Jump to content

Mailliw73

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    7523

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Mailliw73

  1. Mailliw73
    Back when I joined, it was rare. Very rare. I think I went six months of active posting and got to 16 rep. Then it slowly became more and more common with a sudden spike about a year and a half ago, I think. Now upvotes are tossed out, not meaninglessly, but very often.
  2. Mailliw73
    I also agree that jokes, while funny, don't necessarily deserve 20 up votes. Especially compared to theory crafting or well-written RP. I do believe that roleplay or well done analysis(Sanderson Elimination is what I'm thinking of) deserves upvotes. That's where the majority of my upvotes go. If there's a joke that I find particularly funny, I'll upvote it regardless of the current reputation that post has. The biggest problem I see is, and this is just an example and shouldn't be construed as an attack as I really do like this member, that when Twi posts one of the best roleplay posts ever written on this forum and it gets just over ten upvotes(which is extremely good) but her posting a picture of a pug can easily garner just as much if not more. What contribution did that pug really make? It didn't take effort and it didn't change much about the forum, but she kickstarted the most successful roleplay ever to be on this forum and isn't as recognized for it.
  3. Mailliw73
    I just posted a link to this thread in the Random Stuff thread to see if more of that opinion will be shared.
  4. Mailliw73
    Might I suggest that if any of you have opinions concerning the reputation system, you visit this thread and share? http://www.17thshard.com/forum/topic/52208-upvotes-and-downvotes/
  5. Mailliw73
    Voidus nailed perfectly most of my thoughts on the matter already, so I don't have much to say. I'd also like to second the badges(yeah, I know, they're coming) idea. Those were cool when I first joined but were removed shortly after, so I never earned one. The titles being tied to post count instead of reputation is also something I highly support, if possible. I personally think the quota would be good at 15. 10, even for me, and I don't up vote anywhere near as prolifically as some other members, has been a bit small. I hit it earlier today and j was intentionally saving up votes. So, if you're taking suggestions, 15 is my preference.
  6. Mailliw73
    Maren Noles is signing up. She's a Native American, originating from Oregon.
  7. Mailliw73
    That was half my point. Actually, our thoughts have covered every possibility if there are only 2 Tineyes. Why does 1 and 1 make the most sense? Yes, that automatically balances, but the Tineye role is an easy one to balance. If both are on the Village side, I'd expect we have an extra Lurcher. Same for if both are on the Spiked side. That balances quite nicely all by itself, no weird convolutions needed. I will agree there. And, while I don't like the Follow the Cop strategy, I do agree that both Seekers should have someone come forward today with their opinions on Wyrm and or Hellscythe. Heck, me too, if you want.
  8. Mailliw73
    Can you clarify the first paragraph? Your reaction has nothing to do with Wyrm being good or evil? Huh?Second, Stink revealed two nights ago, not last night. Just to make sure we're clear. It is still possible Wyrm is Spiked, I'll agree, but it is not obvious as you think. It is the most basic possibility, but I've learned that Eliminators can think of the strangest plans. From the moment they both revealed, I've felt that something was off about the Tineyes. My thoughts are: 1. There's two village Tineyes 2. There's two evil tineyes(now disproven) 3. There's two village Tineyes and one evil one who has been intentionally not using their power to throw us off and make us kill both of our own Tineyes. Two people have claimed Seeker. Thad a risky one to claim if you can't back it up. So I'm inclined to trust that there's at least one and that the other may be a Spiked. Lurchers are actually very unlikely to protect from a Spiked kill. They aren't "supposed" to have been able to do it by this point. Sometimes kills happen for unknown reasons. This one could have been predicted, yes. But not all can be. Edit: I meant that with my theory that the Spiked want us to lynch Wyrm on our own, you're the one trying to get us started on voting for Wyrm.
  9. Mailliw73
    Hellscythe. What Elbereth said. (I mean, I did say it first. She just posted it first. ) You've either fell for exactly what you were meant to or you're trying to get the Bandwagon going.
  10. Mailliw73
    Basically my reaction too.
  11. Mailliw73
    Oh sorry. I couldn't remember. Orlok Venture.
  12. Mailliw73
    Luckat, Sart actually just took his vote off of me. Venture. Orlok, did you ever give a reason for going so inactive? I'll change my vote back to Venture if I need to seal the lynch.
  13. Mailliw73
    Congrats yourself! You did very, very well, especially for a first time player. We commented on that several times in the doc and was one reason why Ada wanted to leave you alive.
  14. Mailliw73
    I contacted him when it looked like he could be lynched and he hadn't replied. Knowing him to be a very active player, I PMd him to see what's up. He replied with his answer of being sick and needing a laptop. Then he diedI'll second Hellscythe's question, Stink.
  15. Mailliw73
    Thanks Wilson for GMing and Kas for helping out! I have some comments, but I know that they're what Wilson wants to say, so I'll let her say them. Wow, when I first saw our Diagrammist team, I thought we had this in the bag and it seemed way too overpowered. But, as the game wore on, about half our team was inactive at one point, probably more. You guys almost came back. You were quite close and after I died, I began to worry. You all played a great game! Lopen, these last couple games, you've figured everything out, you're just not able to get all the support you need. You've definitely moved up a couple threat levels. Great job!
  16. Mailliw73
    Very bottom right corner of the Forum homepage. It's just above the online users list.
  17. Mailliw73
    I offered myself directly already, and to one Seeker, I offered myself like 3 cycles ago. But nothing.
  18. Mailliw73
    What happened to 9 pages of discussion? I'll say this: Apparently there are 2 Seekers making groups and it seems they haven't overlapped yet. Also, if we must lynch someone, we can go off Kas's wishes and kill the last claimed Smoker if you guys want.
  19. Mailliw73
    They do. I've heard that there's a proven group already working together. Venture. I still want to hear your answer though and if I don't get one by next cycle, I will actually try to lynch you. Edit: Scratch that, I'm still voting for you.
  20. Mailliw73
    No, sorry, I was making a joke referencing LG6. Didn't mean to disregard what you were saying though. Earlier, as in, less than 24 hours ago?
  21. Mailliw73
    Your gut is a darkfriend Spiked.
  22. Mailliw73
    So, Stink says to kill Wyrm, while Wyrm says to kill Hellscythe and I. Okay... Yeah, I'm starting to highly doubt the existence of a coinshot, unless they're inactive. Venture, I still want an explanation for your votes on me.
  23. Mailliw73
    Emma wishes she could stab him in the neck too, but she's been dealing with him, so she knows how to hit and not draw blood. She may have been practicing...
  24. Mailliw73
    Yeah, sorry, I edited it to make that clearer. She just hit him with the handle.
  25. Mailliw73
    The Dalles, Episode IV: A New Scumbaggery Followed by: The Dalles, Episode V: Emma Strikes Back.
×
×
  • Create New...