch wipes a streak of grease across her forehead, lookin’ up from the schematic with a look of intense concentration. Well, paint me copper and call me a conductor! I turn my back for one minute to tighten a manifold, and suddenly we got "ghosts" huddlin’ in the maintenance vents? Chiji, if there's really a "coordinated train" movin' through the PMs, then my Grumble-Gauge just hit the red-line. I ain't gonna be the heavy wrench that helps a "coordinated train" smash a crewmate into the scrap-heap—not until I see the math in the public thread. That’s just sloppy engineerin’. I’m reconsidering Chiji and switchin' back to Ophellia. Ophellia still actin’ like a clogged pipe, and I’d rather put pressure on a quiet leak than be a pawn in some PM-gambit. Consider this a system reboot while I wait for the air to clear on these "secret huddles." Stay safe and don't touch my doodads! -Finch
Ivory Dragonfly Posted January 9 Posted January 9 Not sold on e!Octo For the Mauve Crocodile. Plum Rhinoserous On 1/5/2026 at 11:46 PM, Saffron Iguana said: "Well, I finally got the dog (and it's hair) disposed of. Unfortunately my job description doesn't allow me to do any more work today. I understand that it's my responsibility to do the cleaning in my allotted time, and I shall strive to be more productive on the morrow." Well, I was about to say that it was odd Dragonfly was leaving random poke votes when they are in the lead, but that's been resolved now. My vote on Sage Kanga has outlived its pokiness. In general I find Axolotl a more compelling option than Dragonfly, but I'm also interested in the Dragonfly voters. In particular, Scarlet Octo hasn't really given much more past their original vote, despite things changing a bit since then. Seems like a "I found an easy vote so I'll just sit on it" kinda attitude. Not that I'm one to talk, but what can you do. Saffron Iguana
Oxblood Beagle Posted January 9 Posted January 9 9 hours ago, Sunburst Toucan said: OK Here is my justification for, however briefly, voting for Axoltotl: I don't have one. I was trying to change my vote off of Elephant from the start, which was a poke vote so felt unjustified. I did a terribe job at that, and tried to show I wasn't suspicious of Elephant by being suspicious of someone else. I was trying to avoid drawing attention to myself (see previous point about posting little seeming a decent way to do that at the moment), so wanted to pick the least suspicious person to change my vote to. I concluded it might be the person a lot of people were already suspicious of? Apparently, I picked wrong. I'd like to ask, if you didn't have any reason to vote them, why did you feel the need to vote right there and then? Instead of simply unvoting and then waiting until you were able to catch up with the thread and have a better read of people's alignments 1 hour ago, Salmon Meerkat said: Honestly, that's for me vibes, but I don't like a post Gecko made during D1, something along the lines of "I don't want Dragonfly to die, so I'm..." I don't have a lot of other reads, so like I said earlier, I could see a e!<Dragonfly, Gecko> world, but they also pushed Kanga, so... I really don't know. Actually, what about an <e!Dragonfly, v!Gecko>? I could also see that. Gecko is less e! in my opinion, but that could just be Dragonfly's gimmick. V!Albatross for good analysis, I find that elims can struggle with that. E!lean Croc for D1, but could just be a simple mistake. I think there are probably 3 or 4 elims yet, so I'm thinking e!<Croc, Dragonfly, Gecko?, Octo?>. I believe there were also other people who said similar lines like Heron saying he didn't want the DF vote to go through when DF had claimed Lurcher. What do you think of that? And can you walk me through again why you think DF is elim in both of these scenarios? What makes you suspicion of them?
Saffron Iguana Posted January 9 Posted January 9 (edited) 20 minutes ago, Ivory Dragonfly said: Not sold on e!Octo For the Mauve Crocodile. Plum Rhinoserous Saffron Iguana This seems like a non-sequitur to me, though I have to admit that I haven't really been able to interpret a lot of what you've been saying this game. Seems a bit odd that the moment I try and create a counter-train to Octo that the two people I'm voting with immediately switch, and one of them onto me. I'd still rather Octo die than Heron, but literally everyone with votes now other than Rhino is on my "Don't exe today" list. Edited January 9 by Saffron Iguana
Indigo Weasel Posted January 9 Posted January 9 1 hour ago, Oxblood Beagle said: Alright, so I think that Octopus is just being scapegoated, and I'm side-eyeing Flamingo, Toucan, Axolotl, and Elephant for mostly hopping on Weasel's reasoning, as well as, not bringing other reads to the table. I don't think they're all elim, but it's quite possible at least one of them is there since it seems like an easy vote to latch on. Anyways, I'd like to ask more about your thought process of the world where Octopus is elim @Indigo Weasel. So, I have some questions: - Do you think this Coinshot claim was premeditated during the night? - Do you think it's not possible that this was just a genuine mistake for them to reveal themselves as Coinshot? Because I feel like part of your argument is assuming every villager would do the most optimal play and we have seen that that isn't necessarily the case (i.e. people voting during night after the flip, people not reading who died, Kanga not self-preserving at EOD, etc) There were some posts by Octopus that drew my attention. On D1, Jo clarified that Lurchers can self-protect, which prompted Octopus to ask this question: This is the sort of question where asking it has no tangible benefit for most players because why would a coinshot self-kill regardless of their alignment. BUT, I could see why someone who rolled Coinshot would ask it as someone curious about the mechanics of their role On N1, Octopus has these two posts where the first post, although it's in RP, it does seem to be suggesting that they're coinshot with the emphasis on "I need to know" in a statement where the following pronouns are all "We". In both of these phases' posts, it seems to suggest that if Octopus was an elim, this was a premeditated plan to eventually claim as Coinshot. However, from their posting and the way they've been moving in this game, they don't strike me as the type of player to make this kind of calculated move. They come across more as a player who's still gaining more experience playing this game (forgive me if I'm wrong) and has ended up drawing more suspicion on themselves for something that was genuinely a mistaken move. Outside of this, my concern is that if Octopus is indeed a v!Coinshot and there is an e!Kandra, this is the prime opportunity to get that role. We already know that Kanga's role was taken. It's quite possible a v!Kandra got it because they are of a higher generation, and so, since the elims are aware of this fact, they then might try to hop on this wagon to score an opportunity to have an added KP at night and there's enough traction on it right now where they can safely hide themselves in this wagon. So, I would suggest against this execution and I feel like we've let some people keep staying under the radar and be off the hook (like Flamingo, Elephant, and Toucan), so I would prefer to direct attention on them for today (I'll be reading more of what they said and try to see where I'll be voting) Okay, I had a rehearsal I had to be at, but I can answer this now. it is entirely possible this was premeditated, but it would probably be a backup, as the Elims would have no way of knowing that they were going to lose one. I don’t really think there’s a way to tell though. it is possible this was a mistake by Octopus, but Octopus hasn’t said anything to further that thought. He never said claiming was a mistake, in fact, he’s doubled down saying he was trying to get himself off the chopping block. So while it’s possible, I don’t think so. You are right, there’s no way for him to do everything optimally, but if if was a mistake, Octopus probably would’ve said that, or try to throw doubt on the fact that he claimed coinshot or something. There are many ways to fix or at least throw doubt on this, even in the case of a mistake.
Sapphire Elephant Posted January 9 Posted January 9 Alright so I'm feeling kind of lost I'm going to keep my vote on Octopus for now I'm v!reading Weasel and DF right now, just from vibes I don't really have anything else beyond that right now. I am kind of short on time, I will try and finish going through Day 1 again later today.
Taupe Gecko Posted January 9 Posted January 9 Dingo was suspicious of Croc N1 Flamingo was very defensive of Heron: On 1/7/2026 at 12:27 AM, Onyx Flamingo said: Wait so sorry you have sus on me for defending myself??? I understand, but else was I supposed to do in that situation, 'no yeah i have no defense so just vote me out i want to die'????????? What did you want me to do??? 11 minutes to EoD my computer was in my backpack and I was on my way to school, with no ability to check my anon account on my phone. Last time I had checked, Violet Axl was the only counter train to kangaroo. Sorry if this is defensive, but I just... i mean i guess the point of this post is too be defensive? Alright I wrote the above hours ago its expired I'm not gonna complete it Call me crazy (I absolutely am) but I wanna kill either Flamingo or Ig Going Ig based off current trends 58 minutes ago, A Jo in the Bush said: If y'all post 60 times in the last 11 minutes of the turn again, I'm resurrecting all the dead players. Please figure out who you're executing earlier than that. (For legal reasons, this is a joke. Do what you want.) Hehe
Saffron Iguana Posted January 9 Posted January 9 24 minutes ago, Taupe Gecko said: Call me crazy (I absolutely am) but I wanna kill either Flamingo or Ig Going Ig based off current trends My prediction is everyone gets cold feet about Octo at the last minute and switches to me.
Taupe Gecko Posted January 9 Posted January 9 1 minute ago, Saffron Iguana said: My prediction is everyone gets cold feet about Octo at the last minute and switches to me. Let’s see what happens But I don’t wanna exe our Coinshot
Indigo Weasel Posted January 9 Posted January 9 1 minute ago, Saffron Iguana said: My prediction is everyone gets cold feet about Octo at the last minute and switches to me. I literally can’t, I’m asleep then, so rest assured my vote will stay on Octo, unless you do something incredibly suspicious.
Magenta Albatross Posted January 9 Posted January 9 18 minutes ago, Indigo Weasel said: I literally can’t, I’m asleep then, so rest assured my vote will stay on Octo, unless you do something incredibly suspicious. in that case, their SE-sense will tingle and he will sleep walk to the computer and vote on you
Taupe Gecko Posted January 9 Posted January 9 22 hours ago, Saffron Iguana said: So you think someone else killed Croc and they just aren’t speaking up? To elaborate a bit more, Octo and Axol are on my short list not just because of their claims, but because there is stuff in the writeup that reflects their claims. In particular, I’d say after Beagle that Octo is the next most village person in the game. Why would e!Octo make a claim that could be easily disproven when the elims have already lost 2 players? Honestly, if you weren’t involved in exeing Kanga then this post would be enough for me to vote on you. Quite a bold post from Ig, this was 22 hours ago, Indigo Weasel said: Claiming Coinshot is a stupid move. Even if the real coinshot comes forward and says they did it. For one it’s word against word, and two, we’re in the same situation as before, claiming coinshot means the Elims can now know who the coinshot is. And right now, Octopus claiming Coinshot for no reason, other than to brag about exeing and Elim. Is a fantastically terrible idea. There is no advantage gained from doing this. As for easily being disproven, why would a Coinshot speak up? They’ll just hit him night 2. Claiming coinshot would mean Elims know they’re a Coinshot, and the. Target them, and the lurchers won’t know who to protect. There is no advantage to claiming coinshot. Just problems and mistakes, if coinshot has to tell role, the best move would be to do it in Pm to a lurcher, and try and get them to protect you at night. It is entirely possible that Octopus claimed Coinshot in order to get another Coinshot to claim. Which reveals role and therefore can get exed. Why do you believe Octopus? I’m sorry Weasel I think you’re village but I also think the average player isn’t as strategic as you seem to think (no offense to Octo) 20 hours ago, Sunburst Toucan said: Okay, so apparently I accidentally drew a load of suspicion onto myself with my suspicions of Axolotl. Great. Noted: don't be stupid. Or unjustified. My vote for now is on Scarlet Octopus, mostly for all the aforementioned reasons about claiming Coinshot. Perhaps they're hoping a Lurcher will protect them? If so, they're drawing a lot of attention, mostly negative. I would guess they're either an Elim trying to throw us, or possibly a villager who let their role slip in PMs and now needs protection? Anyway, that's my vote for now. Don’t like this from Toucan 14 hours ago, Sapphire Elephant said: Can someone give a votecount? I'm reading through the D1 posts, and I don't like how Octopus is sounding. I don't completely understand why DF thought they were an elim D1 but Octopus' defense didn't sound like it came from a villager to me Just from vibes this feels very elim-y to me. Don’t like this either but don’t expect two elims on one train. Retracted almost instantly anyways 13 hours ago, Scarlet Octopus said: The biggest reason to know that I really am a coinshot is my first post, which was posted a minute after this thread came up. If I were an Elim, I wouldn't have known that another Elim was going to be killed, and I couldn't have claimed as early as I did. Wait I actually get this I think Octopus is saying they learned about Croc’s death via PM not writeup 11 hours ago, Scarlet Octopus said: Looks like, despite revealing myself not to get exed today, I'm still going to get exed if this continues. What's the vote count at? Edit: Vote switching from Toucan to Weasel What’s the reasoning for the switch here? 10 hours ago, Sunburst Toucan said: OK Here is my justification for, however briefly, voting for Axoltotl: I don't have one. I was trying to change my vote off of Elephant from the start, which was a poke vote so felt unjustified. I did a terribe job at that, and tried to show I wasn't suspicious of Elephant by being suspicious of someone else. I was trying to avoid drawing attention to myself (see previous point about posting little seeming a decent way to do that at the moment), so wanted to pick the least suspicious person to change my vote to. I concluded it might be the person a lot of people were already suspicious of? Apparently, I picked wrong. I still don't trust Octopus - again, largely for the pointless Coinshot claim. To dispute their three reasons: one, surprise is easy to feign. Two, there's little evidence to support their claim. Three, I don't see the point of another Coinshot counterclaiming (if there is one) as it would only make them a target as well (although that could well just be poor reasoning on my part). Don’t like this 9 hours ago, Violet Axolotl said: Gosh that was a lot to read Ok what I've seen so far, I'm gonna place a hesitant vote on octo. I don't like how weak his reasons from claiming and otherwise have been. Like weasel has been saying, if octo is indeed CS, then why claim? Don’t like this either but don’t wanna go after Axl now 9 hours ago, Onyx Flamingo said: Because I dont really know whats happening although that is fair, i should make a vote soon. Light e!lean on Octopus I just dont have any other e!reads *slow clap* Flamingo, are you following others or your own gut? 4 hours ago, Saffron Iguana said: With 2-3 Lurcher claims (depending on Dingo's seriousness) I'm tempted to buy into an elim Coinshot. I don't think that explains Croc's death though, and if Octo is elim then he's probably vanilla or a Thug or something. Since PMs are up, if Octo is elim, either the elims had an extra kill that they used on a teammate, or a villager killed Croc. In the latter case, e!Octo is trying to get the villager responsible to reveal. But since PMs are open, that villager could just claim to someone they trust. Of course, Octo's post was pretty early in the day, so they might have missed PMs being available. There are also Kandra to consider; like Heron said, if there is a Village Kandra that didn't claim the Seeker role last night then e!Octo probably wouldn't make the play everyone is theorizing. So if Octo is elim, the elims probably have a Kandra that hasn't used their ability yet. That might actually make sense, if they thought they could trade Octo for a Coinshot. Okay, maybe everyone voting Octo isn't as kayana as I thought. Still seems a bit weird given that the elims have lost 2 players, but a Coinshot doubles their killing power so as long as they have 2 people left the play kinda makes sense. Uh oh bro’s changing his mind… yet call me crazy but I think e!Ig should park on a strong stance 2 hours ago, Plum Rhinoceros said: AlbaTross I see what you did there … Alright I really shoulda read all that earlier but my main suspicion RUGHT now is Toucan, although I’m satisfied with killing Ig or even Elephant (but I don’t want Octo dead and I will die on that hill) Ig willing to back me up on Toucan? 1 hour ago, Saffron Iguana said: I think I'll switch from Toucan to Rhino. I have a preference for the former but I'm still not sold on e!Octo, and of the current available options I have a decent village read on Heron, while Rhino is in my POE. I'm also v!reading Alb right now, so I'm not really a fan of Rhino's vote. Alright I’m going to sleep now but I should be awake for like two hours before rollover so maybe we can torture Jo again (that’s a joke. Hopefully, you never know) I also feel bad for the decline in RP but for me, mainly, it’s a matter of time ‘Night guys Happy killing
Magenta Albatross Posted January 9 Posted January 9 alright going to bed pretty soon my advice to you lot don't kill the Coinshot
Taupe Gecko Posted January 9 Posted January 9 2 minutes ago, Ivory Dragonfly said: Sleep Indigo Weasel Hide contents Justification? Cause the way I see it Weasel played a big part in Kanga’s death Also guys dang I’m beginning to realize how powerful an elim deep wolf could truly be
Magenta Albatross Posted January 9 Posted January 9 Just now, Taupe Gecko said: Justification? Cause the way I see it Weasel played a big part in Kanga’s death I kinda thought we collectively cleared Weasel cuz off Kanga's death, but apparently not
Ivory Dragonfly Posted January 9 Posted January 9 Just now, Taupe Gecko said: Justification? Cause the way I see it Weasel played a big part in Kanga’s death (For legal reasons, this is a joke. Do what you want.) 1
Oxblood Beagle Posted January 9 Posted January 9 Currently, I'd like to vote within the three people (Toucan, Flamingo, Elephant) who hopped on the Octo wagon without providing as much reasoning to it. I feel like an elim could have slipped into that as an opportunity to try and get a Coinshot as additional KP. So I tried to look into what they've done and said so far Toucan Spoiler D1: poke votes Elephant and disappears for the rest of the day N1: votes Axolotl despite it being night and when prompted, says it was a change in suspicion, but doesn't explain why D2 - admits that one of the best strategies to avoid suspicion is by posting little and shows self-awareness that saying that could incriminate him (since he's posted little also) - voted Octo following other's reasoning but doesn't seem to have a lot of conviction initially - later says he didn't have a justification for voting Axl - offers more reasoning to suspect Octo (which feels a little like they had help from a team to come up with that) Flamingo Spoiler D1 - posts 5 RP posts, the 6th post is them still feeling lost despite engaging in the thread - defends DF and then follows Croc's reasoning for voting Axl N1: had a rather defensive reaction to being in the PoE D2 - seemingly forgets that Croc died - votes Octo following other's reasoning and doesn't have any other reads to share Elephant Spoiler D1 - cites that they v!read DF as real saboteurs would not draw attention - when Meerkat voted Kangaroo, he voted him for being too willing to switch votes (which was the same reason for DF being suspected) - has a v!lean on Croc N1: Asks "How did you know Kanga is evil?" D2 - suspected Octo based on their D1 vote on DF - drops the vote because they forgot Octo claimed Coinshot - votes Octo again following Weasel's reasoning All three have some odd moments of not knowing something (Toucan with voting during night, Flamingo forgetting Croc died, and Elephant not knowing Kangaroo flipped), and I'm not sure how deliberate or genuine that is. But it might be a factor to consider who is likely to manufacture such a reaction I'll admit, I don't have a deep reasoning to suspect them, which is partly due to them not really saying that much. But from what little they said, I feel inclined to vote Onyx Flamingo here. I'm suspicious of the fact that they were acting lost on D1 despite being in thread then hopping on the Axl wagon. Later on in N1, they were rather defensive when placed in the PoE and currently in D2, they didn't have other reads to share and admitted to just be following Weasel's reasoning. So, I guess part of this is less that they're that suspicious, but they haven't given me enough to convince me that they're village Also, on Iguana, I'm still suspicious of the part where they switched their vote off Kangaroo when Weasel's vote brought it to 3. But I do like their D2 more and he looks a little better in my eyes when he tried to dissuade against the Octo wagon before it gained traction.
Taupe Gecko Posted January 9 Posted January 9 Just now, Ivory Dragonfly said: (For legal reasons, this is a joke. Do what you want.) … k? 1 minute ago, Oxblood Beagle said: Currently, I'd like to vote within the three people (Toucan, Flamingo, Elephant) who hopped on the Octo wagon without providing as much reasoning to it. I feel like an elim could have slipped into that as an opportunity to try and get a Coinshot as additional KP. So I tried to look into what they've done and said so far Toucan Hide contents D1: poke votes Elephant and disappears for the rest of the day N1: votes Axolotl despite it being night and when prompted, says it was a change in suspicion, but doesn't explain why D2 - admits that one of the best strategies to avoid suspicion is by posting little and shows self-awareness that saying that could incriminate him (since he's posted little also) - voted Octo following other's reasoning but doesn't seem to have a lot of conviction initially - later says he didn't have a justification for voting Axl - offers more reasoning to suspect Octo (which feels a little like they had help from a team to come up with that) Flamingo Hide contents D1 - posts 5 RP posts, the 6th post is them still feeling lost despite engaging in the thread - defends DF and then follows Croc's reasoning for voting Axl N1: had a rather defensive reaction to being in the PoE D2 - seemingly forgets that Croc died - votes Octo following other's reasoning and doesn't have any other reads to share Elephant Hide contents D1 - cites that they v!read DF as real saboteurs would not draw attention - when Meerkat voted Kangaroo, he voted him for being too willing to switch votes (which was the same reason for DF being suspected) - has a v!lean on Croc N1: Asks "How did you know Kanga is evil?" D2 - suspected Octo based on their D1 vote on DF - drops the vote because they forgot Octo claimed Coinshot - votes Octo again following Weasel's reasoning All three have some odd moments of not knowing something (Toucan with voting during night, Flamingo forgetting Croc died, and Elephant not knowing Kangaroo flipped), and I'm not sure how deliberate or genuine that is. But it might be a factor to consider who is likely to manufacture such a reaction I'll admit, I don't have a deep reasoning to suspect them, which is partly due to them not really saying that much. But from what little they said, I feel inclined to vote Onyx Flamingo here. I'm suspicious of the fact that they were acting lost on D1 despite being in thread then hopping on the Axl wagon. Later on in N1, they were rather defensive when placed in the PoE and currently in D2, they didn't have other reads to share and admitted to just be following Weasel's reasoning. So, I guess part of this is less that they're that suspicious, but they haven't given me enough to convince me that they're village Also, on Iguana, I'm still suspicious of the part where they switched their vote off Kangaroo when Weasel's vote brought it to 3. But I do like their D2 more and he looks a little better in my eyes when he tried to dissuade against the Octo wagon before it gained traction. You’ll be awake for rollover, right? Cause I’m eyeing Flamingo as an alter to Toucan if it doesn’t work out
Oxblood Beagle Posted January 9 Posted January 9 2 minutes ago, Taupe Gecko said: You’ll be awake for rollover, right? Cause I’m eyeing Flamingo as an alter to Toucan if it doesn’t work out Yeah, I will most likely be there for rollover
Recommended Posts